Skip to content

Application of Simultaneous Chemical and Electrochemical Oxidation Treatment (O3–EO) in River Water and Its Pollutant and Phytotoxicity Evaluation

FieldValue
JournalCatalysts
Published2026-05-21
AuthorsAriana de la Cruz-Hernández, Gabriela Roa-Morales, Carlos Barrera-Díaz, Lilia Tapia-López, Cinthya Pamela Del Río Galván
DOI10.3390/catal16050486

Simultaneous ozonation and electrochemical oxidation removed 98% of turbidity and 80% of TOC from wastewater treatment plant influent after 120 min. In Lerma River water, the combined process removed 94% of COD and 95% of turbidity after 60 min. Both results came from 1 L laboratory tests that used different currents for the two water matrices.

Water sampleTreatment time (min)pHTurbidity (TU)COD (mg/L)
Wastewater treatment plant inlet1208.635971750
Lerma River water607.64343.61275

The inlet sample contained 992.3 mg/L TOC and 9.26 mS/cm conductivity. River water contained 283.2 mg/L TOC and 0.77 mS/cm conductivity. Their color coefficients at 436 nm were 428.42 and 12.11 m−1, respectively.

Treatment times were selected to account for the different contaminant loads. The river matrix therefore received 60 min of treatment, while the plant influent received 120 min. The different treatment times and currents limit direct comparisons between the two matrices.

Two composite samples were collected during the dry season under NMX-AA-003-1980. One came from the treatment plant inlet. The other came from the Lerma River downstream of the plant. Both were refrigerated immediately after collection.

All tests used a 1 L working volume in an ascending-flow glass reactor. Ozone flow was 30 mL min−1, and EO received air without ozone. BDD electrodes measured 22 × 2 × 0.3 cm. Current was 3 A for wastewater and 0.5 A for river water, giving 33.14 and 5.52 A m−2. The combined process applied ozone and current simultaneously. No supporting electrolyte was added.

Turbidity and COD measurements were run in triplicate. COD used 2 mL of sample, digestion at 150 °C for 2 h, and measurement at 620 nm. TOC used catalytic combustion at 680 °C with non-dispersive infrared detection. Color was measured at 436, 525, and 620 nm in a 1 mm quartz cuvette. Each treatment configuration was run in triplicate, and mean values were reported.

After 120 min in plant influent, ozonation removed 62% of COD and 90% of turbidity. EO removed 57% of TOC, compared with 19% for ozone.

For the 60 min river tests, ozone removed nearly 80% of COD and 66.6% of turbidity. EO removed 81.8% of COD and 89% of turbidity.

Ozone produced about 90% true-color removal at 436 and 525 nm in river water. EO gave 20.5% to 26.9% removal, while the combined process exceeded 70%. The metrics therefore favored different oxidants. Ozone was more effective for color removal, while EO gave stronger turbidity and carbon removal.

The wastewater COD curve reached approximately 96% after 120 min with the combined process. For plant influent, true-color removal at 436 nm reached 98.9% for the combined treatment. EO reached 94.7%, and ozone reached 67.3%.

River water gave 41.1% TOC removal with the combined process, close to 41.6% with EO. The COD data fit a pseudo-first-order model. Combined-process rate constants were 0.0233 min−1 for plant effluent and 0.047 min−1 for river water. The EO rate constant was 0.02009 min−1 under the selected conditions.

The authors attribute the combined response to bulk-phase ozone reactions and surface-bound hydroxyl radicals at the BDD anode. They also propose chlorine radicals, hypochlorite, and chlorate as contributing oxidants in chloride-containing matrices. The paper did not quantify each reactive species separately. The authors linked the results to the non-acidic initial pH values of 8.63 and 7.64, which favored ozone decomposition and radical generation.

The paper cites ozone nanobubbles with EO that achieved 81.1% COD and 42% TSS removal in textile wastewater under neutral pH and low voltage. The present 94% river-water COD result was higher, but the matrices and reactors differed.

Phytotoxicity testing used centrifuged supernatant from raw and combined-treated river water. A 5 mL aliquot was centrifuged for 15 min at 12,000 rpm and 4 °C. Four millilitres of supernatant were placed with six Lactuca sativa seeds. Tubes were held at 25 °C in darkness for seven days. Germination required a root protrusion of at least 2 mm. Distilled water served as the control.

Relative germination was 53 ± 12% for raw water and 80 ± 1% for treated water. These values differed significantly at p ≤ 0.05. Raw water reduced relative germination by 47%, while treated water reduced it by 20%.

Relative radicle growth was 42 ± 6% for raw water and 51 ± 10% for treated water. Germination index was 22 ± 6% and 41 ± 8%, respectively. Neither metric differed significantly between the two waters. The treatment therefore improved germination without fully resolving radicle-related effects.

The authors infer that incomplete mineralization left phytotoxic intermediate products. No individual transformation products were identified, so their composition remains unresolved.

Estimated energy-only operating cost was 5.3 to 11.1 USD m−3. EO was 5.3 USD m−3, and the combined process was 11.1 USD m−3. The calculation used an electricity price of 1.3 MXN kWh−1, approximately 0.075 USD kWh−1. River-water EO-based treatments had slightly lower costs because they required less current.

These costs were higher than full-scale or optimized values cited by the authors, but consistent with laboratory-scale advanced oxidation. The estimate includes only energy consumption. The authors describe the values as preliminary and call for site-specific equipment, process optimization, and lower-cost operation before wider use.

The abstract assigns the 98% turbidity and 80% TOC values to river water. The detailed Results, Discussion, and Conclusions place those values in the 120 min wastewater matrix. River water is reported as 95% turbidity and 41.1% TOC after 60 min. The abstract also describes no significant phytotoxicity difference, while Table 1 shows a significant germination difference. These reporting differences need resolution before design or regulatory comparisons.

The BDD anode was chosen for its high oxygen evolution overpotential, chemical inertness, and ability to generate surface-bound hydroxyl radicals. These properties support oxidation at the electrode surface while limiting competing reactions.

The study selected current according to conductivity and contaminant load. The 33.14 A m−2 wastewater condition and 5.52 A m−2 river condition cannot be transferred directly to another matrix. Water chemistry, ozone dosage, pH, chloride content, and reactor mass transfer need site-specific evaluation.

The paper does not report long-term electrode durability, cell voltage, ozone transfer efficiency, or transformation-product profiles. Bulk removal indices therefore establish short-term treatment performance but leave material durability and oxidation byproducts unresolved.

The paper requires boron-doped diamond as the active anode material for electrochemical oxidation of contaminated river water. 6CCVD’s diamond materials catalog includes boron-doped diamond, while the engineering support page can help assess an electrode configuration against the reported cell conditions.

View Original Abstract

Continuous discharges from diverse industrial activities have severely degraded the water quality of the Lerma River, turning it into a major environmental, social, and public health concern. Conventional wastewater treatment processes are often insufficient for eliminating persistent and refractory organic pollutants; therefore, the implementation of advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) is increasingly required to restore water quality. In this context, the present study systematically evaluated the individual and combined effects of ozonation and electrochemical oxidation using boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrodes for the treatment of contaminated river water. Ozonation alone achieved an 89% reduction in turbidity and a 19% decrease in total organic carbon (TOC), while electrochemical oxidation reduced turbidity by 82% and TOC by 57%. Remarkably, the simultaneous application of both treatments resulted in a 98% reduction in turbidity and an 80% decrease in TOC, clearly demonstrating a strong synergistic effect. Regarding true color at 436 nm, associated with yellow chromophore compounds, removal efficiencies of 98.9%, 94.7%, and 67.3% were obtained for the combined process, electrochemical oxidation, and ozonation, respectively. Phytotoxicity tests with Lactuca sativa seeds showed no statistically significant difference in toxicity in water treated with the O3-EO System compared to raw water. These results highlight, for the first time under real river water conditions, the superior performance of the integrated O3-EO system as an effective strategy for the intensified degradation and partial mineralization of persistent organic contaminants, thereby underscoring its strong potential for advanced remediation of heavily polluted surface waters.

  1. 2021 - Ozonation of 47 organic micropollutants in secondary treated municipal effluents: Direct and indirect kinetic reaction rates and modelling [Crossref]
  2. 2020 - Photocatalytic ozonation of wastewater: A review [Crossref]
  3. 2024 - Hydroxyl radicals in ozone-based advanced oxidation of organic contaminants: A review [Crossref]
  4. 2020 - Enhanced degradation of atrazine by microbubble ozonation [Crossref]
  5. 2020 - Nano-catalysts in ozone-based advanced oxidation processes for wastewater treatment [Crossref]
  6. 2020 - Electrochemical oxidative degradation of X-6G dye by boron-doped diamond anodes: Effect of operating parameters [Crossref]