Skip to content

Comparison of optical trapping wavelengths for nanoscopic diamonds containing nitrogen-vacancy centers

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2024-05-01
JournalJournal of Physics Communications
AuthorsSrestha Roy, Atanu Ghosh, Muruga Lokesh, Gokul Nalupurackal, Snigdhadev Chakraborty
InstitutionsIndian Institute of Technology Madras
Citations2
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • Core Investigation: Comparative analysis of two near-infrared (NIR) trapping laser wavelengths (975 nm vs. 1064 nm) on the photoluminescence (PL) and charge-state dynamics of optically trapped nanodiamonds containing high-density nitrogen-vacancy (NV) center ensembles.
  • Primary Finding: At matched IR power (100 mW) and green excitation (~83 µW at 532 nm), 1064 nm illumination induces an ~80% reduction in integrated NV PL, whereas 975 nm causes only an ~45% reduction.
  • Trap Performance Parity: Optical trap stiffness is statistically equivalent for both wavelengths (1.93 ± 0.11 pN·µm-1 at 1064 nm; 1.88 ± 0.06 pN·µm-1 at 975 nm) for 0.5 µm diamond particles — confirming the PL difference is not a trapping-efficiency artifact.
  • Mechanistic Insight: A rate-equation model incorporating effective ionization (Ieff) and recombination (Reff) rates reveals that 1064 nm drives significantly faster NV charge-state cycling than 975 nm. Wavelength-dependent multiphoton or Jahn-Teller-related pathways are speculated but unconfirmed.
  • Application Recommendation: The authors explicitly recommend 975 nm as the preferred trapping wavelength for NV-based quantum sensing, biosensing, and spin-preservation protocols.
  • Methodology: Optical tweezers with 100X/1.3 NA objective, quadrant photodiode (QPD) position detection, confocal PL spectroscopy (550-800 nm), and power-spectrum analysis (Berg-Sørensen & Flyvbjerg algorithm).
  • Strategic Value for Engineering Teams: Establishes a quantitative benchmark for selecting IR source wavelengths when integrating fluorescent nanodiamonds into hybrid quantum-biophotonic platforms.
ParameterValueUnitContext
Trapping Laser 1 (IR)975nmTest condition; lower PL quenching
Trapping Laser 2 (IR)1064nmTest condition; higher PL quenching
Excitation Laser (Green)532nmNV spin initialization and readout
Green Laser Max Power~83µWMaximum available at sample
IR Laser Power Range20 - 100mWVariable attenuation series
PL Collection Range550 - 800nmCovers NV0 ZPL (575 nm) and NV- ZPL (637 nm)
NV- Zero Phonon Line (ZPL)637nmNegative charge state emission
NV0 Zero Phonon Line (ZPL)575nmNeutral charge state emission
NV- Excited-State Lifetime Reference~10-12 (bulk)nsTypical; not directly measured in this work
Trap Stiffness @ 1064 nm1.93 ± 0.11pN·µm-1For 0.5 µm diamond
Trap Stiffness @ 975 nm1.88 ± 0.06pN·µm-1For 0.5 µm diamond
Trapped Particle Diameter0.5µmMicrodiamond cluster
Objective (Trapping/Collection)100X, 1.3 NA—Oil immersion
Condenser10X, 0.25 NA—Forward-scatter QPD detection
PL Quenching @ 100 mW IR, 1064 nm~80%Integrated PL reduction
PL Quenching @ 100 mW IR, 975 nm~45%Integrated PL reduction
Charge-State Split Wavelength650nmBoundary for NV0 / NV- ratio analysis
PL Time Fluctuation (Noise Floor)~10%Per-spectrum uncertainty
Calibration MethodPower spectrum (Berg-Sørensen)—Trap stiffness extraction
Effective Ionization Rate (Ieff)Wavelength-dependents-1Model-derived; rises with IR power
Effective Recombination Rate (Reff)Wavelength-dependents-1Model-derived; rises with IR power
PL Ratio Model DependenciesTwo-photon (quadratic in Pgreen)—Consistent with 2-photon ionization
  1. Sample Preparation
    • High-density NV ensemble nanodiamonds (~0.5 µm diameter clusters).
    • High-pressure high-temperature (HPHT) origin implied; detonation nanodiamond surface functionalization literature cited for biocompatibility context.
  2. Optical Trapping Setup
    • Single-beam gradient trap via 100X/1.3 NA oil-immersion objective.
    • Switching between 975 nm and 1064 nm fiber-coupled IR lasers under matched power conditions (20-100 mW).
  3. Excitation & Readout Path
    • 532 nm green laser co-aligned through dichroic mirror 1 (long-pass 580 nm).
    • PL collected in epi-configuration, filtered (580 nm long-pass), and directed to spectrometer (550-800 nm) or QPD via 50/50 beam splitter.
  4. Calibration & Trap Characterization
    • Power spectral density (PSD) of Brownian motion recorded on QPD.
    • Trap stiffness extracted using Berg-Sørensen & Flyvbjerg calibration algorithm.
  5. PL Quenching Protocol
    • Reference spectrum taken under green-only illumination per trapped cluster.
    • Scaling factor applied to account for cluster exchange during long acquisitions.
    • Integrated PL computed over 550-800 nm; sub-650 nm and above-650 nm segments used to extract NV0/NV- PL ratio.
  6. Rate-Equation Modeling
    • Five-level effective system: NV- ground/excited, NV0 ground/excited, conduction band.
    • Fitted parameters: effective ionization (Ieff) and recombination (Reff) rates as functions of green and IR powers.
    • Compared simulated PL ratios to experimental data across 20-100 mW IR sweep.
  • Applicable Materials:

    • High-Density NV Ensemble Nanodiamonds (SCD, ~0.1-500 µm thickness range): Directly matches the trapped particle class used in this study. 6CCVD supplies monocrystalline SCD plates and membranes with controlled NV center densities suitable for ensemble magnetometry and spin-preservation studies.
    • Optical-Grade SCD Wafers: For groups seeking bulk SCD substrates to laser-cut or FIB-milled into sub-micron particles with native, high-purity NV ensembles.
    • Heavy Boron-Doped PCD (BDD): An alternative platform for groups investigating charge-state dynamics under IR illumination where conductive substrates enable in-situ electrical biasing to complement optical control.
    • Boron-Doped SCD: For combined spin + electrochemical sensing modalities where IR charge-state manipulation must be decoupled from electrochemical noise.
  • Customization Potential:

    • Particle Sizing & Thickness Control: 6CCVD’s thickness range (SCD 0.1 µm - 500 µm; substrates up to 10 mm) allows delivery of ultra-thin membranes that can be post-processed via laser cutting or focused ion beam milling to match the 0.5 µm trapped-particle regime, or scaled up for bulk spectroscopic standards.
    • Custom Metalization (Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, Cu): For follow-on experiments integrating plasmonic nanostructures (Hapuarachchi et al. 2022; Kumar et al. 2015) to enhance NV emission or engineer NV-plasmon coupling, 6CCVD’s in-house metallization can deposit Ti/Pt/Au or Au-only stacks with sub-nm Ra interface quality (SCD polish Ra < 1 nm).
    • Wafer Dimensions up to 125 mm (PCD): Enables parallel fabrication of dozens of micro-trapping targets or on-chip photonic integration platforms.
    • Surface Engineering: Polished surfaces (Ra < 1 nm SCD; < 5 nm inch-size PCD) reduce surface-state density — a critical lever since the authors explicitly flag surface states (Ref. [38], Dhomkar et al. 2018) as contributors to charge dynamics in nanodiamonds.
  • Engineering Support:

    • The paper’s central open question — the microscopic origin of wavelength-dependent ionization/recombination cross-sections — points to a need for systematic studies across variable NV densities and well-characterized surface terminations. 6CCVD’s in-house PhD team can assist with material selection to define matched-sample sets (e.g., SCD with specified nitrogen concentration, varying NV conversion efficiency via electron irradiation/annealing partnerships, and standardized surface polishing) for controlled-variable follow-up studies.
    • For biosensing translation (Refs. [17]-[22]), where 975 nm trapping must coexist with low-absorption biological windows, 6CCVD can advise on functionalization-ready surface preparations and biocompatibility-validated nanodiamond fractions.
    • For plasmonic-NV hybrid devices (Refs. [12]-[13]), joint metallization + diamond sourcing accelerates prototype iteration.
  • Call to Action:

    • For custom specifications, matched sample sets, or material consultation on NV-diamond quantum sensing, trapping, and biosensing platforms, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.
View Original Abstract

Abstract In this article, we explore the effect of two different infrared (IR) laser wavelengths on the optical properties of trapped nano-diamonds containing high-density ensembles of nitrogen vacancy (NV) centers. We investigate 975 nm and 1064nm wavelengths for trapping lasers and find that NV photoluminescence quenching is more prominent for 1064nm illumination than for 975 nm illumination when simultaneously excited with a 532 nm laser. In order to understand the underlying mechanism, we develop a rate-equation-based model that takes into account various transition probabilities. The model suggests that the findings cannot be explained only by imposing modification of the NV charge-state ratio under varied illumination wavelengths, and, thus, we speculate that the effective ionization and recombination rates associated with NV charge states for the studied samples are highly wavelength-dependent in the probed regime. Importantly, the results demonstrate that 975 nm laser is desirable for optical trapping of NV-diamonds, especially for NV-based sensing applications.

  1. 2000 - The physical implementation of quantum computation [Crossref]
  2. 2014 - Nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond: Nanoscale sensors for physics and biology [Crossref]
  3. 2010 - Single-shot readout of a single nuclear spin [Crossref]
  4. 2011 - Quantum measurement and orientation tracking of fluorescent nanodiamonds inside living cells [Crossref]
  5. 2013 - The nitrogen-vacancy colour centre in diamond [Crossref]
  6. 2023 - Accelerated self assembly of particles at the air-water interface with optically assisted heating due to an upconverting particle [Crossref]
  7. 2008 - Nanoscale imaging magnetometry with diamond spins under ambient conditions [Crossref]
  8. 2008 - Nanoscale magnetic sensing with an individual electronic spin in diamond [Crossref]
  9. 2013 - Nanoscale nuclear magnetic resonance with a nitrogen-vacancy spin sensor [Crossref]
  10. 2013 - Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy on a (5-nanometer) 3 sample volume [Crossref]