From Sintering Route to Cutting Response - Circular-Saw Granite Cutting with Microwave-Hybrid Sintered Diamond Segments
Paper details
Section titled “Paper details”| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Journal | Journal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing |
| Published | 2026-05-02 |
| Authors | Raquel S. Henriques, Pedro F. Borges, Adriano Coelho, Pedro M. Amaral, Jorge Cruz Fernandes |
| DOI | 10.3390/jmmp10050161 |
Microwave-hybrid sintered diamond segments reduced segment wear by 19.8% at 22 mm/s feed, 30 m/s peripheral speed, and 18 mm depth. Mean resultant cutting force increased by 36.9%, reaching 649.5 N versus 474.5 N for hot-pressed segments. The authors associate the lower wear with stronger diamond retention, but suggest that retained, low-friability grits blunt over time and raise the force demand.
Segment design and sintering routes
Section titled “Segment design and sintering routes”Both routes produced metal-bond, diamond-impregnated segments measuring 34 × 3.8 × 8 mm. Each 400 mm disc carried 28 Ag-brazed segments on a steel rim. Two discs per route produced 56 segments for each process.
Hot pressing used a 70 kW press at 850 °C, with a 3 min dwell and heating at about 80 °C/min. Uniaxial pressure remained applied during the dwell and was released after cooling. An optical pyrometer monitored temperature.
MWHS used a 2.45 GHz oven with up to 1 kW output and a SiC susceptor around the samples. The cycle reached 820 °C, held for 5 min, and heated at about 67 °C/min. Manual power steps followed an S-type thermocouple setpoint just above the samples. A quartz tube protected the segments from oxidation. Both gases had 99.999% purity. Hot pressing used Ar with 5 vol.% H2, while the MWHS tube was purged for 5 min with Ar containing 7 vol.% H2. That gas flowed at 2 L/min through heating, dwell, and cooling.
Reported MWHS matrix porosity was 5 to 6%, against 0% for HP. MWHS matrix density was 7.78 ± 0.07 Mg/m³, versus 8.24 ± 0.01 for HP. Its dynamic Young’s modulus was 165 ± 3 GPa, versus 193 ± 2 GPa for HP. Segment flexural strength was 1039 ± 83 MPa for MWHS and 986 ± 120 MPa for HP.
Sawing procedure and force measurement
Section titled “Sawing procedure and force measurement”Tests used 60 Rosa Porriño granite slabs measuring 1000 × 600 × 20 mm. Tap water flowed at 22 L/min without additives or lubricants. Peripheral speed was 20, 30, or 40 m/s. Feed speed was 22, 30, or 38 mm/s. Depth was 9 or 18 mm.
Each test began with tool weighing and continued through successive 0.018 m² slots. The tool was cleaned and dried after each slot, and total cut area ranged from 1.2 to 3.0 m².
Conditioning continued to 1 m² under the test condition until forces stopped decreasing systematically.
A 50 kg LT05 cell measured horizontal force. Three 50 kg 535 QD cells measured vertical force. Signals passed through an EL574 conditioner, were sampled at 10 Hz, and received no digital filtering. Resultant force was the vector sum. Mass loss from a Radwag PS10100.R2 balance was divided by cut area to give wear rate.
Force and wear results
Section titled “Force and wear results”Mean resultant force lay between 200 and 650 N under most conditions. Test 3 reached 900 N at 22 mm/s feed, 30 m/s peripheral speed, and 18 mm depth. The authors considered this force regime unsuitable for granite cutting.
At 30 mm/s feed and 30 m/s peripheral speed, reducing depth from 18 to 9 mm lowered MWHS mean force from 485 to 360 N. HP force fell from 442.5 to 315.5 N. The lowest means occurred at 30 mm/s feed, 40 m/s peripheral speed, and 18 mm depth. Only HP disc 2 produced enough cuts for that comparison.
Table 3 reports six condition-level comparisons. Feed is in mm/s, peripheral speed in m/s, and depth in mm.
| Test | Feed / peripheral speed / depth | Mean force, MWHS / HP, N | Wear rate, MWHS / HP, g/m² | MWHS change, force / wear |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 38 / 30 / 18 | 479 / 399 | 6.69 / 7.11 | +20.1% / -5.9% |
| 2 | 30 / 30 / 18 | 485 / 442.5 | 6.78 / 6.69 | +9.6% / +1.3% |
| 3 | 22 / 30 / 18 | 649.5 / 474.5 | 6.82 / 8.50 | +36.9% / -19.8% |
| 4 | 30 / 40 / 18 | 400 / 382 | 4.88 / 5.72 | +4.7% / -14.7% |
| 5 | 30 / 20 / 18 | 487 / 385 | 10.19 / 10.61 | +26.5% / -4.0% |
| 6 | 30 / 30 / 9 | 360 / 315.5 | 3.70 / 4.38 | +14.1% / -15.4% |
Values are means. Percentage changes use the paper’s MWHS minus HP definition. Test 4 uses only HP disc 2.
MWHS wear was lower in five of six conditions. The exception was 30 mm/s feed, 30 m/s peripheral speed, and 18 mm depth. MWHS wear reached 6.78 g/m², versus 6.69 g/m² for HP. The 1.3% wear increase came with a 9.6% force increase in that condition.
Why wear and force diverged
Section titled “Why wear and force diverged”Mass loss grew approximately linearly with cut area, supporting abrasion-dominated wear over the tested range. SEM images of bending fractures showed clean diamond surfaces in HP segments. MWHS diamonds had rougher surfaces with metallic matrix attached. The authors interpret this as evidence consistent with stronger diamond-matrix interaction and retention.
They propose that retained grits shield the matrix from debris-driven abrasion. This can lower segment mass loss even when the matrix has lower intrinsic abrasion resistance. Stronger retention also delays controlled grit release. Low-friability grits then polish and blunt instead of microfracturing. They then contribute less to stone microchipping and can raise cutting force.
The lower MWHS matrix modulus is consistent with the proposed matrix-compliance contribution, although the paper did not isolate it. A cited dielectric study estimated a diamond loss tangent of 0.0015 at 22.3 GHz and room temperature. It also reported increasing loss with temperature and decreasing frequency. The authors suggest that this possible absorption shift could promote local reactions between diamond and matrix during MWHS.
Comparison with the abrasive wear model
Section titled “Comparison with the abrasive wear model”The authors applied an empirical wear model from prior work that links mass loss to normal force, hardness, rupture stress, toughness modulus, Young’s modulus, and a stone-dependent constant. Assuming abrasive wear dominated, the model predicted about 24% more wear for MWHS than HP. The prediction used the earlier condition of 25 mm/s feed, 24 m/s peripheral speed, and 5 mm depth.
Those conditions differ from the current test program. The predicted direction also opposes the measured result in most current conditions. The authors therefore favor diamond retention and matrix shielding over an explanation based on superior intrinsic matrix abrasion resistance.
Limitations and unresolved mechanisms
Section titled “Limitations and unresolved mechanisms”Two discs per route were tested, so the paper gives descriptive trends without inferential tests. Test 4 included only one usable HP disc. At 22 mm/s feed, 30 m/s peripheral speed, and 18 mm depth, the wear-rate coefficient of variation was 22.7% for MWHS and 4.2% for HP.
Optical inspection after cutting did not support statistically robust conclusions. Exposed grits were heterogeneous, and inspected areas had limited representativeness. The authors omitted those images. SEM examined bending fractures rather than worn cutting surfaces.
Pull-out and chipping could not be separated without systematic surface mapping or debris analysis. The paper did not measure tool and workpiece interface temperature, leaving the proposed thermal coupling unresolved. Local thermal gradients and microstructural heterogeneity are possible MWHS contributors, as the authors suggest.
The findings apply to Rosa Porriño granite, tap-water cooling, and the tested feed, speed, and depth ranges.
Implications for segment selection
Section titled “Implications for segment selection”MWHS is feasible, but the data do not support treating it as a universal replacement for HP. It tended to favor lower wear and dimensional stability, which may reduce downtime. HP favored lower forces and may reduce energy demand, although the paper did not report electrical energy.
Route selection should follow the target operating window, including feed, peripheral speed, depth, and cooling. It should also follow the priority between tool life and cutting efficiency. The paper does not identify one route as universally better.
The authors propose more friable diamonds to restore sharp edges through micro-fracture. They also suggest minor binder composition changes to promote controlled matrix removal and renewed diamond exposure. Optimizing the MWHS thermal cycle remains necessary. The target is balanced retention and renewal, not maximum retention alone.
Qualification should track force drift and mass loss per machined area across the intended granite and operating window. A lower wear rate alone does not establish a better cutting response.
View Original Abstract
Balancing low segment wear with stable cutting forces remains a challenge in granite sawing. This work compares diamond-impregnated saw segments produced by microwave- hybrid sintering (MWHS) and hot pressing (HP) when cutting Rosa Porriño granite. Tests were performed under tap-water cooling (22 L min−1) while varying peripheral speed (20-40 m s−1), feed speed (22-38 mm s−1), and cutting depth (9-18 mm). Cutting forces were recorded during successive slots, and wear was quantified as mass loss per machined area (1.2-3.0 m2 per test). MWHS segments exhibited lower wear than HP segments, with reductions up to ~20%, consistent with improved diamond retention and reduced binder exposure to debris-driven abrasion. Under higher cutting severity, however, MWHS segments developed higher forces, indicating reduced grit renewal and progressive blunting, plausibly linked to stronger diamond-matrix bonding and the low-friability diamond grade used. In contrast, HP segments operated at lower forces but showed higher wear, consistent with greater surface renewal through controlled grit release. Tuning diamond friability and matrix compliance in MWHS is proposed to stabilize forces while preserving the wear advantage. Overall, MWHS is a viable route for granite cutting segments, but further optimization is required to achieve HP-equivalent behavior across the tested conditions.
Electronic Grade Intrinsic Diamond Epitaxial Wafer H Terminated Superior 100 Mosfet Ready Substrate
View Specs →
Advanced Thermal Simulation Service Diamond Heat Spreader Performance Analysis
View Specs →
Diamond Heat Spreader With Copper Coated Metalized Surface
View Specs →References we cover
Section titled “References we cover”Original source
Section titled “Original source”References
Section titled “References”- 2010 - Experimental study for the cutting forces during sawing granite with diamond circular saw blades [Crossref]
- 2020 - Comparison of wear characteristics of diamond segments under different sawing modes in sawing hard stone [Crossref]
- 2013 - Comparison between cobalt and niobium as a matrix component for diamond impregnated tools used for stone cutting [Crossref]
- 2001 - Forces and energy in circular sawing and grinding of granite [Crossref]
- 2019 - Forces and wear in high-speed machining of granite by circular sawing [Crossref]
- 2005 - Wear characteristics of circular diamond saws in the cutting of different hard abrasive rocks [Crossref]
- 2012 - Cutting force and diamond tool wear in stone machining [Crossref]
- 2018 - Estimation of power consumption in the circular sawing of stone based on tangential force distribution [Crossref]