Skip to content

'Surface Roughness and Seeding Process Influence on Boron Doped Micro/Nanocrystalline Diamond Adhesion on Titanium Substrate'

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2018-11-21
JournalTrends in Textile Engineering & Fashion Technology
AuthorsSilvia S Oishi
InstitutionsInstituto Nacional de Pesquisas Espaciais
Citations1
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • Objective: Systematic evaluation of Boron-Doped Diamond (BDD) and Nanocrystalline BDD (NBDD) film adhesion on Titanium (Ti) substrates, analyzing the interplay between surface roughness and seeding methodology.
  • Material System: Microcrystalline (BDD) and Nanocrystalline (NBDD) diamond films deposited via Hot Filament Chemical Vapor Deposition (HFCVD) on 1.0 x 1.0 cm2 Ti substrates.
  • Variable Matrix: Twenty distinct sample sets generated by combining two film morphologies, five Ti surface roughness profiles (Sandblasted, As-received, Polished with #80, #600, and #2000 sandpaper), and two seeding pre-treatments.
  • Seeding Contrast: Comparative analysis between traditional ultrasonic agitation (US) with 0.25 µm diamond particles and Electrostatic Self-Assembly (ES) with 4 nm nanodiamond in KCl.
  • Key Finding: Electrostatic seeding (ES) with 4 nm nanodiamond provided superior adhesion across all roughness profiles, preventing delamination even on highly polished (SP2000) Ti surfaces where US-treated samples failed.
  • Adhesion Validation: Rockwell C indentation test (VDI 3198 norm) confirmed that combining ES pre-treatment with greater substrate roughness optimizes interfacial bonding by mitigating thermal expansion mismatch.
  • Application Relevance: Establishes a reliable protocol for fabricating robust, doped diamond electrodes on Ti for electrochemical, biomedical, and aerospace environments.
ParameterValueUnitContext
Substrate MaterialTitanium (Ti)-1.0 x 1.0 cm2 surface area
Diamond Morphology 1BDD (Microcrystalline)-Standard grain structure
Diamond Morphology 2NBDD (Nanocrystalline)-Ball-like / cauliflower grain structure
Deposition TechniqueHFCVD-Hot Filament Chemical Vapor Deposition
Growth Duration20hPer sample set
Substrate Temperature650°CControlled during deposition
Reactor Pressure30TorrMaintained throughout growth
Gas Mixture (BDD)198 : 2sccm (H2 : CH4)~1% CH4 concentration
Gas Mixture (NBDD)184 : 16sccm (H2 : CH4)~8% CH4 concentration
Boron Source Flow30sccmH2 carrier gas through bubbler
Boron Concentration30,000ppmB/C ratio in methanol/B2O3 solution
Seeding Method 1 (US)0.25µmDiamond particles in hexane, 1h ultrasonic agitation
Seeding Method 2 (ES)4nmDiamond particles in 1mM KCl, PDDA functionalization
Ti Surface States5VariantsSB, AS, SP80, SP600, SP2000
Adhesion TestRockwell C-Per VDI 3198 norm
Indentation Loads10 / 50kgfInitial / Secondary load
Indenter Geometry120°°Diamond tip cone
Nucleation Density (ES)>1011cm-2High-density electrostatic seeding
Nucleation Density (BEN)108 - 1011cm-2Reference value for Bias Enhanced Nucleation
  • Substrate Preparation: Five Ti surface states were engineered by varying abrasive treatments:
    • SB (Sandblasted): High roughness, deep mechanical incisions.
    • AS (As-received): Native surface morphology.
    • SP80 / SP600 / SP2000: Sequential mechanical polishing using decreasing sandpaper grit sizes.
  • Seeding Process - Ultrasonic (US):
    • Submerged in suspension of 0.25 µm diamond powder in hexane.
    • Ultrasonicated for 1 hour.
  • Seeding Process - Electrostatic (ES):
    • Chemical attack with 40% ammonium fluoride for 2 seconds to remove native oxide.
    • Surface modification via dipping in 10 wt% cationic polymer (PDDA) solution for 30 minutes.
    • Rinse in DI water, dry with N2 gas.
    • Immersion in 1mM KCl + 4 nm nanodiamond colloidal solution for 10 minutes.
  • Film Deposition (HFCVD):
    • Gas activation via hot filament.
    • BDD growth: 198 sccm H2 + 2 sccm CH4.
    • NBDD growth: 184 sccm H2 + 16 sccm CH4.
    • Boron incorporation: 30 sccm H2 bubbler line (B/C ratio = 30,000 ppm).
    • Maintain chamber at 30 Torr and 650 °C for 20 hours.
  • Characterization Suite:
    • Morphology: FEG-SEM (Tescan Mira 3).
    • Quality/Phase: Micro-Raman spectroscopy (514.5 nm Ar+ laser, Horiba LabRAM HR Evolution).
    • Crystallography: XRD (PANalytical X’Pert PRO MPD, Cu Kα radiation, λ=1.54 Å).
    • Topography: Optical profilometry (Veeco WYKO NT 1100).
  • Adhesion Testing:
    • Rockwell C indentation hardness tester (Model 20-70 HRC/HR-150A).
    • Sequential loading: 10 kgf (initial) followed by 50 kgf (destructive).
    • Qualitative analysis of plastic deformation and coating fracture (VDI 3198).
  • Applicable Materials:

    • For this specific study involving doped diamond on titanium substrates, our Heavy Boron Doped PCD and Boron Doped Nanocrystalline Diamond (NBDD) films are the direct commercial analogs. We provide precisely engineered BDD layers with controlled sp2/sp3 hybridization ratios, ideal for electrochemical and biomedical electrodes.
    • Our Optical Grade SCD and Polycrystalline Diamond (PCD) wafers are available for applications requiring superior thermal management where Ti substrates are utilized as heat spreaders or MEMS components.
  • Customization Potential:

    • Substrate Versatility: While this paper focuses on 1.0 x 1.0 cm2 Ti squares, 6CCVD routinely deposits diamond on complex geometries and substrates up to 125mm (PCD). We can tailor the deposition to match specific Ti alloy compositions or geometries (foils, meshes, 3D porous structures).
    • Metallization Integration: For device fabrication requiring electrical contacts, we offer internal metallization capabilities (Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, Cu). This allows for the deposition of diamond directly onto pre-metallized Ti substrates, or post-deposition metallization for electrode integration.
    • Seeding Expertise: We recognize the critical role of the 4 nm electrostatic seeding process highlighted in this research. Our material preparation protocols utilize advanced nanodiamond seeding techniques to ensure high nucleation density (>1011 cm-2) and minimal interfacial stress.
    • Laser Cutting & Shaping: Custom shapes and precise dimensions for BDD/Ti composite electrodes can be achieved using our laser cutting services, ensuring minimal delamination at cut edges.
  • Engineering Support:

    • The primary failure mode discussed in this paper—delamination due to thermal expansion mismatch between diamond and Ti—requires careful material selection and process optimization. Our in-house PhD engineering team specializes in matching diamond film properties (thickness, doping level, grain size) to specific substrate thermal and mechanical profiles.
    • We provide consultative support for researchers looking to scale HFCVD findings to MPCVD platforms, offering guidance on gas chemistry, boron incorporation, and adhesion enhancement strategies for electrochemical, aerospace, and advanced sensor applications.
  • Call to Action:

    • For custom specifications, metallization consultations, or material selection for your diamond-on-titanium research, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.
View Original Abstract

CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition) diamond deposition on different materials requires surface treatment such as diamond particles seeding on the substrate dispersed in an appropriate solvent by using ultrasonic agitation. On the other hand, seeding process by electrostatic attraction of nanodiamond particle have produced films with higher nucleation density compared to that obtained from ultrasonic treatment. In addition, nucleation and growth of micro/nanocrystalline boron doped diamond films (BDD/NBDD) on titanium (Ti) substrates represent a complex process, mainly due to the poor film adhesion related to the difference in the thermal expansion coefficients between the film and the substrate.