Characterization and Valuation of Rough Diamonds
Paper details
Section titled “Paper details”| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Journal | Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) |
| Published | 2026-10-16 |
| Authors | Дронова Нона Дмитриевна |
| DOI | 10.5281/zenodo.23418135 |
Rough diamond value depends on weight, form, color, and defectiveness, with internal stress affecting processing decisions. The guide reports raw prices from $0.8 to $6,000 per carat and states that valuation error can reach 15% in practice.
Evaluation criteria
Section titled “Evaluation criteria”The authors treat four properties as the principal value factors: weight, purity or quality, color, and crystal form. Sorting also records surface condition, cracks, inclusions, joints, and internal diamond growth. Jewelry and technical rough are separated before these criteria are applied.
An ideal octahedron with flat facets and sharp direct edges has the highest form value, but the guide says natural crystals rarely grow with that symmetry. Curved facets, rounded edges, stepped relief, and distortion are common.
The guide further separates shape from preservation. Whole crystals may be chipped by no more than one third of the original form without a significant shape change. A fragment contains at least two thirds of the original volume.
Inspection and measurement
Section titled “Inspection and measurement”The document gives conventional sorting steps rather than an experimental campaign. Weight is measured with electronic scales with accuracy up to 0.001 carat. Dimensions are assigned through screens, while shape is inspected visually with a sixfold magnifier. Purity is judged from the number, size, and contrast of inclusions and from physical defects. The quality procedure specifies a tenfold magnifier, with a microscope for smaller sorts.
Color is checked in daylight against white paper and compared with reference shades. The guide recommends a mercury quartz SVD-120A lamp with a UFS-3 filter for ultraviolet excitation. Observation uses an MBS-2 binocular microscope with a ZH-3 filter.
Polarized microscopy reveals strain patterns that ordinary microscopy can miss. The guide reports 100 percent X-ray luminescence from diamonds and uses this response for extraction and identification. Under ultraviolet excitation, only some diamonds glow.
The carat definition is inconsistent within the document. One section gives 1 metric carat as 200 mg. A later section gives 1 carat as 0.1 g.
Morphology and aggregate forms
Section titled “Morphology and aggregate forms”The authors place rough forms in six crystallographic systems and show simple and combination habits. The cubic illustrations include octahedron, cube, rhombic dodecahedron, tetrahedron, and related combinations. Their discussion stresses how strongly curved facets can prevent direct identification with standard crystallographic polyhedra.
Three aggregate forms receive separate treatment. Bort consists of small crystals and poorly faceted grains in irregular aggregates. Ballas contains small crystals arranged mainly in cyclic twins and can approach a sphere. Carbonado is cryptocrystalline, with a smooth surface formed from rounded, table-like grain surfaces.
Alluvial transport rounds crystal edges, chips corners, and dulls facets. Stronger impacts can produce sphere-like grains with rough, opaque surfaces.
Distortion is the ratio of the longest crystal dimension to the shortest. The guide applies these thresholds:
| Shape class | Length to width ratio |
|---|---|
| Regular shape | 1:1 |
| Insignificant distortion | 1.5:1 |
| Small distortion | 2:1 |
| Distorted | 3:1 |
| Big distortion | 4:1 |
| Needle-shaped or lamellar | More than 4:1 |
Defects and internal stress
Section titled “Defects and internal stress”Crystals are divided into central, intermediate, and peripheral areas of equal thickness. The classification distinguishes the same defect type by its location.
Olivine inclusions measure 0.5 to 1 mm along long axes and may occur as groups of 5 to 10. Garnets reach 0.2 mm. Chromspinelides occur as about 10 to 15 grains per crystal and range from 1 mm to grains barely visible under high magnification. Sulfides include pentlandite, pyrrhotine, and chalcopyrite. They can form rosettes in disk-shaped cracks.
Cracks may be submicroscopic or cross the whole crystal. They follow cleavage directions and can contain graphite along their walls. Diamond cleaves along planes parallel to octahedron faces. This combination gives the material high hardness but also makes impact damage important.
Under polarized light, strain produces anomalous double refraction. The guide treats the pattern as a processing indicator. A cut through a tension center may initiate or extend cracks. Local tension around impact chips can slow cutting, while tension linked to mixed inclusions has no serious effect on cutting.
Sorting thresholds and intended use
Section titled “Sorting thresholds and intended use”The defectiveness scale has five levels. Clear stones show no defects under a sixfold magnifier. Minor defects are barely visible at that magnification. Small defects are barely visible to the naked eye but clear at sixfold. Large defects are visible to the naked eye and can include inclusions no larger than half the thickness of one area. Extremely large defects allow larger inclusions and longer cracks.
Color is sorted into six groups: colorless, insignificant color, small color, clear color, colored, and brown. The guide emphasizes that visual classification remains partly subjective because the inspector’s eye remains the main tool.
The stated international weight groups are tiny at 0.01 to 0.15 carat, small at 0.15 to 0.66 carat, average at 0.7 to 1.8 carats, and large at 2 to 10.8 carats. Crystals from 10.8 to 50 carats are called Special, and those above 50 carats are called Name. These are the guide’s reported boundaries rather than a newly tested sizing scheme.
Jewelry and technical material receive different sorting. The former Soviet specification defines nine categories, with the first two mainly serving jewelry. Technical uses include measuring tips, drawing machines, drills, marine chronometer cap jewels, glass cutters, wheel dressing, and well drilling devices. Only transparent crystals are used to produce brilliants.
Price benchmarks and uncertainty
Section titled “Price benchmarks and uncertainty”Russian rough exports cited in the guide range from $0.8 to $6,000 per carat. The average for Argail material is $10 per carat. The guide also says Argail produced more than one third of global extraction.
Its market summary places more than 50 percent of physical deliveries in the lowest quality small diamond segment, with an average price near $1 per carat. About 35 percent consists of low quality Indian goods at about $50 per carat. Average and high quality material accounts for about 15 percent of deliveries and averages $350 per carat. The guide’s $10 per carat Argail average lies between the $1 and $50 segment averages.
Price can rise sharply within a narrow weight band. For stones of comparable shape, quality, and color, material weighing 1.00 to 1.24 carats commands over 30 percent more per carat than material weighing 0.90 to 0.99 carats. The difference can reach 140 percent for colorless stones at the highest stated quality.
The guide says specialists sort rough into 6,000 categories. It assigns a minimum valuation error of 5 percent and says practical error can reach 15 percent. The market figures are cited benchmarks rather than results from a valuation experiment in the document.
Limits and material selection
Section titled “Limits and material selection”Several limits affect direct use of the guide. The 2005 Moscow text provides historical classifications and market examples. The metadata dates the Zenodo record to 2026. It reports no sample set, calibration campaign, statistical analysis, or validation of the stated error rates. It also gives the inconsistent carat definitions noted earlier.
Shape and color grading are partly subjective. The defectiveness system uses the human eye, and the authors acknowledge ambiguity in its boundaries. Color origin remains unresolved in the text. The authors present mixture and crystal lattice explanations, then cite nitrogen content as an important factor. These statements should not be read as one demonstrated mechanism.
For engineers, carat weight cannot stand alone as a selection criterion. Rough intended for tools must be checked for cleavage, crack depth, inclusion distribution, preserved form, and strain under polarized light. The guide warns that internal tension can make a crystal crack during cutting even when no inclusion has been found.
Selection records should preserve the inspection conditions and defect map used for valuation. Weight alone omits the processing controls identified by the guide.
View Original Abstract
Original title: Характеристика и оценка алмазного сырья Authors: N. D. Dronova and I. E. Kuzmina Original publication: Moscow State Mining University, Moscow, 2004 Publication type: Educational and methodological textbook Full-text language: Russian Abstract This educational and methodological textbook provides a systematic examination of the mineralogical, crystallographic, morphological, technological, and commercial characteristics of natural rough diamonds, with particular emphasis on their classification, sorting, and valuation. The publication explores the relationship between the physical properties of diamond crystals, their natural morphological features, internal and external defects, suitability for processing, and economic value. The first sections introduce the principal crystallographic forms of natural diamonds and describe their morphological diversity, including octahedral, cubic, dodecahedral, and combined crystal forms. Special attention is given to the deformation of crystal morphology, growth structures, surface characteristics, and the occurrence of polycrystalline and granular diamond aggregates, including bort, ballas, and carbonado. The textbook examines the effects of natural mechanical processes, alluvial abrasion, fractures, cleavage, and crystal breakage on the appearance and quality of diamond rough. A separate section discusses the principal physical and gemological characteristics used in diamond assessment, including crystal weight, dimensions, color, transparency, inclusions, surface defects, and internal structural features. The technological properties of diamonds are considered in relation to their suitability for cutting and processing. These include cleavage, luster, transparency, coloration, luminescence, and stress-related optical effects. The publication also presents approaches to the classification of rough diamonds, distinguishing gem-quality and industrial diamonds according to their intended applications and quality characteristics. Considerable attention is devoted to the sorting of rough diamonds by weight, crystal shape, surface morphology, color, and quality. The textbook describes classification groups, sorting procedures, and technical specifications used in the diamond industry during the period covered by the original publication. The final section examines the pricing of rough diamonds, including the influence of weight, quality, classification, market conditions, and anticipated processing results on commercial value. An illustrated appendix provides detailed drawings of natural diamond crystal forms and morphological varieties, supporting the identification and classification of rough diamonds. Scientific and educational significance The publication serves as a methodological reference for the study of natural diamond morphology, rough diamond classification, diamond sorting, and valuation principles. It may be of interest to gemologists, mineralogists, diamond industry professionals, jewelry appraisers, researchers, and students specializing in mineral processing and gemstone evaluation. The textbook also provides a historical record of classification approaches and professional practices used in the diamond industry in the early 2000s. Historical context and limitations Originally published in 2004, this textbook reflects the technical classifications, industry terminology, commercial practices, and pricing conditions of its publication period. Historical price examples, classification systems, and technical specifications should not be interpreted as current market information or automatically applicable contemporary standards. Any use of these materials for present-day commercial diamond valuation requires verification against current market data, applicable regulations, and relevant professional standards. Bibliographic information Dronova, N. D., & Kuzmina, I. E. (2004). Характеристика и оценка алмазного сырья [Characterization and Valuation of Rough Diamonds]. Moscow State Mining University, Moscow. Full text: Russian-language PDF. Digital edition: Digitized reproduction of the original 2004 educational publication. Характеристика и оценка алмазного сырья Авторы: Н. Д. Дронова, И. Е. Кузьмина Издание: Московский государственный горный университет, Москва, 2004 Тип публикации: Учебное пособие Аннотация Учебное пособие посвящено изучению минералогических, кристаллографических, морфологических, физических и технологических характеристик природных алмазов, а также вопросам классификации, сортировки и оценки алмазного сырья. В работе систематизированы сведения о кристаллических формах алмазов, особенностях их природного роста, морфологии поверхности, внутренних и внешних дефектах, технологических свойствах и характеристиках, влияющих на коммерческую ценность алмазного сырья. Рассматриваются основные кристаллографические формы алмазов, включая октаэдрические, кубические, додекаэдрические и комбинационные разновидности. Особое внимание уделено деформации кристаллов, характеру развития граней, особенностям поверхности и зернистым образованиям алмаза — борту, балласу и карбонадо. Описаны признаки аллювиального износа, трещиноватости и излома кристаллов, а также их значение при характеристике и оценке природных алмазов. Представлены основные характеристики алмазного сырья и методы их определения: масса, размеры, форма, окраска, прозрачность, включения, поверхностные дефекты и особенности внутреннего строения. Рассмотрены технологические свойства кристаллов алмаза, включая спайность, блеск, прозрачность, окраску, люминесценцию и особенности проявления двупреломления, обусловленного внутренними напряжениями. Значительная часть пособия посвящена классификации алмазного сырья, его разделению на ювелирные и технические категории, определению качественных характеристик и сортировке алмазов по массе, форме, цвету и наличию дефектов. Изложены принципы сортировки необработанных алмазов, классификационные группы и технические условия, применявшиеся в алмазной промышленности в рассматриваемый исторический период. Отдельный раздел посвящён вопросам ценообразования и определения стоимости алмазного сырья с учётом массы, качества, коммерческой категории, состояния рынка и предполагаемых результатов последующей обработки. Приложение содержит многочисленные иллюстрации природных кристаллов алмаза, демонстрирующие особенности их морфологии, роста, деформации и комбинационных форм. Научно-методическое значение Пособие представляет интерес для специалистов в области геммологии, минералогии, алмазной промышленности, оценки драгоценных камней, ювелирного производства и технологии обработки минералов. Материал может использоваться в образовательных и исследовательских целях, в том числе для изучения исторических подходов к классификации, сортировке и оценке природных алмазов. Примечание об историческом характере информации Пособие опубликовано в 2004 году. Содержащиеся в нём технические классификации, нормативные ссылки, коммерческие сведения и ценовые показатели отражают практику соответствующего периода. При использовании материалов для современной оценки алмазного сырья необходимо учитывать действующие стандарты, современные технологии обработки и актуальные рыночные условия. Библиографические сведения Дронова Н. Д., Кузьмина И. Е. Характеристика и оценка алмазного сырья: учебное пособие. — М.: Московский государственный горный университет, 2004. Полный текст: русский язык, PDF. Характер цифровой публикации: цифровая копия оригинального учебного пособия 2004 года. English keywords Rough diamonds; Diamond valuation; Diamond grading; Diamond classification; Diamond sorting; Diamond morphology; Diamond crystallography; Natural diamonds; Diamond crystal defects; Diamond quality assessment; Gemology; Diamond pricing; Industrial diamonds; Diamond processing Русские ключевые слова Алмазное сырьё; Оценка алмазов; Классификация алмазов; Сортировка алмазов; Морфология алмазов; Кристаллография алмаза; Природные алмазы; Дефекты кристаллов; Геммология; Ювелирные алмазы; Технические алмазы; Ценообразование алмазов; Обработка алмазов
Electronic Grade Intrinsic Diamond Epitaxial Wafer H Terminated Superior 100 Mosfet Ready Substrate
View Specs →
Single Crystal Cvd Diamond Plate
View Specs →