Skip to content

On the influence of reference sample properties on magnetic force microscopy calibrations

MetadataDetails
Publication Date2025-12-01
JournalReview of Scientific Instruments
AuthorsBaha Sakar, Christopher Habenschaden, S. Sievers, H. W. Schumacher
InstitutionsLeipzig University, Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt
AnalysisFull AI Review Included
  • Core Challenge: Quantitative Magnetic Force Microscopy (qMFM) relies on calibration via reference samples to derive a Tip Transfer Function (TTF). Discrepancies exist between TTFs derived from classical reference samples and those independently measured via Nitrogen-Vacancy (NV) centers.
  • Root Cause Identified: The primary cause of TTF inaccuracies is a loss of spectral information in the low-frequency domain due to the Wiener filter regularization process used to manage measurement noise.
  • Critical Finding: Accurate reconstruction of a Sample Under Test (SUT) depends more on the spectral overlap between the reference sample and the SUT than on an accurate real-space reconstruction of the tip stray field itself.
  • Validation Methods: The study utilized forward simulations of artificial samples (varying domain sizes from 10.24 µm to 20.48 µm) and experimental validation using two distinct multilayer stacks (CoPt and TiPtCo).
  • Practical Implication: Standard CoPt reference samples (with ~170 nm domain widths) are highly suitable for nanostructures like 100 nm skyrmion lattices but fail for micrometer-scale features like a QR-code pattern.
  • Future Outlook: The development of new reference samples with micrometer-scale features is required to extend qMFM capabilities for larger magnetic textures.
ParameterValueUnitContext
MFM Field Sensitivity80µT/√HzState-of-the-art MFM performance baseline
MFM Spatial Resolution10nmState-of-the-art imaging capability
MFM Tip Coating (Low-Moment)20nmCoCr coating thickness on MFM_LM tip
Nominal Tip Radius30nmMFM_LM tip specification
Tip-to-NV Distance80nmDistance during NV magnetometry
NV Measurement Step Size100nmGrid spacing for NV scans
Cantilever Stiffness (C)3.063N/mSimulated cantilever parameter
Cantilever Q-Factor160.7-Simulated cantilever parameter
Skyrmion Diameter (Sim)100nmSimulated test feature size
Test Sample Thickness (Sim)25nmSimulated film thickness
Saturation Magnetization (Sim)1.4 x 105A/mSimulated Ms
CoPt Stack: Ms500 ± 30kA/mReference sample magnetic property
CoPt Stack: Domain Wall Width~16nmBloch-type transition width
CoPt Stack: Average Domain Width~170nmCharacteristic magnetic feature size
CoPt Stack: Domain Width (Exp.)235nmExperimentally derived width via self-correlation
TiPtCo Stack: Domain Width345nmExperimentally derived width via self-correlation
Lift Height (MFM Scan)60nmExperimental ambient condition scan height
Lift Height (NV Calibration)80nmDistance matching NV quantum calibration
  • MFM Two-Pass Mode Operation: Scanning a magnetically coated oscillating cantilever at a defined measurement height (z) to monitor phase shift (∆φ) induced by tip-sample stray field interaction.
  • Wiener Filter Regularization: Application of an inverse Wiener filter with a regularization parameter (α1, α2) to perform stable deconvolution and derive the TTF/ICF without amplifying noise. The optimal α is determined via the L-curve criterion.
  • Effective Charge Density Calculation: Discrimination of MFM images into up/down magnetized domains, followed by applying a domain wall operator to derive the effective magnetic surface charge density.
  • Forward Image Simulation: Convolution of the ICF derived from NV-measured BzNV data with the calculated effective charge density pattern, incorporating typical ambient noise profiles.
  • Quantum Calibration via NV Magnetometry: Scanning an MFM tip over a single NV center embedded within a diamond solid immersion lens to independently determine the tip stray field distribution with quasi-atomic resolution.
  • Spectral Analysis & Overlap Mapping: Circular averaging of 2D Fourier transforms and comparison of spectral densities across wavelengths (λ) and wave vectors (k) to identify overlapping frequency components.
  • Applicable Materials: The NV magnetometry component of this study relies on Single Crystal Diamond (SCD) with embedded NV centers (often utilizing a solid immersion lens geometry). 6CCVD’s Optical Grade SCD and custom-engineered diamond substrates are ideally suited for fabricating these quantum sensing platforms due to our capability to produce low-roughness surfaces (Ra < 1nm) and precise thickness control (0.1µm - 500µm).
  • Customization Potential: To replicate the quantum sensing probe, a highly specific diamond geometry is required. 6CCVD offers laser cutting services for SCD and PCD wafers up to 125mm, allowing for the creation of the solid immersion lens shapes or custom NV-center substrates necessary for high-resolution magnetic field sensing.
  • Metallization for Sensor Fabrication: The metallization of diamond for NV-center electrodes or sensor contacts requires robust, specialized adhesion layers. 6CCVD’s in-house custom metalization capabilities (Ti, Pt, Au, W, etc.) are perfectly suited for fabricating the complex electrode structures required for diamond-based quantum sensors and MFM calibration standards.
  • Engineering Support: Selecting the correct diamond substrate (SCD vs. PCD, specific doping levels) is critical for the signal-to-noise ratio in quantum magnetometry. 6CCVD’s in-house PhD engineering team can assist researchers in material selection to optimize NV-center density, coherence properties, and fluorescence yield for advanced magnetic imaging projects.
  • Call to Action: For custom specifications, specialized diamond geometries, or material consultation regarding your next-generation MFM or quantum sensing research, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.
View Original Abstract

Magnetic force microscopy (MFM) allows the characterization of magnetic stray field distributions with high sensitivity and spatial resolution. Based on a suitable calibration procedure, MFM can also yield quantitative magnetic field values. This process typically involves measuring a reference sample to determine the distribution of the tip’s stray field or stray field gradient at the sample surface. This distribution is called the tip transfer function (TTF) and is derived through regularized deconvolution in Fourier space. The properties of the reference sample and the noise characteristics of the detection system significantly influence the derived TTF, thereby limiting its validity range. In a recent study, the tip stray field distribution, and hence the TTF, of an MFM tip was independently measured in real space using a nitrogen vacancy center as a quantum sensor, revealing considerable discrepancies with the reference-sample-based TTF. Here, we analyze the influence of the feature distribution of the reference sample and the MFM measurement parameters on the resulting TTF. We explain the observed differences between quantum-calibrated stray field distributions and the classical approach by attributing them to a loss of information due to missing or suppressed spectral components. Furthermore, we emphasize the importance of the spectral coverage of the TTF. Our findings indicate that for high-quality reconstruction of the stray field of a sample under test (SUT), it is more critical to ensure a strong overlap of frequency components between the reference sample and the SUT than to achieve an accurate real-space reconstruction of the tip stray field distribution.

  1. 2006 - Synthesis, properties, and applications of ferromagnetic-filled carbon nanotubes [Crossref]
  2. 2008 - Iron-filled carbon nanotubes as probes for magnetic force microscopy [Crossref]
  3. 2010 - Monopolelike probes for quantitative magnetic force microscopy: Calibration and application [Crossref]
  4. 2011 - Quantitative magnetic force microscopy on permalloy dots using an iron filled carbon nanotube probe [Crossref]
  5. 2015 - Bimodal magnetic force microscopy with capacitive tip-sample distance control [Crossref]
  6. 2018 - Magnetic force microscopy with frequency-modulated capacitive tip-sample distance control [Crossref]
  7. 2024 - Magnetic force microscopy: High quality-factor two-pass mode [Crossref]
  8. 2021 - Quantum calibrated magnetic force microscopy [Crossref]
  9. 2018 - Epitaxial hard magnetic SmCo5 MFM tips—A new approach to advanced magnetic force microscopy imaging [Crossref]
  10. 2022 - Magnetic force microscopy contrast formation and field sensitivity [Crossref]