A Chemist’sGuide to Solid-State Qubits - DiamondColor Centers as Embedded Vacancy-Centered Molecules
Paper details
Section titled “Paper details”| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Journal | ACS Central Science |
| Published | 2026-07-27 |
| Authors | John Mark P. Martirez |
| DOI | 10.1021/acscentsci.6c00548 |
Negatively charged BCVC− and neutral OCVC0 emerge as possible alternatives to the negatively charged nitrogen-vacancy center NCVC−. Their calculated bright transitions occur at 3.80 eV and 2.65 eV, with natural emission lifetimes of 5.6 ns and 2.3 ns. The NCVC− benchmark has a 2.26 eV green transition and a 9.5 ns literature lifetime. All three excitation energies lie below the 5.5 eV band gap of diamond.
Defect models with a periodic diamond environment
Section titled “Defect models with a periodic diamond environment”Localized electronic structure allowed each defect to be modeled as a vacancy-centered molecule embedded in periodic diamond. The authors first built defective C₁₂₆D supercells. D represented B, N, O, or C for an isolated vacancy.
DFT in VASP with the r²SCAN-L functional optimized the structures and reproduced the experimental cubic lattice constant within 0.0006 Å. The authors then recalculated ground-state densities and energies with HSE06.
Each defect was carved from its supercell as a C₁₅D cluster. F₁₂ and O₁₂ capping produced the hypothetical molecule C₁₅DF₁₂O₁₂. Capped density functional embedding theory derived an optimized effective embedding potential from the surrounding lattice. The potential captured the lattice interaction and mutual dielectric response of the defect and host.
Prior benchmarking of NCVC− covered the embedding functional, cluster and supercell sizes, basis set, and active-space character. Embedded state-averaged CASSCF and embedded NEVPT2 calculations in Molpro then provided vertical excitation energies, transition dipole moments, oscillator strengths, and natural lifetimes. This work was computational, with no fabricated color-center samples.
Spin states and structural symmetry
Section titled “Spin states and structural symmetry”For D = B, N, and O, molecular orbital analysis resolved three occupied dopant-carbon sigma orbitals, three empty sigma-star orbitals, and four nonbonding frontier orbitals. These frontier orbitals govern the magnetic and optical properties of each center.
Before Jahn-Teller distortion, substituted defects can adopt C3v symmetry, while an undistorted vacancy retains Td symmetry. BCVC−, NCVC−, and OCVC0 have spin-triplet ground states. NCVC− and OCVC0 are isoelectronic, with singly occupied degenerate e orbitals. BCVC− has a related occupation but adds an empty B 2p-derived a₁ orbital.
Removing an electron produces doublets for BCVC0, NCVC0, and OCVC+, while VC0 becomes a spin singlet. Removing another electron yields singlet BCVC+, NCVC+, and OCVC2+ states with accessible triplet excited states.
Uneven occupation of degenerate frontier orbitals causes Jahn-Teller distortion. At 298 K, thermal energy is about 0.025 eV. NCVC0 and VC0 gain 0.25 to 0.56 eV from distortion, so their lower-symmetry structures remain fixed at room temperature. For BCVC0 and OCVC+, stabilization is 0.01 to 0.14 eV, so thermally induced structural fluctuations matter. Their primary electronic states require more than one electronic configuration. At 298 K, BCVC0 has normalized probabilities of 0.84 for Cs and 0.16 for C3v.
Optical energies against measured benchmarks
Section titled “Optical energies against measured benchmarks”A vertical excitation energy holds the nuclei fixed. A zero-phonon line reflects phonon and electronic relaxation after the vertical excitation. Vertical energy is therefore at least as large as zero-phonon energy. For diamond defects, the zero-phonon line typically lies 0.2 to 0.3 eV below the vertical energy.
BCVC− has a triplet ground state and two triplet excited states. The first, 1³E, occurs at 3.05 eV. The second, 2³E, occurs at 3.80 eV, 0.75 eV above the first. The 3.05 eV result agrees with the measured 3 eV minimum for optical pump spin polarization. The calculation instead assigns the brighter transition to 2³E, contrary to an assumption in a recent experiment. Its oscillator strength is 0.44, compared with 0.056 for 1³E. Their ratio is 7.8.
OCVC0 and NCVC− have first triplet excitations at 2.65 eV and 2.26 eV. These correspond to blue and green light, respectively. The NCVC− excitation energies agree with reported experimental values within 0.1 eV.
Each center also has a doubly degenerate 1¹E singlet about 0.7 eV above its triplet ground state. The gap from the 3E excited state to the 1¹A₁ shelving singlet is 0.37 eV for NCVC− and 0.68 eV for OCVC0. The authors therefore expect intersystem crossing to be more probable for NCVC−.
NCVC0 absorbs at 2.74 eV, while OCVC+ absorbs at 3.41 eV. Electronic relaxation to their first excited states yields 2.58 eV and 3.26 eV. The measured 2.16 eV zero-phonon line for NCVC0 indicates 0.4 eV of structural relaxation.
The vacancy calculations also match measured features. Calculated VC− absorption at 3.2 to 3.4 eV reproduces its phonon sidebands near 3.23, 3.30, and 3.38 eV. Its measured zero-phonon line is 3.149 eV. For VC0, the calculations predict red absorption at 1.73 eV and orange absorption at 1.93 eV. Measured zero-phonon peaks occur at 1.673 and 1.665 eV.
Brightness, lifetimes, and shelving states
Section titled “Brightness, lifetimes, and shelving states”The transition dipole moments for BCVC−, VC−, and OCVC0 fall within 3.5 to 5 D. These allowed transitions should produce bright emission. OCVC0 is nearly as bright as NCVC−.
The paper defines the crystal axes as x = [101], y = [121], and z = [111]. BCVC−, NCVC−, and OCVC0 transition dipoles lie perpendicular to the dopant-carbon-vacancy axis. VC− has three equivalent dipole directions.
The calculated 5.6 ns and 2.3 ns lifetimes are shorter than the 9.5 ns literature lifetime for NCVC−. Shorter lifetimes can support more frequent signal generation during optical readout. These values are upper bounds, however, because nonradiative channels such as phonon-induced scattering can shorten the actual lifetime.
BCVC− and OCVC0 both have accessible singlet excited states that could serve as shelving states. The 2¹E singlet of BCVC− lies about 0.2 eV below 2³E. By comparison, the 1¹A₁ singlet lies 0.9 eV below 1³E. The doublet defects BCVC0, NCVC0, and OCVC+ have unfavorable quartet-state energies for intersystem crossing. Their transition dipoles are also small, making them dim or dark for fast optically detected magnetic resonance.
Unresolved issues for qubit use
Section titled “Unresolved issues for qubit use”The electronic and optical results provide an initial screen, not a demonstration of qubit operation. The authors identify electron-phonon coupling, ground- and excited-state zero-field splitting, intersystem crossing and phosphorescence probabilities, coherence lifetimes, and field sensitivity as unresolved.
OCVC0 has a specific stability problem. It is less stable than the double-vacancy complex VCOCVC0 because oxygen favors two covalent bonds. Any experiment using the isolated oxygen-vacancy center must therefore control competing defect formation.
In OCVC2+, a five-state emb-SA-CASSCF reference combined with emb-NEVPT2 produced an unphysically low ³A₂ energy relative to a three-state calculation. The authors suggest that compromise orbitals may explain the result. A proper multistate multireference perturbation treatment was unavailable.
The structural model does not establish how the defects form. Placing D at one vacancy in the figure is a construction rule, not a claimed implantation mechanism. Charge-state occupancy can also change optical and magnetic response. Device characterization must distinguish intended states from other charge states.
Material and device choices
Section titled “Material and device choices”Dopant and charge state should be selected together for optical control. BCVC− offers UV excitation and a short calculated lifetime. OCVC0 offers blue excitation and a still shorter lifetime. NCVC− remains the green-excitation benchmark. These values let engineers select a pump wavelength and estimate readout repetition rate before fabrication.
Singlet charge states also merit attention. BCVC+, NCVC+, and OCVC2+ have spin-singlet ground states and metastable triplet excited states. The triplet can carry magnetic sensitivity while the resting state remains magnetically inactive. VC0 has a nearby triplet that could serve as a transient electron-spin ancilla, although its excited-state structure and lifetime require separate evaluation. Neutral doublets appear less suitable for fast optical readout.
A boron-vacancy program needs substitutional boron adjacent to a carbon vacancy and deliberate control of BCVC charge state. An oxygen-vacancy program needs the same vacancy arrangement plus suppression of VCOCVC0 formation. These requirements follow from the modeled structures and their reported optical responses.
Materials and support
Section titled “Materials and support”The paper’s BCVC model calls for substitutional boron adjacent to a carbon vacancy in a diamond host. 6CCVD lists boron-doped diamond in its diamond materials catalog. Its engineering support service covers custom fabrication questions for that quantum-device material. The paper does not specify a required defect concentration, crystal grade, or sample size.
View Original Abstract
Abstract Diamond point defects or color centers are at the crux of solid-state quantum technology applications, from computing to sensing. Modeling molecular qubits has advanced by leaps and bounds mainly due to the advanced quantum mechanical (QM) tools in the arsenal of quantum chemists for modeling (isolated) molecular systems, which should be easily translatable for analogous systems in the solid state. Here, we simulate a series of diamond defects: a carbon vacancy (VC) and second row substitutions that are adjacent to a VC or DCVC, with D = B, N, and O, to evaluate their magnetic and optical properties. We applied molecular orbital principles, an embedded cluster method, and a multiconfigurational QM theory to computationally characterize the above-mentioned defects for a multitude of spin, charge, and excited states. Our computational approach delivered high-quality QM insights that compare well with experiments. Furthermore, with this framework, we confirm the spin-triplets BCVC- and OCVC0 to be analogous to NCVC-, with calculated bright transitions that respectively correspond to UV (3.80 eV) and blue (2.65 eV) light absorption and emission lifetimes (τ) of 2.3 and 5.6 ns, which are higher in energy and more short-lived (and thus brighter) than that for NCVC-: green (2.26 eV), τ = 9.5 ns.
Boron Doped Single Crystal Diamond Plate
View Specs →
High Concentration Quantum Grade Single Crystal Diamond
View Specs →
Boron Doped Diamond On Titanium Bdd Electrode
View Specs →References we cover
Section titled “References we cover”- Optical properties of a diamond NV color center from capped embedded multiconfigurational correlated wavefunction theory
- Advances in Quantum Defect Embedding Theory
- Bottom-up fabrication of scalable room-temperature diamond quantum computing and sensing technologies
- Identification and Reversible Optical Switching of NV+ Centers in Diamond
- Vibrationally resolved optical excitations of the nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond
Original source
Section titled “Original source”References
Section titled “References”- 2021 - Quantum guidelines for solid-state spin defects [Crossref]
- 2021 - Semiconductor qubits in practice [Crossref]
- 2010 - Quantum computing with defects [Crossref]
- 2016 - Solid-state single-photon emitters [Crossref]
- 2020 - Identifying candidate hosts for quantum defects via data mining [Crossref]
- 1994 - Magnetic susceptibility of carbon structures [Crossref]
- 2023 - Bandgap evolution of diamond [Crossref]
- 1940 - The dielectric constant of diamond [Crossref]
- 2025 - Bottom-up fabrication of scalable room-temperature diamond quantum computing and sensing technologies [Crossref]
- 2010 - Fabrication of single optical centres in diamond─a review [Crossref]