Approach for Polishing Diamond Coated Complicated Cutting Tool - Abrasive Flow Machining (AFM)
At a Glance
Section titled “At a Glance”| Metadata | Details |
|---|---|
| Publication Date | 2018-11-21 |
| Journal | Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering |
| Authors | Xinchang Wang, Chengchuan Wang, Changying Wang, Changying Wang, Changying Wang |
| Institutions | Shanghai Jiao Tong University |
| Citations | 13 |
| Analysis | Full AI Review Included |
Post-Processing Diamond Coated Cutting Tools via Abrasive Flow Machining: A Technical Analysis
Section titled “Post-Processing Diamond Coated Cutting Tools via Abrasive Flow Machining: A Technical Analysis”Executive Summary
Section titled “Executive Summary”- Method Innovation: First-ever application of Abrasive Flow Machining (AFM) for post-processing diamond-coated complicated cutting tools to simultaneously reduce surface roughness and resharpen cutting edges.
- Optimal Architecture Identified: Boron-doped microcrystalline / undoped fine-grained composite diamond (BDM-UFGCD) coating post-AFM delivers the best balance of surface finish (Rz = 1.18 µm) and tool longevity.
- Adhesion Enhancement: Boron doping combined with micro-sized underlying grains creates mechanical interlocks that prevent rapid film removal—the primary failure mode in nano-grained CVD diamond tools.
- Tool Life Multiplier: AFM-BDM-UFGCD coated cutters achieved 1040 m milling length, ~4.7× longer than uncoated WC-Co reference (R-WC at 220 m) and ~7.4× longer than fine-grain WC-Co (F-WC at 140 m).
- Workpiece Compatibility: Validated for peripheral finish-milling of 6063 Al-Mg alloy—anodized aluminum widely used in consumer electronics (e.g., smartphone housings).
- Surface Roughness Reduction: AFM reduced rake-face Ra from ~242 nm to under 50 nm for nano-grained coatings; cutting edge radius reduced from 36.7 µm to 28.8 µm.
- Failure Mode Insight: Pure nano-grained films (UFGD/BDFGD) suffer premature film delamination; pure micro-grained films (UMCD/BDMCD) cannot achieve surface finish requirements—composite architecture is essential.
Technical Specifications
Section titled “Technical Specifications”| Parameter | Value | Unit | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Workpiece Material | 6063 Al-Mg Alloy | — | Anodized aluminum for phone shells/consumer electronics |
| Workpiece Dimensions | 300 × 200 × 6 | mm | Plate format for milling tests |
| Workpiece Composition (Al) | 99.24 | wt% | EDS-measured |
| Workpiece Composition (Mg) | 0.49 | wt% | EDS-measured |
| Workpiece Composition (Si) | 0.21 | wt% | EDS-measured |
| Substrate | WC-6 wt% Co (regular grain 0.5-1.5 µm) | — | R-WC reference |
| Cutter Diameter (D) | 10 | mm | Hilt diameter |
| Cutter Length (L) | 75 | mm | Total length |
| Edge Length (l) | 30 | mm | Peripheral edge |
| Helix Angle (β) | 45 | ° | — |
| Rake Angle (γo) | 30 | ° | Peripheral cutting edge |
| Relief Angle (αo) | 15 | ° | Peripheral cutting edge |
| Edge Radius (r) | 0.01-0.02 | mm | As-designed |
| Film Thickness | 9-11 | µm | All five film types |
| UMCD Grain Size | 2-4 | µm | Microcrystalline |
| BDMCD Grain Size | 1-3 | µm | Microcrystalline with boron |
| UFGD/BDFGD Grain Size | 20-500 | nm | Nanocrystalline cauliflower morphology |
| Rake Ra (UMCD, as-deposited) | 242.54 | nm | High roughness |
| Flank Ra (UMCD, as-deposited) | 267.91 | nm | High roughness |
| Rake Ra (BDMCD, as-deposited) | 237.15 | nm | — |
| Flank Ra (BDMCD, as-deposited) | 252.4 | nm | — |
| Edge Radius Before AFM | 36.7 | µm | P-R-WC after pretreatment |
| Edge Radius After AFM | 28.8 | µm | AFM-BDM-UFGCD |
| Rotational Speed (n) | 10000 | r/min | Cutting parameter |
| Milling Speed (v) | 314 | m/min | Cutting parameter |
| Milling Width (ae) | 0.08 | mm | Peripheral finish-milling |
| Milling Depth (ap) | 7.5 | mm | — |
| Feed Rate (f) | 1200 | mm/min | — |
| Lubrication | Oil-base suspension | — | — |
| Tool Life Threshold (Rz) | 1.6 | µm | Failure criterion |
| Avg Tool Life (AFM-BDM-UFGCD) | 1040 | m | Best performer |
| Avg Tool Life (R-WC) | 220 | m | Uncoated reference |
| Avg Tool Life (F-WC) | 140 | m | Fine-grain WC-Co reference |
| Avg Tool Life (AFM-BDFGD) | 400 | m | Second-best diamond |
| Avg Tool Life (AFM-UFGD) | 320 | m | — |
| Workpiece Rz (AFM-BDM-UFGCD) | 1.18 | µm | Approaching uncoated quality |
| Workpiece Rz (F-WC) | 0.85 | µm | Best uncoated finish |
| Workpiece Rz (R-WC) | 0.96 | µm | — |
Key Methodologies
Section titled “Key Methodologies”- Substrate Pretreatment (Alkali-Acid Two-Step)
- Murakami alkali solution etching to roughen deposited surfaces
- Acid solution etching to remove surface Co (graphitization inhibitor)
- Diamond grit (0.5-1 µm) grinding to remove loose etched layers and boost nucleation density
- Film Deposition (HFCVD)
- Reactor: Home-made Hot Filament CVD vacuum reactor
- Carbon source: Acetone + hydrogen mixture
- Boron source: Trimethyl borate [(CH3O)3B] pre-mingled with acetone for BDD variants
- Nucleation stage: 30 min initial heteroepitaxy step
- Five film architectures: UMCD, BDMCD, UFGD, BDFGD, BDM-UFGCD composite
- Composite Film Architecture (BDM-UFGCD)
- Underlying layer: Boron-doped microcrystalline diamond (enhanced adhesion via mechanical interlocks)
- Surface layer: Undoped fine-grained diamond (low surface roughness for polishing)
- Abrasive Flow Machining (AFM) Post-Processing
- Abrasive paste with diamond particles
- Targets both rake and flank faces + peripheral cutting edges
- Single control variable: diamond particle size in paste
- Most effective on nano-grained surface layers
- Characterization Techniques
- Surface roughness: Confocal microscopy (Zeiss Axio CSM700), 50 µm scan length
- Edge radius: FESEM cross-sectional analysis (Zeiss ULTRA55)
- Workpiece roughness: Portable roughometer (MITUTOYO SJ-210)
- Raman spectroscopy: 800-1900 cm-1 range for film quality verification
- Cutting force: Kistler-9272 dynamometer (real-time)
- Cutting Test Protocol
- Machine: Hurco VMX42 machining center
- Mode: Peripheral finish-milling (limited by AFM/jig reach)
- Failure criterion: Rz > 1.6 µm on as-machined workpiece
- Sample size: 5 specimens per variant for lifetime statistics
6CCVD Solutions & Capabilities
Section titled “6CCVD Solutions & Capabilities”-
Applicable Materials
- To replicate the high-adhesion BDM-UFGCD architecture, Heavy Boron-Doped PCD wafers or boron-doped microcrystalline films are required for the underlying adhesion layer. 6CCVD produces tunable boron-doped diamond via MPCVD with precise control over grain morphology (micro vs. nano) and dopant concentration.
- For the low-roughness finishing layer, Optical Grade Nanocrystalline PCD or fine-grained PCD with sub-500 nm grain size provides the cauliflower morphology ideal for post-AFM polishing.
- For monolithic alternatives without composite complexity, 6CCVD’s Single Crystal Diamond (SCD) delivers superior machining performance for ultra-precision Al alloy finishing—though at higher cost and geometric constraints.
- Custom Dimensions: PCD plates/wafers up to 125 mm enable coating of large or uniquely shaped tool substrates, while SCD and PCD thicknesses from 0.1 µm to 500 µm support both thin-film and thick-film composite architectures.
-
Customization Potential
- The paper’s WC-Co milling cutters (10 mm hilt, 75 mm length, three-edge geometry) benefit from diamond films engineered to specific thicknesses (9-11 µm). 6CCVD’s MPCVD reactors support precise thickness control within this range.
- For tooling requiring brazed or soldered diamond films, 6CCVD provides in-house metalization (Ti, Cr, Au, Pt, Pd, W, Cu)—critical for film-substrate adhesion optimization on WC-Co substrates where Co migration remains a challenge.
- Laser cutting services are available for shaping SCD/PCD cutting edges to complex geometries (ball end mills, drills, form tools) referenced as future work in the paper.
-
Engineering Support
- 6CCVD’s in-house PhD engineering team specializes in material selection for demanding tribological applications—precisely the adhesion-versus-roughness tradeoff explored in this study. For Al-alloy finish-milling projects requiring extended tool life, our team can recommend optimal boron concentration, grain architecture, and film thickness based on specific cutting parameters and workpiece alloys.
- We can also advise on polishing pathways: while AFM was effective for nano-grained films in this study, 6CCVD’s Ra < 1 nm SCD polishing and Ra < 5 nm inch-size PCD polishing capabilities offer alternative finishing routes for high-precision cutting edges.
-
Call to Action
- For custom specifications or material consultation, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.
View Original Abstract
Lower surface roughness and sharper cutting edge are beneficial for improving the machining quality of the cutting tool, while coatings often deteriorate them. Focusing on the diamond coated WC-Co milling cutter, the abrasive flow machining (AFM) is selected for reducing the surface roughness and sharpening the cutting edge. Comparative cutting tests are conducted on different types of coated cutters before and after AFM, as well as uncoated WC-Co one, demonstrating that the boron-doped microcrystalline and undoped fine-grained composite diamond coated cutter after the AFM (AFM-BDM-UFGCD) is a good choice for the finish milling of the 6063 Al alloy in the present case, because it shows favorable machining quality close to the uncoated one, but much prolonged tool lifetime. Besides, compared with the micro-sized diamond films, it is much more convenient and efficient to finish the BDM-UFGCD coated cutter covered by nano-sized diamond grains, and resharpen its cutting edge by the AFM, owing to the lower initial surface roughness and hardness. Moreover, the boron incorporation and micro-sized grains in the underlying layer can enhance the film-substrate adhesion, avoid the rapid film removal in the machining process, and thus maximize the tool life (1040 m, four times more than the uncoated one). In general, the AFM is firstly proposed and discussed for post-processing the diamond coated complicated cutting tools, which is proved to be feasible for improving the cutting performance