Skip to content

Harnessing Diamond Surface Features for Dense and Aligned NV Ensembles

FieldValue
JournalNano Letters
Published2026-08-17
AuthorsEveline Postelnicu, Lillian B. Hughes, Tri Nguyen, Simon A. Meynell, C. E. Jilly‐Rehak
DOI10.1021/acs.nanolett.6c02155

Hillocks on (001)-oriented diamond concentrated ¹⁵N to a peak of about 2 × 10¹⁹ cm⁻³, up to 1000 times the planar film. Each of the four hillock sidewalls hosted a distinct NV orientation, with near-perfect preferential alignment within each sidewall. The sidewalls also reached a 1.7 to 2% ratio of NV centers to substitutional nitrogen P1. This was up to four times the typical 0.5% conversion for grown-in NVs on (001) diamond.

Two single-crystal diamond thin films were grown on (001)-oriented substrates by plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition in a Seki SDS6300 reactor. The low-miscut substrate had a 0.60° polar miscut and a −33° offset from the [110] azimuth. The high-miscut substrate had a 1.25° polar miscut toward [110]. Both films received nominal 7 to 15 nm ¹⁵N-doped layers during growth.

The low-miscut process used a 750 W plasma with 0.025% CH₄ in 400 sccm H₂ at 25 torr and about 800°C. A 3 h ¹²C buffer preceded a 3 h ¹⁵N layer supplied at 5 sccm ¹⁵N₂, and a 3 h ¹²C cap followed. The high-miscut film used 2 h buffer and cap layers and two 2 h ¹⁵N layers. Their doping temperatures were 800°C and 900°C. Before growth, the substrates received a 500 nm etch after fine polishing.

SEM and AFM mapped hillock shape, while panchromatic and hyperspectral CL measured spatial and spectral luminescence. Site-coincident nanoSIMS measured ¹⁵N at 50 to 70 nm spatial resolution. TEM and 4D-STEM examined the buried defects, while CWESR, Hahn echo, DEER, and XY-8 measured NV orientation, coherence, P1 density, and NV density. The reported NV measurements used regions that had not been intentionally irradiated for vacancy creation.

Nitrogen accumulation at hillock sidewalls

Section titled “Nitrogen accumulation at hillock sidewalls”

The brightest CL ring in the low-miscut hillocks coincided with the ¹⁵N isotope map. NanoSIMS found a sidewall peak of about 2 × 10¹⁹ cm⁻³, compared with about 2 × 10¹⁸ cm⁻³ in the planar film. The hillock center also exceeded the background, but its nitrogen density was 10 times lower than the sidewall density. Depth profiles broadened through the inclined sidewall, consistent with a longer path through the doped interval and a thicker sidewall layer.

Across three hillocks and 12 sidewalls, nitrogen density showed no observable dependence on sidewall angle. The paper reports a contrast scale of 3.12 × 10¹⁸ cm⁻³ per degree, or 17.7 ppm per degree. Upper and lower sidewalls contained more nitrogen than left and right sidewalls, producing twofold rather than fourfold symmetry.

Hyperspectral CL showed a stronger NV⁰ peak at the hillock, although the electron beam converts NV⁻ to NV⁰ during measurement. H3 and broad A-band peaks indicated that other point defects or complexes may also be present.

TEM showed stacking faults and two threading dislocations at the hillock center. The dislocations were predominantly edge-type, because they nearly disappeared under g = 004 but remained visible under g = 220. This differs from the screw-dislocation spiral model often associated with pyramidal hillocks. The inverted top and defect structure are consistent with the authors’ conclusion that the morphology began with surface preparation rather than a substrate screw dislocation. They propose an etch pit or divot that nucleated disordered growth, which produced stacking faults and then threading edge dislocations.

Nitrogen-rich sidewall bands produced strain contrast under both g = 004 and g = 220. The contrast was not chemically informative. EDS and EELS did not detect nitrogen above the carbon background. The stated practical detection limit was about 0.1 at% or 10²⁰ cm⁻³, above the measured sidewall peak.

Sidewalls lay 19 to 25° from the (001) plane, close to the 25.2° inclination of a {113} facet. TEM resolved a 27° inner edge before doping, a 19° outer edge, and 24° sidewall growth after doping. The authors interpret the lower outer angle as a higher lateral-to-vertical growth ratio during nitrogen deposition. They say this is more consistent with facet-specific incorporation kinetics than simple miscut and step-density scaling.

CWESR mapped four NV orientations on each hillock, with one dominant frequency in each sidewall domain. Linecuts across the hillock showed that this preferential alignment was near-perfect. The paper defines a quadrant as the full segment extending from the center in the {113} direction. Each quadrant held a single preferential orientation, including material grown before and after the intentional ¹⁵N interval. Residual chamber nitrogen was proposed to explain aligned incorporation during those periods. The top remained close to (001), where all four NV orientations can form. Using the measured nitrogen densities, the authors estimated that (001) accounts for only 2 to 3% of NVs within the quadrants.

The exact sidewall structure remains unresolved. The authors consider a distinct {113} facet or a mixture of {001} and {111} facets. A single orientation is expected on {111}, while growth kinetics may also favor alignment at 800°C. AFM at ambient pressure and projection through the TEM foil may have hidden individual facet steps.

XY-8 analysis found 0.11 to 0.19 ppm NV density, and DEER found 5.4 to 10.4 ppm of substitutional nitrogen, identified as P1. These values give a 1.7 to 2% NV/P1 ratio. Hahn echo T₂ times ranged from 8.1 to 17.6 μs across three hillocks and were consistent with P1-limited decoherence.

The paper compares this conversion with 0.5% for (100) and (110) films, 4 to 11% for (111), and 25% for (113). The authors caution that the substrate comparison is not direct.

The 1.25° sample contained elongated, rougher hillocks and many step bunches. Its two ¹⁵N layers formed two nitrogen-rich rings, with the first ring containing more nitrogen than the second. Their separation records how the hillock widened between the doping intervals. Step bunches contained about 10 times the background nitrogen. A larger step bunch produced CL intensity as strong as the hillock center.

Nitrogen aggregation in both samples reached about 2 × 10¹⁹ cm⁻³, regardless of background doping. The authors suggest this ceiling could reflect a maximum incorporation efficiency for {113}-oriented facets. Step bunches also warrant study as nitrogen-rich surface features, but their NV orientation was not measured in this work.

The square hillock morphology was not ubiquitous and depended on chamber history or surface preparation. The authors did not establish a reproducible process window for producing it. The mechanism for one orientation per sidewall and for twofold sidewall nitrogen symmetry remains unresolved. TEM contrast also did not chemically identify nitrogen.

The studied hillock center contains stacking faults and edge dislocations, while the sidewalls retained P1-limited coherence. The result therefore does not show that a rough hillock surface is generally suitable for NV devices. The authors call for controlled overgrowth across facet inclinations toward {113} and {111}. Atomistic simulations and systematic growth studies are needed to connect facet angle, nitrogen incorporation, and NV alignment.

For material selection, the measured difference between hillock sidewalls and the planar film reaches three orders of magnitude. The authors expect dense, aligned ensembles to increase sensitivity and support strong NV interactions for sensing and simulation. The result suggests that (001) growth can create local aligned ensembles without a uniformly (111)-oriented film.

For NV-ensemble quantum sensing and simulation devices, the relevant requirement is a single-crystal (001)-oriented diamond substrate for nitrogen-doped PECVD overgrowth. 6CCVD’s diamond materials catalog lists MPCVD-grown single-crystal plates and wafers up to 125 mm, with thickness from 0.1 to 500 micrometers and polishing below Ra 1 nm for single-crystal material. Catalog orientation and compatibility with the reported PECVD process would need confirmation during engineering support.

View Original Abstract

Controlling nitrogen doping in diamond is key to advancing nitrogen-vacancy (NV) center devices. We harness the hillock, a typically undesirable surface feature, to incorporate high densities of grown-in, aligned NV centers on a (001)-oriented substrate. Enhanced cathodoluminescence at hillock sidewalls is correlated via nanoSIMS to up to 1000× greater nitrogen incorporation compared to the planar film. We find that these hillocks are associated with stacking faults and edge-type dislocations, consistent with an origin in surface preparation rather than substrate screw dislocations. Yet, the growth is orderly enough that each of the four hillock sidewalls hosts a distinct NV orientation. A 1.7-2% grown-in NV/substitutional nitrogen (P1) ratio, 4× higher than typical (001)-oriented growth, is measured via NV decoherence analysis. By revealing that spontaneously formed hillocks act as natural laboratories for dense, aligned NV formation, this work motivates systematic investigation of facet-dependent nitrogen incorporation and preferential NV alignment in (001) diamond.