Skip to content

Nature of point defects in bulk hexagonal diamond

FieldValue
JournalJournal of Applied Physics
Published2026-09-02
AuthorsLing Zhu, Xuanxuan Zhang, Guliqinayi Alimu, Chen-Min Dai, Chunlan Ma
DOI10.1063/5.0344287

Carbon vacancies dominate the calculated intrinsic conductivity of bulk hexagonal diamond. They pin the Fermi level about 1 to 1.5 eV above the valence band maximum, giving bulk hexagonal diamond weak p-type character. Boron acts as an effective acceptor, while nitrogen and phosphorus act as donors. Several vacancy-based complexes also show multiple spin and charge states within the band gap.

All calculations used density functional theory in VASP. The defect supercell contained 432 atoms and used a single Gamma point, described as a 1 × 1 × 1 Monkhorst-Pack mesh. PBE within GGA handled structural relaxation with a 420 eV plane-wave cutoff. Relaxation continued until all atomic forces fell below 0.01 eV/Å. HSE06 with an exact-exchange fraction of 0.32 supplied total defect energies. This setting produced a 4.62 eV band gap for the 432-atom supercell, close to the 4.68 eV GW value. Spin polarization determined defect ground states, especially for defect complexes. The FNV scheme corrected image charge interactions using a static dielectric constant of 6.05. Formation energies were referenced to the valence band maximum and varied with Fermi level and chemical potentials. Most competing phases had positive formation energies, so the authors used the carbon-rich limit and expected little difference from the carbon-poor limit. The formation and binding energies below use this carbon-rich limit.

Under the carbon-rich limit, neutral VC has a formation energy of 7.10 eV. The vacancy leaves four dangling bonds and creates three defect states within the band gap. With spin polarization, these states split into six spin states. VC is stable in +1, neutral, -1, and -2 charge states as the Fermi level changes. Its donor transition lies close to the valence band maximum. The acceptor transitions reach the middle of the gap and approach the conduction band minimum.

The selected Ci4 configuration breaks two C-C bonds, forms three new C-C bonds, and leaves two dangling bonds. Its neutral formation energy is about 12 eV, nearly 5 eV above VC and above the divacancies. The calculations therefore assign Ci4 a low concentration and negligible influence on conductivity.

Two adjacent vacancies form axis-aligned VVa and basal-aligned VVb. Their neutral formation energies are 10.53 and 10.46 eV. Their binding energies are 3.67 and 3.74 eV. They produce six dangling bonds, four in-gap states, and eight spin states. Their formation energies exceed that of VC, limiting their effect on intrinsic conductivity. Compensation between the +1 donor state and -1 acceptor state of VC sets the Fermi-level position.

Boron substitution causes little lattice distortion because B has an atomic size similar to C. Substitution leaves one C dangling bond and a half-occupied in-gap state. The neutral BC formation energy is 1.68 eV under carbon-rich conditions. BC remains -1 across most Fermi levels, becomes neutral below 0.44 eV, and becomes +1 below 0.12 eV. These results identify B as a benign acceptor capable of increasing p-type conductivity. AlC and GaC have neutral formation energies of 8.71 and 9.17 eV. Their larger atomic sizes shift their acceptor levels upward, and they have little effect on conductivity. The interstitial B configuration has a neutral formation energy near 12 eV and is unstable.

NC has a neutral formation energy of 3.80 eV, lower than the 7.10 eV value for VC. It breaks one original C-C bond and creates three N-C bonds of about 1.47 Å. The +1 state dominates across most Fermi levels, so N acts as a benign n-type dopant. PC has a neutral formation energy of 6.65 eV, close to that of VC. Its 1+/0 transition lies close to the conduction band minimum, making P an effective shallow donor. AsC has a neutral formation energy of 10.26 eV, which limits its effect on conductivity. The interstitial N configuration has a neutral formation energy near 10 eV and is unstable. Other interstitial dopants were neglected because their larger atomic sizes produced unstable configurations.

Neutral MgC has a formation energy of 11.80 eV. CaC and SrC reach 17.03 and 21.27 eV. MgC is bipolar but mainly acts as an acceptor. It shows donor behavior only below a Fermi level of 0.95 eV. SiC is neutral, has no localized gap state, and has a formation energy of 4.31 eV. GeC behaves similarly, with a formation energy of 6.89 eV. SnC and PbC are deep donors with neutral formation energies of 13.74 and 17.44 eV. Pb-C bonds of 1.91 and 1.94 Å exceed Si-C bonds of 1.73 and 1.72 Å. This difference reflects severe lattice distortion and poor orbital overlap.

Vacancy complexes bind dopants and vacancies

Section titled “Vacancy complexes bind dopants and vacancies”

All calculated neutral defect complexes have positive binding energies, making each complex more stable than the corresponding separated defects. Here X denotes a dopant and V denotes a carbon vacancy. B and N complexes adopt configuration XVI, with X replacing a host carbon beside an adjacent vacancy. The remaining dopants adopt configuration XVII, with X between two vacancies in a split-vacancy structure. The a orientation follows the axis, while the b orientation follows the basal direction.

Binding energies include MgVa at 8.98 eV, BVa at 2.54 eV, NVa at 4.62 eV, and PVb at 8.45 eV. PVb is about 2 eV more stable than PVa, which the authors link to reduced structural distortion. Most XV complexes favor negative charge states over most Fermi levels and therefore act mainly as acceptors. The formation energies of BVa, SiVa, PVb, NVa, PVa, and AsVb are comparable to that of VC. These complexes may therefore affect hole concentration and act as p-type dopants. Formation energies for most XVa and XVb orientations are similar. PV and AsV differ because their basal orientations are more stable.

Quantum defect candidates require experimental checks

Section titled “Quantum defect candidates require experimental checks”

VC, MgC, and the divacancies each contain multiple spin states within the band gap. VC has three gap states split into six spin states, while each divacancy has four gap states split into eight spin states. MgC also has three gap states split into six spin states. Except for PV and AsV, the XV complexes introduce multiple spin and charge states within the gap. These electronic structures make the defects candidates for color centers and qubits.

The paper cites a -3 charged MgV center in cubic diamond as a 1448 nm telecom-band emitter. The present calculation does not predict that wavelength or any optical transition for hexagonal diamond. Neither spin coherence nor qubit performance was calculated.

The evidence is computational, and the paper reports no experimental measurements of defect concentrations, conductivity, or optical lines. The conclusions depend on a 432-atom supercell, a single Gamma point, and the chosen defect chemical potentials. The C-rich limit was used because the calculated competing phases had positive formation energies. The benchmark between PBE and HSE06 covered the -1 carbon vacancy, whose total energies differed by less than 0.01 eV. Only five random interstitial positions were generated for each interstitial species before selecting the lowest-energy configuration. Other local minima could therefore remain outside the search. Formation energies also depend on charge state and Fermi level, so the reported values apply to the stated conditions.

For material selection, B is the calculated acceptor with the lowest formation energy, while N and P are the effective donors. Carbon-vacancy control matters for intrinsic HD because its compensation sets the Fermi level. Any decision to use VC, MgC, or an XV complex as a qubit still requires measured optical transitions and spin lifetimes.

View Original Abstract

Hexagonal diamond (HD), an exotic carbon allotrope recently synthesized in bulk form, exhibits superior mechanical properties compared to cubic diamond and holds promise for advanced industrial and quantum applications. Using first-principles calculations, we systematically investigate intrinsic defects, extrinsic dopants, and defect complexes in HD. Our study shows that VC dominates intrinsic conductivity, while Ci is unstable. Among extrinsic dopants, boron acts as a benign acceptor enhancing p-type conductivity, whereas nitrogen and phosphorus serve as effective donors for n-type conductivity. Group II and Group IV dopants, however, introduce high formation energies or neutral charge states with limited impact. Furthermore, VC, MgC, and XV defect complexes display multiple spin and charge states within the HD bandgap, highlighting their potential as color centers for hosting qubits. These results not only clarify the defect physics of HD but also demonstrate its broader implications for conductivity engineering and quantum technologies.