Skip to content

Urban wastewater treatment with combinations of electrooxidation – photocatalysis and electrocoagulation – photocatalysis

FieldValue
JournalSpringer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology)
Published2026-07-27
AuthorsDemetrios Marmanis, Kalliopi Ladomenou, Jacob G. Fantidis, Kyriaki Marmani, Vassiliki Mesazou
DOI10.1051/e3sconf/202672703007/pdf

UV-assisted electrooxidation reduced COD from 516 mg/L to below 50 mg/L in 1 h at 600 mA and 10 V. The 300 mL sample began at pH 8.3. Each result averaged three repeats, with reported variation below 3%.

The boron-doped diamond anode and Ti/Pt cathode gave the shortest reported time to the COD limit. Without UV, they reached below 50 mg/L after 2 h. With UV, they reached below 50 mg/L after 1 h under the same 600 mA and 10 V conditions.

Al/Al electrocoagulation at 400 mA and 4 V was the authors’ preferred balance for the village system. It left 67 mg/L COD after 2 h at 10.67 Wh/L. The visible-light hybrid reached below 50 mg/L after 2 h with the same electrical use. The UV hybrid reached below 50 mg/L after 1.5 h with added lamp use.

All eight measurement sets used a 300 mL electrochemical cell connected to a DC power supply. The electrooxidation cell used a BDD anode and a Ti/Pt cathode. The UV source was a 50 W lamp at 385 nm, positioned 15 cm from the sample.

Measured parameters included COD, pH, temperature, and electrical consumption. The COD meter was a TR 420 with reactor, while pH came from a WTW meter. A conductivity meter, Spectroquant Pharo 100 photometer, and magnetic stirrer were also used.

The methods state that every experiment began at 516 mg/L COD and pH 8.3. Each run ended when COD approached the equipment limit below 50 mg/L. Treatment time was therefore set by measured COD rather than a fixed schedule.

Without UV, COD fell from 516 mg/L to 229 mg/L after 1 h. It then fell below 50 mg/L after 2 h, while electrical use reached 40 Wh/L. The measured pH rose from 8.3 to 8.37 after 1 h and 9.7 after 2 h.

With UV, COD reached 94 mg/L after 0.5 h and below 50 mg/L after 1 h. The measured pH was 7.15 after 0.5 h and 6.9 after 1 h. The table reports energy use of 20+50 Wh/L at 1 h.

The authors warn against adding lamp and electrolysis energy values for direct comparison. The lamp can operate on a larger quantity than the 0.3 L experimental sample.

At 400 mA and 4 V, Al/Al electrodes lowered COD from 516 mg/L to 243 mg/L after 1 h. COD was 67 mg/L after 2 h, and electrical use was 10.67 Wh/L. At 600 mA and 5 V, COD reached 198 mg/L after 1 h and 62 mg/L after 2 h. Electrical use was 20 Wh/L at 2 h.

The lower-current run used 10.67 Wh/L instead of 20 Wh/L and produced a similar final COD. The authors therefore treated Al/Al operation at 400 mA and 4 V as the optimum electrocoagulation condition.

Fe/Fe electrodes performed poorly. At 400 mA and 4 V, COD was 463 mg/L after 1 h and 322 mg/L after 2 h. At 600 mA and 5 V, COD was 432 mg/L after 0.5 h and 297 mg/L after 1 h. The authors found no advantage from iron’s lower electrode cost because final COD remained high.

The endpoint data below preserve the paper’s energy notation.

ConfigurationCurrent and voltageLast reported timeCOD at that time, mg/LReported energy use, Wh/L
Electrooxidation, BDD/TiPt600 mA, 10 V2 h<5040
Electrooxidation plus UV600 mA, 10 V1 h<5020+50
Electrocoagulation, Al/Al400 mA, 4 V2 h6710.67
Electrocoagulation, Al/Al600 mA, 5 V2 h6220
Electrocoagulation, Fe/Fe400 mA, 4 V2 h32210.67
Electrocoagulation, Fe/Fe600 mA, 5 V1 h29710
Al/Al plus visible light400 mA, 4 V2 h<5010.67
Al/Al plus UV400 mA, 4 V1.5 h<508+50

Visible-light photocatalysis was combined with Al/Al electrocoagulation at 400 mA and 4 V. COD fell to 233 mg/L after 0.5 h, 146 mg/L after 1 h, and 106 mg/L after 1.5 h. It reached below 50 mg/L after 2 h while electrical use remained 10.67 Wh/L.

The results describe the light source as sunlight, although the setup is labeled visible-light photocatalysis. The authors suggest that a transparent tank could improve treatment during summer.

The UV-lamp hybrid reached 98 mg/L COD after 0.5 h and 67 mg/L after 1 h. COD fell below 50 mg/L after 1.5 h, with 8+50 Wh/L reported in the table.

Compared with electrooxidation, UV shortened the time to the COD limit from 2 h to 1 h. Compared with visible light, it shortened the Al/Al treatment time from 2 h to 1.5 h. The paper says direct energy comparisons remain uncertain because the lamp can treat more than the 0.3 L sample volume.

The photovoltaic design used RETScreen Clean Energy Project Analysis Software. PVGIS data from 2005 through 2023 provided solar radiation at the optimum panel angle. Daily average global irradiation ranged from 2.49 kWh/m² in December to 7.15 kWh/m² in July.

Hortokopi had 355 residents in the 2021 census. The design assumed water needs of approximately 200 L per person per day. Demand was calculated from 10.67 Wh/L and the modeled populations of 400 citizens in winter and 800 residents in summer.

The simulated plant had 13 kW rated installed power, 92% inverter efficiency, and 10% general losses. Generated energy exceeded monthly demand in every month. Excess energy was lowest in November and highest in July.

The authors state that direct-current demand allowed the system to operate without an inverter. The paper reports consistency with prior photovoltaic-powered electrocoagulation work and lower photovoltaic energy cost. It does not provide a side-by-side cost calculation, so that comparison remains qualitative. The authors suggest selling excess energy to the grid for greater economic benefit.

Unresolved issues and engineering implications

Section titled “Unresolved issues and engineering implications”

Treatment used 300 mL samples, while the 13 kW result came from simulation rather than a full-scale trial. The study reports COD, pH, temperature, and energy, but gives no full wastewater composition or contaminant-specific removal. It also gives no electrode area, diamond thickness, surface finish, electrode spacing, or treatment flow rate.

The reported 600 mA condition cannot be converted to current density without electrode area. It also does not define a scaled BDD surface specification. Initial pH is inconsistent across the paper. The methods state 8.3 for every experiment, while electrocoagulation tables list initial values from 7.73 to 7.96. This discrepancy should be resolved before scaling the process.

The UV energy entries also need clarification. Tables include +50 Wh/L, while the text warns that the 0.3 L lamp experiments cannot be compared directly with larger-volume operation. RETScreen used 92% inverter efficiency, which the paper does not reconcile with its statement that no inverter is required.

Engineers can treat Al/Al at 400 mA and 4 V as the paper’s village-scale candidate. The BDD/TiPt system gives the fastest COD result, but its overall energy advantage was not established. Continuous flow, seasonal wastewater variation, electrode durability, and full-scale photovoltaic operation were not tested.

The tested electrooxidation cell used boron-doped diamond as the anode and Ti/Pt as the cathode. 6CCVD lists boron-doped diamond in its diamond materials catalog. Because the paper leaves diamond area, thickness, surface finish, and electrode spacing undefined, those requirements should be defined with the supplier’s engineering support.

View Original Abstract

Water quality of is an issue of vital importance in every aspect of everyday life. The improvement of the quality of wastewater aligns with this direction. Electrocoagulation and electrooxidation were the two methods which used in the presented work. In the case of electrooxidation, experiments were carried out with a current of 600 mA and a voltage of 10 volts with BDD and Ti/Pt electrodes for two cases: with and without the use of UV photocatalysis. The electrocoagulation experiments included six different cases: Al/Al electrodes with a current of 400 mA and 600 mA, Fe/Fe electrodes with a current of 400 mA and 600 mA, Al/Al electrodes with a current of 400 mA and 600 mA, combination of electrocoagulation with Al/Al electrodes at a current of 400 mA and visible-light photocatalysis and a combination of electrocoagulation with Al/Al electrodes at a current of 400 mA and UV photocatalysis. A small village named Hortokopi, near Kavala was used as a case study. All required energy was supplied by an autonomous photovoltaic power plant, designed using the RETScreen Clean Energy Management Software.