An ex vivo evaluation of submicron diamond irrigant using sonic agitation systems on the penetration of calcium silicate-based sealers into dentinal tubules
Paper details
Section titled “Paper details”| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Journal | Scientific Reports |
| Published | 2026-09-07 |
| Authors | Chia-Yun Lee, Yun-Hsien Shih, James Leo Gutmann, Huan‐Cheng Chang, Haw‐Ming Huang |
| DOI | 10.1038/s41598-026-69665-2 |
Sonic irrigation with 3% NaOCl containing 500 nm submicron diamond particles at 10 mg/mL produced the highest mean maximum sealer penetration depth in the study. Across the coronal, middle, and apical thirds, penetration averaged 662.97 ± 146.43 µm. This exceeded the 406.84 ± 103.63 µm average for 17% EDTA with sonic agitation, with p < 0.001. Mean sealer coverage was 75.09 ± 10.89% and was comparable to EDTA-SA at 73.73 ± 11.86%. The findings apply to extracted single-rooted teeth and one calcium silicate-based sealer.
Experimental design
Section titled “Experimental design”Forty-eight human mandibular premolars extracted for orthodontic purposes were screened by radiography. The study excluded teeth with open apices, prior endodontic treatment, significant pulpal infection, or multiple canals. Random allocation produced four groups of 12 teeth: NaOCl-MI, NaOCl-SA, EDTA-SA, and NaOCl-D-SA.
Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) preparation were destructive and mutually exclusive. Six teeth per group underwent SEM, and six underwent CLSM. ProGlider and ProTaper Gold files shaped each canal to the F2 apical size of #25 at 300 RPM.
Irrigation protocols and measurements
Section titled “Irrigation protocols and measurements”Each protocol delivered 5 mL of irrigant across three consecutive cycles. The three activated groups received 10 seconds of sonic agitation per cycle. An EndoActivator used a medium 22 mm tip at power setting 3, positioned 1 mm short of the working length. Irrigation ended with 3 mL of saline and paper-point drying.
NaOCl-MI used 3% NaOCl manually. NaOCl-SA used the same solution with sonic agitation. EDTA-SA used 17% EDTA with sonic agitation. NaOCl-D-SA used 3% NaOCl containing 500 nm diamonds at 10 mg/mL with sonic agitation. Commercial particles were synthesized at high pressure and high temperature, then ground and acid-treated for purification and surface modification. Earlier characterization placed their size distribution around the nominal 500 nm value.
SEM images at 2000× magnification were scored on a four-level tubule-exposure scale. Scores ranged from 1 for completely exposed tubules to 4 for complete smear-layer coverage. Two blinded examiners had almost perfect agreement, with κ = 0.82.
For CLSM, the authors labeled CeraSeal with 0.1% Rhodamine B and used hydraulic condensation. Specimens were held at 37 °C in 100% humidity for 7 days. CLSM used 4× magnification and a 575 nm excitation wavelength to quantify sealer coverage and maximum depth perpendicular to the canal wall.
Smear layer removal
Section titled “Smear layer removal”NaOCl-D-SA and EDTA-SA achieved significantly greater smear-layer removal than both NaOCl controls, with p < 0.05. The two leading groups did not differ significantly, with p > 0.05. The authors report that sonic activation alone did not outperform manual NaOCl.
SEM images showed dentinal tubules largely obscured in the two NaOCl-only groups. EDTA-SA and NaOCl-D-SA produced comparable tubule exposure. Irrigant formulation therefore affected this outcome under the tested conditions.
Sealer coverage
Section titled “Sealer coverage”The linear mixed-effects model found a protocol effect on coverage, with p < 0.001. Root third had no significant effect, with p = 0.094. The interaction between protocol and root third was also nonsignificant, with p = 0.304.
NaOCl-D-SA produced average coverage of 75.09 ± 10.89%. EDTA-SA produced 73.73 ± 11.86%, while NaOCl-SA and NaOCl-MI produced 31.16 ± 6.48% and 24.45 ± 5.89%, respectively. NaOCl-D-SA exceeded both NaOCl controls at p < 0.001 but did not differ from EDTA-SA, with p = 1.000.
Its coverage remained consistent across thirds: 75.31 ± 16.91% coronally, 75.76 ± 10.55% in the middle, and 74.20 ± 14.30% apically.
Maximum penetration depth
Section titled “Maximum penetration depth”CLSM depth was defined as the deepest sealer extent measured perpendicular to the canal wall. Values below are mean ± standard deviation.
| Irrigation protocol | Coronal depth, µm | Middle depth, µm | Apical depth, µm | Average depth, µm |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NaOCl-MI | 219.41 ± 82.04 | 150.20 ± 59.57 | 60.01 ± 26.42 | 143.21 ± 35.70 |
| NaOCl-SA | 279.92 ± 71.58 | 256.00 ± 59.61 | 125.93 ± 39.81 | 220.61 ± 45.77 |
| EDTA-SA | 585.67 ± 70.07 | 485.36 ± 191.39 | 219.18 ± 47.30 | 406.84 ± 103.63 |
| NaOCl-D-SA | 908.02 ± 229.76 | 689.04 ± 159.46 | 391.86 ± 83.42 | 662.97 ± 146.43 |
NaOCl-D-SA exceeded both NaOCl controls in every third, with all p ≤ 0.001. It also exceeded EDTA-SA in each third: p < 0.001 coronally, p = 0.016 in the middle, and p = 0.043 apically. Its average depth exceeded all three comparators, each at p < 0.001.
Within NaOCl-D-SA, penetration decreased from coronal to middle to apical, with all pairwise differences at p < 0.001. The mixed-effects model confirmed effects of protocol and root third, both with p < 0.001. The interaction between protocol and root third was also significant, with p < 0.001.
Interpretation and prior work
Section titled “Interpretation and prior work”The authors propose that sonic oscillation increases wall shear and particle-wall collisions, which may disrupt the smear layer. They also suggest that 500 nm particles may interact with dentinal tubule orifices and constricted apical regions. Reported tubule diameters are approximately 1 to 3 µm, narrowing to about 0.9 µm near cementum. The study did not track particle entry, surface charge, dispersion stability, or particle-wall contact, so these remain proposed mechanisms.
Surface cleanliness alone cannot explain the depth result. NaOCl-D-SA and EDTA-SA had similar SEM scores, but the diamond protocol produced deeper penetration. The authors suggest that particle-assisted changes in dentinal microtopography may favor sealer wetting and micromechanical interlocking. This mechanism was not measured directly in the present experiment.
The 500 nm formulation was selected from earlier work on 10 mg/mL particles ranging from 50 to 1000 nm. Earlier sonic experiments found effective coronal and middle smear removal, no significant difference from EDTA at p > 0.05, and superior apical removal at p < 0.05. A separate micro-CT study cited by the authors also found accumulated hard-tissue debris removal comparable with EDTA.
Limitations and engineering implications
Section titled “Limitations and engineering implications”Each SEM or CLSM comparison used six teeth per protocol. Natural dentine heterogeneity, including sclerotic and irregular secondary dentine, could affect both outcomes. Root length, curvature, ovality, donor age, storage duration, and dentine sclerosis were not systematically characterized or balanced. SEM assessed surface morphology only, and preparation artifacts and observer judgment could affect the scores.
The study did not assess diamond particle retention. Retention could affect sealer hydration, setting, bonding, and interfacial adaptation. The authors also did not evaluate erosion, excessive abrasion, microcracks, or tubule-wall alteration, especially in the apical third. Delivery reproducibility, validated sterilization, clinical cost, and periapical extrusion safety remain uncertain.
Only CeraSeal was tested. Its viscosity, flowability, wettability, and interaction with each treated surface were not assessed. Rhodamine B may dissociate from the sealer and diffuse independently, which could overestimate absolute penetration depth by an unknown amount. The evidence therefore applies to one sealer, one tracer, one particle formulation, and extracted teeth.
For dental irrigation development, the tested specification is limited to 500 nm diamonds at 10 mg/mL in 3% NaOCl. The results do not establish performance for other particle sizes or concentrations. Development still requires controlled particle delivery, formulation stability, biocompatibility, validated sterilization, and direct measurement of dentinal damage, particle retention, and extrusion safety. Until those data and in vivo results exist, NaOCl-D-SA remains an experimental particle-assisted protocol rather than a replacement for EDTA-based chelation.
View Original Abstract
Abstract The smear layer influences dentine permeability and may compromise sealer penetration, which is critical for achieving an effective three-dimensional seal during root canal obturation. This ex vivo study evaluated whether a 500 nm submicron diamond irrigant (10 mg/mL) with sonic agitation improves smear layer removal and dentinal tubule penetration of a calcium silicate-based (CS-based) sealer. Forty eight single-rooted teeth were prepared to Protaper Gold F2 and allocated to four irrigation protocols ( n = 12): (a) 3% sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) with manual irrigation (NaOCl-MI); (b) 3% NaOCl with sonic agitation (NaOCl-SA); (c) 17% ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid with sonic agitation (EDTA-SA); and (d) 3% NaOCl plus submicron diamonds with sonic agitation (NaOCl-D-SA). Smear-layer removal was scored on SEM images (Hülsmann) and compared using Kruskal-Wallis with Dunn’s test. After hydraulic condensation with Rhodamine B-labelled CS-based sealer, CLSM quantified maximum penetration depth and sealer coverage; variables were analyzed using linear mixed-effects models with Bonferroni-adjusted pairwise comparisons ( p < 0.05). NaOCl-D-SA and EDTA-SA achieved effective smear removal, whereas NaOCl-MI and NaOCl-SA were inferior. Sealer coverage was higher in NaOCl-D-SA than NaOCl-MI/NaOCl-SA and comparable to EDTA-SA. NaOCl-D-SA produced the greatest penetration depth, followed by EDTA-SA; across all groups, coronal and middle penetration depths tended to exceed apical depths. Our results suggested that submicron diamond irrigation with sonic agitation improved smear-layer removal and enhanced CS-based sealer penetration under ex vivo conditions. This approach warrants further in vivo and clinical evaluation.
Electronic Grade Intrinsic Diamond Epitaxial Wafer H Terminated Superior 100 Mosfet Ready Substrate
View Specs →
Single Crystal Cvd Diamond Plate
View Specs →