Skip to content

Analyse de la bague de Monseigneur Paul Dupont des Loges, évêque de Metz de 1843 à 1886

FieldValue
Published2026-09-22
AuthorsMarie Chabrol, Aurélien Delaunay
DOI10.63000/g8mcv226pae7f

The analysis identified the ring’s central stone as an approximately 8.1 carat emerald of probable Colombian origin. The four colorless stones were confirmed as natural diamonds through nitrogen-vacancy luminescence. Inclusion morphology, spectroscopy, and elemental analysis agreed on the emerald’s Colombian attribution.

Identification and gemmological properties

Section titled “Identification and gemmological properties”

The green center was classified as beryl of the emerald variety. Its refractive index was 1.573 to 1.580, measured with a Gemax refractometer. It showed clear blue-green and yellow-green pleochroism. It returned to extinction every quarter turn under a polariscope, confirming its anisotropic response.

The center stone measures 12.80 by 12.70 by 6.76 mm. Its square outline had cut corners, a modified brilliant crown, and a step-cut pavilion. The authors called this a mixed cut, a style that emerged in the middle of the 18th century and became popular during the 19th century.

The estimated mass was 8.1 carats, calculated with a density of 2.71. The complete ring weighed 24.67 g. The colorless stones had few inclusions, with some frost and needles visible. The authors graded their clarity from VVS to VS and their symmetry as passable.

The ring used yellow gold with a fineness of 750/1000, called 18 carats at the time. A horse-head purity hallmark established this metal grade. That mark was valid from 1838 to 1919, so it is consistent with the ring’s 1868 manufacture.

An anchor-shaped hallmark bearing the initials E. V. identifies Ernest Vever. The mark was registered with the Paris customs authorities in 1876. Its presence on the ring suggests that Vever used it in Metz, possibly as early as 1848.

An engraving inside the shank records June 29, 1868. The date preceded the 25th anniversary of the bishop’s episcopal consecration. The Dames de Metz commissioned the ring for that jubilee. A July 7, 1868 report recorded a total cost of 2,000 francs for the ring and its case bearing the bishop’s arms.

The neogothic design includes two angels flanking the central stone. Floral enamelwork covers parts of the table. The colorless stones occupy the ring’s ends in bezel settings.

The examination combined optical observation with five analytical methods. The report describes analysis of the mounted stones in their ring settings.

EvidenceInstrument and conditionsPurpose
Microscopy and photographyZeiss Stemi 508 trinocular microscope, System Eickhorst Gemmaster LED stand, OrbitVu Alphashot micro cabinet, and Canon EOS 6D Mark II with EF1000 F/2.8L Macro IS USMObserved inclusions, fractures, cut geometry, enamel, and hallmarks
Refractometry and polariscopyGemax refractometer and polariscopeMeasured refractive index and optical response
Infrared spectroscopyThermo Scientific IS50 FTIR, liquid-nitrogen-cooled MCT detector, 4 cm⁻¹ acquisition, 200 scans, XT-KBr splitterCharacterized water in the emerald
UV-visible-NIR spectroscopyJasco V-670, 1 nm interval, 400 nm/min scan speed, 2 nm slit, photomultiplier tube with PbS photoconductive cellIdentified chromium and vanadium absorption features
Raman and photoluminescenceRenishaw InVia with 514 nm laser at 100 mW, 1800 lines/mm grating, and 10 scans on average; Exa photoluminescence at 405 nmResolved chromium emission, diamond N3 centers, and emerald water
Elemental analysisThermo ARL Quant’X EDXRFMeasured vanadium, chromium, and iron concentrations

Each method addressed a different part of the identification. Microscopy located inclusions and fissures. Raman spectroscopy separated the two water signals. UV-visible-NIR spectroscopy assigned broad absorption bands. Photoluminescence isolated chromium and N3 emission. EDXRF measured the elemental composition.

Microscopy found three-phase, finger-like fluid inclusions in the central emerald. The authors describe these inclusions as typical of Colombian emeralds. Their morphology supplied the main inclusion-based evidence for the proposed origin.

The emerald also contained fissures with visible dendrites. The authors interpreted the dendrites as remnants of an old filling material. They identified the material only as probably cedar oil, so the oil identification remains less certain than the Colombian inclusion association.

The emerald therefore records both geological formation features and later treatment. The fluid inclusions support the origin assessment, while the dendrites record an intervention made during the stone’s history.

Chromium-related red photoluminescence was clear under 405 nm excitation. Under 514 nm excitation, the emerald produced two emission bands at 680 and 684 nm. The authors assigned both bands to chromium.

The UV-visible-NIR spectrum showed absorption bands at 430 and 600 nm. The authors linked these bands to chromium and assigned a 410 nm shoulder to vanadium. Absorption bands at 850 and 372 nm were absent. The authors therefore excluded iron as a cause of the emerald’s color.

Raman spectroscopy near 3600 cm⁻¹ produced two water peaks. The larger peak occurred at 3607 cm⁻¹ and represented type I water. The smaller peak occurred at 3598 cm⁻¹ and represented type II water.

The authors interpreted the ratio between these peaks as evidence of low alkali content. They said this result reinforced the probable Colombian origin and was consistent with the work of Huong and colleagues published in 2010.

EDXRF measured 840.6 ppm vanadium, 759.1 ppm chromium, and 442.4 ppm iron. Vanadium exceeded chromium, and chromium exceeded iron.

The authors describe this concentration profile as characteristic of Colombian emeralds. They characterize those stones as iron-poor and rich in vanadium. The measured profile agrees with the Raman and inclusion evidence rather than relying on color alone.

Detected iron did not create the 850 nm or 372 nm absorption features. The chemical measurement and the UV-visible-NIR spectrum therefore addressed separate questions. One quantified elemental content, while the other tested whether iron contributed to the observed color.

The colorless stones emitted blue luminescence associated with N3 centers at 415 nm. An N3 center comprises three nitrogen atoms around a vacancy. The authors used this photoluminescence signature to identify all four colorless stones as natural diamonds.

The stones were described as rounded cushion old-mine cuts in bezel settings. Their reported clarity ranged from VVS to VS. Few inclusions were visible, although the authors also noted frost and needles. The stones had passable symmetry.

Limits and material selection implications

Section titled “Limits and material selection implications”

The emerald’s geographic attribution remains probable rather than mine-specific. The authors call the fluid inclusions typical of Colombia and support that attribution with Raman spectroscopy and elemental analysis. The cedar-oil filler also remains a probable identification.

The diamond analysis established natural origin through N3 luminescence. The paper does not assign a mine, age, or growth method to the four colorless stones. Those results support historical gemstone identification, not device-grade diamond characterization.

For historical jewelry material selection, the results separate three levels of evidence. Measured properties establish emerald and natural diamond identity. Inferred origin supports the Colombian attribution for the emerald. Observed dendrites and residual oil record later treatment.

None of these findings provides a basis for selecting diamond for an engineering device. The study concerns a mounted 19th-century jewel and does not report device-relevant material data. The ring remains in the treasury of Metz Cathedral and will be displayed at the Musée de la Cour d’Or from November 13, 2026, to May 18, 2027.

View Original Abstract

ANALYSIS OF THE RING OF MONSIGNOR PAUL DUPONT DES LOGES, BISHOP OF METZ FROM 1843 TO 1886 - In April 2026, the Laboratoire Français de Gemmologie had the opportunity to analyze the ring of Monsignor Paul Dupont des Loges as part of a broader study of the Metz Cathedral Treasury and in preparation for the “Vever, Exceptional Jewelers” exhibition, which will be held from November 13, 2026, to May 18, 2027, at the Cour d’Or Museum in Metz. The analysis confirmed the nature of the stones: +8 carats Colombian emerald and old-cut diamonds.