Coupling spins to nanomechanical resonators - Toward quantum spin-mechanics

At a Glance

Metadata	Details
Publication Date	2020-12-07
Journal	Applied Physics Letters
Authors	Hailin Wang, Ignas Lekavicius
Institutions	University of Oregon
Citations	36
Analysis	Full AI Review Included

Executive Summary

This tutorial summarizes the state-of-the-art in spin-mechanics, focusing on coupling solid-state spins (color centers in diamond) to nanomechanical resonators for quantum information applications.

Core Platform: Spin-mechanical resonators function as solid-state analogs of cavity Quantum Electrodynamics (QED) systems, enabling quantum control over both electron spins and mechanical vibrations (phonons).
Coupling Regimes: Two primary coupling mechanisms are explored: 1) Direct mechanically driven transitions (Jaynes-Cummings analogy) and 2) Phonon-assisted sideband transitions (Trapped-Ion analogy).
Quantum Goal (C > 1): The primary challenge is reaching the full quantum regime, defined by a cooperativity parameter (C) greater than 1, which requires maximizing the single-phonon spin-mechanical coupling rate ($g$) relative to the spin and mechanical loss rates (γ_s, γ_m).
Role of Strain Coupling: Achieving high coupling rates relies critically on orbital strain coupling rather than pure spin coupling. Negatively charged silicon vacancy (SiV) centers are significantly more promising than nitrogen vacancy (NV) centers for reaching C > 1 due to their strong orbital coupling.
Material Engineering: Future systems must combine strong orbital strain coupling (using Group IV centers) with nearly materials-loss limited nanomechanical resonators, often achieved through advanced phononic band-gap engineering to suppress anchor losses.
Applications: The realization of the full quantum regime will enable mechanically mediated spin entanglement and the construction of phononic quantum networks.

Technical Specifications

Parameter	Value	Unit	Context
NV Ground-State Transverse Strain Coupling (d_⊥/2π)	21.5	GHz	Measured coupling constant.
SiV Orbital Strain Coupling (D/2π)	~1	PHz	Deformation potential, order of magnitude.
SiV Spin-Orbit Splitting (λ_so/2π)	47	GHz	Separation between ground-state doublets.
Nanocantilever Q-factor (Q_m)	10⁶	N/A	Typical Q_m for out-of-plane modes (< 10 MHz).
Diamond Microdisk Frequency (ω_m/2π)	~2	GHz	Mechanical breathing modes.
Diamond Microdisk Q-factor (Q_m)	~10⁴	N/A	Limited by clamping loss of pedestal.
Estimated NV Coupling Rate (g/2π)	~10	Hz	Calculated for NV ground state (weak coupling limit).
Estimated SiV Coupling Rate (g/2π)	~10	kHz	Calculated for SiV excited state (strong orbital coupling limit).
Required Q_m for C > 1 (SiV)	Approach 10⁶	N/A	Necessary to reach the full quantum regime with SiV centers.
Operating Temperature (Sideband Experiments)	8	K	Temperature used for optically driven sideband spin transitions.
Nanoresonator Effective Mass (m_eff)	10	picogram	Numerical estimate for diamond resonator (ω_m/2π = 1 GHz).

Key Methodologies

The realization of quantum spin-mechanics relies on precise nanofabrication, material engineering, and advanced quantum control techniques:

Nanoresonator Selection and Fabrication: Utilizing diverse nanomechanical structures, including cantilevers, double-clamped beams, microdisks, optomechanical crystals, Surface Acoustic Wave (SAW) resonators, and Bulk Acoustic Resonators (BARs).
Phononic Band-Gap Engineering: Implementing phononic crystals to embed nanomechanical resonators. This technique suppresses clamping or anchor losses, which is crucial for achieving high mechanical quality factors (Q_m) necessary for C > 1.
Spin System Integration: Incorporating solid-state defect centers (NV, SiV, GeV, SnV) into the resonator material (primarily diamond) via methods like implantation or epitaxial growth, ensuring the spin is located at a high-strain region of the mechanical mode.
Direct Mechanically Driven Transitions (Cavity-QED Analogy): Generating mechanical strain (e.g., using piezoelectric films like ZnO patterned with electrodes) to induce state mixing between spin states (e.g., m_s = ±1 in NV centers) and drive resonant Rabi oscillations.
Sideband Transitions (Trapped-Ion Analogy): Employing optical fields tuned near the red or blue sidebands of the spin-excited state transition. This phonon-assisted process leverages the strong orbital strain coupling (deformation potential D) in the excited state to mediate spin-phonon interaction.
Orbital Strain Coupling Enhancement: For Group IV centers (SiV), applying an off-axis magnetic field to lift orbital degeneracy and induce spin mixing. This allows the strong orbital strain coupling (D) to effectively drive spin transitions, dramatically increasing the single-phonon coupling rate ($g$).
Decoherence Suppression: Utilizing techniques such as acoustic-dressed spin states (similar to microwave-dressed states) and adiabatic passage methods to suppress spin decoherence induced by the nuclear spin bath or optical excitation.

Commercial Applications

The development of quantum spin-mechanics provides foundational technology for several emerging fields in quantum science and engineering:

Quantum Computing and Networks:
- Quantum Interconnects: Mechanical vibrations (phonons) serve as quantum buses or transducers, mediating coherent interactions between distant spins or linking different types of qubits (e.g., spin, superconducting, optical).
- Phononic Quantum Networks: Utilizing closed mechanical subsystems (e.g., alternating phononic crystal waveguides) to scale quantum networks and overcome limitations of chiral or unidirectional spin-phonon interactions.
- Spin Entanglement: Realizing mechanically mediated entanglement between distant solid-state spins.
Quantum Sensing and Metrology:
- High-Sensitivity Sensing: Using single-spin qubits (like NV centers) as highly sensitive probes for detecting mechanical motion, magnetic fields, and strain gradients (e.g., Magnetic Resonance Force Microscopy).
- Quantum Transduction: Developing highly efficient quantum transducers for converting quantum signals between different domains (e.g., microwave to optical, or spin to mechanical).
Advanced Materials and Devices:
- Phononic Device Engineering: Utilizing phononic band-gap structures for high-Q resonators and phonon routers, crucial for integrating mechanical elements into quantum circuits.
- Acoustic Quantum Control: Enabling all-acoustic methods for quantum control of solid-state qubits, potentially simplifying device architecture compared to microwave or optical control.

View Original Abstract

Spin-mechanics studies interactions between spin systems and mechanical vibrations in a nanomechanical resonator and explores their potential applications in quantum information processing. In this review, we summarize various types of spin-mechanical resonators and discuss both the cavity-QED-like and the trapped-ion-like spin-mechanical coupling processes. The implementation of these processes using negatively charged nitrogen vacancy and silicon vacancy centers in diamond is reviewed. Prospects for reaching the full quantum regime of spin-mechanics, in which quantum control can occur at the level of both a single spin and a single phonon, are discussed with an emphasis on the crucial role of strain coupling to the orbital degrees of freedom of the defect centers.

Tech Support

Original Source

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0024001

References

2001 - Colloquium: Manipulating quantum entanglement with atoms and photons in a cavity [Crossref]
2008 - The quantum internet [Crossref]
2015 - Cavity-based quantum networks with single atoms and optical photons [Crossref]
2011 - Sound-based analogue of cavity quantum electrodynamics in silicon [Crossref]
2012 - Coherent, mechanical control of a single electronic spin [Crossref]
2013 - Mechanical spin control of nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond [Crossref]
2015 - Coherent control of a nitrogen-vacancy center spin ensemble with a diamond mechanical resonator [Crossref]
2015 - Strong mechanical driving of a single electron spin [Crossref]
2016 - Optomechanical quantum control of a nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond [Crossref]
2019 - Spin-phonon interactions in silicon carbide addressed by Gaussian acoustics [Crossref]