Skip to content

The Effect of Boron Doping Concentration on the Electrochemical Oxidation of Chlorine Using BDD Electrode

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2022-12-20
JournalJournal of The Electrochemical Society
AuthorsZhishen Li, Bo Zhou, Wanlin Yang, Zejun Deng, Fenglei Chen
InstitutionsUniversity of Edinburgh, Central South University
Citations10
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • Objective: Systematically investigates how five different boron doping concentrations (ultra-light to ultra-heavy) in BDD electrodes impact the electrochemical oxidation of chloride solutions, specifically targeting active chlorine (AC) yield vs. toxic byproduct formation.
  • Key Finding: Lightly doped BDD (~1.23 × 1020 cm-3) delivers the optimal balance — high AC yield, lowest energy consumption per unit AC, and minimal generation of toxic ClO3- and ClO4- byproducts.
  • Trade-off Identified: Ultra-heavy doping (>7.5 × 1021 cm-3) reduces grain size to ~0.4 µm, increases sp2 phase content, and increases ClO3-/ClO4- yields by 2-4× compared to lightly doped electrodes during organic pollutant degradation.
  • Material Insight: Boron doping concentration inversely correlates with grain size (1.42 µm → 0.4 µm) and oxygen evolution potential (2.41 V → 2.22 V), directly influencing electrochemical surface area and charge transfer resistance.
  • Method: HFCVD-grown BDD films on monocrystalline silicon (20 × 25 × 1 mm), tested in 0.1 M NaCl and simulated organic wastewater (tetracycline + glucose) at 40-50 mA cm-2.
  • Application Validation: Lightly doped BDD demonstrated superior performance for degrading chlorine-containing organic wastewater while suppressing hazardous perchlorate formation.

ParameterValueUnitContext
Substratep-type monocrystalline Si—20 × 25 × 1 mm dimensions
Growth MethodHFCVD—4 parallel spiral filaments, 10 mm side length
Filament-to-Substrate Distance8mmFixed deposition geometry
Chamber Pressure3kPaMaintained during CVD
H2 : B2H6 : CH4 Ratio97 : x : 3.0sccmx = 0, 0.2, 0.6, 1.0, 1.4, 1.8, 4.0
B2H6 Dilution5% v/v in H2—Precursor gas mixture
Ultra-light B Concentration1.1 × 1019cm-3Background residual B only
Light B Concentration1.23 × 1020cm-3Optimal performance benchmark
Medium B Concentration1.591 × 1021cm-3
Heavy B Concentration2.583 × 1021cm-3
Ultra-heavy B Concentration7.516 × 1021cm-3Performance degradation onset
Median Grain Size (Ultra-light)1.42µm
Median Grain Size (Ultra-heavy)0.40µmSignificant grain refinement
Raman Diamond Peak1332cm-1Shifts left with higher B content
Raman Graphite Peak1580cm-1Visible only in ultra-heavy films
OEP — Ultra-light2.41VHighest oxygen evolution potential
OEP — Ultra-heavy2.22VLowest OEP
Rct Range65.34 → 3.83ΩDecreases with higher doping
CPE Range4.23 → 418.91µFIncreases with surface roughness
Scan Rate (CV)2-20mV s-1K4[Fe(CN)6]/K3[Fe(CN)6] redox probe
Scan Rate (CV — H2SO4)100mV s-10.05 M H2SO4
Current Density40-50mA cm-2Electrolysis operating condition
Anode Exposed Area20 × 25mm2
Electrolyte Volume0.5LCell capacity
Electrode Gap10mmAnode-cathode spacing
Stirring Speed150rpm
Max AC Concentration (Light BDD)681.73mg L-1Peak active chlorine yield
Final ClO3- (Light BDD)180.73mg L-1Lower than heavier doping
Final ClO4- (Light BDD)40.27mg L-1Lowest byproduct formation
Peak AC Current Efficiency54.54%
Peak Total Chlorine Efficiency85.02%
TC Degradation — ClO3- (Ultra-heavy)1.67-1.79×—Relative to light BDD
TC Degradation — ClO4- (Ultra-heavy)2.56-3.92×—Relative to light BDD

  1. Substrate Preparation: p-type monocrystalline silicon (20 × 25 × 1 mm) ultrasonically cleaned in 5-10 nm diamond suspension for 15 min to seed nucleation sites.
  2. HFCVD Deposition: Four parallel heating wires spaced 10 mm apart, positioned 8 mm above the substrate, operated at 3 kPa chamber pressure.
  3. Gas Recipe: H2 : B2H6 (5% in H2) : CH4 = 97 : x : 3.0 sccm, with x varied to produce five distinct doping tiers.
  4. Doping Categorization: Samples grouped as ultra-light (0-0.1 sccm), light (0.1-0.4 sccm), medium (0.4-1.2 sccm), heavy (1.2-2.0 sccm), and ultra-heavy (4.0 sccm).
  5. Surface Activation: Anodic polarization in 0.1 M H2SO4 at 5 V for 30 min to standardize surface terminals before electrochemical testing.
  6. Electrochemical Characterization: CV in 0.05 M H2SO4 (100 mV s-1) and K4[Fe(CN)6]/K3[Fe(CN)6] system (2-20 mV s-1); EIS measured for charge transfer resistance.
  7. Raman Spectroscopy: 532 nm excitation to quantify B-doping concentration, sp3/sp2 ratio, and crystallinity.
  8. Electrolysis Testing: 0.1 M NaCl at 50 mA cm-2, with DPD method for AC quantification and ion chromatography (ICS-3000) for ClO3-/ClO4-.
  9. Organic Wastewater Simulation: Tetracycline (TC) and glucose (GLu) at 0.1 g L-1 to validate real-world performance with competing oxidation reactions.

  • Applicable Materials: This study requires Lightly Boron-Doped Polycrystalline Diamond (BDD) with controlled doping in the 1020 cm-3 range — precisely the regime where 6CCVD’s customizable boron doping excels. For researchers seeking to extend this work to single-crystal platforms, our Optical Grade SCD can be doped to matched specifications.

  • Customization Potential: The paper employed 20 × 25 mm Si substrates for HFCVD growth. 6CCVD routinely fabricates BDD films on substrates up to 125 mm (PCD) and offers custom metalization (Ti, Pt, Au, Pd, W, Cu) for direct integration into electrochemical flow cells. Laser cutting services are available for non-standard geometries, enabling rapid prototyping of electrode arrays.

  • Engineering Support: Selecting the optimal B-doping concentration requires balancing grain size, OEP, and sp3/sp2 ratio — a multi-variable optimization problem. 6CCVD’s in-house PhD engineering team provides direct consultation on doping calibration, film thickness (0.1 µm - 500 µm), and surface finishing (Ra < 5 nm for inch-size PCD) to match your specific wastewater treatment or sensor application.

  • Reproducibility Advantage: Unlike the HFCVD filament geometry described (which can introduce B contamination variability), 6CCVD’s MPCVD processes deliver superior doping uniformity and lower defect density — critical when targeting the lightly doped regime where trace impurities disproportionately affect electrochemical performance.

Call to Action: For custom specifications, doping consultation, or material selection for your electrochemical oxidation research, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.

View Original Abstract

Boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrode is an excellent candidate for anodic electrochemical oxidation of wastewater. However, higher concentrations of ClO 3 − and ClO 4 − of biotoxicity was found during chloride electrolysis using BDD electrodes compared to other electrode materials. In this study, BDD electrodes with five different boron doping concentrations were fabricated on silicon substrates using hot-filament chemical vapor deposition (HFCVD) method. The physical and electrochemical characterisation were conducted, which confirmed that with the decrease of boron concentration, the crystal size of the diamond decreased, oxygen evolution potential decreased, charge transfer resistance decreased while the electro-active surface area (EASA) increased. The electrochemical oxidation experiments of NaCl solution were carried out with these five BDD electrodes and time-dependent traces of product concentrations, current efficiencies and energy consumptions were compared and discussed. When the boron concentration increased, the minimum energy required to produce unit active chlorine (AC) decreased initially then increased, the same tendency was found in the yields of ClO 3 − and ClO 4 − . The lightly doped BDD (1.23 × 10 20 cm −3 ) showed low energy consumption and high yield of AC, and low yields of ClO 3 − and ClO 4 − . Electrolysis of chlorine-containing organic wastewater was studied which further demonstrated the good performance of lightly doped BDD electrode.