Skip to content

Determination of output factor for 6 MV small photon beam - comparison between Monte Carlo simulation technique and microDiamond detector

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2016-03-01
JournalJournal of Physics Conference Series
AuthorsKomkrit Krongkietlearts, P Tangboonduangjit, N Paisangittisakul
InstitutionsChulalongkorn University, Ramathibodi Hospital
Citations6
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • The study validates synthetic single-crystal diamond as a small-volume detector for measuring 6 MV photon-beam output factors used in stereotactic radiotherapy, IMRT, and VMAT.
  • The PTW microDiamond detector had a 0.004 mm3 sensitive volume, approximately four times smaller than the comparison stereotactic field detector’s 0.017 mm3 volume.
  • Monte Carlo calculations used EGSnrc/BEAMnrc/DOSXYZnrc to model a Varian Clinac iX and radiation transport in water.
  • The calibrated accelerator model used an initial electron energy of 6.2 MeV and a radial intensity FWHM of 0.6 mm, producing measurement-to-simulation differences below 1% for the reference beam data.
  • For 1 × 1, 2 × 2, 3 × 3, and 5 × 5 cm2 fields at 5 cm and 10 cm depths, the microDiamond and SFD results agreed with Monte Carlo calculations within 2%.
  • The results support the use of high-purity, high-resolution SCD for small-field dosimetry, while also highlighting the need to control sensitive-volume geometry, detector perturbation, and calibration uncertainty.
ParameterValueUnitContext
Photon-beam nominal energy6MVSmall-field radiotherapy beam
Linear acceleratorClinac iX—Modeled and measured radiotherapy system
Initial electron-beam energy6.2MeVBest-fit Monte Carlo parameter
Radial electron-intensity FWHM0.6mmBest-fit Monte Carlo parameter
Reference source-to-surface distance100cmBeam calibration and common-data measurements
Reference field size10 × 10cm2Calibration field
Additional simulated/measured field sizes1 × 1, 2 × 2, 3 × 3, 5 × 5cm2Small-field output-factor evaluation
Measurement depths5 and 10cmPercentage depth dose, profiles, and output factors
Scan resolution1mmIBA Blue Phantom2 profile scan
microDiamond modelPTW-60019—Synthetic single-crystal diamond detector
microDiamond diameter2.2mmOverall detector diameter reported by the paper
microDiamond sensitive volume0.004mm3Active sensing volume
SFD sensitive volume0.017mm3Comparison detector
Sensitive-volume reductionApproximately 4×—microDiamond relative to SFD
microDiamond materialSynthetic single-crystal diamond—Tissue-equivalent radiation-sensing material
Calibration-field agreement<1%Selected Monte Carlo parameters versus measured PDD and profiles
General measurement/simulation agreement<2%Field-size, depth-dependent output-factor comparisons
Detector repetition count5MeasurementsAveraged central-axis dose for each field and depth
Detector or calculationDepth1 × 1 cm22 × 2 cm23 × 3 cm25 × 5 cm2Difference from MC
SFD5 cm0.75740.87860.91400.93731.2-1.6%
microDiamond5 cm0.75860.87990.91150.93811.1-1.7%
Monte Carlo5 cm0.74570.86730.90180.9266Reference
SFD10 cm0.69950.82430.86690.90521.3-1.8%
microDiamond10 cm0.70280.81130.86450.89201.3-1.9%
Monte Carlo10 cm0.68930.80990.85330.9037Reference
  1. Model the treatment head

    • Used EGSnrc and BEAMnrc to construct a Monte Carlo model of a Varian Clinac iX.
    • Supplied accelerator geometry and beam-defining information using the high-energy accelerator Monte Carlo data package.
  2. Calibrate the radiation source

    • Calculated percentage depth dose and dose profiles for a 10 × 10 cm2 field at 100 cm SSD.
    • Compared profiles at 5 cm and 10 cm depths with measured data.
    • Varied initial electron energy and radial intensity distribution.
    • Selected the parameter set producing the lowest chi-square value and a measurement-to-simulation difference below ±1%.
  3. Apply the calibrated model

    • Used the selected initial electron energy of 6.2 MeV.
    • Used a radial-intensity FWHM of 0.6 mm.
    • Simulated dose distributions in water for fields of 1 × 1, 5 × 5, and 10 × 10 cm2 at 5 cm and 10 cm depths.
  4. Acquire common beam data

    • Used the IBA Blue Phantom2 for scanning.
    • Set source-to-surface distance to 100 cm.
    • Used a 10 × 10 cm2 field.
    • Scanned dose profiles at 5 cm and 10 cm depth with 1 mm spatial resolution.
  5. Measure output factors

    • Used the PTW-60019 microDiamond and the Scanditronix IBA SFD.
    • Positioned the detectors at 5 cm and 10 cm depths.
    • Measured the central-axis dose for the small fields.
    • Repeated each microDiamond measurement five times and used the mean value.
  6. Compare results

    • Compared SFD and microDiamond measurements with Monte Carlo calculations.
    • Evaluated relative output factors for 1 × 1, 2 × 2, 3 × 3, and 5 × 5 cm2 fields.
    • Confirmed differences below 2% across the tested conditions.
Application requirementRecommended 6CCVD materialRationale
High-resolution small-field dosimetryOptical Grade SCDProvides a single-crystal platform suitable for precision sensing and minimizes grain-boundary-related variability
Enhanced charge collection and sensor responseElectronic Grade SCDSupports detector-grade electrical performance and stable charge transport
Radiation-hard sensor developmentHigh-purity SCDSuitable for experiments requiring stable response under repeated irradiation
Large-area or distributed sensingPCDAvailable for custom wafer or plate-scale detector architectures
Conductive detector structuresBoron-Doped PCD or BDDSupports lower-resistance electrode integration where charge transport is important
Reference or comparative detector studiesOptical Grade SCDCan be used for custom detector elements, test structures, and validation samples

The paper specifically uses a synthetic single-crystal diamond detector, so Optical Grade or Electronic Grade SCD is the closest material class for reproducing or extending the work. For applications requiring larger sensing areas or custom electrode layouts, PCD and BDD may also be evaluated.

  • Detector geometry: Custom SCD plates and wafers can be supplied in dimensions up to 125 mm for PCD, with SCD and PCD thicknesses available from 0.1 µm to 500 µm.
  • Sensitive-volume control: Diamond thickness, lateral dimensions, and active-area definition can be tailored for the intended detector design.
  • Electrical contacts: In-house metalization supports Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, and Cu.
  • Patterning and separation: Custom laser cutting and machining can define electrodes, apertures, and mounting geometries.
  • Surface quality: SCD polishing is available to Ra < 1 nm, while inch-size PCD can be polished to Ra < 5 nm.
  • Sensor integration: Substrates up to 10 mm thick are available for supporting detector packages and test fixtures.
  • Application-specific development: The 6CCVD engineering team can review electrode layout, active volume, substrate requirements, and irradiation configuration before material selection.

6CCVD’s in-house PhD team can assist with material selection and process development for similar small-field radiotherapy dosimetry and radiation-detector projects. The relevant design considerations include:

  • Diamond crystal quality and defect density
  • Active-volume thickness and lateral size
  • Charge-collection efficiency
  • Contact metalization and electrode geometry
  • Surface preparation and polishing requirements
  • Radiation stability and repeatability
  • Integration into phantom, collimator, or accelerator-test configurations

A material consultation should specify the intended beam energy, field size, measurement depth, detector orientation, dose range, and required uncertainty before selecting the final SCD grade, PCD architecture, or electrode stack.

StageRecommended action
1. Define measurement geometrySpecify field sizes, depth, SSD, and active volume
2. Select diamond gradeUse Optical Grade or Electronic Grade SCD for the initial detector prototype
3. Design contactsSelect Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, or Cu according to the required conductivity and interface design
4. Define surface specificationUse Ra < 1 nm SCD polishing where low surface roughness is important
5. Fabricate and separateApply custom laser cutting for active-area definition and mounting features
6. Validate under irradiationCompare output factors against reference detectors and Monte Carlo calculations
7. Optimize for productionEvaluate PCD or BDD for larger-area, higher-throughput, or lower-resistance sensor formats
  • The paper’s detector performance depends on a very small active volume; therefore, dimensional tolerance and active-area definition are more important than bulk material size alone.
  • For replication, prioritize SCD grade, thickness uniformity, surface finish, electrode quality, and contact adhesion.
  • For scaling, evaluate PCD or BDD when a larger active area, greater mechanical robustness, or lower device resistance is required.
  • Monte Carlo validation of the complete detector geometry should include the diamond active volume, electrode materials, housing, phantom, and surrounding water-equivalent medium.
  • The study supports diamond as a practical candidate for high-resolution radiation dosimetry, but it does not by itself establish a complete detector qualification program for clinical deployment.

For custom specifications or material consultation, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.

View Original Abstract

In order to improve the life’s quality for a cancer patient, the radiation techniques are constantly evolving. Especially, the two modern techniques which are intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) and volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) are quite promising. They comprise of many small beam sizes (beamlets) with various intensities to achieve the intended radiation dose to the tumor and minimal dose to the nearby normal tissue. The study investigates whether the microDiamond detector (PTW manufacturer), a synthetic single crystal diamond detector, is suitable for small field output factor measurement. The results were compared with those measured by the stereotactic field detector (SFD) and the Monte Carlo simulation (EGSnrc/BEAMnrc/DOSXYZ). The calibration of Monte Carlo simulation was done using the percentage depth dose and dose profile measured by the photon field detector (PFD) of the 10×10 cm2 field size with 100 cm SSD. Comparison of the values obtained from the calculations and measurements are consistent, no more than 1% difference. The output factors obtained from the microDiamond detector have been compared with those of SFD and Monte Carlo simulation, the results demonstrate the percentage difference of less than 2%.