Skip to content

Tuning sp3/sp2 carbon ratio of heavily boron-doped diamond electrodes fabricated via hot-filament chemical vapour deposition with CO2 addition

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2025-11-20
JournalScientific Reports
AuthorsTaisuke Kageura, Kenshin Takemura, Michiko Maeda, Atsushi Otake, Yasuaki Einaga
InstitutionsNational Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology, Keio University
Citations1
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • Core Challenge: Achieving heavily boron-doped diamond (BDD) with both a high sp3/sp2 ratio and high boron concentration via Hot-Filament Chemical Vapor Deposition (HFCVD) has been historically difficult due to filament oxidation and reduced boron incorporation efficiency when oxygen is introduced.
  • Novel Approach: The authors demonstrate a solution by introducing CO2 gas as a mild oxygen source during HFCVD growth, leveraging its selective etching of non-diamond sp2 carbon while preserving the tungsten filament.
  • Key Achievement: Successful long-term (10 hour) synthesis of uniform, heavily boron-doped polycrystalline diamond films on 3-inch Si wafers with a metallic conductivity threshold maintained.
  • Optimal Recipe: A [CO2]/[H2] ratio of 2000 ppm was identified as the optimum condition, yielding a sp3/sp2 ratio increase (IωZCP/IG+ID from 0.117 to 0.193) and a growth rate increase (from ~170 to ~220 nm/h).
  • Electrochemical Performance: The resulting BDD electrodes exhibit a potential window of ~3.72 V and ΔEp values (0.073-0.086 V) comparable to high-standard BDD electrodes typically produced via MPCVD.
  • Application Impact: The CO2-assisted HFCVD method provides a scalable, cost-effective pathway to manufacture BDD electrodes for industrial wastewater treatment, electrochemical sensors, and CO2 reduction.
ParameterValueUnitContext
Substrate(001)-oriented 3-inch Si wafer—HFCVD growth substrate
Filament MaterialTungsten—Diameter 0.12 mm, length 400 mm
Filament-Substrate Distance~15mmHFCVD setup
Filament Temperature2000-2200°CTypical diamond growth range
H2 Flow Rate2000sccmCarrier gas
CH4 Flow Rate (Pre-dep / Growth)0 / 60sccmCarbon source
TMB (B(CH3)3) Flow Rate0.09sccmBoron source (91% H2 dilution)
[CO2]/[H2] Range Tested0 - 5000ppmOxygen additive
Optimum [CO2]/[H2]2000ppmBest sp3/sp2 ratio without filament break
Pre-deposition Pressure36TorrInitial nucleation step
BDD Growth Pressure15TorrMain growth step
Growth Duration10hoursLong-term stability test
Boron Concentration (0 ppm CO2)1.2 × 1021cm-3SIMS measurement
Boron Concentration (2000 ppm CO2)4.3 × 1020cm-3SIMS measurement
Growth Rate (0 ppm CO2)~170 (SIMS) / 120 (SEM)nm/hMeasured by SIMS & cross-sectional SEM
Growth Rate (2000 ppm CO2)~220 (SIMS) / 170 (SEM)nm/hMeasured by SIMS & cross-sectional SEM
IωZCP/IG+ID (0 ppm)0.117—UV Raman sp3/sp2 indicator
IωZCP/IG+ID (2000 ppm)0.193—UV Raman sp3/sp2 indicator
Potential Window3.58 - 3.72VMeasured in 0.1 M H2SO4
ΔEp (Fe(CN)63-/4-)0.073 - 0.086V1.0 mM K3[Fe(CN)6], scan rate 100 mV/s
  • Substrate Preparation: (001)-oriented 3-inch single-crystalline Si wafers seeded with diamond powder (avg. grain size 365 nm) diluted in ethanol prior to CVD growth.
  • Filament Setup: Tungsten wires (Φ = 0.12 mm, L = 400 mm) positioned ~15 mm above substrate; filament temperatures controlled to 2000-2200 °C via power output.
  • Two-Step CVD Process:
    • Step 1 — Pre-deposition: H2 2000 sccm, no CH4, TMB 0.09 sccm, 36 Torr, 1 hour.
    • Step 2 — BDD Growth: H2 2000 sccm, CH4 60 sccm, TMB 0.09 sccm, 15 Torr, 10 hours.
  • CO2 Gas Introduction: CO2 (99.99% purity) added with ratios [CO2]/[H2] swept from 0 to 5000 ppm.
  • Structural Characterization: Schottky emission SEM (15 keV) for surface and cross-sectional morphology; Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry (IMS-7f, Cs+ primary ion, 16 keV) for boron depth profiles.
  • Raman Spectroscopy: Dual-wavelength approach — 532 nm for boron-doping effects and 325 nm (UV) for high-precision sp3/sp2 ratio determination.
  • Electrochemical Analysis: Anodic pretreatment via potential cycling (-1.8 V to 3.0 V, 2 cycles); potential window determined by linear fit intersection method in 0.1 M H2SO4; CV measurements in 1.0 mM K3[Fe(CN)6] / 0.2 M H2SO4.
  • Heavy Boron-Doped Polycrystalline Diamond (BDD): The paper targets heavily boron-doped PCD films with metallic conductivity ([B] > ~1 × 1020 cm-3). 6CCVD supplies Heavy Boron-Doped PCD with customizable boron concentrations across the metallic conductivity regime, manufactured via MPCVD for the highest sp3 phase purity.
  • High sp3/sp2 Ratio Films: For applications demanding minimal non-diamond carbon content — such as the electrochemical sensors and wastewater treatment highlighted in this study — 6CCVD’s Optical Grade PCD and High-Purity PCD deliver industry-leading crystalline quality with tunable grain sizes.
  • Large-Area PCD Wafers: 6CCVD provides polycrystalline diamond plates and wafers up to 125 mm diameter, ideal for scaling the 3-inch wafer results demonstrated in this paper to industrial production volumes.
  • Thickness Control: The ~1.2-1.7 µm films grown in this study fall well within 6CCVD’s standard thickness range (0.1 µm - 500 µm for SCD and PCD). Thicker free-standing substrates (up to 10 mm) are also available for heavy-duty electrode applications.
  • Boron Concentration Tuning: 6CCVD’s in-house doping processes allow precise specification of [B] from lightly doped (~1018 cm-3) to heavy metallic-regime doping (>1021 cm-3), replicating or extending the parameter space explored by Kageura et al.
  • Surface Polishing: For electrochemical applications where surface roughness directly affects electron transfer kinetics, 6CCVD offers Ra < 5 nm polishing on inch-size PCD and Ra < 1 nm on SCD, critical for reducing background currents and improving sensor sensitivity.
  • Metallization Services: 6CCVD’s internal metallization capabilities (Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, Cu) enable custom electrode contact geometries. Ti/Pt/Au stacks are commonly specified for BDD electrodes to ensure robust ohmic or Schottky contacts as required.
  • Laser Cutting & Dicing: Custom part geometries — including the 3-inch wafer format or smaller die for sensor arrays — can be produced via 6CCVD’s precision laser cutting services.
  • Application Context: This research directly targets electrochemical sensors, wastewater treatment, CO2 reduction electrolysis, and ozone water generation — all areas where BDD electrode performance is gated by sp3/sp2 ratio, boron concentration, and crystalline quality.
  • PhD-Level Consultation: 6CCVD’s in-house PhD engineering team specializes in MPCVD and HFCVD diamond synthesis, and can assist with material selection — matching boron concentration, film thickness, surface finish, and metallization to your specific electrochemical cell design or sensor architecture.
  • Replicating or Extending the Research: Customers seeking to validate the CO2-assisted HFCVD findings using MPCVD-grown reference standards, or those requiring higher sp3 purity benchmarks, can leverage 6CCVD’s vertically integrated production chain.

For custom specifications, boron-doping consultation, or material selection for your electrochemical sensor, wastewater treatment, or electrolysis project, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.

View Original Abstract

Boron-doped diamond (BDD) is an excellent electrode material for electrochemical sensors and both high sp 3 /sp 2 carbon component ratios and high boron concentrations are significant factors for specific applications. Hot-filament chemical vapour deposition (HFCVD), which is a conventional technique for synthesising large and uniform BDD electrodes for industrial applications, presents challenges when synthesising films with the above characteristics. In this study, we demonstrate the stable long-term synthesis of heavily boron-doped polycrystalline diamond with a high sp 3 /sp 2 ratio by adding CO 2 gas and adjusting the H 2 /CH 4 /B(CH 3 ) 3 /CO 2 gas ratio during HFCVD. Adding an appropriate amount of CO 2 gas not only reduces the sp 2 carbon component but also improves crystallinity and increases growth rate while maintaining metallic conductivity despite a moderate decrease in boron concentration. Electrochemical measurements reveal that our BDD electrodes exhibit excellent characteristics comparable to those of high-standard BDD electrodes synthesised using microwave plasma-assisted CVD.