Skip to content

Frequency-dependent dielectric behavior of aerosol jet-printed nanodiamond thin films

FieldValue
JournalApplied Surface Science
Published2026-10-28
AuthorsFlyn White, Attila Rektor, Tony Valayil Varghese, Karthik Chinnathambi, Josh E. Eixenberger
DOI10.1016/j.apsusc.2026.168786

Aerosol jet-printed nanodiamond films behaved as predominantly capacitive dielectrics over 10 kHz to 1 MHz. A 10 kHz Arrhenius fit for the 250-400 °C annealing interval gave an apparent activation energy of about 0.3 eV. The authors linked transport to thermally assisted hopping or interfacial charge movement, not intrinsic band conduction. A 2 µm film retained dominant sp3 diamond bonding after annealing to 500 °C.

The starting material was a commercial, water-based detonation nanodiamond suspension with an average particle size of about 5 nm and a concentration of 10 mg/ml. Its particles had a predominantly sp3 structure and oxygen-functionalized surfaces. The authors added ethanol and ethylene glycol as co-solvents. A water, ethanol, and ethylene glycol ratio of 4:1:1 produced modified ink at about 6.7 mg/ml.

The modified ink had a surface tension of about 42 mN m−1. Its viscosity remained near 2 cP from 0 to 360 s−1, and the shear stress response was linear. These results identified Newtonian behavior. Contact angles were about 12° on glass, 31° on Si/SiO2, and 43° on sapphire, showing different spreading on each surface.

Printing used an AJ-200 aerosol jet printer with an ultrasonic atomizer and about 2 mL of ink. The platen was held at 60-70 °C, the ink bath at 22 °C, and the stage speed was 1.5 mm/s. Sheath and atomizer flows were 25 and 20 sccm, while atomizer current ranged from 0.25 to 0.30 mA. The films covered Micrux Ti/Au interdigitated electrodes on glass. The electrodes had 50/150 nm Ti/Au thickness, 5 µm fingers, 5 µm gaps, and 180 electrode pairs.

Profilometry gave average thicknesses of 1.0 µm, 1.8 µm, and 2 µm after 5, 10, and 15 passes. The 2 µm film was used for Raman analysis and every electrical measurement. Optical images showed continuous coverage and no visible delamination or gaps after thermal treatment.

TEM showed dense, quasi-spherical particles about 5-10 nm across. High-resolution images measured a 0.214 nm lattice spacing assigned to diamond (111) planes. Selected-area diffraction produced concentric rings, confirming a polycrystalline structure. Raman spectra retained a diamond peak near 1322 cm−1 from 23 °C through 500 °C. Bulk diamond is typically near 1332 cm−1. A broad band near 1600 cm−1 indicated disordered or graphitic carbon. Its gradual change with annealing showed that the surface carbon structure evolved, although no dominant graphitic response appeared.

Electrical measurements used one film annealed sequentially in air at 100, 150, 200, 250, 300, 350, and 400 °C. Each dwell lasted 60 min. The sample returned to room temperature before each impedance and capacitance measurement. Annealing stopped at 400 °C because the electrode assembly degraded at higher temperatures. The exposed Ti/Su8 adhesion layer was not conductive enough for impedance measurements. This limit belongs to the test structure, not the nanodiamond film.

TGA/DSC examined the modified powder from 25 to 1000 °C at 10 K min−1 under argon and air. Argon produced a small mass loss near 96 °C, consistent with moisture and weakly bound surface species. A gradual mass decrease appeared at about 500-600 °C. In oxygen, sharp mass loss began near 480 °C and indicated oxidative carbon degradation. FTIR identified O-H, C-H, C=O, and C-O or C-O-C surface bands. Their intensity decreased after argon annealing, supporting removal or modification of oxygen-containing groups.

Raman measurements on the printed film stopped at 500 °C because the film delaminated from the electrode at higher temperatures. The persistent diamond peak showed that the dominant bonding survived the accessible thermal range.

A Keithley 4200ASCS parametric analyzer with a CVIV module measured impedance magnitude and capacitance at room temperature from 10 kHz to 1 MHz. The probes contacted the coated interdigitated electrodes directly. Impedance was relatively high at low frequency, decreased gradually as frequency rose, and approached a lower resistance limit at high frequency. The authors associated this response with dielectric polarization and restricted low-frequency charge transport.

Annealing changed the response. Impedance was high after 100-200 °C treatment and peaked at 200-250 °C. It fell substantially above 250 °C. Higher annealing temperatures also produced higher capacitance across most of the measured range. The authors suggest that oxygen-group removal, fewer interfacial traps, improved particle contacts, and surface-carbon restructuring altered conduction and polarization.

Capacitance was highest at lower frequencies, then declined into a more stable mid-frequency and high-frequency regime. Slow dipolar and interfacial polarization could not follow the faster field at higher frequencies. The paper does not report an absolute dielectric constant. Fringe fields, electrode geometry, and incomplete field filling between fingers prevent reliable permittivity extraction from these measurements.

Because the same film received each annealing step, every electrical point included the sample’s cumulative thermal history. The reported trends therefore describe a treatment sequence, not independent samples at each temperature.

Dissipation factor and transport mechanism

Section titled “Dissipation factor and transport mechanism”

The authors estimated the printed layer’s resistance and capacitance by subtracting the bare electrode response. They used a parallel equivalent circuit, with one response for the coated device and one for the bare device. The dissipation factor was calculated from frequency, resistance, and capacitance. It was highest at 10 kHz and lower at higher frequencies, consistent with interfacial polarization as the main loss mechanism.

The dissipation factor reached a minimum near 200-250 °C at all three reported frequencies. It then rose sharply above 250 °C, most strongly at 10 kHz. The authors list thermally assisted transport through surface sp2-carbon phases as a possible contributor to this rise. Changes in surface groups and interparticle interfaces may also affect the loss.

The Arrhenius fit used only the 250-400 °C interval. The 100-200 °C data did not follow the same linear relationship and were dominated by interfacial polarization and limited particle contact. The fit of ln(1/Z) against 1000/T gave an apparent activation energy of about 0.3 eV. The authors interpret the small value as evidence for hopping or interfacial transport through localized states, grain boundaries, and surface traps.

The activation energy is close to values cited for other diamond films. The paper reports 0.25 eV for CVD diamond films over a similar temperature range. It also cites 0.38 eV for microwave plasma CVD films above 100 °C. The printed nanodiamond result sits between those reference values. The paper presents these measurements as reference points from films produced by other deposition methods.

Several limits affect device qualification. The interdigitated geometry supports qualitative trends but not a reliable dielectric constant. The authors propose a parallel-plate capacitor for quantitative permittivity measurements. Humidity was neither controlled nor logged during electrical testing. The authors found no specific evidence of humidity variation, but could not exclude ambient water adsorption as a contributor to conductivity because the nanodiamond surfaces carried polar, oxygen-containing groups.

The ex-situ Raman, FTIR, and TGA results also cannot separate three concurrent effects: oxygen-group desorption, improved particle-to-particle contacts, and changes in the sp2-carbon fraction. The authors call for complementary in-situ or spatially resolved methods to distinguish them. The 0.3 eV value is history-dependent rather than an intrinsic in-situ activation energy. Higher temperatures also produce oxidative degradation in oxygen, while the electrical anneal was capped by the electrode at 400 °C.

For a printed dielectric, the data identify a processing tradeoff. Sequential air annealing near 200-250 °C produced the lowest dissipation factor and the highest impedance in this specimen. Annealing above 250 °C lowered impedance and raised capacitance, but also increased loss. A low-loss insulator would favor the 200-250 °C state. A device that depends on charge transport could use a higher-temperature state, with greater dielectric loss. Both choices require humidity control and calibration for the actual electrode geometry.

The demonstrated films retained dominant sp3 diamond bonding through 500 °C while their impedance, capacitance, and loss changed with frequency and cumulative annealing history.

View Original Abstract

Direct write printing has been evolving rapidly as a viable technique to produce functional semiconducting, metallic and dielectric thin films on rigid and flexible substrates. Diamond thin films produced by conventional epitaxial techniques have found a wide range of applications, and printing has the potential to provide functional diamond thin films inexpensively and over large areas. Here, the frequency-dependent electrical behavior of printed nanodiamond thin films is investigated to clarify their charge-transport and dielectric characteristics. Detonation nanodiamond inks were printed into continuous films by aerosol jet printing. The structural and chemical properties were evaluated through transmission electron microscopy, Raman spectroscopy, and additional thermal and surface analysis. Electrical characterization over a broad frequency range revealed predominantly capacitive behavior with impedance decreasing as annealing temperature increased. Capacitance-frequency measurements showed a stable mid-frequency dielectric response, while thermal activation analysis indicated that the transport is dominated by trap-assisted or interfacial conduction mechanisms. These findings establish aerosol-jet printed nanodiamond films as high-resistivity dielectric layers whose electrical properties evolve predictably with annealing temperature and frequency, supporting their potential use in flexible electronics, insulating layers, and high temperature sensing platforms.