Skip to content

Electrochemical Removal of Clavulanic Acid from Aqueous Matrices Using BDD Anode

FieldValue
JournalApplied Sciences
Published2026-09-03
AuthorsJakub Trawiński, Robert Skibiński
DOI10.3390/app16178788

More than 99% of clavulanic acid was removed within 30 min by BDD electrooxidation in Pahokee peat humic and fulvic acid matrices. LC-MS showed nearly complete degradation after 30 min at pH 7, while pH 3 and pH 9 each removed 85% after 60 min. These measurements track disappearance of the parent compound, not complete mineralization. The strongest NPOC result still left about 25% of initial organic carbon after 90 min.

Test conditions and analytical measurements

Section titled “Test conditions and analytical measurements”

Electrolysis used a Metrohm Autolab PGSTAT302N in galvanostatic mode. The anode was a free-standing 1.00 cm by 1.00 cm BDD plate with 0.06 cm thickness and 6000 ppm boron doping. Its reported effective electroactive area was approximately 2 cm². A platinum coil served as cathode, and the electrodes were held 0.6 cm apart at the same depth.

Each run used 20 mL in a cylindrical cell under constant stirring. Buffered solutions contained 10 mg L⁻¹ clavulanic acid and 20 mM phosphate buffer at pH 3, 7, or 9. Organic-matter tests also contained 10 mg L⁻¹ of one standardized humic substance and were not buffered. Their pH values ranged from 5.96 to 6.43.

Samples were taken at 0, 15, 30, 60, and 90 min. Each 1.1 mL aliquot supplied 0.1 mL for LC-MS and 1 mL for TOC analysis. After each run, the BDD was cleaned in Na2SO4 for 5 min at 10 mA. The polarity was then reversed and cleaning was repeated.

Positive-mode LC-MS monitored the parent ion at m/z 200.0553. NPOC was measured with a Shimadzu TOC-L CPH analyzer. All analyses were performed in duplicate. The authors selected BDD for its reported ability to generate reactive oxygen species, including hydroxyl radicals, but did not quantify those species.

The LC-MS method used a Kinetex Polar C18 column with a 9 min gradient, 0.3 mL min⁻¹ flow, and 5 μL injection. TOC measurements used 1000 μL injections and automatic dilution of 10. A 10% coefficient-of-variation limit triggered repeat measurements.

Parent compound removal depended strongly on pH. The neutral run reached nearly complete degradation at the 30 min sample. Acidic and basic runs each reached 85% removal at 60 min, although the basic condition slowed during the latter part of treatment. The authors therefore propose pH adjustment or neutralization before electrolysis during scale-up.

ConditionTest matrixParent compound resultTime
pH 310 mg L⁻¹ clavulanic acid with 20 mM phosphate buffer85% removed60 min
pH 710 mg L⁻¹ clavulanic acid with 20 mM phosphate bufferNearly complete degradation30 min
pH 910 mg L⁻¹ clavulanic acid with 20 mM phosphate buffer85% removed60 min
Pahokee peat humic or fulvic acid10 mg L⁻¹ clavulanic acid with 10 mg L⁻¹ humic substance99% removed30 min

Humic matrices alter degradation and mineralization

Section titled “Humic matrices alter degradation and mineralization”

Five standardized natural-water constituents were tested: Pahokee peat humic acid, Pahokee peat fulvic acid, Suwanee River humic acid, Suwanee River fulvic acid, and Suwanee River natural organic matter. The abbreviations used below are PPHA, PPFA, SRHA, SRFA, and SRNOM, respectively.

PPFA and PPHA produced the fastest and most similar parent compound loss. SRHA and SRFA degraded more slowly, while SRNOM behaved more closely to the Pahokee peat materials. Because the pH span was narrow, the authors assigned the differences to interactions with the organic matrix rather than pH. Dissolved organic matter therefore did not slow removal in the majority of cases, and several matrices improved it.

This result differs from the general expectation that dissolved organic matter can either accelerate or slow BDD-driven degradation. The tested humic substances did not prevent rapid parent compound removal. Their identity still affected the slower mineralization and energy results.

Transformation products form through beta-lactam ring cleavage

Section titled “Transformation products form through beta-lactam ring cleavage”

UHPLC-HRMS detected two transformation products, TP1 and TP2. Both were assigned the formula C6H8NO6 and m/z 190.0346. TP1 eluted at 0.84 min and TP2 at 1.07 min. TP1 produced fragment ions at m/z 120.0283 and 74.0228, which led the authors to propose a cyclic N-oxide derivative. TP2 produced a fragment at m/z 146.0453 and a decarboxylation pattern more similar to clavulanic acid.

Both products formed through β-lactam ring cleavage followed by hydroxylation. The authors interpret this cleavage as removing the β-lactamase-inhibitory structure. Secondary pyrazine derivatives reported for other clavulanic acid degradation routes were not detected here.

An earlier BDD study of cefuroxime axetil by the same team also lacked a pyrazine route. The authors suggest that a different second-ring structure could change core reactivity. The paper did not test the transformation products’ toxicity, while the authors note that possible toxic properties should not be neglected.

Mineralization takes longer than parent compound removal

Section titled “Mineralization takes longer than parent compound removal”

LC-MS and NPOC gave different treatment endpoints. At 90 min, the PPHA reaction mixture retained about 25% of its initial NPOC, while the PPFA mixture retained 40%. The Suwanee River matrix results fell between these extremes, with 67% to 74% mineralization and 26% to 33% remaining NPOC. All matrices removed a substantial majority of organic carbon within 90 min, but full conversion took longer than parent compound disappearance.

Humic-only controls had lower mineralization rates than mixtures containing clavulanic acid. This comparison indicates that clavulanic acid drove most of the observed carbon depletion. NPOC cannot distinguish carbon from clavulanic acid from carbon in the humic substance, so the result is not a compound-specific mass balance.

Energy consumption was calculated from average cell potential, current, reaction time, sample volume, and NPOC reduction. Results were reported as kWh per g of NPOC. SRNOM and PPHA had the lowest energy demand. SRHA had the highest demand, while PPFA had the weakest mineralization. Carbon removal and energy demand therefore did not rank the matrices in the same order.

The results support BDD anodes for batch treatment under controlled pH, but they do not establish full-scale performance. Each experiment used only 20 mL, all analyses were duplicated, and the longest observation was 90 min. Periodic electrode stability tests showed no significant changes in electrochemical parameters. The authors could not provide complete structural information because the electrode was commercial.

The test concentration of 10 mg L⁻¹ also exceeds the 84.74 μg L⁻¹ clavulanic acid concentration reported for wastewater treatment plant effluents in a cited survey. That survey also found insufficient removal after ultrafiltration. The paper did not report clavulanic acid removal at the lower effluent concentration or in a continuous reactor. The organic-matter tests used standardized humic substances rather than a reported wastewater sample.

Scale-up must therefore track parent compound, NPOC, and energy demand separately. The two transformation products also require toxicity assessment before environmental safety is established. The authors propose BDD for water treatment systems under the reported pH control, electrode configuration, and batch conditions.

The study used a free-standing, 6000 ppm boron-doped diamond anode for electrochemical water treatment. 6CCVD’s diamond materials catalog lists boron-doped diamond and plates up to 125 mm, while engineering support can help adapt the paper’s 1.00 cm by 1.00 cm geometry. The catalog gives no 6000 ppm grade, and the paper’s 0.06 cm plate exceeds the 500 micrometer maximum.

View Original Abstract

In this study, the application of the boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrode for electrochemical removal of clavulanic acid was investigated. The studied pharmaceutical is one of the most commonly prescribed β-lactamase inhibitors, which raises concerns about its impact on the spread of antibiotic resistance, as well as environmental toxicity. Preliminary experiments conducted in buffered solutions showed that neutral pH ensures substantially higher degradation rates than basic and acidic conditions. Further studies featuring standardized humic substances revealed that the presence of dissolved organic matter can even improve the process’s performance, resulting in over 99% degradation achieved within 30 min of the electrooxidation experiment. Two detected intermediates were identified as the products of a β-lactam ring cleavage, which supposedly led to the loss of enzyme inhibiting properties. Total organic carbon (TOC) analysis (namely the non-purgeable carbon—NPOC—assay) showed that the time necessary to fully mineralize clavulanic acid is significantly longer than to degrade it. Nevertheless, BDD electrodes can be successfully applied for the removal of the studied compound from aquatic environments, which confirms their suitability as a part of water treatment systems.