Theoretical evaluation of electronic density-of-states and transport effects on field emission from n-type ultrananocrystalline diamond films
At a Glance
Section titled “At a Glance”| Metadata | Details |
|---|---|
| Publication Date | 2019-05-28 |
| Journal | Journal of Applied Physics |
| Authors | Oksana Chubenko, Stanislav S. Baturin, Sergey V. Baryshev |
| Institutions | Michigan State University, George Washington University |
| Citations | 16 |
| Analysis | Full AI Review Included |
Executive Summary
Section titled “Executive Summary”- Core Value Proposition: Comprehensive theoretical framework adapting the Stratton-Baskin-Lvov-Fursey formalism to explain current-density saturation in nitrogen-incorporated ultrananocrystalline diamond ((N)UNCD) field emitters, resolving a long-standing deviation from Fowler-Nordheim (FN) behavior at high applied fields.
- Material System: n-type, highly conductive, two-phase (N)UNCD composed of sp3 diamond grains embedded in sp2-rich graphitic grain boundaries; electron transport dominated by delocalized π-π∗ bands.
- Three Critical Mechanisms Investigated: Partial penetration of the electric field into the material (space-charge layer), field-dependent carrier mobility (optical phonon scattering), and density-of-states (DoS) structure (position/shape of π-π∗ bands).
- Key Finding: Current-density saturation plateau arises from limited electron supply within the impurity π-π∗ bands combined with decreasing electron mobility at high fields — not Child-Langmuir space-charge screening as previously speculated.
- Quantitative Result: Theoretical saturation plateau (~104-106 A/cm2) matches experimental uncertainty window when field-dependent mobility is incorporated; plateau varies by ~2 orders of magnitude depending on localization length Lloc (5-60 Å).
- Critical Parameter — Pseudo Band Gap Eππ∗: The narrowest parameter controlling saturation; reducing Eππ∗ from 3.8 eV to 1.8 eV increases saturation plateau ~100×.
- Application: Validates (N)UNCD as a planar large-area cold cathode for electron sources operable at low fields (few V/µm) in moderate vacuum.
Technical Specifications
Section titled “Technical Specifications”| Parameter | Value | Unit | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fundamental band gap EΣΣ∗ | 5.45 | eV | Energy separation between extended states in (N)UNCD |
| Pseudo band gap Eππ∗ | 2.1 | eV | (N)UNCD-specific π-π∗ band separation |
| Variance of π bands w | 0.53 | eV | Width of Gaussian π-π∗ density-of-states peaks |
| Energy at which σ merges with Σ, Em | 6.5 | eV | Band-tail transition energy |
| Band-tail slope energy E0 | 0.68 | eV | Exponential σ-band decay into gap |
| Pre-integration factor B1 | 2.5 × 105 | cm-1 | π-π∗ optical transition coefficient |
| Pre-integration factor B2 | 1.5 × 105 | cm-1 eV-1/2 | π-σ∗ optical transition coefficient |
| Low-field electron mobility µ0 | 1.5 | cm2/V·s | (N)UNCD bulk mobility |
| Critical field for mobility roll-off F0 | ≥104 | V/cm | Threshold for deviation from Ohm’s law |
| Localization length Lloc | 10-40 | Å | Delocalization range of interband-gap states (best-fit range) |
| Dielectric constant κ | 4.5 | — | Average value for polycrystalline carbon materials |
| Work function φ | 3.6 | eV | (N)UNCD work function |
| Optical constant K | ~3.44 × 10-37 | eV2·cm5 | Joint density-of-states prefactor |
| A1 (Stratton constant, 300 K) | 1.08 × 107 | A/cm2 | Pre-factor in Stratton emission equation |
| B1 (Stratton constant, 300 K) | 6.83 × 107 | V·eV-3/2·cm-1 | Field-barrier scaling constant |
| C1 (Stratton constant, 300 K) | 1.02 × 108 | eV-1/2·cm-1 | Barrier image-rounded constant |
| Field enhancement factor β | 440-1850 | — | Range derived from localization length; experimental ≈ 1000 |
| Bulk carrier concentration n(yb) | 1017-1018 | cm-3 | Depends on Lloc |
| Surface carrier concentration n(0) | 1020-1021 | cm-3 | At accumulation layer maximum |
| Saturation current density (field-dep. mobility) | 104-106 | A/cm2 | Match to experiment with µ = µ(F) |
| Saturation current density (field-indep. mobility) | 105-108 | A/cm2 | Theoretical upper bound with µ = µ0 |
| Experimental applied field range | 0-6.8 | V/µm | Tested up to 6.8 V/µm |
| Cathode-anode gap | 106 | µm | Parallel-plate test configuration |
| Maximum measured current | ~100 | µA | At E ≈ 6.8 V/µm |
| Cathode diameter | 4.4 | mm | Stainless steel substrate |
| Mean electron emission angle α | ~0.9 | ° | To surface normal |
| Average grain size | 4-16 | nm | Varies with nitrogen content (0%-20%) |
| Grain-boundary width | 0.5-2.2 | nm | Increases with nitrogen |
| Critical Child-Langmuir current | ~107 | A/cm2 | Excluded as primary saturation cause |
Key Methodologies
Section titled “Key Methodologies”- Theoretical Framework Adaptation: Extended Stratton’s semiconductor field-emission formalism to incorporate a complex density-of-states structure comprising π, π∗, σ, σ∗, Σ, and Σ∗ bands instead of conventional parabolic conduction/valence bands.
- Self-Consistent Solution: Coupled Poisson’s equation (bulk charge distribution, band bending, and field-dependent mobility) with Stratton’s surface emission equations via numerical graphical intersection to obtain j vs. Fs characteristics.
- Density-of-States Modeling: Approximated π and π∗ bands as Gaussian functions centered at Eπ and Eπ∗ with variance w2; Σ and σ band tails represented by square-root and exponential functions, respectively.
- Field-Dependent Mobility Implementation: Applied the empirical Caughey-Thomas expression µ = µ0 / [1 + (F/F0)γ] with γ = 2 for electrons; used F0 ≥ 104 V/cm as the acoustic-to-optical phonon scattering transition.
- Sample Preparation (Experimental Reference): (N)UNCD film grown via CVD on Ni/Mo-buffered 4.4 mm diameter stainless steel stub; film characterized in parallel-plate diode configuration against a YAG:Ce/Mo cathodoluminescent anode screen.
- Emission-Area Quantification: Image-processing algorithm applied to FE patterns on YAG screen to extract SYAG(E) and the number of local maxima NLM as functions of applied field; correction factors applied for electron trajectory divergence (β), grain-boundary surface fraction (~0.174), and sp2 fraction (~0.52).
- Parameter Sweep Analysis: Systematically varied Eππ∗ (1.8-4.0 eV), w (0.48-0.71 eV), B1 (6.1 × 103-2.5 × 105 cm-1), κ (3-10), and Lloc (5-60 Å) to identify dominant physical drivers of FN deviation and saturation.
6CCVD Solutions & Capabilities
Section titled “6CCVD Solutions & Capabilities”Applicable Materials
Section titled “Applicable Materials”Replicating or extending the (N)UNCD field-emission research described here requires a polycrystalline diamond film with carefully controlled sp2/3 phase composition and electronic-grade surface quality. The most appropriate 6CCVD offerings are:
| 6CCVD Material | Relevance to This Work |
|---|---|
| Polycrystalline Diamond (PCD) — Nano-grain Grade | Closest analog to UNCD microstructure; suitable baseline for studying grain-boundary conduction and π-π∗ band transport. |
| Boron-Doped Polycrystalline Diamond (BDD) | Provides an n-type comparator reference (or can be tuned); 6CCVD’s heavy-to-light boron doping range enables controlled carrier concentration studies analogous to the DoS variations explored here. |
| Optical-Grade Single-Crystal Diamond (SCD) | Useful as a control (zero sp2 grain-boundary contribution) to isolate the role of grain-boundary networks in field emission. Polished to Ra < 1 nm. |
| Custom (N)UNCD or nitrogen-varied PCD Films | 6CCVD can tailor nitrogen incorporation during MPCVD growth to engineer the pseudo band gap Eππ∗ and carrier concentration — the two parameters identified as the dominant levers for saturation plateau tuning. |
Customization Potential
Section titled “Customization Potential”- Doping Engineering: The paper identifies Eππ∗, w, and B1 as the three DoS parameters that control the saturation plateau. 6CCVD’s in-house MPCVD reactors support precise control of nitrogen and boron incorporation levels, enabling researchers to probe the same parameter space the authors identify as critical.
- Thickness Control: Films can be supplied from 0.1 µm to 500 µm (PCD) — the paper’s theoretical model assumes semi-infinite thickness, but finite-thickness experimental samples (e.g., thin-film cathodes) require precise thickness specification to avoid substrate artifacts.
- Wafer Dimensions: Plates/wafers up to 125 mm diameter are available, accommodating the 4.4 mm cathode geometry used here as well as scaled-up large-area emitter arrays.
- Metalization for Diode Assembly: The experimental setup used a Ni/Mo buffer layer on stainless steel. 6CCVD’s internal metalization capability covers Ti, W, Pt, Au, Pd, and Cu — enabling direct deposition of buffer layers (Ti/W for adhesion) and contact electrodes (Au/Pt for low-resistance contacts) without requiring external vendors.
- Laser Cutting & Dicing: Custom cathode geometries (mm- to wafer-scale) can be laser-cut to specified dimensions with edge quality suitable for high-vacuum FE experiments.
- Polishing for Surface Studies: Ra < 5 nm polishing on inch-size PCD ensures a well-defined vacuum interface for reproducible field-emission measurements and Fowler-Nordheim analysis.
Engineering Support
Section titled “Engineering Support”- 6CCVD’s in-house PhD engineering team can assist with material selection for planar cold-cathode electron source projects, including guidance on the trade-off between grain size (4-16 nm in this work), grain-boundary width (0.5-2.2 nm), nitrogen content, and the resulting π-π∗ band structure.
- For projects targeting specific saturation current-density plateaus (e.g., 104-106 A/cm2 regime identified in this paper), our engineers can recommend doping and microstructure parameters based on the Stratton-Baskin-Lvov-Fursey-type analysis demonstrated here.
- Custom consultation available for designing parallel-plate diode test configurations, including anode material selection, cathode-anode gap engineering, and UHV-compatible metallization stacks.
- Materials can be supplied with or without conductive buffer layers (Ni/Mo/Ti/W) depending on your substrate integration requirements.
Call to Action
Section titled “Call to Action”For custom specifications or material consultation on planar diamond field emitters, custom nitrogen-incorporated UNCD films, or metallized cathode assemblies, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.
View Original Abstract
In the nitrogen-incorporated ultrananocrystalline diamond [(N)UNCD] films, representing an n-type highly conductive two-phase material comprised of sp3 diamond grains and sp2-rich graphitic grain boundaries, current is carried by a high concentration of mobile electrons within large-volume grain-boundary networks. Fabricated in a simple thin-film planar form, (N)UNCD was found to be an efficient field emitter capable of emitting a significant amount of charge starting at the applied electric field as low as a few volts per micrometer, which makes it a promising material for designing electron sources. Despite semimetallic conduction, field emission (FE) characteristics of this material demonstrate a strong deviation from the Fowler-Nordheim law in a high-current-density regime when (N)UNCD field emitters switch from a diodelike to a resistorlike behavior. Such a phenomenon resembles the current-density saturation effect in conventional semiconductors. In the present paper, we adapt the formalism developed for conventional semiconductors to study current-density saturation in (N)UNCD field emitters. We provide a comprehensive theoretical investigation of (i) partial penetration of the electric field into the material, (ii) transport effects (such as electric-field-dependent mobility), and (iii) features of a complex density-of-states structure (position and shape of π−π∗ bands, controlling the concentration of charge carriers) on the FE characteristics of (N)UNCD. We show that the formation of the current-density saturation plateau can be explained by the limited supply of electrons within the impurity π−π∗ bands and decreasing electron mobility in a high electric field. Theoretical calculations are consistent with the experiment.