Skip to content

Analysis of Primary Stripper Foils at SNS by an Electron Beam Foil Test Stand

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2015-01-01
JournalJACOW
AuthorsEric Paul Barrowclough, C. S. Feigerle, Christopher Luck, M. Plum, Robert W. Shaw
InstitutionsUniversity of Tennessee at Knoxville, Oak Ridge National Laboratory
Citations1
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • Application: Diamond stripper foils for charge-exchange of hydride (H-) ions at the Spallation Neutron Source (SNS) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
  • Operating Environment: Ultra-high thermal load from 1.0-1.4 MW pulsed proton beams (current target), with planned upgrades to 2.0 MW and 3.0 MW.
  • Material Solution: Nanocrystalline diamond (NCD) films grown via plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition (MPCVD) on silicon substrates, with selective use of microcrystalline and boron-doped variants.
  • Key Specification: 17 x 45 mm free-standing foil, 350 µg/cm² aerial density (~1.0 µm thick), with a 17 x 30 mm free-standing active region and a 17 x 15 mm silicon handle.
  • Beam Equivalence: A 30 keV, 1.6 mA/mm² electron beam replicates the thermal load of a 1.4 MW SNS beam (~4.4x higher electron stopping power in carbon reduces required current density).
  • Tested Foil Variables: Lithography corrugation patterns (concentric rings, U-shape, checkerboard, ellipses, diagonal lines), crystal grain size (nano vs. micro), aerial density, and boron doping concentration.
  • Thermal Operating Range Validated: Foil temperatures from 710 K to 1,889 K during controlled escalation tests, with no intrinsic failure modes observed.
ParameterValueUnitContext
Foil Footprint17 x 45mmTotal diamond-plus-handle assembly
Free-Standing Active Area17 x 30mmRegion where Si is etched away
Silicon Handle17 x 15mmRemaining Si frame for mounting
Aerial Density350µg/cm²Production-standard NCD foil
Film Thickness~1.0µmCorresponds to 350 µg/cm² at ρ ≈ 2.0 g/cm³
SNS Beam Energy1.0GeVH- proton beam
SNS Pulse Width1,000µsBeam-on duration per cycle
SNS Pulse Frequency60HzRepetition rate
Protons per Pulse1.5 x 1014pppLinear accelerator output
Beam Hits per Proton7-10hitsAccumulator ring circulation
Peak Hit Density4.5 x 1013p/mm²Injection + circulation
Peak Beam Density7.2 x 1016p/mm²/sEquivalent to 7.2 mA/mm²
Electron Beam Energy (FTS)30keVTable-top equivalent
Electron Beam Current (FTS)1.6mA/mm²Equivalent thermal load
Stopping Power Ratio (e⁻ : p)~4.43x30 keV e⁻ vs. 1 GeV p in amorphous C
Electron Spot Size (focused)0.300mm²Minimum rastered spot
Raster Spot Area0.0265cm²Standard FTS illumination zone
Electron Gun Emission Range1 x 10-6 - 5.000mAOperating envelope
Raster Frequency (X & Y)0 - 15,000HzBeam scanning range
Pulse Width Range1 - 1 x 106µsPulsed operation flexibility
Test Foil Temperatures710.9 - 1,889.1KFrom 0.272 mA to 4.800 mA
Peak Emissivity Measured0.8350—Calculated via blackbody transmission
Silicon Substrate Etch Depth30mmChemical etching of (100) Si
Substrate MaterialSemiconductor-grade (100) Si—Wafer for conformal growth
  1. Substrate Preparation: Semiconductor-grade (100) silicon wafer patterned with lithography (checkerboard, U-shape, concentric rings, ellipses, diagonal lines) to define post-etch corrugation.
  2. Diamond Growth: Plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition (MPCVD) of nanocrystalline diamond (with optional microcrystalline or boron-doped variants) to target 350 µg/cm² aerial density.
  3. Silicon Etch: Chemical removal of 30 mm of the silicon substrate beneath the diamond film, yielding a free-standing corrugated foil with a silicon handle.
  4. Foil Mounting: Foil attached to actuator bracket (up to 4 foils per cycle) inside a stainless steel vacuum chamber equipped with Faraday cup, residual gas analyzer, IR camera, and HD video.
  5. Electron Beam Calibration: 30 keV electron gun rastered in X and Y at ~0.0265 cm² spot to match the 7.07 mm² SNS beam footprint.
  6. Pulsed Simulation: 60 Hz repetition, 1 ms pulse width matching SNS timing; current escalated from 0.272 mA to 4.800 mA to cover 0.090 MW to 1.585 MW equivalent power.
  7. Thermal Mapping: IR camera and blackbody transmission measurements captured temperature and emissivity at each beam spot.
  8. Material Characterization: Raman spectroscopy evaluated phase conversion (NCD → graphite); visual inspection captured tears, rips, and flutter behavior.
  9. Lifetime Testing: Cumulative beam exposure (5 minutes per current step, up to 50 minutes total) to identify extrinsic vs. intrinsic failure modes.

The stripper foil program at ORNL/SNS requires nanocrystalline diamond (NCD) films in the 1 µm thickness range, with selective use of microcrystalline diamond and boron-doped diamond. 6CCVD’s MPCVD process directly supports these variants:

  • Nanocrystalline Diamond (NCD): Ideal for the 350 µg/cm² (~1.0 µm) target. 6CCVD’s NCD films exhibit the fine grain structure required for conformal lithographic transfer and uniform stress distribution.
  • Microcrystalline Diamond (MCD): Available for comparative grain-size studies, with controlled crystal morphology to match ORNL’s reference foils.
  • Boron-Doped Polycrystalline Diamond (BDD): Heavy or tailored boron doping levels for evaluation of electrical conductivity effects on charge stripping and thermal emissivity.

For research teams exploring single-crystal alternatives for next-generation stripper foils (where lower defect density may extend lifetime beyond 3 MW), 6CCVD’s Optical Grade SCD films can be supplied down to 0.1 µm thickness, with Ra < 1 nm polished surfaces.

The 17 x 45 mm foil geometry with a 17 x 30 mm free-standing region and silicon handle is well within 6CCVD’s prototyping envelope. Our capabilities directly support extension and customization of this work:

  • Wafer-Scale Growth: MPCVD reactors accommodate silicon substrates up to and beyond the 6-inch diameter used for ORNL’s production foils, enabling larger-format stripper foils or batch processing of multiple test coupons.
  • Custom Thickness Control: From 0.1 µm to 500 µm for both freestanding films and supported layers, allowing precise tuning of aerial density beyond the 350 µg/cm² benchmark.
  • Lithography & Etch Partnerships: 6CCVD can deliver as-grown diamond-on-silicon for in-house patterning, or partner with established lithography foundries for full corrugated foil fabrication.
  • Metallization: For hybrid charge-stripping diagnostics or instrumented foils (thermocouples, emissivity patches), 6CCVD offers in-house deposition of Ti, Pt, Au, Pd, W, and Cu with sub-µm precision.
  • Laser Cutting & Shaping: Free-standing diamond films can be laser-cut to non-standard geometries, including circular apertures, multi-aperture arrays, or asymmetric handle configurations.

6CCVD’s in-house PhD team brings deep expertise in MPCVD reactor kinetics, diamond-substrate interface engineering, and high-thermal-load material qualification. For accelerator and beam-physics groups pursuing:

  • SNS Power Upgrade Programs (2.0 MW / 3.0 MW): We can model and supply candidate foils with varied aerial density, grain size, and corrugation topology to extend the empirical dataset reported in this work.
  • Failure Analysis & Raman Phase Mapping: Consultation on graphitization thresholds, sp²/sp³ ratio benchmarks, and post-irradiation characterization protocols.
  • Next-Generation Stripper Concepts: Including boron-doped variants for enhanced emissivity control, ultra-thin SCD membranes for reduced stopping-power losses, and engineered heterostructures.

Global shipping is available on DDU terms by default, with DDP options for turnkey logistics to national laboratories and international research facilities.

For custom specifications, foil prototyping, or material consultation on stripper foil development and other high-thermal-load diamond applications, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.

View Original Abstract

Diamond foils are used at the Spallation Neutron Source (SNS) as the primary strippers of hydride ions. A nanocrystalline diamond film, typically 17x45 mm with an aerial density of 0.35 mg/cm², is deposited on a corrugated silicon substrate by plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition. After growth, 30 mm of the silicon substrate is etched away, leaving a freestanding diamond foil with a silicon handle that can be inserted into SNS for operation. An electron beam test facility was constructed to study stripper foil degradation and impact on foil lifetime. The electron beam capabilities include: current up to 5 mA, focused spot size of 0.30 mm², and rastering in the x- and y-directions. A 30 keV and 1.6 mA/mm² electron beam deposits the same power density on a diamond foil as a 1.4 MW beam on SNS target. Rastering of the electron beam can expose a similar area of the foil as SNS beams. Experiments were conducted using the foil test stand to study: foil flutter and lifetime; effects of corrugation patterns, aerial densities, crystal size (micro vs. nano), and boron doping; temperature distributions and film emissivity; and conversion rate of nanocrystalline diamond into graphite.