Skip to content

Direct Electrochemical Detection of Carbaryl in Water using Boron-Doped Diamond Electrodes

FieldValue
JournalChimica et Natura Acta
Published2026-08-15
AuthorsNatasha Fransisca, Chico Permana Putra, Salma Nur Zakiyyah, Muhammad Ihda H.L. Zein, Yeni Wahyuni Hartati
DOI10.24198/cna.v14.n2.72780

Boron-doped diamond electrodes detected carbaryl directly in water over 10 to 100 μM with a reported limit of detection of 5.30 μM. Differential pulse voltammetry gave a clear oxidation peak at about 1.30 V versus Ag/AgCl and a calibration R² of 0.9975. Seven measurements at 100 μM produced an RSD of 2.35% and 100.97% recovery. The sensor also detected carbaryl added to tap water without filtration, centrifugation, pH adjustment, or organic solvent.

The electrode comparison established where BDD provides a usable carbaryl signal. Pt and Au showed no oxidation peak from 0.6 to 1.6 V under the test conditions. The authors attributed GCE’s weak peak to competition from the oxygen evolution reaction. BDD produced a broad, well-defined oxidation peak from 1.20 to 1.45 V. Its peak was centered near 1.30 V versus Ag/AgCl.

Differential pulse voltammetry made the BDD response sharper and stronger than the GCE response. The measured signal-to-background ratio was 2.95 for BDD and 2.44 for GCE. The authors attribute this performance to BDD’s wide potential window, low background current, electrical conductivity, and chemical stability. These properties allowed carbaryl oxidation without prior chemical hydrolysis.

Electrode fabrication and characterization

Section titled “Electrode fabrication and characterization”

The working electrode was boron-doped diamond fabricated on a silicon (111) substrate. A microwave plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition system, CORNES Methods/ASTeX-5400, used acetone and trimethoxyborane as carbon and boron precursors. The boron-to-carbon atomic ratio was approximately 1%. The paper reports a boron concentration of approximately 2 × 10²¹ cm⁻³.

Aqua regia removed impurities after deposition. Chronoamperometric cleaning then prepared the surface for electrochemical testing. The tested electrode was oxygen-terminated BDD produced by anodic pretreatment described in Supporting Information S2.

Carbaryl was reagent-grade C12H11NO2 from Tokyo Chemical Industry. Double-distilled water was used for solution preparation, and the reagents received no further purification.

Field-emission SEM with a JEOL JCM-6000 examined surface morphology. Raman spectroscopy used an Acton SP2500 with a 532 nm green laser diode under ambient conditions. The authors report that SEM and Raman results confirmed a polycrystalline surface and high boron doping. The main text does not report roughness values or grain measurements.

Measurement conditions and oxidation pathway

Section titled “Measurement conditions and oxidation pathway”

Cyclic voltammetry used 1 mL of 100 μM carbaryl with 0.1 M Na2SO4. The potential swept from 0.6 to 1.6 V for one cycle. The step potential was 0.01 V, and the scan rate was 50 mV/s. Measurements were performed at room temperature. A saturated KCl Ag/AgCl electrode served as the reference, and a Pt wire served as the counter electrode. Differential pulse voltammetry used a 1.0 to 1.5 V range at the same scan rate.

The authors propose direct oxidation of the carbamate moiety at about 1.30 V. Oxidative cleavage may then produce 1-naphthol, methylamine, and CO2. They identify 1-naphthol as a reaction product following oxidation. Electrogenerated hydroxyl radicals formed during water oxidation may further oxidize 1-naphthol at the positive BDD potential. The authors associate the broad peak with overlapping oxidation steps. No product identification is reported to confirm the proposed pathway.

Scan-rate tests used 20, 40, 60, 80, and 100 mV/s. Peak current rose with scan rate. Current versus the square root of scan rate gave R² = 0.9995. Current versus scan rate gave R² = 0.9905. A logarithmic scan-rate plot gave R² = 0.9999 and a slope of 0.5575. The slope was close to the theoretical value of 0.5 for a diffusion-controlled process. The authors used these results to assign predominantly diffusion-controlled oxidation rather than surface adsorption.

The DPV calibration covered 10 to 100 μM with R² = 0.9975. The detailed results and conclusion give an LOD of 5.30 μM and an LOQ of 17.68 μM for BDD. GCE gave an LOD of 30.21 μM and an LOQ of 100.69 μM.

ElectrodeSignal-to-background ratioLOD (μM)LOQ (μM)
GCE2.4430.21100.69
BDD2.955.3017.68

Seven replicate measurements at 100 μM gave an RSD of 2.35% and 100.97% recovery. The reported values fall within CAC pesticide-residue criteria of 70% to 120% recovery and RSD below 20%.

For the real-water test, carbaryl was added to tap water collected from the authors’ laboratory. The sample also contained 0.1 M Na2SO4. It received no filtration, centrifugation, or pH adjustment before DPV. The reported trace showed the carbaryl oxidation peak.

Earlier studies listed in the paper used acetonitrile and reported lower detection limits. Their electrodes and modifiers also differed, so these values are not direct equivalence tests.

ElectrodeMediumDetection rangeLODReference
BDDAcetonitrile10 nM to 10 μM3 nMRao et al. 2002
BDDAcetonitrile1 to 30 μM0.041 μMCodognoto et al. 2006
BDD/GrAcetonitrile1 to 6 μM0.07 μMPop et al. 2017
Low silica X zeolite/CPEAcetonitrile1 to 100 μM0.3 μMSalih et al. 2017
3DG/Au/GCEAcetonitrile0.004 to 0.3 μM0.0012 μMRahmani et al. 2018
BDDWater10 to 100 μM5.30 μMThis work

The benefit claimed for this work is direct water analysis without prior sample pretreatment. The trade-off is a higher LOD than the earlier studies listed in the table. The method avoids the organic media used by those studies while retaining a clear oxidation response.

The authors acknowledge that the 5.30 μM LOD is higher than values reported for several carbaryl sensors operated with organic solvents. The LOD also lies below the 10 μM lower calibration point. The paper therefore reports no calibration data below 10 μM for the BDD electrode.

The real-sample result covers carbaryl added to tap water at 100 μM. The paper does not report field water, unspiked samples, interference tests, or a selectivity study. It also omits long-term drift, storage stability, and operational lifetime data for the BDD electrode. These omissions limit claims about continuous or field deployment.

The abstract lists an LOQ of 100.69 μM, but the detailed results and conclusion report 17.68 μM for BDD. The detailed text assigns 100.69 μM to GCE. This inconsistency should be checked before transferring the analytical figures into a test protocol.

The results support BDD when the sample must remain aqueous and the analyte requires a high positive oxidation potential. For the measured response, oxygen termination, a broad potential window, and low background current are the relevant electrode properties. The tested cell used 0.1 M Na2SO4, an Ag/AgCl reference, and a Pt counter electrode.

The method removes filtration, centrifugation, and pH adjustment from the tested tap-water workflow. It does not match the lower LODs of earlier solvent-based sensors. Low-level calibration, matrix testing, interference data, and electrode stability results would be needed before field monitoring claims could be evaluated.

The material requirement is boron-doped diamond for the working electrode of an aqueous carbaryl sensor. The paper needs an oxygen-terminated polycrystalline BDD working electrode, fabricated by MPCVD in the study, for a carbaryl oxidation peak near 1.30 V versus Ag/AgCl. The diamond materials catalog lists boron-doped diamond, which matches the working-electrode material used in the paper. For custom fabrication planning, 6CCVD offers engineering support.

View Original Abstract

Carbaryl (1-naphthyl methylcarbamate) is a carbamate pesticide used to cause adverse environmental and health effects when misused through water contamination. Therefore, this research aimed to develop a direct electrochemical detection method for carbaryl in aqueous media using boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrodes. In this context, BDD electrodes exhibited superior electrochemical performance compared to conventional materials such as gold (Au), platinum (Pt), and glassy carbon electrodes (GCE) due to a wide potential window, low background current, and excellent chemical stability. Cyclic and differential pulse voltammetry reported a well-defined oxidation peak for carbaryl at 1.30 V, with significantly enhanced sensitivity. The results showed that there was a linear response in the concentration range of 10-100 μM, with a detection limit of 5.30 μM, quantification limit off 100.69 μM, excellent reproducibility (RSD = 2.35%) and recovery (100.97%). Furthermore, SEM and Raman analyses confirmed the polycrystalline structure and high boron doping level of BDD surface. The method was validated using tap water samples, confirming the applicability for real-world environmental monitoring. These results suggested the potential of BDD electrodes for sensitive, rapid, and direct detection of carbaryl in water without the need for complex sample preparation.