Skip to content

Surface production of negative deuterium ions from plasma-exposed boron doped diamond and graphite - work function measurements using photoemission yield spectroscopy

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2023-07-01
JournalPlasma Sources Science and Technology
AuthorsR.J. Magee, Brandan Maurice, Joey Demiane, Jean-Marc Layet, Timo Gans
InstitutionsUniversity of York, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique
Citations3
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • Core Challenge: Investigates cesium-free alternatives for negative-ion surface production in fusion neutral beam injection (NBI) systems, directly comparing Boron-Doped Diamond (BDD) and Highly Oriented Pyrolytic Graphite (HOPG).
  • Methodology: Utilizes an Inductively Coupled Plasma (ICP) deuterium source (150 W, 2 Pa) coupled with in-situ Photoemission Yield Spectroscopy (PYS) and a Magnetized Retarding Field Energy Analyzer (MRFEA) to evaluate work function and negative-ion yield.
  • Key Material Finding: BDD exhibits an optimal negative-ion yield at 400°C - 500°C, whereas HOPG shows a continuous decrease in yield as temperature increases from 50°C to 750°C.
  • Electronic Distinction: The work function of HOPG strongly correlates with negative-ion current (metallic behavior), while the work function of BDD does not directly correlate (dielectric-like behavior), suggesting bulk-to-surface electron transport mechanisms differ significantly.
  • Maximum Photocurrent: Maximum photocurrent (Iph,max) trends closely mirror negative-ion current trends in both materials, implying a common driving mechanism tied to surface state and electronic transitions.
  • Engineering Significance: Validates BDD as a viable cesium-free material candidate for ion thrusters and magnetic confinement fusion reactors (e.g., ITER), specifically at elevated operating temperatures.
ParameterValueUnitContext
RF Generator Power150WInductively Coupled Plasma (ICP) source
RF Frequency13.56MHzStandard industrial plasma frequency
Operating Pressure2PaLow-pressure deuterium plasma
Deuterium Gas Flow7.4sccmFeed gas into the source region
Plasma Potential7VBulk plasma reference potential
Sample Bias (Low Energy)-60VDC voltage applied to sample
Sample Bias (High Energy)-130VDC voltage applied to sample
Positive Ion Current (Low E)22µAIncident on sample
Positive Ion Current (High E)26µAIncident on sample
Ion Flux (Low E)2.7 × 1018ions m-2 s-1Calculated flux density
Ion Flux (High E)3.2 × 1018ions m-2 s-1Calculated flux density
Sample Temperature Range50 - 750°CRegulated via tungsten filament
BDD Thickness3µmDeposited microcrystalline layer
BDD Charge Carrier Density~2.0 × 1020cm-3Heavy boron doping concentration
HOPG Surface Area12 × 12mm2ZYB grade graphite
HOPG Density2.265g cm-3Reference material property
HOPG Electrical Resistivity3.5 × 10-5Ω cmReference material property
PYS Light Source300WXenon lamp (200 nm < λ < 450 nm)
PYS Light Modulation35HzChopper frequency
PYS Wavelength Range200 - 450nmIncident photon energy scan
Cone Bias Voltage+7.5VElectron collection during PYS
BDD Peak Negative-Ion Yield~30nAObserved at 400°C - 500°C
BDD Work Function (Low T)3.3 - 3.6eVFluctuates between 50°C - 500°C
BDD Work Function (High T)4.2eVMeasured at 750°C
HOPG Work Function (Low T)~4.0eVMeasured at 50°C
HOPG Work Function (High T)~4.5eVMeasured at 750°C
HOPG Peak Negative-Ion Yield~12nAMeasured at 50°C
HOPG Peak Photocurrent~300pAMeasured at 200°C
  • Plasma Generation: Deploy an Inductively Coupled Plasma (ICP) using a 13.56 MHz RF generator at 150 W, fed with 7.4 sccm deuterium gas at 2 Pa chamber pressure.
  • Plasma Expansion: Allow the plasma to expand through a grounded mesh from the source region into the diffusion chamber to reach the sample stage.
  • Sample Mounting: Secure the BDD or HOPG sample using a molybdenum clamp on a four-axis holder with integrated tungsten heating and thermocouple feedback.
  • Plasma Exposure (Conditioning): Ignite the plasma for 30 minutes prior to testing to condition the chamber walls.
  • Thermal & Electrical Biasing: Heat the sample to the target temperature (50°C - 750°C) and apply a DC bias (-60 V or -130 V) for 5 minutes to stabilize surface conditions.
  • Plasma Shut-Down: Switch off the RF generator and gas supply to isolate the sample from external plasma influences.
  • Photocurrent Measurement: Illuminate the sample with a 35 Hz modulated 300 W xenon lamp via a monochromator (200 nm - 450 nm), measuring the resulting photocurrent with a lock-in amplifier.
  • Work Function Calculation: Apply the Fowler method to the photocurrent yield curves to extract the work function and assess electronic state changes.

The research described requires highly engineered, heavily doped diamond thin films capable of withstanding elevated temperatures (up to 750°C) while maintaining stable electronic properties under high-flux deuterium plasma bombardment. To replicate or extend this research, we recommend the following 6CCVD materials:

  • Heavy Boron Doped Polycrystalline Diamond (BDD): Our BDD wafers are synthesized via MPCVD and offer carrier densities in the range of 1019 - 1021 cm-3, matching the ~2.0 × 1020 cm-3 requirement observed in this study.
  • Optical Grade Single Crystal Diamond (SCD): For experiments requiring pristine surface states to isolate bandgap and Negative Electron Affinity (NEA) effects, our SCD plates provide unmatched crystallinity and polishing (Ra < 1 nm).
  • Custom Sputtered Diamond Films: If the 3 µm microcrystalline BDD layer needs to be deposited on non-standard substrates, our team can tailor deposition thickness (0.1 µm - 500 µm) and dopant gradients.

The paper utilizes specific sample dimensions (12 × 12 mm2) and exposes samples to thermal and electrical extremes. 6CCVD is fully equipped to support this:

  • Custom Dimensions: We provide custom laser cutting and dicing services for diamond plates and wafers up to 125 mm in diameter, accommodating both HOPG-sized samples and larger fusion-grade components.
  • Metalization & Clamping: The paper uses a molybdenum clamp to hold the sample under high heat. 6CCVD offers internal metalization capabilities (Ti, Pt, Au, W, Pd, Cu) to provide robust, ohmic, or brazed contacts directly onto the diamond surface, eliminating contact resistance issues during high-temperature plasma exposure.
  • Substrate Manufacturing: For researchers looking to integrate diamond into larger vacuum chamber arrays, our thick PCD substrates (up to 10 mm) provide excellent mechanical stability for retarding field energy analyzers (MRFEA) and plasma facing components.

Transitioning from graphite-based negative-ion sources to cesium-free diamond systems requires precise control over sp2/sp3 hybridization, doping uniformity, and surface morphology. The in-house PhD engineering team at 6CCVD specializes in material selection for extreme environment plasma applications, including fusion energy research, ion thrusters, and semiconductor processing. We can assist in optimizing boron dopant levels, surface polishing grades (Ra < 1 nm to < 5 nm), and hybrid polycrystalline/single-crystal architectures to maximize negative-ion surface production yield in your specific reactor or thruster geometry.

For custom specifications, heavy doping consultations, or material selection for negative-ion source development, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.

View Original Abstract

Abstract Negative-ion sources are of considerable interest for applications such as materials processing and neutral beam injection for magnetic confinement fusion. The efficient production of negative ions in these sources often relies on surface production. Work function measurements are critical to enable a detailed understanding of the mechanisms that underpin this. In this study we used a combination of photoemission yield spectroscopy and the Fowler method to determine the work functions of boron doped diamond (BDD) and highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG) directly after exposure to a low-pressure inductively coupled deuterium plasma (150 W, 2 Pa). A magnetised retarding field energy analyser is used to measure the negative ion current from the samples. During plasma exposure, samples are biased at −130 V or −60 V and their temperature is varied between 50 ∘ C and 750 ∘ C. The results show that the increasing work function of the plasma exposed HOPG occurs over the same sample temperature range as the decreasing negative-ion current. In contrast, the work function of BDD does not show a clear relationship with negative-ion current, suggesting that different mechanisms influence the negative-ion production of metal-like HOPG and dielectric-like BDD. The necessity for an additional fitting parameter for the Fowler fits to BDD suggests that its electronic properties are changing under plasma exposure, unlike HOPG. For both materials, the maximum photocurrent measured from the samples displays a strong similarity with negative-ion current, suggesting they are driven by a common mechanism. The in-situ measurement of the work function using non-invasive techniques is of interest for the development of negative ion sources.

  1. 2009 - High-energy negative ion beam obtained from pulsed inductively coupled plasma for charge-free etching process [Crossref]
  2. 2013 - Plasma etching: yesterday, today and tomorrow [Crossref]
  3. 2016 - Brief review on plasma propulsion with neutralizer-free systems [Crossref]
  4. 2015 - Alternate extraction and acceleration of positive and negative ions from a gridded plasma source [Crossref]
  5. 2015 - The PEGASES gridded ion-ion thruster performance and predictions [Crossref]
  6. 2010 - Interesting experimental results in Japan proton accelerator research complex H- ion-source development (invited) [Crossref]
  7. 2000 - Negative ion sources for high energy accelerators (invited) [Crossref]
  8. 2005 - Negative hydrogen ion sources for accelerators [Crossref]
  9. 2018 - An overview of negative hydrogen ion sources for accelerators [Crossref]
  10. 2020 - Achievement of the ITER NBI ion source parameters for hydrogen at the test facility ELISE and present Status for deuterium [Crossref]