Unveiling the Crystal Structures of Ice Polymorphs by using Neutron Diffraction under Pressure
Paper details
Section titled “Paper details”| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Journal | Nihon Kessho Gakkaishi |
| Published | 2026-08-31 |
| Authors | Kazuki Komatsu |
| DOI | 10.5940/jcrsj.68.144 |
Neutron diffraction in ice X directly captured two hydrogen-position peaks merging into one near 80 GPa, showing the approach to a symmetric hydrogen bond. Extending the experiment beyond 100 GPa required a nanopolycrystalline diamond anvil cell and more than a decade of pressure-cell development. The broader results also show that path-dependent hydrogen ordering in high-pressure ice can be followed in situ under controlled temperature and pressure.
Neutron diffraction resolves hydrogen disorder
Section titled “Neutron diffraction resolves hydrogen disorder”At least 20 crystalline ice phases had been confirmed by July 2026. Most use tetrahedral oxygen coordination, but their hydrogen configurations and pressure responses differ.
Hydrogen contributes only one electron, so X-ray diffraction has weak sensitivity to its position. Neutrons scatter from nuclei, and deuterium has a coherent scattering length of 6.67 fm. Oxygen has a similar value of 5.80 fm. These constants do not depend on neutron wavelength or scattering angle. The measurement therefore resolves hydrogen or deuterium occupancy, average positions, and displacement distributions without burying the signal under oxygen.
X-ray diffraction can still locate some hydrogen sites in ice. It is less reliable when the key quantities are occupancy and the shape of a split or broad position distribution.
The J-PARC PLANET beamline, completed in 2012, enabled time-of-flight diffraction under pressure. The method covers a broad d-spacing range from limited scattering angles. Its long sample-detector path reduces sensitivity to sample displacement. High time and angular resolution detects small cell-parameter changes during pressure-temperature cycling.
MITO system controls pressure and temperature
Section titled “MITO system controls pressure and temperature”MITO was developed from 2010 to about 2013 to reproduce metastable ice phases through independent temperature and pressure control. Earlier experiments used a Paris-Edinburgh cell at ISIS. Cooling the whole cell in a liquid nitrogen bath caused fluctuations of at least 5 K. Such fluctuations mattered because ice phase paths depend strongly on temperature and pressure.
MITO routes liquid nitrogen through the sample region and vaporizes remaining liquid with a heater. A mass-flow controller then regulates the nitrogen gas. This design cools the sample without immersing the pressure cell.
For high-density amorphous ice relaxation, the earlier protocol cooled water below 100 K and then pressurized it to about 1.5 GPa. It then decompressed to ambient pressure while cold and tracked scattering intensity during a hold. MITO allowed that route to be controlled while scattering intensity was followed over time.
The reported MITO operating range is 0 to 15 GPa and 60 to 473 K. Liquid nitrogen provides rapid cooling. A cryocooler provides stable cooling for long holds. These controls let the team separate phase identity from the route used to reach it.
Ice XV reveals partial hydrogen ordering
Section titled “Ice XV reveals partial hydrogen ordering”Ice VI first appears when room-temperature water reaches about 1 GPa and has disordered hydrogen positions. Salzmann and co-workers reported its ordered phase, ice XV, in 2009. They cooled a solution containing 0.01 mol/L HCl near 1 GPa. They used DCl for neutron diffraction.
Initial MITO experiments failed to order ice VI under comparable conditions. Later tests showed why preparation mattered. One-time rapid quenching crystallized the ice before later ordering. Slow cooling instead moved HCl to grain boundaries, where the authors suggest it ceased to function as an ordering-promoting defect.
Ordering could be followed after the ice VI sample was recovered at low temperature to ambient pressure. The ice-XV-specific 003 reflection began to appear around 100 K. Its intensity rose during an isothermal hold. The c/a ratio varied less than the reflection intensity.
The diffraction-peak width changed earlier than either observable. The authors interpret this as nucleation of small ordered domains with different configurations. Those domains cause lattice strain and broaden the peaks. Axis ratios and intensities reveal the average periodic structure only after ordering has progressed.
A first-principles search considered 45 possible hydrogen configurations for an ice-VI-sized cell. Several configurations remained energetically competitive below the typical ordering temperature. This result supports the authors’ proposal that ice XV is partially ordered. The true crystal structure remains unresolved.
Ice XIX depends on the pressure-temperature route
Section titled “Ice XIX depends on the pressure-temperature route”In 2018, a high-pressure in situ permittivity cell was developed for this problem. Water’s strong dipole makes permittivity sensitive to small hydrogen motions. During cooling of ice VI under pressure, the ordering temperature fell with pressure below 1.6 GPa. Above 1.6 GPa, it rose instead. That reversal suggested that another ordered phase had become stable.
Powder neutron diffraction with MITO at PLANET then resolved a new set of peaks. They could not be indexed with the ice VI or ice XV cells. The new cell was √2 × √2 × 1 relative to ice VI. The authors named this phase ice XIX.
The ice-VI-to-ice-XIX transition reached a steady state within tens of minutes. Ice XV did not reach a steady state after a 10-hour hold in the earlier experiments. Unit-cell volume and c/a increased during ice XV ordering, but both decreased for ice XIX.
These measurements show two ordered outcomes from the same disordered ice VI phase. They also show that the pressure-temperature path selects the outcome. The detailed structures of ice XV and ice XIX are still unknown. The cause of their different kinetics and cell changes remains unresolved.
Time-resolved diffraction tracks hydrogen motion
Section titled “Time-resolved diffraction tracks hydrogen motion”Ice VII is a disordered phase stable from 2 to 60 GPa, and ice VIII is its ordered phase. Time-resolved neutron diffraction followed the creation and growth of ordered domains during the ice-VII-to-ice-VIII transition.
MITO cooling experiments found that the ordering rate reached a minimum near 10 GPa. Under the authors’ scenario, molecular rotation slows as pressure rises while hydrogen translation between neighboring sites speeds up. Their crossover near 10 GPa produces the kinetic minimum.
The neutron experiment linked hydrogen dynamics directly to changes in crystal symmetry during ordering. Later in situ dielectric measurements verified the rotational-translational crossover.
Reaching 100 GPa with a diamond anvil cell
Section titled “Reaching 100 GPa with a diamond anvil cell”Reaching 100 GPa required a different balance between pressure capacity and neutron sample volume. In 2013, neutron diffraction needed at least about 10 mm³ of sample. A conventional 100 GPa cell used about 1 × 10⁻⁴ mm³. The volume gap was 100,000.
The nanopolycrystalline diamond anvil offered a route because it was stronger than single-crystal diamond. Early anvils fractured below the target pressure. Over more than ten years, the team revised cell design, anvil shape and dimensions, and gasket materials.
In March 2021, the group recorded a neutron diffraction pattern above 100 GPa. By December 2023, a satisfactory dataset had been assembled for detailed structural analysis. Rietveld refinement yielded the unit cell, atomic positions, and atomic displacement parameters.
The authors represented the hydrogen distribution as the sum of two Gaussian functions. Ice VII showed two separated peaks. Near 80 GPa, the peaks merged into a single distribution. This was the first direct observation of the change from bimodal to unimodal hydrogen positions. It tracks the pressure-driven approach to a symmetric hydrogen bond in ice X.
Unresolved structures and engineering limits
Section titled “Unresolved structures and engineering limits”The detailed crystal structures of ice XV and ice XIX are not yet settled. Calculations identify several competing hydrogen configurations, but the experiments do not assign one unique structure to either phase. The data also do not explain why ice XIX reaches steady state much faster than ice XV.
The pressure-temperature dependence suggests that other disordered phases may also have second or third ordered states. The author treats this as an indication that the ice phase diagram remains incomplete. At still higher pressures, the paper suggests that familiar ice rules may no longer apply. Plastic and superionic phases are presented as possible regimes, not as measurements reported here.
For high-pressure materials studies, the results show why hydrogen occupancy and position distributions require neutron data when phase identity depends on proton order. For diamond-anvil selection, strength alone did not determine performance. Anvil shape, dimensions, gasket material, cell geometry, and sample volume had to be developed as a system. The engineering target is a validated pressure-temperature path inside a neutron-compatible sample volume, not a maximum pressure rating alone.
View Original Abstract
Water exhibits remarkable polymorphism, with more than twenty crystalline ice phases identified to date. Understanding their crystal structures, hydrogen ordering, and pressure-induced structural transformations requires precise determination of hydrogen positions, making neutron diffraction an indispensable technique. However, the combination of neutron diffraction and high-pressure experiments has long been hindered by severe technical challenges arising from the small sample volumes required at high pressure. This article reviews our efforts to overcome these limitations through the development of advanced high-pressure neutron diffraction techniques, particularly the MITO system for individual pressure and temperature control and the integration of nano-polycrystalline diamond anvil cells with the PLANET beamline at J-PARC. These developments have enabled detailed investigations of hydrogen ordering and dynamics in high-pressure ice polymorphs. Studies on ice XV and the newly discovered ice XIX revealed the existence of partially ordered states and demonstrated that a single hydrogen-disordered phase can transform into distinct ordered phases depending on the pressure-temperature pathway. Time-resolved neutron diffraction measurements of the ice VII-VIII transition further uncovered a crossover between molecular rotational and proton translational motions that governs hydrogen-ordering kinetics. Extending neutron diffraction measurements beyond 100 GPa finally made it possible to directly observe the evolution of the hydrogen distribution toward the symmetrized hydrogen bond in ice X. These achievements illustrate how advances in experimental methodology have opened new opportunities for exploring the structural complexity of ice and hydrogen-bonded materials under extreme conditions.
Single Crystal Cvd Diamond Plate
View Specs →
Boron Doped Single Crystal Diamond Plate
View Specs →