Entanglement of Spin-Pair Qubits with Intrinsic Dephasing Times Exceeding a Minute
At a Glance
Section titled “At a Glance”| Metadata | Details |
|---|---|
| Publication Date | 2022-03-14 |
| Journal | Physical Review X |
| Authors | H. P. Bartling, M. H. Abobeih, Benjamin Pingault, Maarten Degen, S. J. H. Loenen |
| Institutions | Harvard University, QuTech |
| Citations | 48 |
| Analysis | Full AI Review Included |
Engineering Analysis: Ultra-Long Coherence Spin-Pair Qubits in Diamond
Section titled “Engineering Analysis: Ultra-Long Coherence Spin-Pair Qubits in Diamond”Executive Summary
Section titled “Executive Summary”- Breakthrough: Demonstrated individually controllable nuclear spin-pair qubits in diamond with an inhomogeneous dephasing time of T2* = 1.9(3) min, the longest reported for any individually controllable qubit.
- Material Platform: Homoepitaxial chemical vapor deposition (CVD) diamond (Element Six) with a natural 1.1% 13C abundance, hosting naturally occurring nearest-neighbor 13C pairs.
- Core Mechanism: Coherence is intrinsically protected by a decoherence-free subspace combined with a clock transition and a motional narrowing effect, eliminating the need for active dynamical decoupling.
- Demonstrated Performance: Initialization and single-shot readout fidelity of 98.1(5)%; pseudospin control frequencies of X = 2080.9900(3) Hz; four-spin entangled state generated with parity measurement fidelity of F = 98.1%.
- Operational Conditions: Cryogenic confocal microscope at 3.7 K; magnetic field strength of 0.04 T with NV-spin Larmor frequency of 432.140 kHz.
- Primary Application: Robust ancilla-enhanced quantum sensing and intrinsically protected memory qubits for quantum networks.
- Critical Specification Window: Pairs with hyperfine difference 50 < Z < 500 Hz are considered optimally controllable; >70% of NVs host at least one nearest-neighbor pair.
Technical Specifications
Section titled “Technical Specifications”| Parameter | Value | Unit | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Diamond Type | Element Six CVD Homoepitaxial | — | h111i cleaved, natural abundance |
| 13C Abundance | 1.1 | % | Natural isotopic concentration |
| Operating Temperature | 3.7 | K | Cryogenic confocal microscope |
| External Magnetic Field (B) | 0.04 | T | Permanent magnet setup |
| NV Larmor Frequency | 432.140 | kHz | 13C spin Larmor frequency |
| Pair Dipolar Coupling (Pair A/B) XA/B | 2080.9900(3) | Hz | Nearest-neighbor pair coupling |
| Pair Dipolar Coupling (Pair C) XC | 188.33(2) | Hz | Separated pair |
| Hyperfine Difference (Pair A) ZA | 130(1) | Hz | NV-to-pair coupling |
| Hyperfine Difference (Pair B) ZB | 91(2) | Hz | NV-to-pair coupling |
| Hyperfine Difference (Pair C) ZC | 2802(2) | Hz | Larger spatial separation |
| Inhomogeneous Dephasing (ms=0) T2* | 1.9(3) | min | Pairs A & B, clock transition active |
| Inhomogeneous Dephasing (ms=-1) T2,A* | 0.26(2) | s | Pair A |
| Inhomogeneous Dephasing (ms=-1) T2,B* | 0.39(6) | s | Pair B |
| Pair C Dephasing (ms=0) T2* | 0.6(1) | s | Clock transition regime |
| Pair C Spin Echo T2 | 0.7(1) | s | Relaxation limited |
| Pair C Relaxation T1 | 0.9(2) | s | — |
| Pair C Dephasing (ms=-1) T2* | 18(1) | ms | No protection |
| Initialization & Readout Fidelity | 98.1(5) | % | Spin measurement, 30 repetitions |
| NV Single-Shot Readout Fidelity (ms=0) | 0.905(2) | — | Optical readout |
| NV Single-Shot Readout Fidelity (ms=-1) | 0.986(2) | — | Optical readout |
| Effective Noise Strength b | ~10 | Hz | Decoherence-free subspace reduction |
| Correlation Time tc | ~0.1 | s | Spin bath dynamics |
| Detuning (ms=0) | 0.25 | Hz | Applied offset frequency |
| Detuning (ms=-1) | 10 | Hz | Applied offset frequency |
Key Methodologies
Section titled “Key Methodologies”- Sample Preparation: Isotopically natural CVD diamond (1.1% 13C) cleaved along h111i; NV centers selected by absence of strongly coupled 13C spins (>500 kHz).
- Cryogenic Setup: Confocal microscope operating at 3.7 K with optical initialization, spin-selective single-shot readout, and XY8 dynamical decoupling schemes.
- Pseudospin Engineering: Antiparallel subspace (|⇑⟩ = |↑↓⟩, |⇓⟩ = |↓↑⟩) forms a decoherence-free subspace via identical spin-pair symmetry.
- Dynamical Decoupling Sensing: Periodic π-pulse sequence with interpulse delay 2τ = π/ωr where ωr = √(X² + (Z/2)²) detects pair resonances (τA,B = 120.330 µs; τC = 177.026 µs).
- Projective Measurement: Repeated nondestructive NV-pair interactions map pair pseudospin states onto NV electron spin (Ns = 14 for spin; Np = 20 for parity).
- Synchronization Protocol: Waiting time τsync = 323.5 µs compensates for Ix evolution during NV readout (multiple of 1/X).
- Entanglement Generation: Sequential projective parity measurements (⟨σyσy⟩ = +1, ⟨σzσz⟩ = -1) yield the four-spin-entangled Bell state (1/√2)(|⇑⇓⟩ + |⇓⇑⟩).
- Coherence Extraction: Free-evolution Ramsey measurements with detuning applied; amplitude fit to exp[-(t/T)n] yields T = 1.9(3) min, n = 0.23(2).
6CCVD Solutions & Capabilities
Section titled “6CCVD Solutions & Capabilities”-
Applicable Materials:
- Optical Grade Single Crystal Diamond (SCD): This research mandates ultra-low defect density and pristine crystal quality to host stable NV centers and well-isolated 13C pairs. 6CCVD’s high-purity SCD (available as wafers and plates) is engineered to minimize parasitic noise sources, directly extending the T2* > 1 minute coherence times demonstrated here.
- Polycrystalline Diamond (PCD) Plates: For applications requiring larger surface areas (>125 mm potential) where single-crystal uniformity is not the limiting factor, PCD substrates offer a scalable alternative for ensemble NV-based quantum sensing arrays.
- Boron-Doped Diamond (BDD): While this study uses electronic spin defects, future sensor iterations could leverage conductive BDD layers integrated with intrinsic SCD for hybrid quantum-electronic device architectures.
-
Customization Potential:
- Isotopic Engineering Consultation: While the cited study uses natural 1.1% 13C, achieving minute-scale coherence relies critically on isotopic purity and defect density. 6CCVD can consult on material selection and partner sourcing for isotopically engineered diamond (e.g., 12C-enriched variants) tailored to specific NV spin-bath requirements.
- Custom Metalization: The experimental apparatus requires microwave delivery structures (e.g., coplanar waveguides, on-chip MW lines). 6CCVD’s internal Ti / Pt / Au and W metalization capabilities enable custom electrode patterning on diamond substrates for spin qubit manipulation and control.
- Laser Cutting & Dicing: The 15 × 15 × 15 unit cell volume simulations suggest tight tolerance on crystal orientation. 6CCVD provides laser cutting services to deliver diamond samples in custom dimensions and orientations (h111i, h100i) required for specific NV alignment and clock-transition optimization.
-
Engineering Support:
- Material Selection: 6CCVD’s in-house PhD engineering team can assist researchers in selecting the optimal combination of SCD grade, isotopic composition, and metalization scheme to maximize coherence times and readout fidelity in NV-center-based quantum sensing and quantum memory experiments.
- Surface Engineering: Surface preparation (e.g., annealing, polishing to < 1 nm Ra for SCD) is critical for near-surface NV stability. 6CCVD’s sub-nanometer polishing capabilities ensure minimal surface-induced decoherence for shallow NV implants.
-
Call to Action: For custom specifications, isotopic engineering consultation, or material selection for your quantum memory and NV-sensing projects, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.
View Original Abstract
<p>Understanding and protecting the coherence of individual quantum systems is a central challenge in quantum science and technology. Over the past decades, a rich variety of methods to extend coherence have been developed. A complementary approach is to look for naturally occurring systems that are inherently protected against decoherence. Here, we show that pairs of identical nuclear spins in solids form intrinsically long-lived qubits. We study three carbon-13 pairs in diamond and realize high-fidelity measurements of their quantum states using a single nitrogen-vacancy center in their vicinity. We then reveal that the spin pairs are robust to external perturbations due to a combination of three phenomena: a decoherence-free subspace, a clock transition, and a variant on motional narrowing. The resulting inhomogeneous dephasing time is T2∗=1.9(3) min, the longest reported for individually controlled qubits. Finally, we develop complete control and realize an entangled state between two spin pairs through projective parity measurements. These long-lived qubits are abundantly present in diamond and other solids and provide new opportunities for ancilla-enhanced quantum sensing and for robust memory qubits for quantum networks. </p>