Skip to content

Radiation hardness of three-dimensional polycrystalline diamond detectors

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2015-05-11
JournalApplied Physics Letters
AuthorsS. Lagomarsino, Marco Bellini, C. Corsi, V. Cindro, K. Kanxheri
InstitutionsIstituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare, National Institute of Optics
Citations49
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • Core Innovation: Fabrication and testing of three-dimensional (3D) polycrystalline diamond detectors utilizing graphitic columnar electrodes created via pulsed laser irradiation, compared against conventional planar (2D) sensors.
  • Unprecedented Radiation Hardness: Devices tested under fast neutron irradiation up to a fluence of 1.2 × 1016 cm-2 (1 MeV-equivalent)—described as the highest neutron damage ever experimented for this detector class.
  • Performance Multiplier: 3D detectors deliver a signal up to 3× higher than planar (2D) sensors at maximum fluence, attributed to shorter carrier collection paths and reduced bias voltage requirements.
  • Material Strategy: Demonstrated on polycrystalline electronic-grade CVD diamond, overcoming the size and cost limitations of single-crystal diamond (which is capped at ~8 × 8 mm2). Polycrystalline diamond is available up to ~120 mm diameter and costs ~3× less per unit area.
  • Geometric Configuration: Inter-electrode spacing engineered at 70 µm or 100 µm with bulk thickness of ~500 µm, enabling high charge collection efficiency (CCE).
  • Simulated and Validated: Device behavior modeled with Synopsys SENTaurus TCAD and benchmarked against 90Sr-beta irradiation data, achieving strong agreement with experimental results.
  • Application Horizon: Targeted at upcoming high-luminosity high-energy physics (HEP) experiments (e.g., LHC upgrades) where fluences are projected to increase by ≥10×.
ParameterValueUnitContext
Detector Architecture3D (columnar graphitic electrodes) vs. 2D (planar)—Compared on same PCD substrate
Diamond GradePolycrystalline electronic-grade CVD—Active sensor material
Substrate Thickness~500µmBulk detector volume
Inter-Electrode Spacing70 or 100µmLaser-fabricated graphitic column pitch
Electrode TypePulsed-laser graphitized columns—Perpendicular to surface
Bias Voltage (2D)±800VStandard planar operation window
Bias Voltage (3D)±200 (simulated)VReduced due to short drift distance
Collection Efficiency (pre-irradiation, 3D)Up to ~0.1 (10% normalized)—Beta source 90Sr at 100 µm pitch
Max Tested Fluence1.2 × 1016cm-21 MeV-equivalent neutrons
Signal Improvement (3D vs 2D)Up to 3×—At highest fluence level
Reference Single-Crystal 3D CCE95% at 3VPrior benchmark (SCD 3D)
Carrier Mobilities (diamond)High (both carriers)cm²/VsLarge saturation velocity
Band Gap (diamond)5.5eVLarge displacement energy
Operating TemperatureRoom temperature (no cooling)—Inherently radiation tolerant
Simulation ToolSynopsys SENTaurus TCAD—I-2013.12 release
  1. Substrate Selection: Polycrystalline electronic-grade CVD diamond plates selected for large-area scalability (up to 120 mm Ø) and cost-effectiveness vs. single-crystal.
  2. 3D Electrode Fabrication: Pulsed laser irradiation used to write graphitic columns perpendicular to the diamond surface at controlled spacing (70 µm or 100 µm).
  3. Planar (2D) Reference Fabrication: Conventional planar metallization electrodes patterned on identical PCD samples for direct A/B comparison.
  4. Pre-Irradiation Characterization: Charge collection efficiency (CCE) measured using a 90Sr beta source under variable bias (±800 V for 2D, lower for 3D).
  5. Neutron Irradiation Protocol: Samples exposed to fast neutrons at the Jozef Stefan Institute (Ljubljana) reactor with 1 MeV-equivalent fluence steps up to 1.2 × 1016 cm-2.
  6. Kerma Normalization: Neutron spectra converted using kerma factors (Caswell et al., 1980) to provide 1 MeV-equivalent displacement damage units.
  7. Post-Irradiation Testing: CCE re-measured under identical bias conditions; data normalized to pre-irradiation values to extract damage coefficients.
  8. TCAD Simulation: Carrier transport modeled in Synopsys SENTaurus TCAD using Shockley-Read-Hall recombination and field-dependent mobility; trap densities tuned to match Hecht’s law and experimental CCE curves.
  9. Hecht Equation Fitting: Carrier dynamics fit to extract effective trapping lengths and trapping time constants as a function of fluence.
  10. Raman/Electrical Imaging: Laser-induced graphitic channels characterized for sp2/sp3 ratio, electrical resistivity, and column morphology.
Requirement from Paper6CCVD Capability
Polycrystalline electronic-grade diamond (500 µm bulk)Electronic Grade PCD available in 0.1 µm - 500 µm thickness range
Large-area substrate (up to 120 mm Ø scalability)PCD plates/wafers up to 125 mm diameter
High-purity active volume for charge transportOptical / Electronic Grade PCD with controlled sp2 content
Single-crystal benchmark / comparison samplesSingle Crystal Diamond (SCD) up to 8 × 8 mm2, 0.1 µm - 500 µm
Graphitic electrode patterning via laserCompatible with customer-furnished post-processing; 6CCVD supplies polished substrates
Metallization for planar (2D) contactsIn-house metalization (Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, Cu) for ohmic/Schottky contacts
Surface preparation for low-leakage operationSCD polishing Ra < 1 nm; PCD polishing Ra < 5 nm at inch-scale
High-resistivity material for low leakage currentBoron-Doped Diamond (BDD) available in tailored resistivity grades
Global delivery to HEP labs (CERN, GSI, JSI)Global shipping (DDU default, DDP available)
  • Primary: Electronic-Grade Polycrystalline Diamond (PCD) — directly matches the active substrate used in this work; available in thicknesses up to 500 µm and diameters up to 125 mm for next-generation 3D detector arrays.
  • Reference / Benchmark: Optical Grade Single Crystal Diamond (SCD) — recommended for groups wishing to reproduce the 95% CCE at 3 V benchmark reported for SCD 3D detectors.
  • Alternative (Low-Leakage Variant): Intrinsic/High-Purity PCD for applications requiring minimal dark current at extreme fluences.
  • Custom Thickness: Substrates can be supplied from 0.1 µm freestanding films up to 10 mm-thick bulk plates to accommodate non-standard drift volumes.
  • Laser Cutting & Dicing: 6CCVD provides precision laser cutting services, enabling delivery of detector-grade coupons in custom geometries ready for graphitization.
  • Custom Metalization: Ti/Pt/Au, Cr/Au, or all-carbon graphitic contact schemes can be applied in-house to streamline the 2D reference fabrication workflow.
  • Resistivity Tuning: Boron-doping concentration can be specified to engineer depletion voltage and contact behavior.
  • 6CCVD’s in-house PhD engineering team can assist with material selection (PCD grade, thickness, surface finish) for radiation-hard detector projects targeting HEP, neutron imaging, dosimetry, and synchrotron beam diagnostics.
  • Consultation available for Hecht-equation fitting, trapping length estimation, and TCAD-compatible material parameter extraction to accelerate detector simulation cycles.
  • Material datasheets include carrier mobility, lifetime, and defect density benchmarks drawn from published literature and internal characterization.

For custom specifications, radiation-hard diamond substrates, or material consultation on 3D detector prototyping, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.

View Original Abstract

The three-dimensional concept in particle detection is based on the fabrication of columnar electrodes perpendicular to the surface of a solid state radiation sensor. It permits to improve the radiation resistance characteristics of a material by lowering the necessary bias voltage and shortening the charge carrier path inside the material. If applied to a long-recognized exceptionally radiation-hard material like diamond, this concept promises to pave the way to the realization of detectors of unprecedented performances. We fabricated conventional and three-dimensional polycrystalline diamond detectors, and tested them before and after neutron damage up to 1.2 ×1016 cm−2, 1 MeV-equivalent neutron fluence. We found that the signal collected by the three-dimensional detectors is up to three times higher than that of the conventional planar ones, at the highest neutron damage ever experimented.

  1. 2010 - Diamond detectors for hadron physics research [Crossref]
  2. 2005 - Physics potential and experimental challenges of the LHC luminosity upgrade [Crossref]
  3. 2009 - Radiation Sensors for High Energy Physics Experiments, in CVD Diamond for Electronic Devices and Sensors
  4. 2012 - Signal and noise of diamond pixel detectors at high radiation fluences [Crossref]
  5. 2002 - High carrier mobility in single-crystal plasma-deposited diamond [Crossref]
  6. 2006 - Development of single-crystal CVD-diamond detectors for spectroscopy and timing [Crossref]
  7. 2011 - In-beam diamond start detectors [Crossref]
  8. 2013 - Three-dimensional diamond detectors: Charge collection efficiency of graphitic electrodes [Crossref]
  9. 2013 - A novel detector with graphitic electrodes in CVD diamond [Crossref]
  10. 2013 - Laser-processed three dimensional graphitic electrodes for diamond radiation detectors [Crossref]