Skip to content

Atomic-Level Polishing of Single-Crystal Diamond Using a Combination of Reactive Ion Etching and Chemical Mechanical Polishing

FieldValue
JournalMaterials
Published2026-06-22
AuthorsRongchen Zhang, Xiangbing Wang, Xuejian Cui, Yi Hong, Nan Jiang
DOI10.3390/ma19122677

A combined reactive ion etching (RIE) and chemical mechanical polishing (CMP) process reduced single-crystal diamond roughness from Ra = 0.68 nm to Ra = 0.35 nm. The verification sample was synthetic (110) IIa single-crystal diamond. The verified sequence used 200 W for 600 s with an Ar:O2:CF4 ratio of 40:50:10, followed by 2 h of CMP. AFM used tapping mode over 20 µm × 20 µm, and three random points per sample were averaged.

The study separated plasma modification from mechanical removal. SCD1 was the optimized condition. SCD2 doubled RF power, SCD3 doubled etch time, and SCD4 increased the CF4 share. SCD5 received CMP without RIE.

SampleTreatmentRF powerEtching timeAr/O2/CF4 flow
SCD1RIE200 W600 s40:50:10
SCD2RIE400 W600 s40:50:10
SCD3RIE200 W1200 s40:50:10
SCD4RIE200 W600 s40:10:50
SCD5CMP onlyNot appliedNot appliedNot applied

All RIE runs used a total gas flow of 100 sccm. Chamber pressure was regulated automatically by the RIE-100 system. The design tests plasma power, etch time, and gas composition against a CMP-only control.

The samples were synthetic (110) IIa single-crystal diamonds measuring 10 mm × 10 mm × 0.5 mm. Their incoming surfaces had been mechanically polished.

Before testing, each sample was immersed in boiling piranha solution, H2SO4:H2O2 = 7:3 by volume, for 8 h. Acetone and anhydrous ethanol ultrasonic cleaning followed for 10 min each. High-purity nitrogen completed the drying step.

During RIE, Ar ions bombard the surface. CF4 supplies fluorine radicals, and O2 supplies active oxygen radicals. The authors attribute the surface change to combined physical bombardment and chemical reaction. This disrupts the original sp3 lattice and forms a softer sp2/sp3 amorphous carbon layer with nanoscale columnar structures.

RIE usually raises roughness before CMP. The modification is an intended intermediate state, not the finished surface.

After RIE, each diamond was fixed to a loading block with molten paraffin and pressed against the polishing pad. CMP used a UNIPOL-1502 machine, a soft polyurethane pad, and COMPOL 80 colloidal silica slurry diluted 1:10 with deionized water.

The polishing disk rotated at 30 r/min for 2 h. The loading block weighed 2.5 kg. This produced a calculated sample pressure of 0.245 MPa for the 10 mm × 10 mm face.

The authors chose the soft pad to avoid new scratches and subsurface damage. Abrasive action then strips the RIE-modified layer and planarizes the surface.

AFM detected a large roughness increase after RIE and a net reduction after CMP. The reported SCD1 stage values were 2.47 nm before RIE, 3.52 nm after RIE, and 1.54 nm after CMP. The CMP-only SCD5 changed from 2.60 nm to 2.27 nm under the same CMP conditions.

SampleTreatmentStarting RaFinal Ra
SCD1RIE then CMP2.47 nm1.54 nm
SCD5CMP only2.60 nm2.27 nm
SCD6RIE then CMP0.68 nm0.35 nm

The control showed no obvious improvement. SCD1’s RIE step increased Ra by 42.5%. SCD2 rose from 1.39 nm to 2.68 nm, a 92.8% increase, when RF power doubled to 400 W. SCD3 rose from 1.19 nm to 1.73 nm, a 45.4% increase, when etch time doubled to 1200 s.

The authors link the larger change at 400 W to a thicker, less uniform modified layer. They attribute the small gain at 1200 s to a dynamic etch equilibrium. SCD4 used 40:10:50 gas and fell from 2.61 nm to 2.17 nm after RIE. Its later CMP result was worse than SCD1 because stable C-F bonds inhibited formation of the effective soft layer.

Raman used a 532 nm laser over 1000 to 2000 cm⁻¹ with a 3 s single-point acquisition. Spectra of SCD1 retained the diamond peak between 1331.5 cm⁻¹ and 1331.9 cm⁻¹. The deviation from the standard 1332.5 cm⁻¹ position was below 1 cm⁻¹. FWHM remained between 2.27 cm⁻¹ and 2.32 cm⁻¹ without clear broadening. The authors therefore found no obvious lattice distortion or stress in the bulk.

RIE strengthened the broad amorphous-carbon feature near 1425 cm⁻¹ and raised the high-wavenumber fluorescence background. CMP made that feature nearly disappear and returned the background to its initial level.

XPS spectra were charge-corrected to the diamond sp3 C-C peak at 284.80 eV. XPS showed reduced sp3 C-C peak area after RIE, increased sp2 carbon, and a new C-F peak at 288.75 eV. Surface oxygen fell from 8.89% to 3.22%, while fluorine reached 22.75%.

After CMP, the sp2 carbon contribution was effectively removed, C-O disappeared from the O1s fit, and carbon reached 93.45%. These measurements support the proposed removal of the modified layer.

The paper’s direct CMP control is the clearest internal comparison. Hybrid-treated SCD1 improved from 3.52 nm after RIE to 1.54 nm after CMP, whereas CMP alone changed SCD5 from 2.60 nm to 2.27 nm.

The cited literature gives context but is not a head-to-head comparison. Mechanical polishing reached Ra = 8 nm for graded polycrystalline diamond. A metal-bonded diamond wheel reached Ra = 5.1 nm. The authors reported microcracks and nearby crystal defects that affected carrier transfer within 2 µm.

Thermochemical polishing reached up to 7 µm/h above 700 °C in a vacuum environment. It required a special protective atmosphere and carried risks of etch pits, thermal damage, and graphitic residue.

Other CMP work reduced Ra from 8 to 17 µm to 0.4 µm in 3 h with molten LiNO3 and KNO3. A mixed diamond and silicon carbide abrasive slurry produced Sa = 0.856 nm.

Plasma methods reported Ra = 0.28 nm after ICP-RIE with 10% CHF3 in O2. Plasma-assisted CMP of polycrystalline diamond produced Sa = 0.366 nm. ICP etching combined with dynamic friction polishing produced Ra = 0.185 nm.

Earlier Ar/O2/CF4 RIE removed mechanically induced subsurface damage up to 6 µm and reduced roughness by 20% to 44%. These values differ in material, metric, geometry, and process conditions. The present result is therefore best judged against its own CMP-only control rather than as a universal record.

The evidence supports RIE-CMP as a low-damage finishing route for single-crystal diamond. Raman retained the bulk diamond signature, while XPS showed that the sp2-rich modified layer was removed after CMP. For high-power electronics and quantum sensing, the measured benefit is a smoother surface without clear Raman evidence of bulk lattice damage.

Several limits remain. The authors used 10 mm × 10 mm samples and call for large-wafer trials. They did not report a material removal rate for the hybrid process. The cited literature describes conventional CMP as generally below 100 nm/h. The RIE step also leaves 22.75% surface fluorine before CMP and temporarily roughens the surface. The authors propose low-fluorine or fluorine-free gas systems to control this residue.

The AFM evidence covers three 20 µm × 20 µm scans per sample, not a wafer-scale map. No cross-sectional subsurface damage profile, device electrical test, or thermal-transport measurement is reported. The authors describe the result as atomic-level, but the reported finish is a 0.35 nm Ra measurement rather than atomic-resolution topography.

Process qualification should therefore test final roughness across a full wafer, residual fluorine, removal rate, phase residue, and device performance. The paper demonstrates a two-step process on small samples, but it has not established a production process for large-area diamond substrates.

The paper uses 10 mm × 10 mm × 0.5 mm synthetic (110) IIa single-crystal diamond and identifies high-power electronics and quantum sensing as target applications. 6CCVD’s diamond materials catalog lists single-crystal plates up to 125 mm with 0.1 to 500 µm thicknesses and polishing to Ra below 1 nm. These ranges cover the paper’s dimensions and roughness class, while engineering support can define the RIE-CMP finishing requirement, which is not a cataloged product specification.

View Original Abstract

Single-crystal diamond (SCD) is an ideal substrate material for semiconductor devices due to its extremely wide bandgap and exceptionally high thermal conductivity. However, diamond’s extreme hardness and chemical inertness pose challenges for the fabrication of ultra-smooth surfaces. Traditional polishing processes are not only inefficient but also prone to introducing subsurface defects, which severely degrade device performance. To address the above issues, this study proposes a hybrid polishing process combining reactive ion etching (RIE) surface modification with chemical mechanical polishing (CMP), which enables low-loss atomic-level processing of SCD. The study found that RIE treatment induces lattice disorder on the diamond surface, forming a sp2-hybridized amorphous carbon-modified layer. Compared to the sp3 structure of native diamond, this modified layer has lower hardness and is easier to remove. We conducted the verification of the optimized process using high-quality single-crystalline diamond (SCD) samples with an initial surface roughness Ra of 0.68 nm. Under the optimized RIE parameters (substrate bias power: 200 W, etching time: 600 s, gas flow ratio of Ar:O2:CF4 = 40:50:10), the surface roughness Ra was reduced to as low as 0.35 nm after 2 h of CMP treatment. Furthermore, systematic characterization of the SCD’s as-received surface, RIE-modified surface, and CMP-treated surface was performed using Raman spectroscopy and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), elucidating the “etching modification-mechanical removal” polishing mechanism.

  1. 2019 - Conductive diamond: Synthesis, properties, and electrochemical applications [Crossref]
  2. 2019 - Energy-Efficient Metal-Insulator-Metal-Semiconductor Field-Effect Transistors Based on 2D Carrier Gases [Crossref]
  3. 2003 - Elastic, mechanical, and thermal properties of nanocrystalline diamond films [Crossref]
  4. 1994 - Strength of Diamond [Crossref]
  5. 2016 - Single crystal diamond wafers for high power electronics [Crossref]
  6. 2018 - Recent advances in diamond power semiconductor devices [Crossref]
  7. 2024 - Nanoscale diamond quantum sensors for many-body physics [Crossref]
  8. 2024 - Applications of diamond films: A review [Crossref]