Additive Manufacture of Diamond -Titanium Hybrid Quantum Sensors
Paper details
Section titled “Paper details”| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Journal | Advanced Materials Interfaces |
| Published | 2026-04-11 |
| Authors | Daniel Stavrevski, Marsilea A. Booth, David A. Broadway, Islay O. Robertson, Nour Mani |
| DOI | 10.1002/admi.202500762 |
Direct energy deposition retained measurable nitrogen-vacancy fluorescence and spin coherence in 50 μm microdiamond particles embedded in Ti-6Al-4V. The hybrid reached an ODMR sensitivity of 2.10 × 10⁻² ± 5 × 10⁻⁴ K/√Hz at 270 K and a reported low-temperature ZPL sensitivity of 50 mK/√Hz. Its average Hahn echo coherence time was about 2 μs, while CPMG dynamical decoupling produced a 10 μs decay time.
Powder composition and deposition conditions
Section titled “Powder composition and deposition conditions”The powder feed contained a 70:30 mass ratio of Ti-6Al-4V powder and as-received 50 μm microdiamond powder. The Ti-6Al-4V particles were 45 to 90 μm and met ASTM Gd5 ELI. A Turbula mixer blended the powders for 1 to 3 h to improve homogeneity.
The authors identify the operating route as direct energy deposition using a TRUMPF TruLaser Cell 7020 SLM system. The system had a 3.0 kW disk laser, a coaxial laser cladding head, and coaxial powder delivery. The laser focal length was 200 mm and the powder focal distance was 8.0 mm. Argon carried the powders to the focal region, where the rastered beam formed the hybrid material.
The selected deposition conditions were a processing speed of 400 mm/min and a laser power of 800 W. The authors cite earlier work showing that surface-bound diamonds had the highest survivability at the lowest possible Hausner ratio.
NV optical and structural survival after printing
Section titled “NV optical and structural survival after printing”Confocal microscopy before and after printing used 532 nm excitation. The negatively charged NV spectral features showed no significant deviation after deposition. The fluorescence lifetime changed from 19 ns in the as-received powder to 20 ns after printing. That result was averaged over 20 particles and indicated that printing did not introduce a measurable additional decay path.
A majority of the particles remained in the negatively charged NV state. The authors interpret this result as evidence that the surrounding titanium did not change the bulk Fermi energy.
Printed specimens produced extra fluorescence from carbonaceous contamination. The intensity scales before and after printing differed by approximately one order of magnitude. The authors could not fully explain this effect and attributed part of the NV reduction to thermal decomposition during deposition.
About 15% of surface-bound diamonds showed little or no fluorescence. Their greater depth within the titanium matrix led the authors to propose that a Ti-C layer blocked incident light and quenched emission from deeper NV centers.
Raman maps found the diamond D band at 1350 cm⁻¹ and a carbon G band at 1580 cm⁻¹. The D/G intensity ratio approached zero on the titanium surface and rose above 10 when a microdiamond was in focus. The D band full width at half maximum remained below 3 cm⁻¹, supporting retention of the diamond structure. The authors also observed a possible thin graphitic region around particle edges. Appendix measurements detected rutile TiO₂ at the diamond-titanium interface.
Spin coherence after printing
Section titled “Spin coherence after printing”A room-temperature widefield microscope excited the embedded spins with a 532 nm laser. A 40×, 0.68 NA objective produced a 500 × 500 μm field of view, and the optical power density was about 20 W/mm². Microwave excitation came from a lithographically patterned resonator on a glass cover slip below the sample.
Hahn echo measurements gave an average spin-spin relaxation time T2 of about 2 μs. Zeeman splitting indicated an ambient magnetic field of about 50 μT. The measured T2 was lower than the value the authors normally expect from as-received microdiamond. They suggest that rapid cooling of the titanium matrix imposed non-uniform strain on individual particles.
Adding CPMG pulses extended the measured decay time to 10 μs. This result confirms that dynamical decoupling can recover coherence lost in the unmodified Hahn echo signal.
Two temperature readout methods
Section titled “Two temperature readout methods”Temperature response was measured from 15 to 300 K in a closed-cycle cryostat with a base temperature of about 10 K at the sample stage. A thermistor contacted the stage, and each measurement began after its stability reached about ±20 mK. Low laser power and a pulsed ODMR sequence with a 1 to 5 μs delay reduced laser heating.
ODMR tracked the shift of the NV zero-field-splitting peak near 2.87 GHz. The excitation sweep ran from 2840 to 2900 MHz. The all-optical method integrated the ZPL region from 605 to 660 nm and compared it with total NV photoluminescence. The ZPL was centered at 637 nm.
The two methods respond to different physical changes. ODMR follows the temperature-dependent crystal-field splitting. The ZPL ratio follows the Debye-Waller factor and phonon population. The authors state that the ODMR response saturates below about 100 K as lattice contraction approaches a limit. The phonon-mediated ZPL response remains temperature-dependent in that region.
Sensitivity and crossover temperature
Section titled “Sensitivity and crossover temperature”Sensitivity was calculated from one-second time traces averaged over 30 s. The authors used fast Fourier transform spectral densities and root-mean-square noise to determine sensitivity. A separate room-temperature fluctuation test gave a noise floor of about 3 mK/√Hz.
| Sensing method | Sensitivity at 90 K | Sensitivity at 270 K |
|---|---|---|
| ODMR | 0.83 ± 0.9 K/√Hz | 2.10 × 10⁻² ± 5 × 10⁻⁴ K/√Hz |
| ZPL ratio | 0.39 ± 0.09 K/√Hz | 1.19 ± 0.01 K/√Hz |
The crossover occurs between about 90 and 110 K. At 90 K, the lower ZPL sensitivity value of 0.39 K/√Hz performed better than the ODMR value of 0.83 K/√Hz. At 270 K, ODMR performed better, with a sensitivity of 2.10 × 10⁻² K/√Hz compared with 1.19 K/√Hz for ZPL fluorescence.
The paper reports a best ZPL sensitivity of 50 mK/√Hz, but its operating condition is inconsistent across the text. The abstract assigns 50 mK/√Hz to 30 K and gives 1 K/√Hz at room temperature. The introduction assigns the 50 mK/√Hz value to 15 K and gives about 200 mK/√Hz above 100 K. Table 2 gives 1.19 ± 0.01 K/√Hz at 270 K. The conclusion repeats the 50 mK/√Hz best value without assigning a temperature.
Comparison with prior diamond
Section titled “Comparison with prior diamond”The second-order ODMR polynomial used an intercept of 2876 MHz, a linear coefficient of 1.5 × 10⁻² MHz/K, and a quadratic coefficient of −1.9 × 10⁻⁴ MHz/K². Plakhotnik et al. reported corresponding values of 2870 MHz, 6 × 10⁻² MHz/K, and −2.3 × 10⁻⁴ MHz/K². Fukami et al. reported 2875 MHz, 4.39 × 10⁻² MHz/K, and −2.1 × 10⁻⁴ MHz/K². The authors judged the three sets of coefficients to be very similar.
The introduction states that the hybrid sensitivity was comparable to measurements on as-received diamonds. They interpreted this comparison as a negligible effect of printing on the sensing properties. It also notes that fabricated diamond containing many NV centers can reach sensitivity on the order of μK/√Hz.
The current microdiamond powder received no implantation or annealing. Its NV concentration and particle-to-particle emission therefore remained less controlled than in prepared sensor-grade material.
Limits and engineering implications
Section titled “Limits and engineering implications”The main material limitation is the uncontrolled defect population in the as-received powder. The absence of annealing and irradiation leaves emission strength variable between particles. Carbon contamination, possible Ti-C barriers, and reduced NV fluorescence further complicate use of particles located below the surface.
The cause of the reduced T2 was not established. The proposed strain mechanism would require direct measurement of the stress state around each particle. Cross-sectional characterization was also absent. The authors did not perform FIB cross-sections, TEM, or X-ray computed tomography on the reported samples.
The authors propose three development steps: integrating a large ensemble of diamonds, irradiating the particles to improve fluorescence stability, and optimizing printing for better diamond integration. These steps target the particle variability and interface effects observed in the present material.
For a sensor designer, the demonstrated configuration uses ODMR near room temperature and ZPL ratiometry below the roughly 100 K crossover. It supports a two-method thermometer over 15 to 300 K, while particle integration and coherence control remain unresolved for device use.
View Original Abstract
ABSTRACT Additive manufacture represents one of the most advanced techniques for the creation of complex parts for applications as diverse as aerospace and implant surgery. However, a challenge with bespoke manufacture of metal parts is the incorporation of sensor elements in a fashion compatible with the 3D printing process. We have successfully created a new hybrid material of microdiamonds and titanium, which was printed using direct energy deposition. The microdiamonds contain nitrogen‐vacancy color‐centers, and our results show that the quantum and fluorescence properties of the microdiamonds are preserved, with potential to act as quantum sensors embedded in the titanium matrix. We show this potential by demonstrating temperature sensing using 3D printed titanium‐microdiamonds via both fluorescence readout and optically detected magnetic resonance (ODMR). At room temperature, the fluorescence approach had a sensitivity of 1 and the ODMR approach showed 20 . Sensitivity of both modalities varied as a function of temperature, with the ZPL sensitivity exceeding that of ODMR below approximately 100 K, with the ZPL sensitivity at 30 K found to be . We also verify the quantum properties of this diamond with a measured coherence time of 2 showing a dynamic, robust platform for bespoke 3D printing of bio‐friendly quantum sensors.
High Concentration Quantum Grade Single Crystal Diamond
View Specs →
Electronic Grade Intrinsic Diamond Epitaxial Wafer H Terminated Superior 100 Mosfet Ready Substrate
View Specs →
Single Crystal Cvd Diamond Plate
View Specs →References we cover
Section titled “References we cover”- Widefield quantum microscopy with nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond -n strengths, limitations, and prospects
- All-Optical Cryogenic Thermometry Based on Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers in Nanodiamonds