Skip to content

Boron-Doped Diamond Anode-Driven Electrochemical Oxidization of Fluorinated Firefighting Wastewater-Contaminated Groundwater

FieldValue
JournalCatalysts
Published2026-05-10
AuthorsQi Wang, Gongjie Hua, Aiguo Gu, Jie Zou, Kuangfei Lin
DOI10.3390/catal16050443

Under the paper’s optimized conditions, a niobium-supported boron-doped diamond anode achieved 92.5% TOC removal and 77.5% defluorination from simulated fluorinated firefighting wastewater contaminated groundwater in 240 min. Treatment used 100 mM Na2SO4 and 100 mM PMS at 33.3 mA/cm² and pH 6. These are the values reported in the abstract and conclusion.

Groundwater was prepared by diluting commercial fire extinguisher fluid containing 3% AFFF to 5% with well water from Xuhui District, Shanghai. The mixture contained TOC at 25.4 mg/L, total fluorine at 24.6 mg/L, and chemical oxygen demand at 24.6 mg/L. Its initial pH was 8.59. Sulfate, nitrate, carbonate, and chloride concentrations were 39.89, 7.12, 43.39, and 33.16 mg/L, respectively.

EPA Method 1633 LC-MS/MS identified six PFAS in the starting water:

PFASInitial concentration
PFBA0.51 mg/L
PFPeA0.11 mg/L
PFHxA0.26 mg/L
PFHpA0.09 mg/L
PFHxS0.55 mg/L
6:2 FTS9.2 mg/L

PFAS concentrations were measured by LC-MS/MS under EPA Method 1633. TOC was measured with a TOC analyzer, and fluoride with a fluoride ion-selective electrode. Toxicity was measured following ISO 21338:2010 through inhibition of Vibrio fischeri luminescence.

BDD anode fabrication and electrochemical behavior

Section titled “BDD anode fabrication and electrochemical behavior”

Each 20 × 20 × 2 mm niobium support was polished with 200, 400, and 800 grit metallographic sandpaper. It was ultrasonically cleaned in acetone and ethanol for 10 min each. A final ultrasonic treatment used diamond powder from 2 to 4 µm in acetone for 30 min.

Growth used methane and hydrogen, with trimethyl borate carried through hydrogen bubbling. The gas flow ratio was 2:1:40 sccm for hydrogen with borate, methane, and hydrogen. The chamber used 7.5 kW microwave power, 8 kPa pressure, and 900 °C for 12 h.

Raman bands at 515 and 1335 cm⁻¹ supported boron incorporation and a crystalline diamond phase. XRD peaks at 43.6° and 75.0° matched diamond (111) and (220), with (111) predominant. XPS measured 0.24% boron and identified a B-C bond at 187.1 eV. Nb6C5 and Nb2C phases occurred at the interface. The authors associated these carbides with stronger BDD/Nb adhesion.

The oxygen evolution potential was 1.52 V versus Ag/AgCl. EIS gave internal resistance of 8.16 Ω and charge-transfer resistance of 39.5 Ω. CV peak current versus the square root of scan rate was linear, indicating diffusion-controlled reactions without significant side reactions.

Increasing Na2SO4 from 20 to 100 mM raised TOC removal from 50.2% to 86.4%. At 200 mM, removal fell to 76.2%. The authors attributed this decline to stronger oxygen evolution at high electrolyte concentration.

Adding 100 mM PMS to 100 mM Na2SO4 produced 90.3% TOC removal. Both 50 and 200 mM PMS inhibited TOC removal, while 200 mM slightly inhibited defluorination. The authors interpreted PMS as mainly increasing removal of nonfluorinated organic material.

Across 16.7 to 66.7 mA/cm², TOC removal rose from 64.8% to 93.1%. The apparent rate constant increased from 0.0044 to 0.0111 min⁻¹. Defluorination at 240 min stayed near 65% at every current density. The authors stated that residual PFAS could not be defluorinated further. The selected current was 33.3 mA/cm² because higher current caused oxygen bubbles and excess energy use.

At 240 min, TOC removal was 91.9% at pH 6, 86.6% at pH 3, and 81.5% at pH 9. The rate constant was 0.0107 min⁻¹ at pH 6 and 0.007 min⁻¹ at pH 11. Defluorination ranged from 62.5% to 68.1% across pH 3 to 5. It ranged from 74.3% to 77.5% across pH 7 to 9. Thus, pH 6 favored the TOC removal rate, while pH 7 to 9 gave higher defluorination.

At 1% initial PFAS, TOC was completely removed and defluorination reached 92.6%. At 20%, TOC removal was 44.6% and defluorination was 45.2%. The authors attributed lower absolute performance to intermediates consuming reactive species.

Reactive species and transformation pathway

Section titled “Reactive species and transformation pathway”

NaClO4 did not significantly change defluorination, so direct electron oxidation did not dominate. EtOH, TBA, and FFA reduced defluorination from 79.2% to 5.2%, 4.9%, and 2.7%, respectively. EtOH quenches hydroxyl and sulfate radicals, TBA quenches hydroxyl radicals, and FFA quenches singlet oxygen. DMPO and TEMP EPR spectra confirmed hydroxyl radicals and singlet oxygen.

LC-MS/MS showed PFHxS was completely removed within 60 min. PFBA peaked at 180 min, then disappeared by 360 min. PFPeA, PFHxA, PFHpA, and 6:2 FTS disappeared by 360 min after initial increases. PFBS appeared after electrification. This pattern supports stepwise carbon-chain cleavage.

Vibrio fischeri inhibition remained above 95% through 180 min. It then fell from 99.8% to 20.9% between 180 and 360 min. The authors related the high early toxicity to short-chain intermediates.

Park soil from 0 to 20 cm depth was mixed with 500 mL of commercial fluid containing 3% AFFF. The mixture was stirred for 30 min and aged for 8 weeks.

Treatment used 100 mL of 100 mM Na2SO4 and 100 mM PMS at pH 6. A 33.3 mA/cm² BDD anode operated for 720 min. At a 20:1 water-to-soil ratio, TOC removal reached 90.2% and defluorination reached 41.6%. At 10:1, the values were 76.4% and 16.9%, respectively.

PFAS concentrations first increased as compounds desorbed from soil, then decreased. The 20:1 system produced an earlier concentration peak and faster subsequent degradation. The authors related these results to improved mass transfer and reduced inhibition by soil organic matter.

Table 1 places this study among the higher removal and defluorination results in its comparison set.

StudyMain conditionsTimeReported removalDefluorination
This workBDD, 33.3 mA/cm², 100 mM Na2SO4, 100 mM PMS, pH 6, 25.4 mg/L4 h92.5% TOC77.5%
Zhao et al. [41]BDD, 40 mA/cm², 5 mM PDS, pH 3.8, 50 µM2 h>99%60.4%
Uwayezu et al. [42]BDD, 21.4 mA/cm², 1500 mg/L Na2SO4, 10 mg/L2 h>99%40% to 50%
Schaefer et al. [43]BDD, 15 mA/cm², 1500 mg/L Na2SO4, 0.3 mg/L8 hAbout 60%About 55%

The current study used less Na2SO4 than the two 1500 mg/L studies and a similar current density to Zhao et al. Direct ranking remains limited because oxidant, treatment time, pH, and PFAS concentration differ.

Engineering implications and unresolved issues

Section titled “Engineering implications and unresolved issues”

The BDD’s 1.52 V oxygen evolution potential supports organic oxidation while limiting oxygen evolution, according to the authors. The niobium support and carbide interface make coating adhesion an electrode-design consideration. Current density controls reactive-species generation, but higher values increase oxygen bubbles and energy demand. Process design must also choose between pH 6 for TOC removal and pH 7 to 9 for higher fluoride release.

Results came from simulated groundwater and artificially contaminated soil aged for eight weeks. The paper did not report field-scale validation, a full-cell energy balance, or long-term anode performance. Higher PFAS loading reduced performance, while soil treatment produced much less defluorination than groundwater treatment.

The paper also contains numerical mismatches under the stated optimum. Section 2.3 gives 91.9% TOC removal at pH 6, while Section 2.5 and Table 1 use 92.5%. The abstract, conclusion, and Table 1 give 77.5% defluorination, but Section 2.5 gives 68.3% at 240 min. These values should be checked against the source data before reactor sizing. TOC removal also does not establish complete PFAS destruction or fluoride release.

6CCVD’s diamond materials catalog includes MPCVD-grown single-crystal and polycrystalline boron-doped diamond, with plates and wafers up to 125 mm and thickness from 0.1 to 500 micrometers. The paper needs a boron-doped diamond anode, and its cell used a 20 × 20 × 2 mm niobium-supported film. The catalog also lists metallization with Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, or Cu, and polishing to Ra below 5 nm for inch-size polycrystalline material, while the engineering support page can help define a custom plate or wafer format.

View Original Abstract

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) in fluorinated firefighting wastewater (FFW), which are difficult to remediate using conventional technologies, represent a critical environmental hazard due to the extreme persistence and bioaccumulation potential of soil-groundwater systems. Niobium-supported boron-doped diamond (BDD) anodes were synthesized by microwave plasma chemical vapor deposition, and their performance in the electrochemical advanced oxidation processes (EAOPs) of FFW were systematically investigated. Under optimized conditions (100 mM Na2SO4 electrolyte with 100 mM peroxymonosulfate (PMS), current density of 33.3 mA/cm2, pH = 6), the BDD anode achieved near-complete mineralization, with 92.5% total organic carbon (TOC) removal and significant defluorination (77.5% F− release) within 240 min in simulated FFW-contaminated groundwater. For FFW-contaminated soil remediation, 90.2% TOC removal and 41.6% defluorination were achieved after 720 min under optimal treatment (water-to-soil ratio of 20:1). Quenching experiments and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) tests revealed that hydroxyl radicals (·OH) and singlet oxygen (1O2) were the predominant reactive species. Liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry/mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) analysis indicated that PFASs were removed by shortened carbon chains, ultimately mineralizing to CO2 and F−. Toxicity assessment using Vibrio fischeri luminescence demonstrated a reduction in toxicity (from 99.8% to 20.9%), confirming the effective detoxification of BDD-based EAOPs. This work establishes BDD-based EAOPs as a promising technology for eliminating PFASs in groundwater and soil, offering theoretical insights into EAOPs and engineering solutions for PFAS remediation.

  1. 2024 - Firefighting aqueous film forming foam composition, properties and toxicity: A review [Crossref]
  2. 2023 - The wide presence of fluorinated compounds in common chemical products and the environment: A review [Crossref]
  3. 2024 - Firefighting wastewater from a tire recycling plant: Chemical characterization and simultaneous removal of multiple pollutants [Crossref]
  4. 2014 - When the smoke disappears: Dealing with extinguishing chemicals in firefighting wastewater [Crossref]
  5. 2018 - Poly- and Perfluoroalkyl Substances in Runoff Water and Wastewater Sampled at a Firefighter Training Area [Crossref]
  6. 2012 - Identification of Novel Fluorochemicals in Aqueous Film-Forming Foams Used by the US Military [Crossref]
  7. 2021 - Per and poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) as a contaminant of emerging concern in surface water: A transboundary review of their occurrences and toxicity effects [Crossref]
  8. 2024 - Binding of Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS) to Serum Proteins: Implications for Toxicokinetics in Humans [Crossref]
  9. 2024 - Enhanced adsorption of perfluorooctanesulfonic acid (PFOS) in fluorine doped mesoporous carbon: Experiment and simulation [Crossref]