A first-principles study of thermal stability of carbon diamond-like compounds
Paper details
Section titled “Paper details”| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Journal | Journal of Radio Electronics |
| Published | 2026-04-01 |
| Authors | V.A. Greshnyakov, V.V. Pavlik |
| DOI | 10.30898/1684-1719.2026.4.12 |
Six of eight hypothetical diamond-like carbon phases remained stable during 7 ps of first-principles annealing at 300 K. The stable set was TA1, TA3, CA1, CA2, TB, and SA4. SA2 amorphized at 200 K, while LA9 transformed at 300 K into ordered Cmmm or R3m phases with no calculated band gap.
Stable phases at 300 K
Section titled “Stable phases at 300 K”Direct annealing separated the eight structures into six room-temperature candidates and two unstable phases.
| Phase | Annealing result | Structural context |
|---|---|---|
| TA1 | Stable at 300 K and 400 K | 16-tetra(2,2)tubulane |
| TA3 | Stable at 300 K and 400 K | Lowest enthalpy in the 400 K comparison |
| TB | Stable at 300 K | hcp C3 |
| CA1 | Stable at 300 K | T-carbon |
| CA2 | Stable at 300 K | Contains three-membered carbon frameworks |
| SA4 | Stable at 300 K | Crystallographically equivalent atomic sites |
| LA9 | Unstable at 300 K | Transforms into Cmmm or R3m |
| SA2 | Amorphizes at 200 K | High-density diamond-like phase |
Only TA1 and TA3 were shown to remain stable at the 400 K upper end. The paper did not report decomposition temperatures for the other room-temperature candidates.
The 300 K findings agree with earlier empirical-potential annealing of TA1, TA3, and TB. Earlier phonon spectra also supported the mechanical stability of TB and CA1.
First-principles annealing protocol
Section titled “First-principles annealing protocol”All structural relaxations and electronic properties were calculated with density functional theory in Quantum ESPRESSO. The exchange-correlation treatment used the PBE generalized gradient approximation. Norm-conserving Troullier-Martins pseudopotentials represented the ionic cores.
Initial relaxation used a 12 × 12 × 12 k-point grid and an 850 eV kinetic-energy cutoff at 0 K. The calculations used triclinic cells without symmetry constraints and no applied pressure. Relaxation continued until the force on each atom fell below 0.005 eV/Å and the stress fell below 0.5 kbar.
The annealing simulations used variable cells containing 48 to 96 atoms. Monkhorst-Pack grids ranged from 4 × 4 × 4 to 8 × 8 × 8 points, with an 800 eV cutoff. Each trajectory lasted at least 7 ps with a 1 fs time step. The tested temperature interval was 200 to 400 K.
Calculated powder X-ray patterns used Cu-Kα1 radiation with a wavelength of 1.5405 Å. The average coherent scattering region was about 50 nm.
These results are predictions from finite DFT cells rather than experimental annealing tests. The simulation duration, cell size, and temperature interval limit the conclusions that can be drawn from each trajectory.
Enthalpy and molecular-fragment estimates
Section titled “Enthalpy and molecular-fragment estimates”All eight structures survived relaxation at 0 K without losing their ordered form. That result established energetic stability at the relaxed point but did not establish finite-temperature stability.
The authors compared each phase with the gamma1-graphyne-1 carbon phase. LA9, TA1, TA3, and TB had differential enthalpies from -0.33 to -0.01 eV/atom. A more detailed value for LA9 was -0.09 eV/atom. These values suggested stability above room temperature.
CA1, CA2, SA2, and SA4 had differential enthalpies from 0.25 to 0.73 eV/atom. Their expected temperature limits were below the point at which the gamma1-graphyne-1 layer begins to break down, reported at about 240 °C.
The authors also estimated limits from molecular fragments within the crystal structures. TB, CA1, and CA2 contain three-membered carbon frameworks, giving an estimated boundary of 360 to 370 °C. TA1 and TA3 contain ladderane and cyclobutane motifs, giving an estimated boundary of 400 to 500 °C.
Those molecular-fragment limits were expectations rather than measured failure temperatures. The direct annealing simulations, rather than the enthalpy ranking, established which phases remained stable at 300 K.
Ordered products of LA9
Section titled “Ordered products of LA9”The authors associated LA9 instability with C-C bonds about 17% longer than the corresponding bonds in diamond. Annealing broke its least stable interatomic bonds while preserving long-range order.
| Property | R3m phase | Cmmm phase |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | All carbon atoms in equivalent sp2 states | 12 sp2 atoms and 24 sp3 atoms |
| Cell | a = 7.017 Å, c = 3.375 Å | a = 7.167 Å, b = 2.627 Å, c = 12.411 Å |
| Bond lengths | 1.494 Å within rings and 1.375 Å between rings | 1.327 to 1.645 Å |
| Bond angles | 113.5 to 123.1° | 105.94 to 129.63° |
| Density | 2.495 g/cm³ | 3.073 g/cm³ |
| Cohesion difference relative to L6 | 0.49 eV/atom | 0.41 eV/atom |
| Calculated band gap | Absent | Absent |
The R3m density was 10.9% above the cited graphite density of about 2.25 g/cm³. The Cmmm density was intermediate between graphite and the cited diamond density of about 3.52 g/cm³. Both phases had maximum pore diameters no greater than 4.15 Å in densely packed ring arrangements.
Electronic consequences of the LA9 transition
Section titled “Electronic consequences of the LA9 transition”The calculated band structures and densities of states had no band gap for either product. The authors therefore classify both Cmmm and R3m as conductors.
LA9 had a narrow 0.8 eV band gap before transformation. The authors attribute the absence of a gap in the products to increased sp2 character and predict greater electrical conductivity than in LA9.
R3m had more conduction-band states near the Fermi level than graphene and Cmmm. The authors infer that its conductivity should exceed that of graphite, although no experimental carrier density or mobility was measured.
For comparison, the paper cites a room-temperature band gap of about 5.5 eV for conventional diamond. The two LA9 products therefore differ strongly from ordinary diamond in their calculated electronic behavior.
The authors also propose a screening result for the considered equivalent-site diamond-like phases. Room-temperature stability is compatible with a band gap of at least 1.3 eV.
X-ray diffraction signatures
Section titled “X-ray diffraction signatures”The calculated diffraction patterns of Cmmm and R3m differed substantially from those of 2H graphite and LA9. The authors therefore proposed powder X-ray diffraction as a method for identifying either product in carbon material.
The Cmmm phase has two high-intensity peaks at 37.2° and 43.8°. Three medium-intensity peaks occur at 24.8°, 34.1°, and 76.0°.
The R3m phase has a 100% peak at 30.3° and a medium-intensity peak at 39.9°. Three peaks with intensities of 9 to 18% occur at doubled diffraction angles of 44.7°, 69.0°, and 73.5°.
These peak positions provide testable phase signatures. The paper did not synthesize the phases or confirm the predictions with measured diffraction patterns.
Selection guidance and open limits
Section titled “Selection guidance and open limits”TA1 and TA3 provide the strongest thermal stability evidence among the candidates. They remained stable at both 300 K and 400 K. TB, CA1, CA2, and SA4 were supported only at 300 K within the reported tests.
LA9 should not be treated as a stable room-temperature semiconductor. If obtained at low temperature, the authors expect gradual warming toward room temperature to drive its transformation into Cmmm or R3m. SA2 should also be excluded from room-temperature service because its structure amorphized at 200 K.
Several questions remain unresolved. The phases are hypothetical, and the study included no crystal synthesis or device fabrication. The cells contained only 48 to 96 atoms, while each annealing trajectory lasted at least 7 ps. Most stable phases had no observed decomposition boundary because 400 K was the upper test temperature. The PBE functional and selected pseudopotentials also define the numerical model.
For room-temperature engineering, the calculations support TA1, TA3, TB, CA1, CA2, and SA4 over LA9 and SA2. They identify LA9 instead as a possible low-temperature precursor for two ordered conductive phases.
View Original Abstract
This article presents a first-principles study of the thermal stability of eight hypothetical diamond-like carbon compounds, which are semiconductors with crystallographically equivalent positions of all atoms. Simulated annealing of the structures of these compounds was performed using molecular dynamics simulations using density functional theory in the generalized gradient approximation. It was found that phases of the TA1, TA3, CA1, CA2, TB, and SA4 structural types should be stable at 300 K, therefore materials based on them can be used in the development of electronic devices. The structure of the high-density hexagonal diamond-like phase SA2 (hP3) is destroyed with subsequent amorphization at least at 200 K. It was also found that the hypothetical rhombohedral diamond-like semiconductor LA9 (rh6) with a minimum band gap is unstable at 300 K. Annealing the structure of this phase leads to the rupture of the weakest interatomic bonds with its subsequent transformation into one of two new structurally ordered phases, the crystal lattices of which have Cmmm and R3m symmetry. The orthorhombic phase Cmmm is a hybrid and consists of 3- and 4-coordinated carbon atoms in a 1:2 ratio, while the rhombohedral R3m phase consists only of 3-coordinated atoms. The R3m and Cmmm phases should be conductors with an intermediate density from 2.5 to 3.1 g/cm3 and maximum pore sizes not exceeding 4.15 Å. Analysis of powder X-ray diffraction patterns showed that the set of diffraction maxima of the two new phases differs significantly from those for hexagonal graphite and the LA9 phase, which can be used to identify the Cmmm and R3m phases in carbon materials, as well as in studying the configurational transition of LA9 into new crystalline phases.
Products
View Specs →
Electronic Grade Intrinsic Diamond Epitaxial Wafer H Terminated Superior 100 Mosfet Ready Substrate
View Specs →