Skip to content

A FLASH PROTON PLATFORM FOR INSTRUMENTATION AND SMALL ANIMAL UHDR RESEARCH

FieldValue
JournalInternational Journal of Particle Therapy
Published2026-09-01
AuthorsP. Hofverberg, Sullivan Marafico, Jean-Marc Bergerot, Jean-Claude Grini, J. Doyen
DOI10.1016/j.ijpt.2026.101527

The adapted 65 MeV isochronous MEDICYC cyclotron delivered isocenter entrance dose rates exceeding 1000 Gy/s. The platform combined dose delivery accuracy within 1% with dose rate reproducibility within 2% for typical FLASH doses. The Centre Antoine Lacassagne implemented and validated the platform for instrumentation and preclinical research.

The Centre Antoine Lacassagne adapted its 65 MeV isochronous MEDICYC cyclotron and beamlines for a passively scattered FLASH proton platform. The stated objective covers instrumentation and preclinical research activities. The authors modified the cyclotron, beam delivery, beam shaping, and dosimetry systems for ultra-high dose rate irradiation.

Fast delivery relies on a method that phases and dephases the cyclotron radiofrequency field. Beam shaping devices were developed with high transmission and suitable for short irradiations. Each component was assessed against the need for short and reproducible irradiations.

The resulting architecture places dose measurement on the same beamline used for shaped proton irradiation. Beam monitoring and beam stop instrumentation form part of the delivery system rather than serving as separate characterization equipment.

Beam pulses had a 1.2 ms combined rise and fall time. With a 10% rise and fall to plateau ratio, this timing set a minimum irradiation duration of 12 ms. The 12 ms value is conditional on the assumed plateau reference, rather than an independent pulse width specification.

The source timing establishes the current lower bound for exposure. A planned upgrade to the source power supplies will provide pulsed proton delivery with adjustable pulse parameters. That upgrade will support investigation of the FLASH onset.

The timing result applies to the reported rise and fall behavior of the present source configuration. The planned power supply upgrade addresses source control directly. The present results characterize the 1.2 ms combined rise and fall behavior, while adjustable pulse control remains future work.

A double-ring occluding scattering system produced a 50 mm diameter flat field at 18% beam transmission. Dose homogeneity was better than 2% across that field. The transmission value belongs to the shaping configuration used for this flat field.

A second shaping method used 3D-printed hedgehog ridge filters. It produced a 28 mm spread-out Bragg peak. Plateau homogeneity was better than 2% across the full field.

These configurations address separate experimental geometries. The flat field covers a 50 mm diameter area, while the spread-out Bragg peak covers a 28 mm depth range. The paper reports better than 2% homogeneity for both under their stated conditions.

The 18% transmission applies only to the flat field configuration, so throughput cannot be assumed for the ridge filter arrangement. Only the flat field arrangement has a reported transmission value. Instrument developers must therefore match the shaping system to the required irradiation geometry.

A commercial transmission ionization chamber, the IC64, was characterized because it was optimized for high dose rate monitoring. Its response was linear up to 300 Gy/s for large fields. For a narrow pencil beam, its measured linear response reached at least 3000 Gy/s.

These limits are geometry dependent. The limit for large fields is below the reported entrance dose rate above 1000 Gy/s for the 50 mm flat field. The limit for a narrow beam cannot be applied directly to that broad field. This distinction matters when selecting a monitor for UHDR work.

The paper does not report an IC64 response beyond 300 Gy/s for a large field. The chamber was characterized as part of the platform rather than proposed only as a future component. Its response characterization therefore supports use with the validated beamline.

Dose calibration in water followed IAEA TRS-398 and used an Advanced Markus chamber. A Faraday cup provided an independent check. The Advanced Markus recombination correction was 0.3 ± 0.03%. Reported dose agreement with the Faraday cup was 0.5 ± 3.7% at both 1 and 300 Gy/s.

The two calibration rates bracket the low and high ends tested for that comparison. The Advanced Markus comparison reached 300 Gy/s, which is higher than the 1 Gy/s calibration point. These rates do not directly establish agreement at the platform’s entrance dose rates above 1000 Gy/s. This distinction defines the reported validation range.

Beam monitoring and beam stop instrumentation enabled dose delivery accuracy within 1% for typical FLASH doses. Dose rate reproducibility was within 2%. The Faraday cup check tests the calibration chain, while the beam monitor and beam stop support delivery control.

These are separate controls and should not be combined into a single uncertainty claim. The water geometry and independent cup provide two dose references rather than relying on the online chamber alone. The abstract does not specify the dose levels included in the typical FLASH dose statement.

MeasurementReported resultTest condition
Entrance dose rateExceeding 1000 Gy/s50 mm flat field at isocenter
Pulse timing1.2 ms combined rise and fallMinimum duration 12 ms at a 10% rise and fall to plateau ratio
Flat fieldBetter than 2% homogeneity50 mm diameter at 18% beam transmission
Spread-out Bragg peakBetter than 2% plateau homogeneity28 mm full field with hedgehog ridge filters
IC64 responseLinear to 300 Gy/s; at least 3000 Gy/sLarge fields; narrow pencil beam
Delivery performanceAccuracy within 1%; reproducibility within 2%Typical FLASH doses
Calibration agreement0.5 ± 3.7%Advanced Markus versus Faraday cup at 1 and 300 Gy/s
Recombination correction0.3 ± 0.03%Advanced Markus chamber

The numerical results support suitability for preclinical studies, but they also define clear operating boundaries. A detector limit, an entrance dose rate, and a calibration cross-check describe different stages of the beam delivery chain. Device selection should therefore match the measured condition to the intended use.

The 50 mm flat field and 28 mm spread-out Bragg peak also have different shaping requirements. New characterization would be required before extending the large-field IC64 result to the demonstrated platform rate. The narrow pencil beam result reaches at least 3000 Gy/s, but it cannot serve as a broad-field upper limit.

The next phase is an upgrade to the source power supplies for pulsed proton delivery with adjustable pulse parameters. The goal is to investigate FLASH onset. The current 1.2 ms rise and fall timing and 12 ms minimum irradiation duration describe the validated platform before that pulse flexibility is added.

Beam shaping choices also need to match the intended geometry. The double-ring system has measured 18% transmission for a 50 mm flat field. Hedgehog ridge filters delivered a 28 mm spread-out Bragg peak with better than 2% plateau homogeneity.

Clinical beamline adaptations could allow ocular proton therapy under such conditions. The authors present this as a concurrent possibility, not as a validated clinical result.

For instrumentation work, the platform provides measured beam conditions that can serve as design inputs. Detectors, filters, and control systems must be qualified for the field size and intensity they will see. The next experimental milestone is adjustable proton pulsing and direct study of FLASH onset.

View Original Abstract

trains of bunches can be delivered.On the AX research beamline, 68 MeV proton and alpha pulsed beams up to 40 µA permit ultra-high dose-rate (UHDR) radiobiology studies, which require real-time monitoring of beam intensity and profile over a wide dynamic range.Methods: Three complementary detectors are being installed on the AX beamline.(i) DIAMMONI is a diamond semiconductor detector, placed close to the target, which is based on four singlecrystal CVD diamonds (in beam halo).In train mode, it integrates the charge per train and measures train duration (DT) at high flux.(ii) PAF is a multi-PMT profiler based on beam-induced air fluorescence, placed in air, to provide high-intensity timing and profile measurements.(iii) PEPITES relies on secondary-electron emission from ultra-thin gold strips deposited on a radioresistant polyimide substrate, installed inside the beamline in vacuum, to measure beam profiles.Tests with a 68 MeV proton pulsed beam (100 nA-40 µA) with DT=10µs, were done to evaluate linearity/sensitivity, as well as the evolution of signal form with beam intensity.Results: DIAMMONI (diamond with its electronic board) shows good linearity and sensitivity; the same for the PAF detector.Beam parameters: charge per train, overall train shape, and its microstructure, were measured with both DIAMMONI and PAF, enabling the comparison of the two detection technologies and helping identify their optimal operating ranges (100nA-40µA).PEPITES demonstrated beam-profile measurements under a 68 MeV proton beam in continuous mode (1 pA -20 nA), while its response with beam intensity > 20 nA in continuous mode, and in pulsed mode is currently under investigation.Conclusions: These first results are promising for proton pulsed beam monitoring over a wide range of intensities.Ongoing work will extend to alpha UHDR beams; quantify radiation-induced damage (diamond charge-collection efficiency and annealing; polymer mechanical/electrical changes); FLASH-capable electronics for PEPITES; and finalize PAF prototype.