Theoretical and Experimental Study on Dynamic Minimum Cutting Thickness
Paper details
Section titled “Paper details”| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Journal | Journal of Manufacturing Engineering |
| Published | 2026-09-01 |
| Authors | Wang Jianping, Han Bin, Jicai Kuai, Yunqian DUAN, Д. В. Ардашев |
| DOI | 10.37255/jme.v21i3pp117-128 |
A 10 μm edge-radius single-crystal diamond tool cut Al6061 and red copper at reported minimum cutting thicknesses of 2.2 to 3.17 μm and about 2 to 3.5 μm, respectively, as feed speed increased from 1.25 to 5 mm/s. The thickness-to-edge ratios were 0.243 to 0.271 for aluminum and 0.20091 to 0.36109 for copper. In a separate non-free cutting test at 800 r/min and 0.02 mm depth, a 15 μm/r feed produced the lowest reported roughness, with Ra of 0.293 μm for aluminum and 0.309 μm for copper.
A dynamic thickness model
Section titled “A dynamic thickness model”Minimum chip formation occurs at the separation point between the rake and flank faces. Material above this point forms a chip, while material below it is extruded and deformed by the rounded edge and flank.
Force balance gives the following relation between minimum cutting thickness and edge radius:
[ h_{\min}=r_n(1-\cos\theta) ]
The friction coefficient and the tangential-to-normal force ratio determine the angle (\theta). For a 10 μm edge radius, a force ratio of 0.8 and friction coefficients of 0.16 to 0.4 gave calculated thicknesses of 2 to 3.2 μm. At a friction coefficient of 0.18, force ratios of 0.8 to 1.1 gave 2.2 to 3.5 μm.
The authors call this a dynamic model because the minimum thickness can change with cutting time, tool passivation, and workpiece softening under cutting heat. These changes alter the friction coefficient and force ratio during cutting. The paper therefore treats the minimum thickness as a cutting-state value rather than a fixed property of the tool.
Cutting simulation
Section titled “Cutting simulation”Free-cutting simulation used Deform 2D Version 11.0 with a 10 μm edge radius, 3000 rpm, and feeds of 2 and 3 μm/r. For aluminum alloy, the simulated thicknesses were 2.32 and 3.2 μm at those feeds. Pure copper gave 3.7 and 4.3 μm.
These values are simulations rather than experimental measurements. Both materials showed increasing minimum thickness with increasing feed. The simulation used the same friction coefficient for both materials and modeled pure copper rather than red copper. It therefore supports the feed trend more directly than the exact magnitude for red copper.
Locating the transition by force
Section titled “Locating the transition by force”The experiments used continuous variable-depth cuts from zero to the cutting depth. Cutting force was recorded with an SBT970 dynamometer rated for 0 to 2 N with 0.01 N accuracy. Scratch depth and width were measured with an ultra-depth-of-field microscope. No coolant was used.
The cutting process moved from elastic sliding into plowing and then chip formation. The abrupt force change at the plowing-to-cutting transition located minimum chip formation. At 1.25 mm/s, the force change occurred at 1.19 s and 1.49 mm travel. The corresponding calculated scratch depth was 2.3 μm. At 5 mm/s, the transition occurred at 0.45 s and 2.25 mm travel, with a calculated depth of 3.53 μm.
Microscopy then tied the force-transition position to the measured scratch geometry. This method identifies the minimum thickness without requiring direct observation of chip separation.
Measured cutting limits
Section titled “Measured cutting limits”The measured scratch depths were treated as the minimum cutting thicknesses.
| Feed speed, mm/s | Al6061 scratch depth, μm | Red copper scratch depth, μm |
|---|---|---|
| 1.25 | 2.20 | 1.975 |
| 2.50 | 2.63 | 2.203 |
| 3.75 | 2.84 | 2.567 |
| 5.00 | 3.17 | 3.645 |
Each aluminum dataset was averaged from five measurements. Copper trials were repeated twice, with five measurements in each dataset.
For aluminum, the thickness-to-edge ratio increased from 0.243 to 0.271 as feed speed rose. The paper reports a copper ratio of 0.20091 to 0.36109 in its conclusion. These values describe the tested 10 μm diamond edge and the stated workpieces and feeds.
Selecting feed for surface roughness
Section titled “Selecting feed for surface roughness”The Brammertz model links surface roughness to feed, tool nose radius, and minimum cutting thickness. Below the threshold, the tool plows instead of forming chips. This increases burrs and worsens surface quality. Above the threshold, actual cutting thickness and roughness increase.
In non-free cutting, actual thickness depends on feed, cutting depth, and tool nose radius. Feed per revolution therefore cannot be treated as the direct cutting thickness.
At a cutting depth of 0.02 mm, the calculated compatible feeds were 15 to 22 μm/r for aluminum and 14 to 24 μm/r for copper. The validation experiment used a broader feed range of 15 to 35 μm/r at 800 r/min and the same 0.02 mm depth.
At 15 μm/r, the minimum roughness values were Rz of 1.505 μm and Ra of 0.293 μm for aluminum. Red copper produced Rz of 2.014 μm and Ra of 0.309 μm. Below 15 μm/r, both materials developed numerous burrs. Above 15 μm/r, aluminum roughness rose slowly, while copper roughness increased sharply. Both materials therefore showed high roughness at both ends of the feed range and a minimum in the middle.
Comparison with earlier minimum-thickness studies
Section titled “Comparison with earlier minimum-thickness studies”The paper situates its results within several earlier limits. A 1987 study by Osaka University and the LLL Laboratory reported a 1 nm chip using an extremely sharp single-crystal diamond tool. Later molecular dynamics work placed the limit near 5% of the tool edge radius.
Earlier aluminum experiments produced thickness-to-edge ratios of 20% to 40%. Another study on 6082-T6 aluminum found a minimum thickness of 0.2 to 0.3 μm with a 1.4 μm edge radius. Its ratio of 14% to 21% was lower than the 0.243 to 0.271 measured here. A separate copper study reported a ratio of 0.17 using a TiCN-coated WC tool.
The present aluminum ratio falls within the earlier 20% to 40% range. The copper ratio of 0.20091 to 0.36109 lies above the reported value of 0.17. Different workpieces, tool materials, edge radii, and process conditions prevent a direct ranking. The study does not claim to surpass the 1 nm result reported for an exceptionally sharp tool.
Limitations and process implications
Section titled “Limitations and process implications”The results cover one 10 μm single-crystal diamond tool, Al6061, red copper, and feed speeds from 1.25 to 5 mm/s without coolant. The proposed dynamic effect was not isolated through time-resolved wear, passivation, or temperature data. The measured feed dependence therefore applies to the tested conditions, while the proposed continuous response to changing tool and workpiece states remains unvalidated.
The copper data also contain a reporting difference. Figure 10 gives 0.207 to 0.439 for the first trial and 0.188 to 0.29 for the second. The fitted section gives 0.188 to 0.29, while the conclusion gives 0.20091 to 0.36109. This wider spread should be resolved before using the copper fraction as a general design rule.
The conclusion describes the trend as cutting-speed dependence, although the controlled variable in the reported tests is feed rate. The experiments therefore do not establish a universal cutting-speed law.
For diamond tool engineering, edge radius must be considered with friction state and force ratio. The study does not compare diamond grades, so it cannot rank tool materials for wear life. For process control, the force transition and scratch-depth check provide a direct method for calibrating the local minimum thickness. At 800 r/min and 0.02 mm depth, a feed of 15 μm/r gave the lowest reported Ra values of 0.293 μm for aluminum and 0.309 μm for red copper.
View Original Abstract
The cutting thickness has a significant impact on surface quality: the thinner the cutting thickness, the easier it is to achieve good surface quality. The minimum cutting thickness represents the limit for chip formation. Theoretically, performing ultra-precision cutting at the minimum cutting thickness enables the achievement of an excellent machined surface with minimal surface damage and exceptional surface quality. Therefore, exploring the formation mechanism of the minimum cutting thickness and investigating the formation mechanism of surface micro topography under extreme cutting conditions are of great significance for further clarifying the extreme cutting theory, improving surface quality, and extending tool life. A dynamic minimum cutting thickness theory is proposed, followed by calculations and simulations. Furthermore, scratch experiments on aluminum alloys and red copper are conducted using a single-crystal diamond tool, during which the cutting force and scratch depth are measured. The minimum cutting thickness of aluminum alloys and red copper is determined by leveraging the corresponding relationship between the abrupt change in cutting force (from the plowing stage to the cutting stage) and the scratch depth. Based on the minimum cutting thickness, the optimal cutting parameters for the non-free cutting of aluminum alloys and red copper were obtained, and non-free cutting experiments were conducted using these parameters. The results show that the minimum cutting thickness of aluminum alloys and red copper increases with increasing feed rate. The ratios of the minimum cutting thickness to the tool edge radius are in the ranges of 0.243-0.271 and 0.20-0.36, respectively. The optimal surface roughness values are as follows: Rz = 1.505 μm and 2.014 μm, and Ra = 0.293 μm and 0.309 μm, respectively
Diamond Heat Spreader With Copper Coated Metalized Surface
View Specs →
Single Crystal Cvd Diamond Plate
View Specs →