Skip to content

Qutrit Dynamics of Acoustically‐Driven Nitrogen‐Vacancy Centers

FieldValue
JournalAdvanced Quantum Technologies
Published2026-05-01
AuthorsV. Moldoveanu, R. Dragomir
DOI10.1002/qute.70312

Simulations predict that acoustically driven nitrogen-vacancy qubit rotations become genuine qutrit dynamics above 125 K. At 300 K, the single-quantum gate super-fidelity falls below 0.95 after 650 operations without pure dephasing. It falls below 0.95 after 400 operations at Γd = 0.96 kHz. Phonon-assisted relaxation populates the third ground-state spin level during acoustic operations.

Acoustic single-quantum driving couples |0⟩ to |1⟩ or |-1⟩, while double-quantum driving couples |1⟩ to |-1⟩. A two-level model treats the remaining state as inaccessible during a pulse. The full model shows that spin-lattice relaxation breaks this separation.

Under single-quantum driving at 300 K, the nonresonant population P₋₁ reaches 0.15 at 2 ms. It reaches 0.07 at 250 K. Double-quantum driving fills |0⟩ through slower relaxation paths because |0⟩ has no direct resonant acoustic transition. The center eventually reaches thermal equilibrium, with each population equal to 1/3 and the super-fidelity equal to 1/3.

Two-phonon Orbach-like processes drive this behavior above 125 K. They transfer population through both slow and fast relaxation channels, rather than only damping the coherent pair. This is why the paper treats the center as a qutrit when evaluating long gate sequences.

The authors solve a Lindblad master equation for one NV center in the interaction picture. Acoustic fields enter the Hamiltonian commutator, while temperature-dependent spin-lattice relaxation and pure dephasing form the dissipative kernel. The calculation uses the rotating wave approximation and a four-point Runge-Kutta method. The reported NV-center results are simulations rather than new measurements.

Above 125 K, the relaxation model uses two-quasilocalized-phonon modes with energies 68.2 meV and 167 meV. Sample-dependent terms are omitted because they matter mainly below 125 K. The simulations initialize the center in |0⟩.

The reported cases satisfy two approximation conditions. Both Rabi frequencies and relaxation rates are much smaller than the transition frequencies. The dissipative kernel can therefore use the undriven spin basis.

ParameterValueRole
D2.87 GHzNV zero-field splitting
Bz150 GPositive perpendicular magnetic field
σZZ0.5 GPaAxial stress along [001]
f+3.29 GHzSingle-quantum transition for states 0 and 1
f-2.45 GHzSingle-quantum transition for states 0 and -1
fD0.84 GHzDouble-quantum transition for states 1 and -1

The stress susceptibilities are a1 = 0.0044 GHz/GPa and b = -0.0023 GHz/GPa. The model sets b’ = |b|/√2.

At 0.5 GPa, the single-quantum Rabi period is 0.87 μs. At 0.75 GPa, it is about 0.57 μs, close to the experimental value cited by the authors. The double-quantum Rabi period is half the single-quantum period.

Temperature controls relaxation and gate decay

Section titled “Temperature controls relaxation and gate decay”

For Γd = 0 and σZZ = 0.5 GPa, the simulations use these relaxation rates.

TemperatureSingle-quantum rate ΩDouble-quantum rate γ
150 K3 Hz7.81 Hz
250 K30.54 Hz67 Hz
300 K62.23 Hz132.47 Hz

The rates rise with temperature, so the same acoustic pulse produces stronger damping at room temperature. At 300 K, the single-quantum amplitude falls by half between the 0.5 ms and 3 ms sampling windows. Each window is 5 μs wide. Double-quantum amplitudes decay faster still.

At 150 K, the weak damping leaves the motion closer to an ideal two-level rotation. Pure dephasing does not change the phonon-fed off-resonant population. It reduces the coherent oscillations further. The simulations find that the nonresonant population cannot be neglected after 2 ms.

Two acoustic pulses implement a qutrit shift

Section titled “Two acoustic pulses implement a qutrit shift”

The qutrit-shift gate uses consecutive double-quantum and single-quantum acoustic half-periods. Its cycle time is TQ = 0.652 μs at 0.5 GPa. Each ideal cycle shifts the dominant spin state along the triplet.

After three cycles, the ideal gate returns the state to its starting point because Ψ³ = I. At 300 K, relaxation creates a total background population of about 0.15 in one simulated interval. The dominant state cannot then exceed a population of 0.85. This background population prevents a clean sequence of shifts.

The average spin shows large jumps during ideal half-period rotations. The plateaus decline as secondary populations grow. After 3N two-pulse sequences, the super-fidelity equals the population of the initial state. For an initial |0⟩ state, measuring P₀ therefore benchmarks the qutrit-shift gate.

The analysis extends prior acoustic modeling, which neglected longitudinal spin relaxation over its 4 μs simulation window. The present model follows the relaxation and dephasing effects over longer gate sequences.

With no pure dephasing, the double-quantum sequence has the best simulated gate count. Adding dephasing changes that ranking because double-quantum coherences decay faster. Without added dephasing, T1 = 1/(γ + 3Ω), and T2,max = 2T1.

The pure-dephasing time for the double-quantum coherence is 1 divided by 2Γd. The corresponding single-quantum time is four times longer. The qutrit shift contains fewer double-quantum-only rotations and relies more on the slower single-quantum coherence.

At Γd = 1 kHz, close to the empirical limit T2 = T1/2, the double-quantum sequence retains 350 operations with super-fidelity above 95%. The qutrit-shift count is of the same order at that dephasing rate. Across a broad dephasing range, the model still supports at least 100 qutrit-shift gates above the 95% threshold.

The qutrit shift is slower than any single-pulse qubit rotation. Prior nanodiamond work reported T2 above 400 μs at room temperature and two-NV gate fidelities near 96% for similar T2 values. Those results show why dephasing and long gate counts must be assessed together.

The single-center model does not directly describe an acoustic ensemble. Prior work used 45 to 60 centers with different positions in a standing wave. The simulations use wavelengths of 5.7 μm for single-quantum driving and 6.7 μm for double-quantum driving.

Centers at z = 0.1 μm, 0.2 μm, and 0.3 μm receive the pulse sequence tuned to the center at z = 0. The simulation covers ten operations over 7 μs. The first 4 μs remain mostly clean. Later rotations become incomplete because each center has a different Rabi strength.

After the ninth single-quantum operation, P₀ is near 1 for the center at 0.1 μm. It falls to 0.65 for the center at 0.3 μm. The authors suggest low-concentration samples for single-center control. They cite prior samples with about 2 μm between centers and milled nanodiamonds containing few NV centers.

Engineering implications and unresolved issues

Section titled “Engineering implications and unresolved issues”

Material and device selection should account for relaxation at the operating temperature, not only spin-stress coupling. A single-center experiment requires low NV density. An ensemble experiment needs spatial calibration because acoustic phase errors accumulate after several operations.

The acoustic drive must support the selected single-quantum and double-quantum frequencies. Its control bandwidth must remain well below the transition frequencies. The paper leaves several implementation questions unresolved.

It models one center and does not demonstrate the gate experimentally. Its main population simulations do not include the cited 0.3 G transverse field. The sample-dependent relaxation terms are also excluded below 125 K. The authors expect more complex qutrit gates to accumulate more relaxation error. Device planning should compare operation count, dephasing rate, and acoustic-field uniformity together.

The material requirement is a diamond host for an acoustically controlled NV qutrit, with low-density NV centers, controlled [001] stress, and coupling at f- and fD. 6CCVD’s diamond materials catalog lists single-crystal and polycrystalline MPCVD diamond plates and wafers up to 125 mm as candidate host geometries. Geometry, polishing, and integration details for the acoustic and stress assembly can be reviewed through engineering support for custom fabrication support.

View Original Abstract

ABSTRACT We present a theoretical study of the interplay between the spin‐mechanical coupling and spin‐lattice relaxation in the dynamics of a nitrogen‐vacancy center in diamond. Single and double‐quantum spin transitions are driven by resonant acoustic pulses. In addition, the two‐phonon decoherence processes are included in the Lindblad equation of the density operator along with the temperature dependence of the corresponding relaxation rates. Our numerical simulations reveal that these processes activate all spin states of the NV‐center. Therefore, an idealized qubit rotation is replaced by a genuine qutrit dynamics. We then show that consecutive single‐ and double‐quantum acoustic pulses operate as an all‐acoustic qutrit‐shift gate. Besides calculating the time‐dependent populations of the spin states, we discuss the cumulative impact of the spin‐lattice relaxation and spin dephasing on the fidelity of a sequence of qubit and qutrit operations.