Skip to content

Boron-doped Nanodiamond as an Electrode Material for Aqueous Electric Double-layer Capacitors

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2019-11-28
JournalScientific Reports
AuthorsKenjo Miyashita, Takeshi Kondo, Seiya Sugai, Takahiro Tei, Masahiro Nishikawa
InstitutionsDaicel (Japan), Tokyo University of Science
Citations29
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • Core Innovation: Fabrication of Boron-Doped Nanodiamond (BDND) particles via Microwave Plasma-Assisted Chemical Vapor Deposition (MPCVD) on 4.7 nm detonation nanodiamond substrates for high-performance aqueous Electric Double-Layer Capacitors (EDLCs).
  • Material Composition: Hybrid sp2/sp3 carbon structure. The deposition simultaneously forms a Boron-Doped Diamond (BDD) shell and graphitic carbon components, which are partially removed via post-deposition heat treatment.
  • Electrochemical Performance: Achieves a specific capacitance of 15.1 F g-1 in 1 M H2SO4, rivaling activated carbon (20.4 F g-1), but with a significantly wider working cell voltage of 1.8 V (vs. 0.8 V for activated carbon).
  • Expanded Electrolyte Window: Using saturated NaClO4 as the aqueous electrolyte expands the cell voltage to 2.8 V, boosting the energy density to ~20 Wh kg-1.
  • Rate Capability: Exhibits excellent power density (102-104 W kg-1) and high capacitance retention at fast scan rates (up to 1000 mV/s) due to the absence of restrictive micropores found in activated carbon.
  • Cycling Stability: Maintains 96.5% capacitance retention after 10,000 CV cycles at 0-1.8 V and operates stably at 1.6 V during extended floating tests, indicating robust durability for practical energy storage applications.
  • Strategic Value: Combines the wide potential window of BDD with high surface area, making it a promising candidate for compact, high-power aqueous supercapacitor devices.
ParameterValueUnitContext
Primary Particle Size (Substrate)4.7nmDetonation Nanodiamond (ND) core diameter
ND Substrate Surface Area270m2 g-1Initial Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) surface area
Final BDND Surface Area658m2 g-1BET after 8h heat treatment in air
Reference AC Surface Area1318m2 g-1Activated Carbon control sample
Electrical Conductivity> 1S cm-1Measured via packed glass tube method
Boron Concentration (BDD layer)440 - 620ppmDetermined via ICP-AES; increases after heat treatment
B/C Atomic Ratio (Source)20,000ppmTrimethyl borate/acetone precursor mixture
Microwave Power (MPCVD)1300WPlasma generation parameter
Stage Temperature (MPCVD)800°CSubstrate temperature during deposition
Deposition Time (MPCVD)8hTotal layer growth time
Heat Treatment Temperature425°CAir oxidation to remove sp2 carbon
Heat Treatment Time8hOptimal duration for sp2 removal
Specific Capacitance15.1F g-1Measured in 1 M H2SO4 (scan rate 10 mV s-1)
Working Cell Voltage1.8VTwo-electrode symmetric system in 1 M H2SO4
Max Cell Voltage (NaClO4)2.8VTwo-electrode system in saturated NaClO4
Energy Density10Wh kg-1In 1 M H2SO4; reaches ~20 Wh kg-1 in NaClO4
Power Density102 - 104W kg-1Gravimetric power density range
Volumetric Energy Density3 - 4mWh cm-3Energy density per unit volume of electrode layer
Volumetric Power Density0.1 - 10W cm-3Power density per unit volume of electrode layer
Electrode Layer Density (BDND)0.52g cm-3Bulk density of the cast electrode layer
Capacitance Retention (Cycling)96.5%After 10,000 cycles at 0-1.8 V, 10 mV/s
Floating Stability91%Capacitance retention after 12h at 1.6 V
  • Substrate Preparation: Utilize commercial detonation nanodiamond (ND) powder (Daicel Corp.) with an average primary particle size of 4.7 nm and a surface area of 270 m2 g-1 as the base material.
  • Precursor Mixing: Prepare a liquid carbon/boron source by mixing trimethoxyborane/methanol (70%) with acetone. Target a B/C atomic concentration ratio of 20,000 ppm in the precursor.
  • MPCVD Deposition:
    • Load the ND agglomerate into the MPCVD chamber.
    • Set microwave power to 1300 W.
    • Maintain stage temperature at 800 °C.
    • Run deposition for 8 hours to form the conductive BDD shell and sp2 carbon layer.
  • Post-Deposition Heat Treatment: Heat the as-deposited BDND in ambient air at 425 °C for 8 hours to selectively oxidize and remove unstable sp2 carbon impurities, maximizing the specific surface area.
  • Electrode Fabrication:
    • Disperse 10 mg of BDND in 0.5 mL of 30 wt% ethanol to create an ink.
    • Cast 20 µL of the ink onto a Glassy Carbon (GC) disk electrode (3 mm diameter).
    • Dry at 60 °C and fix with 10 µL of 5 wt% Nafion solution (active material load ~0.4 mg).
  • Electrochemical Testing:
    • Use a three-electrode setup with Ag/AgCl reference and Pt counter electrodes.
    • Test in 1 M H2SO4 and saturated NaClO4 electrolytes.
    • Execute Cyclic Voltammetry (CV) at varying scan rates (10 to 1000 mV s-1) to determine capacitance, potential window, and rate capability.
    • Perform a symmetric two-electrode beaker cell test to evaluate practical EDLC cell voltage, energy, and power density.

The successful replication and scaling of the BDND research relies on highly controlled MPCVD processes and precise material engineering. 6CCVD provides the exact infrastructure to support the development of advanced diamond electrode materials.

  • Applicable Materials:

    • Heavy Boron-Doped PCD (Polycrystalline Diamond): For researchers looking to translate this particulate study into thin-film or bulk electrode architectures, 6CCVD’s heavy boron-doped PCD wafers (up to 125mm) offer the same wide potential window and conductivity (> 1 S cm-1) demonstrated in the paper.
    • Boron-Doped Diamond (BDD) Powders/Substrates: If your project requires moving beyond 4.7 nm detonation nanodiamond to larger particulate substrates (e.g., 150 nm, 350 nm, or 3500 nm as cited in the paper’s previous works), our custom MPCVD coating services can deposit uniform BDD layers on various particle sizes.
    • Optical Grade SCD (Single Crystal Diamond): For applications where the sp2 carbon impurities must be strictly eliminated to achieve the widest possible potential window in aqueous media, our ultra-smooth SCD wafers (Ra < 1nm) provide an atomically pristine sp3 carbon platform.
  • Customization Potential:

    • Precision Thickness Control: We specialize in depositing BDD layers with exact thickness tolerances. Whether you require ultra-thin films (0.1 µm) for high-sensitivity sensors or thicker layers (up to 500 µm) for robust bulk electrodes, our MPCVD reactors are calibrated for precise layer growth.
    • Custom Metalization: To facilitate seamless integration into symmetric two-electrode beaker cells or printed electrochemical sensors (as mentioned in the paper’s references), 6CCVD offers in-house metalization with Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, and Cu. This eliminates the need for external vendors and ensures optimal ohmic contact to the diamond surface.
    • Advanced Laser Cutting: Diamond is notoriously difficult to machine. If your BDND device development requires specific electrode geometries or flow-cell architectures, our laser cutting services can shape diamond substrates and wafers to your exact CAD specifications without inducing microfractures.
  • Engineering Support:

    • Navigating the delicate balance between sp2 and sp3 carbon ratios to optimize surface area (m2 g-1) and electrochemical capacitance (F g-1) is challenging. 6CCVD’s in-house team of material scientists and PhD-level engineers can assist with material selection, precursor chemistry optimization, and deposition parameter tuning for your specific Aqueous Supercapacitor or EDLC projects.
    • We can help you transition from laboratory-scale powder substrates to commercially viable, wafer-scale diamond electrodes while maintaining the high-rate charge-discharge capabilities (102-104 W kg-1) highlighted in this study.
  • Call to Action:

    • For custom specifications, heavy boron-doping profiles, or material consultation on your next-generation energy storage device, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.
View Original Abstract

Abstract Herein, a conductive boron-doped nanodiamond (BDND) particle is prepared as an electrode material for an aqueous electric double-layer capacitor with high power and energy densities. The BDND is obtained by depositing a boron-doped diamond (BDD) on a nanodiamond particle substrate with a primary particle size of 4.7 nm via microwave plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition, followed by heat treatment in air. The BDND comprises BDD and sp 2 carbon components, and exhibits a conductivity above 1 S cm −1 and a specific surface area of 650 m 2 g −1 . Cyclic voltammetry measurements recorded in 1 M H 2 SO 4 at a BDND electrode in a two-electrode system shows a capacitance of 15.1 F g −1 and a wide potential window (cell voltage) of 1.8 V, which is much larger than that obtained at an activated carbon electrode, i.e., 0.8 V. Furthermore, the cell voltage of the BDND electrode reaches 2.8 V when using saturated NaClO 4 as electrolyte. The energy and power densities per unit weight of the BDND for charging-discharging in 1 M H 2 SO 4 at the BDND electrode cell are 10 Wh kg −1 and 10 4 W kg −1 , respectively, and the energy and power densities per unit volume of the BDND layer are 3-4 mWh cm −3 and 10 W cm −3 , respectively. Therefore, the BDND is a promising candidate for the development of a compact aqueous EDLC device with high energy and power densities.