Skip to content

Color Changes in Natural Diamonds During Cutting and Polishing - The Role of Crystal Defects, Plastic Deformation, and Technological Factors

FieldValue
JournalZenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published2026-10-16
AuthorsДронова Нона Дмитриевна
DOI10.5281/zenodo.23418609

About 10% to 12% of gem diamonds change color during cutting and polishing, according to the study. Natural diamonds change color 3 to 5 times faster than synthetic diamonds under the compared treatment conditions. The authors associate these changes with plastic deformation and defect-rich regions around cracks.

The paper separates a broad crystal survey from a smaller set characterized for defects and crystal structure.

QuantityReported valueScope
Overall crystal surveyMore than 2,000Crystals studied across the research program
Detailed characterization177Natural and synthetic crystals described by defects and crystal structure
Plastic deformationAbout 70%Share of defects attributed by the authors to plastic deformation
Other causes30%Remainder of the authors’ defect analysis
Structural nonuniformities5%Share specifically associated with structural nonuniformities

These percentages describe the authors’ defect analysis rather than a controlled separation of individual causes. The paper does not provide uncertainty estimates for this breakdown.

The authors used a combined approach that characterized each crystal by its optical nonuniformity, defect content, and crystal structure. Optical spectroscopy supplied absorption and luminescence data. Microscopy and related measurements addressed dislocations, etch features, microcracks, surface defects, microscopic inclusions, hardness, and microhardness.

Absorption spectra were used to classify crystals by their spectral characteristics and structural nonuniformities. Luminescence provided an additional means of following processing-related changes. The authors linked these optical observations to the locations and types of crystal defects.

The study also used a multifactor processing experiment. Its factors were cutting temperature, cutting speed, cutting depth, and abrasive tool quality. The purpose was to determine how these conditions affect color change in crystals with different defect states.

The authors treat dislocations, etch figures, and microcracks as the principal structural defects relevant to color. They report that color changes occur in zones where dislocations accumulate around cracks.

The crack itself does not provide a sufficient explanation. Earlier studies cited in the paper found that not every crack causes a color change. The decisive condition is plastic deformation around the crack. A crack formed without plastic deformation does not produce the same optical change.

The authors’ defect observations support this sequence. Cutting creates a deformed region near a crack. Dislocations accumulate within that region. The optical characteristics then change in the same area.

This mechanism agrees with the prior work discussed by the authors. Their contribution is to apply the crack, deformation, and dislocation relationship directly to machining behavior. They separate the presence of a defect from the deformation state that develops around it.

Plastic deformation dominates the authors’ attribution

Section titled “Plastic deformation dominates the authors’ attribution”

The defect analysis places plastic deformation first among the causes of color change. The larger structural inhomogeneity share is comparatively small. The authors therefore treat plastic deformation as the principal factor rather than a secondary contribution.

Their conclusions also connect the magnitude of color change with defect concentration. Crystals with more defects show larger changes during processing. Cracks make the response worse because they provide locations for deformation and dislocation accumulation.

Inclusions, impurities, and other structural defects can affect the original color of a diamond. The paper does not assign a separate processing-related rate to each of these causes. Its numerical attribution instead concentrates on plastic deformation.

The proposed mechanism is therefore specific. A pre-existing crack supplies a region where machining can cause plastic deformation. The resulting dislocation accumulation changes the optical response of the crystal.

Natural and synthetic diamonds respond differently

Section titled “Natural and synthetic diamonds respond differently”

The paper’s clearest internal comparison places natural diamonds against synthetic diamonds. Natural diamonds change color 3 to 5 times faster during processing. The authors attribute this difference to the higher nonuniformity of natural material.

That nonuniformity includes variations in defect distribution and structural state. As a result, a natural crystal can contain several local conditions capable of changing color. A synthetic crystal used as the comparison has a more uniform defect state under the reported conditions.

The comparison remains qualitative in one important respect. The paper does not identify the growth method or detailed processing history of the synthetic comparison material. It therefore supports a relative observation, not a universal model for all synthetic diamond.

Cutting conditions and luminescence response

Section titled “Cutting conditions and luminescence response”

The processing experiment shows why temperature cannot be separated from the initial crystal state. Cutting temperature, speed, depth, and abrasive tool quality all influence the conditions at which the crystal surface is deformed. The authors give particular attention to the temperature regime during cutting.

The luminescence measurements distinguish crystals with different responses. Samples in the first group retain stable color characteristics during cutting. Samples in the second and third groups show changes. The magnitude of the luminescence change correlates with the degree of crystal defectiveness.

This makes luminescence a process-sensitive indicator in the authors’ analysis. A crystal that appears stable before cutting can still show a spectral change when machining exposes or loads defect-rich regions. Cutting also produces measurable changes in the luminescence spectra of defect-bearing crystals.

The authors recommend considering both structure and process when evaluating or predicting color. Temperature control alone cannot address a pre-existing crack and its potential for localized plastic deformation. Process control alone also cannot remove the effect of crystal nonuniformity.

The headline percentage and the natural-to-synthetic comparison have no reported confidence intervals, error estimates, or detailed sample breakdown. The broad survey and detailed subset show the scale of the work, but they do not establish the precision of either result.

The process comparison in Table 3 is schematic. It identifies the relevant factors but does not provide a quantitative response surface or a numerical sensitivity for each factor. The paper also does not present a model that assigns a separate measured contribution to every defect type and process variable.

Luminescence and visual color observations provide the reported response measures. No single quantitative color-change metric is defined across the full dataset. The conclusions therefore support defect-based process control more directly than a universal color prediction equation.

No CVD-grown material appears in the reported comparison. The natural-to-synthetic ratio and the defect percentages should therefore remain within the scope of the studied natural and synthetic gem crystals.

For natural diamond that will be cut or polished, incoming color alone is an incomplete acceptance criterion. Crack morphology, defect distribution, and signs of plastic deformation should be recorded before machining.

A process qualification should compare absorption and luminescence before and after the intended cutting and polishing route. Natural and synthetic material should be qualified separately because the paper reports different color-change behavior.

This recommendation applies only to natural diamond within the reported scope. The paper provides no basis for predicting color stability in CVD-grown windows, electrodes, or other device-grade diamond materials.

View Original Abstract

Author: Nona D. Dronova Article type: Research-based scientific article derived from a 1991 Candidate of Sciences dissertation Fields: Mineralogy, Crystallography, Gemology, Diamond Processing Technology Abstract This article presents a systematic analysis of the mechanisms responsible for changes in the coloration of natural diamonds during their transformation into polished gemstones. The study examines the relationships between the initial optical properties of rough diamonds, crystal lattice defects, nitrogen-related color centers, plastic deformation, and the mechanical and thermal conditions of diamond processing. The research summarized here combines statistical investigations of diamond color before and after processing with optical spectroscopy, photoluminescence measurements, structural defect analysis, and experimental modeling of diamond-tool interactions. Particular attention is devoted to nitrogen-related N3 centers, dislocation structures, internal stresses, and localized plastic deformation as factors influencing the optical behavior of diamond crystals. The results indicate that diamond color may change during mechanical processing and that such changes are associated with the interaction of intrinsic crystal characteristics and processing-induced structural modifications. The study also examines changes in photoluminescence intensity, the development of brown coloration, and the role of contact temperatures and mechanical stresses in the modification of diamond defect structures. A systems-based framework is presented for understanding the relationship between processing parameters, structural transformations, and the final optical properties of polished diamonds. The findings provide a methodological basis for investigating color stability, improving the assessment of rough diamond characteristics, and analyzing technological factors affecting the production of polished diamonds. Keywords: natural diamonds; rough diamond; diamond coloration; color change; N3 centers; crystal lattice defects; plastic deformation; dislocations; photoluminescence; diamond cutting; diamond polishing; contact temperature; gemology. 1. Introduction Color is one of the principal quality characteristics of natural diamonds and an important determinant of the commercial value of polished gemstones. In addition to weight, clarity, and cutting quality, the color grade of a polished diamond significantly influences its market classification and economic value. The conventional assessment of rough diamonds relies on the examination of their original physical and optical characteristics. However, the color of a finished polished diamond does not always correspond exactly to the coloration observed in the original crystal. During cutting and polishing, diamond crystals are exposed to mechanical forces, localized contact stresses, frictional heating, and other technological influences. Under certain conditions, these factors may affect the structural and optical characteristics of diamond, including the behavior of optically active defects. The central scientific problem is therefore to determine how the original defect structure of natural diamonds interacts with mechanical and thermal processing conditions to influence the color of the resulting polished stones. This article presents the principal scientific findings of Nona D. Dronova’s 1991 dissertation, Changes in Diamond Color During Processing into Brilliant-Cut Diamonds: Systems Analysis and Experimental Investigations. Its purpose is to organize the original research results into an integrated scientific discussion of diamond color changes, crystal defects, plastic deformation, and processing-related physical mechanisms. 2. Research Materials and Methods The original investigation combined statistical analysis of diamond color characteristics with experimental studies of optical properties, crystal defects, and the physical processes associated with mechanical processing. 2.1. Statistical analysis The research examined the color characteristics of natural diamonds supplied for industrial processing and compared them with those of the polished diamonds produced from them. According to the dissertation abstract, the investigations included the study of more than 2,000 diamond crystals. The experimental program also involved 177 specially prepared plane-parallel diamond plates used for detailed observations. Additional production data were analyzed to establish relationships between initial diamond color, crystal size and weight, processing conditions, and the optical characteristics of finished polished stones. 2.2. Optical and spectroscopic investigations The analytical methods included optical and electronic spectroscopy, infrared absorption spectroscopy, photoluminescence investigations, microscopic examination, and polarization-optical techniques. Photoluminescence measurements were used to study the behavior of optically active centers and their response to mechanical processing. The combined analytical approach enabled the comparison of changes in optical properties with the presence of crystal defects and the technological history of the samples. 2.3. Experimental investigation of processing effects The research included experimental modeling of the mechanical interaction between diamond crystals and processing tools. Particular attention was devoted to local contact conditions, including mechanical stresses, frictional heating, and the development of plastic deformation. A method for estimating the temperature of diamond frictional contact surfaces was also developed and investigated. Systems analysis was used to examine the relationships among technological parameters, physical processes, structural defects, and observed changes in optical properties. 3. Statistical Evidence of Diamond Color Changes The statistical results demonstrated that the color characteristics of rough diamonds are not necessarily preserved throughout mechanical processing. Changes in coloration were observed in a portion of the investigated diamonds, with their occurrence depending on the initial crystal characteristics and processing conditions. In one of the production datasets described in the dissertation abstract, approximately 5% of the original diamond population exhibited changes associated with the appearance or intensification of brown coloration. The same investigation identified cases of improvement in observed color characteristics, accounting for approximately 2% of the population considered. These percentages represent the specific historical materials and technological conditions investigated and should not be generalized to contemporary diamond manufacturing without additional evidence. The results demonstrate that processing-related color changes are not necessarily unidirectional. Both unfavorable and favorable modifications of observed coloration may occur, depending on the original characteristics of the diamond and the conditions of mechanical treatment. This finding emphasizes the importance of assessing the structural and optical properties of rough diamonds before processing. 4. Nitrogen-Related Centers and Diamond Coloration An important component of the investigation concerned the relationship between nitrogen-related crystal defects and the optical properties of natural diamonds. Particular attention was given to N3 centers and their association with coloration and luminescence characteristics. The original study considered the presence of these centers as one of the factors relevant to understanding the behavior of diamond color during processing. The optical properties of natural diamonds, however, depend on the combined effects of multiple defect types, their concentrations, and their interactions with other structural features. Consequently, the presence of a particular nitrogen-related center should not be interpreted as a complete explanation of the coloration of an individual diamond. The research examined relationships among nitrogen-related centers, dislocations, internal stresses, absorption characteristics, and luminescence behavior. The findings support the importance of combining spectroscopic observations with structural analysis when investigating processing-induced color changes. 5. Changes in Photoluminescence During Diamond Processing The experimental investigations demonstrated that mechanical processing may alter the photoluminescence intensity of diamond crystals. The dissertation abstract describes observations of luminescence excited by ultraviolet radiation at a wavelength of 365 nm. Measurements were conducted at different stages of processing, allowing the observed optical changes to be compared with the technological treatment of the samples. In some investigated specimens, increased photoluminescence intensity was recorded following processing operations. The magnitude of the observed changes varied according to the initial characteristics of the crystals and the processing sequence. These results indicate that mechanical treatment may influence the state or optical response of luminescence-related defect centers. However, changes in photoluminescence intensity should not be treated as directly equivalent to changes in commercial diamond color grade. The two properties are related to optical behavior but require distinct measurements and interpretations. 6. Plastic Deformation and Dislocation Structures One of the central scientific contributions of the original research was the investigation of plastic deformation as a mechanism associated with changes in diamond optical properties. Mechanical processing produces localized contact stresses that may alter the defect structure of a diamond crystal under suitable conditions. The dissertation examined the movement and multiplication of dislocations, the development of dislocation accumulations, and the interaction be