From Rough Lapping to Fine Lapping - A Systematic Study on Tool-Material Compatibility and Process Parameter Optimization for Polycrystalline Diamond
Paper details
Section titled “Paper details”| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Journal | Micromachines |
| Published | 2026-07-26 |
| Authors | 朱宜存, Bingsan Chen, Yan Xu, Hongping Liao, Chunyu Li |
| DOI | 10.3390/mi17080895 |
Fine lapping with a WC-Co disc produced an Ra of 11.2 nm at 0.45 MPa and 600 r/min. A resin-bonded W10 disc first reduced the MPCVD polycrystalline diamond surface from Ra 420 nm to 106 nm. The study separated tool selection, process optimization, and atomic-scale damage analysis.
Process and measurement setup
Section titled “Process and measurement setup”Double-sided milling and grinding prepared MPCVD PCD disks with a 2.5 mm radius. The starting surface had an Ra of about 420 nm, with pits, grooves, and broad peaks. Its diagonal profile contained five valleys below -0.5 µm and five peaks above 0.5 µm.
White light interferometry covered 416 µm × 416 µm, and five locations were averaged for each Ra value. Optical microscopy used a 200× objective in differential interference contrast mode. Raman spectroscopy used a 532 nm laser to assess changes in the diamond surface.
The lapping machine combined disc rotation, radial carrier oscillation, and free specimen rotation. A magnetic stirrer dispersed the slurry, and a peristaltic pump delivered it to the lapping disc. Reported pressure values were preset machine-gauge inputs, not direct interface measurements. The spindle range was 0 to 2000 r/min, and the pressure range was 0 to 0.6 MPa.
Rough lapping favors a resin bond
Section titled “Rough lapping favors a resin bond”The rough stage combined W10 fixed-abrasive discs with loose slurry abrasives. Fixed grits cut at a negative rake angle, while loose grits fractured and rolled across the surface.
Three bond types were tested at 0.45 MPa and 1200 r/min. Each run used 45 g/L grit concentration and lasted 16 h. Resin produced the lowest Ra at 106 nm, a 74.76% reduction from 420 nm. Bronze reached 122 nm, a 70.95% reduction, while vitrified reached 230 nm, a 45.24% reduction.
The microscopy results supported the roughness ranking. Vitrified-bonded grit produced wide, deep micro-spalling pits under excessive loading. The hard bronze bond retained blunt grits, which ploughed narrow peaks about 0.25 µm wide. The resin bond released blunt grits and exposed fresh sharp grits. The authors linked this behavior to the lower number of sharp peaks. Resin was therefore selected for rough lapping.
Fine lapping favors a stiff WC-Co disc
Section titled “Fine lapping favors a stiff WC-Co disc”Fine lapping tested Cu, Fe, and WC-Co support discs under one common condition. W3.5 grits at 45 g/L, 500 r/min, 0.35 MPa, and 12 h were used throughout. Each metallic disc had square grid grooves to support cutting.
Cu reduced Ra from 106 nm to 19 nm. Fe reached 17 nm, while WC-Co reached 14 nm. These outcomes represented reductions of 82.08%, 83.96%, and 86.79%, respectively. The roughness spread was only 5 nm, so morphology and Raman data were needed for comparison.
WC-Co left fewer pits, no obvious protrusions, and a profile with one narrow valley below -0.06 µm. All three fine-lapped samples had narrower Raman peaks than the rough-lapped specimen. WC-Co produced the smallest Raman full width at half maximum, 5.2 cm⁻¹. That value was 0.61 cm⁻¹ below Cu and 0.4 cm⁻¹ below Fe. The authors associated the narrowing with removal of the amorphous surface phase.
The support moduli were about 110 GPa for Cu, 150 to 170 GPa for Fe, and 500 to 600 GPa for WC-Co. The authors attribute WC-Co’s result to its support stiffness. Its low elastic deformation kept abrasive depth more uniform. Cu was softer, so grits could embed or roll.
Speed and pressure set the operating window
Section titled “Speed and pressure set the operating window”Speed tests varied 400, 500, 600, and 700 r/min at 0.4 MPa for 12 h. Ra fell from 15.9 nm to 13.3 nm and then 11.7 nm before rising to 12.6 nm. Thus, 600 r/min gave the lowest measured roughness in that series. At 700 r/min, the authors observed grit ejection and more surface pits.
Pressure tests held speed at 600 r/min and varied pressure from 0.3 to 0.45 MPa. Ra measured 16.5, 13.9, 11.7, and 11.2 nm at 0.3, 0.35, 0.4, and 0.45 MPa. The gain from 0.4 to 0.45 MPa was only 0.5 nm. At 0.45 MPa, optical images showed no obvious pits. The diagonal profile lacked distinct peaks above 0.04 µm or valleys below -0.04 µm.
Li et al. reported about 96 nm with loose abrasives at 0.3 MPa, W10 grit, and 4% slurry. Another study using an Fe abrasive wheel reported 68.4 nm. The 11.2 nm result is below both values.
Yuan et al. found that grain boundaries and voids became apparent below Ra 20 nm. The earlier WC-Co comparison still showed tiny pinhole-like defects, so feature inspection remains relevant at lower Ra.
Molecular dynamics links pressure to damage
Section titled “Molecular dynamics links pressure to damage”The MD model used a 10 nm × 11 nm × 21 nm PCD cell with a 3 nm single-crystal diamond abrasive. Voronoi grains represented polycrystallinity, and Tersoff interactions were calculated in LAMMPS. The model ran at 300 K with a 1 fs time step and periodic boundaries in all three directions.
Plastic deformation began at grain boundaries because their atomic packing was loose and binding energy low. Compression and shear then broke bonds, lowered lattice order, and produced debris.
At a 10 nm machining distance, raising normal load from 600 to 900 nN increased removed atoms from 2820 to 6467. That was a 129.3% gain, while subsurface damage thickness rose from 0.92 to 1.96 nm. The increase in damage thickness was 113%. Accumulated atom width rose from 3.01 to 4.36 nm, a 44.9% increase.
Amorphous sp2 atoms remained about 2.2 times the sp3 count. The authors associate this result with shear-driven amorphization.
Raising speed from 50 to 200 m/s changed removed atoms from 4580 to 5285, a 15.4% increase. Damage thickness rose from 1.62 to 1.83 nm, a 12.9% increase. Amorphous sp3 counts rose about 3%, while sp2 counts fluctuated between 2137 and 2256.
The model treats one continuously engaged abrasive at constant indentation depth. It excludes centrifugal ejection and interrupted contact, both of which affected the experiments. Pressure therefore governed removal and damage in the model, while speed had a smaller effect. In the experiments, speed also changed how often loose grits contacted the specimen.
Limits on scale-up
Section titled “Limits on scale-up”The best roughness was measured on 2.5 mm-radius disks, so the result remains a laboratory-scale process window. Industrial trials were left for future work. The paper also lists grain-size effects and ultrasonic vibration assistance as future work.
No experimental material removal rate or tool wear was reported for the selected recipe. The MD model represents a single continuously sliding abrasive. It does not reproduce slurry transport, tool wear, or intermittent contact. Thus, the simulations support parameter ranking, not a direct scale-up prediction.
Implications for diamond component engineering
Section titled “Implications for diamond component engineering”The reported sequence offers a concrete starting point for PCD plate and wafer finishing. Start with a resin-bonded W10 disc for high-rate rough removal. Then use W3.5 grits on a stiff WC-Co support for fine lapping.
Within the tested range, 600 r/min gave the lowest speed-series roughness. Pressure above 0.4 MPa added little roughness improvement in the experiments. The MD results warn that higher pressure can deepen subsurface damage. Accordingly, 0.45 MPa should be treated as the measured roughness limit, not a universal setting.
Component engineers should qualify tool stiffness, pressure, and surface defect inspection together. The paper does not establish a bulk production recipe for large wafers.
Materials and support
Section titled “Materials and support”The paper targets MPCVD-grown polycrystalline diamond and identifies semiconductors and optical windows as application areas. Its process requirement is a resin-bonded W10 rough stage followed by a stiff WC-Co fine stage, which can inform an engineering support review. 6CCVD’s diamond materials catalog includes single-crystal and polycrystalline diamond grown by MPCVD, with plates and wafers up to 125 mm.
View Original Abstract
Polycrystalline diamond (PCD) has broad application prospects in semiconductors, optical windows and other advanced fields. Nevertheless, its ultrahigh hardness and chemical inertness pose significant challenges for achieving high-quality surface planarization. Although conventional mechanical lapping is widely adopted, it still suffers from poor surface quality and a lack of theoretical guidance for process parameter selection. This study presents a systematic experimental and simulation investigation on both rough and fine lapping of PCD, focusing on tool selection and process optimization. In the rough lapping stage, three types of fixed diamond abrasive discs with resin, bronze, and vitrified bonds were compared. The soft and tough resin-bonded disc yields the best performance, reducing surface roughness Ra from 420 nm to 106 nm. In the fine lapping stage, three metallic discs—Cu, Fe, and WC-Co—were evaluated. The high-stiffness WC-Co disc achieves the best results, with an Ra of 11.2 nm under conditions of 0.45 MPa and 600 r/min. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations further reveal that increasing lapping pressure significantly enhances the material removal rate but concurrently aggravates subsurface damage (SSD), while the effect of speed is considerably smaller. Therefore, pressure emerges as the key parameter that requires balanced optimization in the fine lapping process.
Single Crystal Cvd Diamond Plate
View Specs →
Boron Doped Single Crystal Diamond Plate
View Specs →
Customized Single Crystal Cvd Diamond Plate
View Specs →References we cover
Section titled “References we cover”Original source
Section titled “Original source”References
Section titled “References”- 2018 - Ultrawide-bandgap semiconductors: Research opportunities and challenges [Crossref]
- 2020 - Insight into the mechanism of low friction and wear during the chemical mechanical polishing process of diamond: A reactive molecular dynamics simulation [Crossref]
- 2025 - Research progress on improving the thermal stability of PCD compact: A review
- 2024 - Study on removal mechanism of PCD wafer by grinding containing transition metals [Crossref]
- 2020 - High-precision mechanical polishing method for diamond substrate using micron-sized diamond abrasive grains [Crossref]
- 2013 - Chemical mechanical polishing slurries for chemically vapor-deposited diamond films [Crossref]
- 2020 - Thermochemical grinding of diamond films in installation for chemical vapor deposition of diamond from the gas phase [Crossref]
- 2022 - Femtosecond and nanosecond laser polishing of rough PCD [Crossref]
- 2022 - Effects of polishing pressure and sliding speed on the material removal mechanism of single crystal diamond in plasma-assisted polishing [Crossref]