Skip to content

Application of response surface methodology (RSM) for optimization and electrochemical oxidation of three mixed antibiotics at boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrodes

FieldValue
JournalDesalination and Water Treatment
Published2026-08-14
AuthorsMD Tanvir Hasnine, Qiuyan Yuan
DOI10.1016/j.dwt.2026.101894
Citations1

Optimized H2O2-assisted Nb/BDD electrooxidation removed 97% of sulfanilamide (SN), 95.50% of tetracycline hydrochloride (TC-HCl), and 88% of sulfamethazine (SMZ) after 90 min. The optimum used 30 mA/cm², pH 4.95, 2.5 mM H2O2, and 6000 µg/L of each antibiotic. TOC fell from 85 to 20 mg/L under the same condition, corresponding to 76.47% removal. The run consumed 66 kWh/m³, with an estimated electrical cost of 6.51 CAD/m³.

The treatment matrix was biologically treated synthetic wastewater rather than raw wastewater. Its sCOD was 150 mg/L, TOC 85 mg/L, TAN 14 mg/L, and soluble phosphorus 2.2 mg/L. Each antibiotic was spiked to 6000 to 12000 µg/L before electrooxidation.

The 3.0 L acrylic batch reactor used two Nb/BDD anodes and two stainless steel cathodes. Total active anodic area was 400 cm², the inter-electrode gap was 3 mm, and mixing was 450 rpm. Applied currents of 6, 8, 10, 12, and 14 A corresponded to 15 to 35 mA/cm².

Preliminary treatment times were 30, 60, 90, and 120 min. The authors selected 90 min because it gave consistent, high removal without extending electrolysis. Every run was performed in triplicate.

H2O2 was added externally from a 30% solution. The stainless steel cathodes were not designed for selective two-electron oxygen reduction, so the study did not use in situ H2O2 generation.

Residual antibiotics were measured by gradient HPLC with UV detection at 254 nm after particulate-removal steps. TOC was measured by high-temperature catalytic combustion at 680 °C.

A 30-run central composite design in Design-Expert 7.0.0 fitted quadratic models for removal at 90 min. The modeled factors were current density, pH, H2O2 dose, and initial antibiotic concentration. Their stated ranges were 15 to 35 mA/cm², pH 3.60 to 9.00, 1.0 to 3.0 mM H2O2, and 6000 to 12000 µg/L per antibiotic. Treatment time was fixed at 90 min rather than included as a response factor.

Each quadratic removal model had p < 0.0001. R² was 0.9853 for SN, 0.9197 for TC-HCl, and 0.9844 for SMZ. Adjusted R² values were 0.9715, 0.8447, and 0.9699, respectively.

Predicted R² was 0.9261 for SN, 0.6469 for TC-HCl, and 0.9300 for SMZ. The TC-HCl model therefore had lower predictive capability than the other two models.

The response models identify current density as the main shared driver. The SN model included current density, pH, initial concentration, and current density squared as significant terms. TC-HCl depended on initial concentration, the current density by concentration interaction, and current density squared. SMZ also showed current density, H2O2 dose, initial concentration, and interaction effects.

TC-HCl had the highest and broadest response region. SN showed weaker curvature and a stronger current-density effect. SMZ was most sensitive to the balance between H2O2 and pollutant loading. Its highest modeled removal occurred at higher H2O2 and lower initial concentration.

The authors describe water oxidation at the BDD surface as producing weakly adsorbed, surface-bound hydroxyl radicals. They propose that mildly acidic conditions raise the oxidative potential of hydroxyl radicals and reduce radical losses through oxygen evolution. Scavenger tests and controlled EPR measurements were not performed, so the study did not partition oxidation among reactive species.

Multi-response desirability optimization maximized all three removals with equal weight. The solution was 30 mA/cm², pH 4.95, 2.5 mM H2O2, and 6000 µg/L of each antibiotic after 90 min. Overall desirability was 0.817.

ResponsePredicted removal (%)Experimental removal (%)Reported error (%)Individual desirability
SN95.3297.001.730.929
TC-HCl92.3595.504.300.851
SMZ86.1688.004.270.688

The selected solution sat at the upper current and H2O2 limits and the lower pH and concentration limits of the stated optimization criteria. It is therefore an optimum within that desirability domain, not proof of a physical limit. Section 3.3 prose reports 96.50% TC-HCl removal once, while Table 6 and the conclusion report 95.50%.

Mineralization, energy, and operating cost

Section titled “Mineralization, energy, and operating cost”

TOC fell from 85 mg/L before treatment to 20 mg/L after 90 min at the optimum, corresponding to 76.47% removal. The TOC result applies to bulk organic carbon, not a compound-specific carbon balance. It supports oxidation beyond parent-compound disappearance, although transformation products were not identified. The reported mineralization current efficiency was about 9.7%.

The 90 min run used 0.198 kWh for the 3.0 L batch, or 66 kWh/m³. Removing 195 mg of TOC required 1015 kWh/kg. At Manitoba Hydro’s industrial rate of 9.864 cents/kWh, the estimated electrical cost was 6.51 CAD/m³ and 100.1 CAD/kg TOC removed.

The paper cites BDD sulfamethoxazole treatment with complete parent removal after 3 h and 65.6% COD removal. It also cites pulsed BDD levofloxacin treatment at 94.4% COD removal in 120 min and 81.43 kWh/m³. These figures provide context rather than direct comparisons because the contaminants, matrices, metrics, and reactor conditions differ.

The result applies to a synthetic matrix after biological treatment. The RSM did not include a zero-H2O2 condition, and the authors did not compare TOC, energy, or cost with matched electrooxidation without H2O2. The data therefore optimize H2O2-assisted treatment but do not establish that H2O2 improves it over electrooxidation alone.

Only short-term reproducibility was assessed. The study did not perform consecutive reuse tests, long-term cycling, cell-voltage monitoring, or pre-use and post-use surface analysis. Gradual activity loss and minor fouling therefore cannot be excluded. Transformation products, toxicity, and the contribution of individual radicals remain unresolved.

The authors warn that chloride, sulfate, bicarbonate, ammonia, and natural organic matter may change radical chemistry, by-product formation, and current efficiency in real matrices. They call for tests with municipal or hospital wastewater, continuous flow, electrocoagulation pretreatment where solids are present, and monitoring of scaling, electrode wear, dissolved metals, and sludge.

The results support Nb/BDD as an anode material for advanced oxidation of antibiotic mixtures. The authors state that BDD stability depends on boron doping, sp3/sp2 carbon content, diamond film integrity, substrate properties, surface chemistry, and water composition. Those properties and the treated-water matrix should be included in material selection alongside the 30 mA/cm² operating result.

The tested device configuration used 400 cm² of active anodic area, a 3 mm gap, 12 A at the optimum, controlled pH, and external H2O2 addition. The reported mineralization current efficiency was about 9.7%. The authors therefore position the process as an advanced polishing step rather than a bulk treatment stage.

Antibiotic-wastewater electrooxidation needs a conductive boron-doped diamond anode for a 12 A run over 400 cm², although the paper omits boron level, film thickness, surface finish, and niobium attachment method. 6CCVD’s diamond materials catalog lists boron-doped diamond, Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, or Cu metallization, and polishing to Ra below 1 nm for single-crystal or below 5 nm for inch-size polycrystalline material. Those unspecified electrode details should be resolved through engineering support before a build.

View Original Abstract

This study investigated hydrogen peroxide (H 2 O 2 ) supported electrooxidation using niobium-based boron-doped diamond (Nb/BDD) electrodes for the simultaneous removal of sulfanilamide (SN), tetracycline hydrochloride (TC-HCl), and sulfamethazine (SMZ) from biologically treated synthetic wastewater. Response surface methodology based on central composite design was applied to evaluate the effects of current density, pH, H 2 O 2 dose, and initial antibiotic concentration on removal performance. The selected operating condition provided a chemically relevant design space by capturing the effects of antibiotic speciation, oxidant generation, radical availability, and pollutant loading. The optimized condition was identified at a current density of 30 mA/cm 2 , pH 4.95, H 2 O 2 dose of 2.5 mM, and initial antibiotic concentration of 6000 µg/ L at 90 minutes. Under this condition, the model predicted removal efficiencies of 95.32%, 92.35%, and 86.16% for SN, TC-HCl, and SMZ, respectively, with an overall desirability of 0.817. Experimental validation confirmed removals of 97%, 95.50%, and 88%, respectively, which is an indication of good performance between predicted and observed values. TOC decreased from 85 to 20 mg/L after 90 min, corresponding to a mineralization efficiency of 76.47%, which confirmed that the process promoted better oxidation beyond parent-compound degradation. Under the optimized operating conditions, the process required 0.198 kWh to treat a 3.0 L batch, equivalent to a specific energy consumption of 66 kWh/m 3 and an estimated electrical cost of 6.51 CAD/m 3 . Overall, the findings demonstrate that H 2 O 2 -assisted Nb/BDD electrooxidation is an effective advanced treatment strategy for antibiotic-containing wastewater, particularly when simultaneous parent-compound removal and mineralization are required.