Skip to content

Direct observation of electron emission from grain boundaries in CVD diamond by PeakForce-controlled tunnelling atomic force microscopy

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2015-07-04
JournalCarbon
AuthorsRobert L. Harniman, Oliver Fox, Wiebke Janssen, Sien Drijkoningen, Ken Haenen
InstitutionsUniversity of Bristol, Hasselt University
Citations65
AnalysisFull AI Review Included

Direct Observation of Electron Emission from Grain Boundaries in CVD Diamond via PF-TUNA

Section titled “Direct Observation of Electron Emission from Grain Boundaries in CVD Diamond via PF-TUNA”
  • Objective: Direct visualization and quantification of electron field emission sites on polycrystalline CVD diamond films using PeakForce-controlled tunnelling atomic force microscopy (PF-TUNA).
  • Key Finding: Electron emission originates preferentially from grain boundaries, not from topographical peaks or sharp edges, effectively debunking the need for geometric field enhancement in diamond cold cathodes.
  • Grain Size Correlation: Emission area scales inversely with grain size: Undoped MCD (18%) → NCD (26%) → UNCD (49%).
  • Doping Effects: Light N, B, or P doping broadens emission sites along grain boundaries; heavy B-doping (~9 × 1020 cm-3) results in near-metallic conductivity with uniform emission across both grains and boundaries (80-90% surface area).
  • Phosphorus Anomaly: Light P-doping induces micro-stepped (111) facets that act as dense emission networks, surpassing even UNCD with 62% emitting surface area.
  • Temporal Instability: Measured emission current decays to ~10% of its initial value within 30 hours of ambient exposure, attributed to surface adsorbates and transfer doping.
  • Engineering Implication: Flat, heavily doped, or nanocrystalline diamond wafers provide superior field emission without complex microfabrication of conical or needle-like structures.
ParameterValueUnitContext
Film Thickness (MCD/NCD)~5µmUndoped & N-doped films
Film Thickness (P-doped)~2.5µmPhosphorus-doped MCD
Film Thickness (Heavy B-doped)~3µmHigh boron concentration
Substrate Resistivity (P-doped)10-20kΩ·cmHighly resistive Si (100)
Deposition Pressure (N-doped)110TorrMWCVD reactor
Deposition Pressure (P-doped)50TorrASTeX PDA-18 reactor
Substrate Temperature (P-doped)820°CP-doped MCD growth
Microwave Power (N-doped)1.0kWNCD deposition
Microwave Power (P-doped)5.0kWMWCVD reactor
Methane Concentration (N-doped)6.5%CH4/H2Renucleation conditions
Methane Concentration (P-doped)1%CH4/H2Microcrystalline growth
Light B-doping (B2H6)~50ppmB concentration ~2.4 × 1019 cm-3
Heavy B-doping (B2H6)~10,000ppmB concentration ~9 × 1020 cm-3
P-doping (PH3)10,000ppm P/CEstimated P ~1 × 1019 cm-3
Resistivity (Undoped MCD/NCD)>10MΩHighly insulating
Resistivity (Light B-doped)~160kΩp-type semiconductor
Resistivity (Heavy B-doped)~100ΩNear-metallic
Activation Energy (N in diamond)1.7eVHigh; causes passivation
AFM Cantilever Spring Constant0.4N/mPtIr-coated tip
Tip Radius20nmNominal PtIr coating
Tip-Sample Bias1 mV - 1 V—Tunnelling regime
Tip-Sample Gap~1nmPeakForce controlled
Emission Current RangepA - hundreds of pA—Per emission site
Bake Temperature200°CVacuum recovery test
Emission Decay Time~30hours~90% reduction post-exposure
  1. Substrate Preparation: Diamond deposition on highly resistive Si (100) substrates (10-20 kΩ·cm) to enable back-contact biasing.
  2. MPCVD/MWCVD Growth:
    • Undoped MCD: Standard CH4/H2 chemistry, H-terminated.
    • UNCD: Inert gas addition (Ar) for renucleation, grain size <10 nm.
    • N-doped NCD: 6.5% CH4/0.7% N2/H2 at 110 Torr, 1 kW.
    • P-doped MCD: 1% CH4/H2 + PH3 at 50 Torr, 820°C.
    • Light B-doped: +50 ppm diborane.
    • Heavy B-doped: +10,000 ppm diborane.
  3. Hydrogen Termination: Post-deposition H-plasma exposure to establish surface conductivity.
  4. Electrical Contacting: Conductive silver paint attaching Si substrate to steel disc; bias applied between grounded sample and AFM tip.
  5. PF-TUNA Imaging: Multi-mode VIII AFM with PF-TUNA module, PeakForce feedback, PtIr cantilevers (k = 0.4 N/m), 5120 × 5120 pixel resolution, 0.1 Hz scan rate.
  6. Threshold Analysis: Quantification of emitting surface area via RMS current threshold; comparison across samples using relative percentage methodology.
  7. Aging Studies: Ambient exposure monitoring with 200°C vacuum bake recovery tests.

The findings in this paper — particularly the dominance of grain boundary emission and the exceptional performance of nanocrystalline and heavily boron-doped morphologies — align directly with 6CCVD’s manufacturing portfolio for vacuum electronic and cold cathode applications.

  • Optical Grade PCD & Heavy Boron-Doped PCD (BDD): The heavy B-doped MCD films (~9 × 1020 cm-3) producing 80-90% uniform emission correspond to 6CCVD’s Heavy Boron-Doped PCD line, where near-metallic resistivity enables uniform electron emission without microfabricated emitter tips.
  • Nanocrystalline Diamond (NCD/UNCD): The inverse grain-size/emission relationship validates 6CCVD’s NCD/UNCD PCD wafers for flat-panel cold cathode arrays, eliminating the need for complex tip-sharpening lithography.
  • Intrinsic & Lightly Doped PCD: For controlled grain boundary emission studies, 6CCVD supplies Optical Grade PCD with custom grain size distributions grown via MPCVD.
  • Doping Precision: 6CCVD’s MPCVD reactors enable calibrated B, N, and P doping across the full spectrum used in this work — from insulating (>10 MΩ) to near-metallic (~100 Ω) regimes.
  • Wafer Dimensions: While this study used small Si-supported films, 6CCVD manufactures freestanding PCD plates up to 125mm in diameter, enabling large-area field emitter arrays for commercial flat-panel displays and accelerator RF injectors.
  • Thickness Control: Films can be supplied from 0.1 µm to 500 µm (PCD/SCD) and up to 10mm for substrates — critical for managing back-contact resistance and mechanical robustness in vacuum devices.
  • Surface Engineering: 6CCVD offers polishing to Ra &lt; 5nm on inch-size PCD, addressing the temporal instability issue highlighted in this paper by providing smooth, controlled surfaces for reproducible emission characterization.
  • Metalization: For device integration, 6CCVD provides in-house metalization (Ti, Pt, Au, W, Cu, Pd) to facilitate back-contacts and electrode patterning required for field emitter array fabrication.
  • Laser Cutting: Custom geometries (including the high-density emitter arrays implied by this research) can be achieved through 6CCVD’s laser cutting services.

6CCVD’s in-house PhD engineering team can assist with:

  • Selecting the optimal grain size-to-doping ratio for specific field emission targets.
  • Replicating the micro-stepped (111) P-doped morphology observed in this study for enhanced step-edge emission sites.
  • Designing H-terminated surface protocols to maximize the initial emission current and minimize the ~90% ambient decay documented in the aging studies.
  • Advising on vacuum storage and transfer best practices to preserve surface transfer doping effects.

For custom specifications, tailored doping concentrations, or material consultation on diamond cold cathode and field emitter projects, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.

View Original Abstract

A detailed investigation of electron emission from a set of chemical vapour deposited (CVD) diamond films is reported using high-resolution PeakForce-controlled tunnelling atomic force microscopy (PF-TUNA). Electron field emission originates preferentially from the grain boundaries in low-conductivity polycrystalline diamond samples, and not from the top of features or sharp edges. Samples with smaller grains and more grain boundaries, such as nanocrystalline diamond, produce a higher emission current over a more uniform area than diamond samples with larger grain size. Light doping with N, B or P increases the grain conductivity, with the result that the emitting grain-boundary sites become broader as the emission begins to creep up the grain sidewalls. For heavy B doping, where the grains are now more conducting than the grain boundaries, emission comes from both the grain boundaries and the grains almost equally. Lightly P-doped diamond samples show emission from step-edges on the (1 1 1) surfaces. Emission intensity was time dependent, with the measured current dropping to ∼10% of its initial value ∼30 h after removal from the CVD chamber. This decrease is ascribed to the build-up of adsorbates on the surface along with an increase in the surface conductivity due to surface transfer doping.

  1. 2008 - Forms and behaviour of vacuum emission electronic devices comprising diamond or other carbon cold cathode emitters [Crossref]
  2. 2011 - A review of recent results on diamond vacuum lateral field emission device operation in radiation environments [Crossref]
  3. 2014 - Planar ultrananocrystalline diamond field emitter in accelerator radio frequency electron injector: Performance metrics [Crossref]
  4. 2014 - High quantum efficiency ultrananocrystalline diamond photocathode for photoinjector applications [Crossref]
  5. 2012 - Field emission from diamond-coated multiwalled carbon nanotube ‘teepee’ structures [Crossref]
  6. 2013 - An increase in the field emission from vertically aligned multiwalled carbon nanotubes caused by NH3 plasma treatment [Crossref]
  7. 2002 - Can we reliably estimate the emission field and field enhancement factor of carbon nanotube film field emitters? [Crossref]
  8. 2001 - Field emission from short and stubby vertically aligned carbon nanotubes [Crossref]
  9. 2008 - Highly resilient field emission from aligned single-walled carbon nanotube arrays chemically attached to n-type silicon [Crossref]
  10. 1998 - A new surface electron-emission mechanism in diamond cathodes [Crossref]