Skip to content

Scratching of Diamond Substrate Using Fixed Ultra-Hard Abrasive Grain Tool

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2026-01-01
JournalInternational Journal of the Society of Materials Engineering for Resources
AuthorsHiroyuki MIZUMA, Masanobu Nakatsu, Tatsuya MIYOTA, Kota NAGAO, Ryota NAMIKI
InstitutionsNikon (Japan), Akita University
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • Core Challenge: Machining single-crystal diamond (SCD) substrates is notoriously difficult due to diamond’s extreme hardness and chemical inertness. Traditional polishing is extremely slow (cutting depth < 1 µm/km).
  • Material Investigation: Four ultra-hard candidates were evaluated as abrasive grains fixed to a wheel saw: Fullerene (C60), Wurtzite Boron Nitride (w-BN), Polycrystalline Diamond (PCD), and Flame Combustion-Synthesized Diamond (FCSD).
  • Key Finding — Grain Geometry Matters: Hardness alone is insufficient. Grain morphology (sharpness and size ≥ 8 µm) and fracture toughness dictate performance. Fullerene and w-BN crushed too easily (van der Waals bonding); PCD grains were too smooth.
  • Winning Abrasive: Flame Combustion-Synthesized Diamond (FCSD) was identified as the most promising abrasive. Its irregular, angular shape effectively initiates micro-cleavage fractures along the diamond’s (111) planes.
  • Operational Threshold: The transition from polishing to scratching requires a minimum load of ~2.7 N (275 gf), producing scratch widths of approximately 8 µm.
  • Strategic Implication: Future manufacturing requires saw wires equipped with FCSD grains to enable controlled brittle-fracture cutting rather than slow friction-based polishing.
ParameterValueUnitContext
Diamond Substrate Size4 × 4 × 0.5mmSCD workpiece dimensions
Wheel Saw Dimensionsφ16 × 0.5mmFixed-grain cutting tool
Cutting Load (Wheel Saw)~3NApplied normal force during cutting
Circumferential Speed~80m/minWheel saw rotational velocity
Polishing Speed< 1µm/km(Cutting depth / traveling distance)
Scratch Threshold Load≥ 2.7 (275 gf)NTransition from polish to scratch
Scratch Width~8µmAverage scratch width at 2.7 N
PCD Grain Size4 - 8µmSummitt Super Abrasive Co.
w-BN Max Grain Size10µmGoodfellow Cambridge
Fullerene Composition99% C60 / 1% C70—Frontier Carbon “Nanom Purple ST”
FCSD Film Thickness~20µmAs-synthesized film before crushing
FCSD Crushed Grain Size< 20µmPost-crushing in crucible
Brazing AlloyCu 85 / Sn 15wt%Bronze brazing filler
Reducing AgentTiH2—Generates reducing atmosphere in vacuum furnace
Cleavage Plane Exploited(111)—Secondary cracks indicate brittle fracture along this plane
Substrate Orientation(100)—Workpiece crystal face
  • Material Selection: Four ultra-hard grain candidates (Fullerene, w-BN, PCD, FCSD) containing elements with consecutive atomic numbers (B, C, N) were selected.
  • Grain Fixation: Abrasive grains were brazed onto a steel wheel saw substrate using a Cu-Sn (85/15) bronze alloy in a high-temperature, high-vacuum furnace.
  • Atmosphere Control: TiH2 was added to the brazing setup to decompose and generate a reducing atmosphere, overcoming the poor wettability between ceramics and the brazing material.
  • Wheel Saw Machining: A φ16 × 0.5 mm rotating wheel saw was applied to a 4 × 4 × 0.5 mm SCD plate under ~3 N load at ~80 m/min circumferential speed.
  • Grinding (Fracture Toughness) Test: Grains were sandwiched between two diamond plates and subjected to compressive forces from 0 to 4 N to assess fracture behavior.
  • Single-Tip Scratching Test: An indenter with variable load (0-3 N) was used to identify the critical load threshold separating polishing from scratching regimes.
  • Surface Analysis: Post-machining SCD surfaces were examined optically to identify scratch morphology, width, and secondary crack propagation along (111) cleavage planes.
  • Applicable Materials:

    • For replicating the workpiece in this study, our Optical Grade Single Crystal Diamond (SCD) plates are ideal. We supply SCD in custom dimensions up to 125 mm (PCD) with thicknesses from 0.1 µm to 500 µm, and substrates up to 10 mm thick for structural/mechanical test coupons.
    • For replicating the abrasive grain source, 6CCVD manufactures high-purity Polycrystalline Diamond (PCD) via MPCVD with controlled grain structures — directly applicable for tool insert fabrication when fine, uniform grain sizes are required.
    • For applications requiring electrical conductivity during scratching/EDM combined machining, our Heavy Boron-Doped Diamond (BDD) provides tunable resistivity while maintaining extreme hardness.
  • Customization Potential:

    • This paper relies on highly specific abrasive grains and brazed tool geometries. 6CCVD supports full-stack customization: we can deliver diamond materials pre-shaped or laser-cut to your tool substrate specifications.
    • Our in-house metallization capabilities (Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, Cu) enable us to apply custom adhesion layers (e.g., Ti bonding layers) directly to diamond surfaces, facilitating integration into brazed or soldered tool assemblies like the Cu-Sn/TiH2 system described in the paper.
    • Surface finishing is controlled to Ra < 1 nm (SCD) and < 5 nm (inch-size PCD), ensuring reference-grade workpiece quality for controlled abrasion experiments.
  • Engineering Support:

    • 6CCVD’s in-house PhD engineering team can assist with material selection, crystal orientation optimization (e.g., (100) vs. (111) surface preparation), and grain-size matching for your specific diamond machining or ultra-hard tooling research. Whether you are developing next-generation saw wires, dicing blades, or scratch-testing protocols, our team provides consultative support from prototype to scale.
  • Call to Action:

    • For custom specifications, metallization consultation, or material selection for your diamond machining R&D, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.
View Original Abstract

Scratching tests of a diamond substrate were performed using a tool fixed with four types of grains potentially harder than diamond. Materials reported by other researchers to be harder than diamonds often contain combinations of carbon, boron, and nitrogen. From the viewpoint of manufacturing, fullerene, wurtzite (hexagonal lattice boron nitride), polycrystalline diamond, and flame-synthesized diamond were selected in this study. After creating and testing saw wires and wheel saws, flame combustion synthetic diamond was determined to be the most promising. This is because only scratches from flame combustionsynthesized diamond initiate cleavage fracture.