Skip to content

Determination of Cutting Performance of Multi-blade and Diamond-wire Gang Saws Used in Natural Stone Cutting

FieldValue
JournalMining Metallurgy & Exploration
Published2026-03-28
AuthorsA. K. Özdogan, M. Karaabat Varol, S. Demirdag
DOI10.1007/s42461-026-01540-0
Citations1

Diamond-wire gang sawing produced 1.16 m²/h across the tested stones, about three times the 0.38 m²/h of the multi-blade saw. The paper reports 244 kWh/m² for the wire saw against 332 kWh/m² for the blade saw and describes the blade saw as 36% higher. Sockets wore 3.8 times as much as diamond beads over equal slab areas.

The comparison ran at a natural stone plant in Türkiye. The authors cut 38 blocks of dolomite, limestone, marble, calcschist, and Lymra limestone into 2 cm slabs.

The multi-blade machine carried 75 blades and used a fixed rate of 20 cm/h. Each blade carried 28 silver-welded sockets, with a 600 mm reciprocating stroke.

The diamond-wire machine carried 76 wires and ran at 80 cm/h. Its 20 m endless loop used sintered, plastic-coated beads spaced 37 per metre. The paper specifies 6.3 mm beads on a 3.2 mm steel wire. The bond matrix contained Fe, Ni, Co, Cu, and Sn, with 40/50 to 50/60 mesh diamond abrasive.

Measurements covered block dimensions, cutting time, electrical energy, water, bead and socket dimensions, and poor-quality slab counts. Rock characterization covered uniaxial compressive strength (UCS), density, porosity, water absorption, chemical composition, and petrographic structure.

UCS testing followed TS EN 1926 and used eight 50 × 50 × 50 mm cubes. Density and porosity followed TS EN 1936, while water absorption followed TS EN 13755. Chemical and petrographic characterization used TS EN 15309 and TS EN 12407.

Mean cutting rates and the rock properties used for interpretation are shown below.

StoneWire rate, m²/hBlade rate, m²/hUCS, MPaOpen porosity, %
Dolomite1.14 ± 0.190.32 ± 0.07146 ± 202.06 ± 0.37
Limestone1.11 ± 0.180.42 ± 0.12124.7 ± 5.30.43 ± 0.04
Marble1.28 ± 0.200.38 ± 0.0570 ± 130.20 ± 0.01
Calcschist1.20 ± 0.090.28 ± 0.05130 ± 240.70 ± 0.01
Lymra limestone1.03 ± 0.380.44 ± 0.0452 ± 48.80 ± 0.73

The wire saw led for every stone type. UCS alone did not show a significant relationship with cutting performance across all five stones. Removing Lymra limestone produced a significant inverse relationship between UCS and performance. Its high porosity and low strength weakened that correlation. The authors therefore gave more weight to composition, grain structure, and porosity than to UCS alone.

The paper’s overall unit consumption was 244 kWh/m² for the wire saw and 332 kWh/m² for the blade saw. The blade mean is 36% above the wire mean on this basis. The comparison uses overall values rather than a uniform block-by-block difference.

Rock-specific wire means ranged from 196 ± 22.80 to 307 ± 93.22 kWh/m². Marble was the lowest wire case at 196 ± 22.80 kWh/m². The blade means ranged from 267 ± 24.17 to 425 ± 85.36 kWh/m², with calcschist highest. The authors linked calcschist demand to its 15.20% SiO₂ and higher abrasiveness.

Wire-saw energy had a poor UCS relationship until Lymra limestone was removed, after which the relationship was moderate. Open porosity showed a strong relationship with wire-saw energy consumption. This indicates that rock structure and cutter-rock interaction may explain more variation than compressive strength alone.

Rock-specific mean use was 54.44 to 74.40 L/m² for the wire saw and 99.94 to 164.56 L/m² for the blade saw. The water feed rates were 1140 L/min for the wire saw and 750 L/min for the blade saw.

The wire saw still used less total water because its shorter cutting time reduced operating time. The authors conclude that its consumption was below 50% for similar block volume and cutting area.

UCS had little effect on wire-saw water use, while open porosity had a strong relationship. The authors suggest adjusting supply to the physical and mechanical properties of each stone. They treat this as an operating recommendation rather than a measured optimization result.

Mean diamond-bead wear was 0.0083 to 0.0097 mm per m² of slab. Mean socket wear was 0.0262 to 0.0409 mm per m². The paper’s overall values were 0.0089 mm for beads and 0.034 mm for sockets. This made socket wear 3.8 times the bead wear.

Bead wear was lowest in Lymra limestone and marble, and highest in dolomite and limestone. Open porosity was more closely related to socket wear than UCS. This supports the paper’s argument that abrasive composition, grain structure, and porosity affect cutter wear.

Surface-quality counts were similar for the two saws. Pre-existing cracks within blocks were the main cause of poor slabs, rather than saw type. The measured counts therefore did not show a large quality advantage for either cutting method.

The authors used ENTROPY weights because limited availability of diamond-wire gang saws prevented reliable user or expert evaluation. TOPSIS then ranked energy consumption, cutting quality, cutting time, and bead or socket wear.

The weights were 0.1228, 0.0915, 0.3584, and 0.4273, respectively. Cutting time and wear received the largest weights. Water was measured but excluded from TOPSIS because the authors reported a lack of variation across alternatives.

The final closeness coefficient was 0.9992 for the diamond-wire saw and 0.0008 for the multi-blade saw. Separate rock rankings selected the wire saw for all five stones, with coefficients from 0.9960 to 1.0000. The multi-blade saw had the higher aggregate cutting-quality value, 0.9880 against 0.9830, but this did not change the overall result.

Earlier work cited in the paper reported that blade gang saws produced slabs at about three times the rate of circular saws. That comparison differs from this threefold wire-to-blade result.

Mendoza et al. compared environmental performance through life cycle assessment. Turchetta et al. examined wire cutting forces, pre-twist, tension, and bead wear. The present work adds a direct field comparison with energy, water, time, quality, and wear measured across five stones.

The evidence is bounded by one plant, five stone types, and 38 blocks. The wire saw ran at 80 cm/h, while the blade saw ran at 20 cm/h. The measured threefold gain therefore does not separate machine design from the imposed operating-speed difference.

Table 9 places Lymra limestone highest for wire-saw energy, while the narrative names dolomite. The paper also states that wire saws can cut slabs from 1.2 to 10 cm, while multi-blade saws commonly use 1.6, 2, or 3 cm. This is a machine capability claim rather than a trial result.

Operators can use the reported values for preliminary selection when throughput, energy, water, and wear dominate. A plant should confirm performance with its own stones, block dimensions, and production plan before purchase.

View Original Abstract

Abstract The objective of this study was to investigate the cutting performance of multi-blade and diamond-wire gang saws used in natural stone plants and to determine the more economical option. In the first phase, five different natural stones with varying physical-mechanical properties were cut using both gang saws, and key operational parameters were measured and compared, including cutting speed, bead/socket wear, energy consumption, water consumption, and surface quality of the slabs. The results revealed significant performance differences between the two cutting technologies. The diamond-wire gang saw achieved a cutting speed that was three times higher than that of the multi-blade gang saw. In terms of energy efficiency, a diamond-wire gang saw represents a 36% lower energy consumption than a multi-blade gang saw. The diamond-wire gang saw uses 50% less water than the multi-blade gang saw in terms of water consumption. In the second phase of the study, the ENTROPY-based TOPSIS method was applied to evaluate the two gang saws with respect to energy consumption, cutting quality, cutting time, and bead/socket wear. Consequently, based on this multi-criteria analysis, the diamond-wire gang saw was identified as the superior option, offering advantages in economic efficiency, cutting precision, and operational speed.