Skip to content

The Effect of De-Cobalt Pretreatment of PDC on the Deposition of Diamond Coatings

FieldValue
JournalCoatings
Published2026-10-06
AuthorsCen Hao, Xiang Bo, Zhenhai Guo, Guoliang Liu, Fuming Deng
DOI10.3390/coatings16101186

Five hours of acid pretreatment gave the best balance for diamond coating by hot filament chemical vapor deposition on polycrystalline diamond compact. The authors selected this condition using coating morphology, composition, and cobalt content. Surface cobalt measured 0.65% by EDS after this treatment, and the coating showed no spallation during indentation. A 7 h treatment lowered surface cobalt further but increased the hole area fraction to 12.6%.

Polycrystalline diamond compact, or PDC, combines polycrystalline diamond with cemented carbide, while cobalt binds the diamond particles during sintering. Above 700 °C, cobalt promotes the transformation of diamond to graphite, which the authors associate with lower tool performance.

The untreated sample contained 10.16% surface cobalt by EDS. XRD identified diamond, CoCx, and WC. Cross sections showed cobalt distributed through the polycrystalline diamond layer in connected and isolated vein-like paths.

After 4 h of deposition, the untreated sample carried a 5 to 6 μm coating with an obvious gap at the interface. AFM measured a maximum original surface hole depth of about 1.2 μm.

Each group used PDC samples from the same batch, sized Φ14 mm × 4 mm. The pretreatment sequence was:

StepReported condition
Initial cleaningUltrasonic cleaning in acetone for 15 min
EtchantH2SO4 and H2O2 mixed at a 1:10 volume ratio
Etching60 °C for 3 h, 5 h, or 7 h
Final cleaning10 min in acetone, then 10 min in ethanol, both ultrasonic

The etchant contacted only the substrate surface in a beaker designed by the research group.

Growth used hot filament chemical vapor deposition, or HFCVD, with four filaments. The worktable was withdrawn during filament carburization. The deposition parameters were:

ParameterFilament carbonizationDeposition
Gas flow1000 mL/min1000 mL/min
Carbon concentration2%2%
Filament temperature2100 ± 100 °C2300 ± 100 °C
Filament power3 kW4 kW
Reactive pressure6 kPa3 kPa
Time90 min240 min

The prose gives a filament to substrate distance of 12 mm during deposition. Table 1 instead lists 9 mm, so the reported geometry requires clarification before reproduction.

After deposition, each specimen received 15 min of ultrasonic acetone cleaning. XRD tracked phases, SEM examined surfaces and sections, EDS measured Co and WC, and AFM measured topography. ImageJ 1.54t converted SEM images into hole maps. Coating adhesion was assessed by indentation.

Surface cobalt fell from 10.16% in untreated sample 1# to 0.87% after 3 h, 0.65% after 5 h, and 0.49% after 7 h. XRD placed surface cobalt close to zero after 5 h, although CoCx and WC peaks rose slightly at 7 h.

The authors attribute the renewed peaks to PCD loss during longer etching, which exposed deeper phases containing cobalt and WC. Cross-sectional EDS found most measured cobalt below 2% after all three treatments. They treat values below 2% as basic cobalt removal.

ImageJ measured hole area fractions of 7.4%, 10.5%, and 12.6% after 3 h, 5 h, and 7 h. Hole diameters spanned 0.1 μm to 10 μm.

At 3 h, the main diameter bands were 0.1 to 0.2 μm and 1 to 2 μm. At 5 h, they were 0.3 to 0.5 μm and 1 to 2 μm. The 7 h sample had more small and large holes.

The authors linked longer etching to more connected holes and a deeper cobalt depletion layer. They proposed that attached diamond particles at 3 h would compete with diamond growth inside holes.

The 5 h condition therefore combined near-complete surface cobalt removal with a 10.5% hole area fraction, below the 12.6% measured at 7 h. At 7 h, the authors proposed that reaction gas would nucleate at high-energy sites before reaching deep hole bottoms. That would leave closed internal holes and reduce PDC strength.

XRD after deposition showed no obvious graphite peaks, so the authors regarded graphite as negligible. Pretreatment duration had little effect on the main coating diffraction pattern. Co and WC surface peaks were also nearly absent after deposition.

Longer pretreatment strengthened the diamond (111) reflection. The authors offered two possible causes: a stronger original substrate reflection and a more exposed (111) surface after etching.

SEM showed micro-nanometer diamond grains on all coatings. Coated surfaces from 3 h and 5 h had fewer holes than the 7 h coating.

Cross-sectional SEM showed that deposition filled many large holes while leaving smaller holes. The authors interpreted the filled channels as evidence that reactive gases entered through connected cobalt removal paths. They also stated that the filling process remained poorly controlled.

EDS found cobalt below 2% within the measured region after deposition. Longer pretreatment produced the lowest measured cobalt concentration.

The authors proposed that the temperature gradient from hot filaments to the water-cooled stage may move cobalt downward from the surface. They said this could explain both lower surface cobalt and suppressed cobalt migration toward the PDC surface.

Five-hour pretreatment produced sample 6# with the shallowest and most regular indentation. Its indentation had sharp edges and no coating spallation, indicating the best interface among the tested groups.

Partial delamination and clear spalling appeared around the indentation edges for the 3 h and 7 h groups. These were qualitative observations because the paper reports no numerical bond strength or indentation load.

The authors concluded that pretreatment reduced compressive stress in the polycrystalline diamond layer. They stated that the 5 h coating had residual stress close to the PDC before deposition, but supplied no numerical stress values.

Engineering implications and evidence limits

Section titled “Engineering implications and evidence limits”

Under the reported 60 °C H2SO4 and H2O2 process, 5 h is the authors’ preferred condition for coating this PDC geometry. A shorter treatment leaves residual cobalt and attached grains that can divert nucleation. A longer treatment deepens connected pores and makes complete filling harder.

Process control should track both cobalt content and pore area because the lowest cobalt value did not produce the best coating. The 7 h treatment reached 0.49% surface cobalt. It also produced more coating holes and edge spalling than the 5 h treatment.

The study used one PDC type from one batch and did not replicate the 3 h, 5 h, and 7 h groups independently. The authors state that repeated experiments are required before treating the 5 h result as reproducible.

The paper reports no cutting test, wear test, or service-life measurement. Improved wear resistance remains a proposed benefit, not a measured result.

The selected 5 h condition applies to the tested 60 °C, 1:10 etchant, Φ14 mm × 4 mm PDC, and stated HFCVD schedule.

Polycrystalline diamond compact is the relevant material family for cutting-tool coating, and the paper needs a Φ14 mm × 4 mm substrate for HFCVD growth. The diamond materials catalog from 6CCVD includes MPCVD-grown polycrystalline diamond plates and wafers up to 125 mm, although the paper used a sintered PDC composite. The linked engineering support can assess custom fabrication requirements, but any substitution of a free-standing plate requires validation against the paper’s PDC structure.

View Original Abstract

During the preparation of polycrystalline diamond compact (PDC), Co is often added as a binder, which reduces the material’s heat resistance and catalyzes the transformation of diamond to graphite at high temperatures, thereby reducing the material’s mechanical properties. After the removal of Co, the exposure of holes beside the diamond grains could also affect the wear resistance of PDC. This article provides a new approach for the surface enhancement of PDC, which involves depositing a layer of diamond coating using the hot filament chemical vapor deposition (HFCVD) method after the removal of Co and investigating the effect of the pretreatment time of PDC on the deposition of diamond. The optimal pretreatment was obtained using the surface morphology, composition, and content of Co for a cross-section of the diamond coatings. A H2SO4-H2O2 solution was mixed in a ratio of 1:10 as the acid corrosion reagent, and the best etching time was 5 h. When the time was short, the residual amount of Co was high, which affected the quality of the diamond coatings. When the time was long, the area fraction of the substrate was high, and the deposited diamond was not able to easily fill the holes caused by corrosion.