Skip to content

Analysis of Impact Rock-Breaking Characteristics and Temperature Field of PDC Cutter

FieldValue
JournalProcesses
Published2026-02-28
AuthorsZebing Wu, Zihao Zhang, Yifei Lin, Zhe Yan, Kenan Liu
DOI10.3390/pr14050807
Citations1

A polycrystalline diamond compact cutter with four saw-type teeth reduced the peak surface temperature of a conventional cutter by 10.69% under impact loading in the authors’ finite element model. The four-tooth design reached 34.99 °C against 46.95 °C for the conventional cutter. In a full-scale bit simulation, the four-tooth design drilled 129.515 mm in 10 s versus 120.209 mm for a conventional bit. That is a 7.74% gain in rate of penetration. Both results come from simulation, and the authors report no single-cutter test to confirm them.

A three-dimensional thermomechanical model was built in ABAQUS/Explicit, with the Drucker-Prager criterion for granite failure and element deletion for fragmentation. The cutter geometry has a 13.44 mm diameter, a 3 mm diamond layer and a 5 mm alloy layer. It cuts a 100 mm by 50 mm by 25 mm rock prism. Contact uses surface-to-surface pairs with the tooth as master, penalty contact and penalty friction, and a friction coefficient fixed at 0.3. The mesh is 1 mm in the contact zone and 1.6 mm elsewhere, with C3D8T elements carrying both temperature and displacement degrees of freedom. Cutting speed is 500 mm/s over a 0.2 s simulation, and the initial field is a uniform 27 °C.

The rock model was checked against literature granite data through uniaxial compression and Brazilian splitting simulations. The uniaxial case used a 50 mm diameter, 100 mm tall sample with 5 mm end displacement. The splitting case used a 50 mm diameter sample with an aspect ratio of 0.5.

MaterialElastic modulus (GPa)Density (kg/m³)Thermal conductivity (W/(m·K))Specific heat (J/(kg·K))
PDC layer8903,500543.0790
Hard alloy layer57915,000100.0230
Granite402,6503.5800

The diamond layer carries 543 W/(m·K) against 3.5 W/(m·K) for granite. Heat generated at the interface therefore spreads through the diamond rather than pooling in one spot.

The impact load comes from an indoor rotary impact test on an 89 mm four-wing PDC bit running at 50 r/min. That test reported a 7 kN static load, a 2 kN peak dynamic load and 5 Hz impact frequency. Drilling rates were 0.0217 mm/s under rectangular wave loading and 0.01684 mm/s under sinusoidal wave loading. The peak dynamic load was about 28.57% of the static load, so the model applies a sinusoidal velocity with a 1.2 mm/s amplitude at 6 Hz.

An energy check gives 42,030 mJ of input mechanical energy against 40,452 mJ of plastic dissipation and 1,505 mJ of frictional dissipation. The closure error is 0.2%. Mesh tests at 1.5 mm, 1 mm and 0.5 mm gave peak temperatures of 55.60 °C, 53.40 °C and 56.27 °C. Peak cutting forces were 4432 N, 4322 N and 4557 N. The 1 mm mesh was chosen as the convergence point with acceptable cost.

Mass scaling tests compared coefficients of 0, 100 and 1000. Stable time steps were 1.48304 × 10⁻⁷ s, 1.48384 × 10⁻⁶ s and 4.33697 × 10⁻⁶ s. The coefficient 100 was selected, since 1000 pushed peak force to 4940 N and peak temperature to 54.26 °C against 4159 N and 51.57 °C without scaling. Varying the frictional heat distribution coefficient between 0.4, 0.5 and 0.6 left the distribution pattern and the ranking of designs intact. Shifting both layers’ thermal properties to their lower limits gave a maximum cutter temperature of 51.88 °C. The upper limits gave 53.97 °C, against 52.39 °C for the standard case.

Five surface geometries were modeled, from one to five saw-type teeth on the cutter crown, building on earlier published work on PDC cutter surface topography. Scheme 1 concentrates stress at the leading edges and the rock contact area in a half-moon and wedge pattern with a small stress gradient. As the tooth count rises, the saw edge loads the rock as a point, so stress concentrates closer to the tip and the rock fails in more places. The concave and convex structure between adjacent saw edges reduces contact area, and the recess in the middle of the tooth extrudes the rock.

Average cutting force and mechanical specific energy both fall and then rise with tooth count, and both reach their lowest value in Scheme 4. Schemes 3 and 4 carry lower overall cutting force than Schemes 1 and 2. Surface temperature follows the same pattern, with Scheme 1 peaking at 37 to 39 °C and Scheme 4 falling to 29 to 31 °C. Scheme 5 rises again because the spacing between teeth becomes too tight for the recesses to shed heat. Contact stresses on the five-tooth design show that edges 1, 2 and 3 carry significant contact force while edges 4 and 5 carry none. That explains why the extra teeth fail to spread heat.

Depths of 0.5, 1, 1.5, 2, 2.5 and 3 mm were simulated at 500 mm/s and a 15° back rake angle. Between 0.5 mm and 1.5 mm the peak and average force fluctuate only slightly, and beyond 1.5 mm both rise sharply. The authors attribute this to a change in rock failure mode, from small block-shaped plastic failure to large brittle detachment that needs repeated crushing. Mechanical specific energy reaches its minimum at a 1.5 mm depth, so that depth gives the best efficiency. Peak surface temperature occurs only at a 1 mm depth, and the tooth stays cooler at every other depth.

Back rake angles of 5°, 10°, 15°, 20° and 25° were then tested at the 1.5 mm depth. At 5° and 10° the saw face increases contact area, the plowing effect weakens, chips are not discharged, and repeated cutting drives force and MSE up. Between 15° and 20° the rock discharges promptly and both force and MSE fall. Above 20° the top surface projects further vertically, causing secondary contact with debris and raising force and MSE again. At 20° the average force and MSE decrease, and the reduced frictional heat brings the peak temperature down.

Cited experimental infrared imaging of a conventional cutter cutting hot rock shows the hot zone on the tooth surface and a surface microcrack, the wear mechanism the new geometry targets. With a conventional tooth in this model, impact loading lifts the peak surface temperature 3 °C above the conventional working condition. It also produces a wider spread, with an overall average temperature difference of 1.33 °C between the two conditions.

Under impact the four-saw tooth reaches a maximum of 34.99 °C, and the rise stays in the grooves between adjacent teeth. The conventional tooth reaches 46.95 °C and spreads to the upper left and upper right of the tooth surface. The difference is a 10.69% reduction in peak temperature, with no widespread thermal concentration on the four-saw tooth. The four-saw curve also holds a narrow fluctuation band, while the conventional tooth curve swings sharply as friction heat builds.

Two 215.9 mm five-blade bits were built in SOLIDWORKS, one with four-saw teeth and one with conventional teeth, with all other structural parameters shared. The rock model was 500 mm in diameter and 300 mm high, with 30 kN drilling pressure, 60 r/min rotation and a 10 s run. The bit was treated as a rigid body with wear ignored, the contact mesh was 4 mm and the rest 12 mm. Inner-circle teeth were analyzed for temperature. The conventional bit holds a local hot area on the tooth surface. The four-saw tooth shows an upward diffusion trend over a wider thermal area and a slower temperature rise. Fragmentation beneath the bit was finer and more uniform for the four-saw design. That held in both the central zone near the inner tooth row and the well wall zone near the outer row.

Bit typeDrilling depth (mm)Cumulative time (s)ROP (mm/s)
Conventional PDC bit120.2091012.02
Saw-tooth PDC bit129.5151012.95

The saw-tooth bit also showed considerably smaller torque fluctuation, which the authors read as lower resistance to rock breakage.

Heat carried away by drilling fluid is ignored, so the temperature field represents frictional heating alone. The uniform 27 °C starting field ignores the geothermal gradient in deep drilling, and the authors state that absolute temperatures will differ from on-site values. Friction is held at 0.3 regardless of temperature, contact pressure or sliding speed, and the diamond and rock are treated as homogeneous with constant thermal properties. No dedicated single-cutter test was run, so cutting forces and cutter temperatures lack direct experimental verification. The authors therefore present the 10.69% and 7.74% figures as comparative trends rather than absolute predictions. The tooth shape remains at the preliminary design stage and has not been made, with laboratory and field trials still ahead.

For cutter selection, the results point to geometry as a thermal control alongside material grade. A profile that spreads heat over the crown and keeps every edge in contact changes both peak temperature and mechanical specific energy. Profile, depth and rake therefore belong in one specification. At 1.5 mm depth and 20° back rake, the four-saw geometry gave the lowest MSE and the lowest peak temperature in the sets tested.

The cutter needs a polycrystalline diamond layer on a cemented carbide backing, with a metallized surface for brazing to the bit body. 6CCVD’s diamond materials catalog lists MPCVD-grown polycrystalline diamond in plates up to 125 mm, with metallization in Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W or Cu. That covers the diamond layer material family and the brazing metal for a cutter of this class. The 13.44 mm saw-type profile and the 3 mm diamond layer are geometry questions for engineering support.

View Original Abstract

Polycrystalline diamond compact (PDC) bits often experience localized heating during impact rock breaking in complex formations, resulting in reduced service life and lower drilling efficiency. An optimized structural design of PDC cutters can significantly enhance bit performance, mitigate thermal concentration, and extend operational longevity. Inspired by previous work on PDC cutter surface topography, five saw-type tooth-shaped cutter designs—featuring one to five saw-type teeth were developed. To evaluate their rock-breaking effectiveness and identify the optimum design, the impact-induced rock fragmentation processes of these cutters were compared using the finite element method. Key indicators, including cutting force, mechanical specific energy (MSE), and cutter surface temperature, were analyzed to determine the superior tooth configuration. Among the five designs, the four-saw-tooth cutter induced the most pronounced stress concentration in the rock. Its optimized number of saw-type teeth ensured full participation of all teeth in rock cutting, enabling efficient rock removal and maximizing breakage performance. Compared with other designs, this cutter exhibited the smallest fluctuations and mean cutting force. The specific mechanical energy decreased initially and then increased with the number of saw-type teeth, reaching a minimum for the four saw-type tooth design. Moreover, it showed the lowest surface temperature and the mildest temperature variation, which helps alleviate localized heating and improve wear resistance. The cutting performance of the four saw-type tooth was further influenced by cutting depth and back rake angle, with optimal values identified as 1.5 mm and 20°, respectively. Compared with a conventional cutter, the four saw-type tooth design reduced the overall surface temperature by approximately 10.69%, with temperature rise confined mainly to the grooves between adjacent saw-type teeth and no widespread thermal concentration observed, confirming its design superiority. Full-scale rock-breaking simulations demonstrated that the bit equipped with four saw-type tooth achieved greater penetration depth and required lower torque than the conventional design, indicating enhanced rock-breaking ability and higher drilling efficiency. In conclusion, the four saw-type tooth PDC cutter design offers a promising approach for developing high-performance drill bits and reducing drilling costs.

  1. 2023 - Numerical simulation study on the influence of composite impact phase difference on rock-breaking efficiency
  2. 2024 - Research Status and Development Suggestions for Impact-Based Rock Breaking and Drilling Acceleration Technology
  3. 2025 - Research and application status of PDC bit rotary percussion drilling technology
  4. 2025 - Heat-Fluid-Solid Coupling Temperature Rise Characteristics of Cutting Teeth of PDC Drill Influenced by the Weight of the Bit [Crossref]
  5. 2021 - Study on Cutting Load and Heat Generation Law of Worn PDC Cutters
  6. 2025 - Research on Optimization Design Method of PDC Bit Based on Impact Failure Mechanism
  7. 2025 - Study on Wear Characteristics and Rock Breaking Mechanism of PDC Cutters Based on Thermal-Mechanical Coupling Simulation
  8. 2021 - Rock-breaking mechanism and heat generation analysis in deep well high-temperature rock
  9. 2015 - Numerical Simulation Study on the Interaction Temperature Field Between PDC Bit Cutters and Rock