Skip to content

Identification of Lithology Based on Vibration Response of Drill Bit

FieldValue
JournalSensors
Published2026-09-24
AuthorsChong Wang, Qilong Xue, 彭正洲, Jin Wang, Weiguo Hai
DOI10.3390/s26196045

Full-size Polycrystalline Diamond Compact bit rock-breaking tests produced 97.4% lithology identification accuracy with a BP neural network. Random forest reached 96.4%, and GRNN reached 95.2% on the same 420-sample test set. The results also show that weight on bit and rotational speed mainly changed vibration amplitude within the tested range.

Granite, sandstone, and limestone blocks measuring 300 mm × 300 mm × 300 mm were drilled with a 154 mm PDC bit. The rig used a flexible drill pipe to transmit torque and pressurized cylinders to apply weight on bit. Two acceleration sensors were placed 0.5 m behind the bit to collect vibration data and cross-check each other. A separate device measured rotational speed at the power head. Weight on bit was measured by a pressure sensor on the lower part of the rock sample.

Acceleration data were sampled at 2 kHz. Rotational speed and pressure data were sampled at 10 Hz. The controlled-variable design allowed lithology, weight on bit, and rotational speed to be varied separately.

Test seriesRockWeight on bitRotational speed
Lithology comparisonSandstone, limestone, granite15 kN40 r/min
Speed comparisonGranite20 kN20, 40, 60 r/min
Weight comparisonGranite10, 14, 18 kN40 r/min

Lithology changes acceleration and spectrum

Section titled “Lithology changes acceleration and spectrum”

At 15 kN weight on bit and 40 r/min, granite produced tangential acceleration from -6.03 g to 5.91 g. Limestone produced -6.69 g to 4.63 g. Sandstone produced -4.06 g to 3.88 g and had the smallest amplitude.

Fast Fourier transforms showed clear differences in the frequency composition of all three signals. Granite had higher peak-to-peak, root mean square, and clearance factor values than limestone and sandstone. Limestone and sandstone differed less in those three features. Kurtosis separated limestone and sandstone from granite. Granite also showed a higher percentage of power in the low-frequency band than sandstone.

The authors therefore combined several time-domain and frequency-domain features. No single signal value captured all differences among the three rocks.

Drilling parameters mainly change amplitude

Section titled “Drilling parameters mainly change amplitude”

At 20 kN weight on bit in granite, tangential acceleration was approximately ±6.1 g at 20 r/min. It reached approximately ±6.9 g at 40 r/min and ±10.1 g at 60 r/min.

At 40 r/min, 10 kN weight on bit produced a range of -3.24 g to 3.45 g. Increasing weight on bit to 14 kN gave -4.69 g to 5.26 g. At 18 kN, the range was -6.41 g to 7.49 g.

FFT spectra changed little in composition as either parameter increased. The amplitude at the dominant frequency increased in both test series. Within the tested conditions, frequency composition was more stable than vibration amplitude.

Preprocessed axial and tangential acceleration and rotational speed supplied the time-domain features. These were root mean square, clearance factor, kurtosis index, and peak-to-peak value. Frequency-domain features were mean frequency and percentage of power in a frequency band.

Weight on bit and rotational speed were included as model inputs because both affect vibration amplitude. Feature values were normalized because their ranges differed substantially.

The t-SNE algorithm mapped the high-dimensional data into a two- or three-dimensional embedding. The visualization showed clear separation among sandstone, limestone, and granite clusters. This supported combining vibration features with drilling parameters rather than relying on one statistic.

The experiments produced 1403 labeled samples from the three rocks under various conditions. Training used 70% of the data, while 30% formed the independent test set. The split yielded 983 training samples and 420 test samples. Lithology labels used one-hot encoding.

The BP network used scaled conjugate gradient training and three hidden layers. The random forest used 50 decision trees and a minimum leaf size of three samples. The GRNN used a spread of 0.3.

ModelOverall accuracySandstone, 71 samplesLimestone, 236 samplesGranite, 113 samples
BP neural network97.4%95.8%99.6%93.8%
Random forest96.4%97.2%99.6%89.4%
GRNN95.2%87.3%97.5%95.6%

The BP network produced the highest overall test accuracy. The random forest reached its lowest class accuracy for granite, at 89.4%. The GRNN reached its lowest class accuracy for sandstone, at 87.3%. Limestone reached 99.6% with both the BP network and random forest. All three models were evaluated on the same 420 samples.

Earlier work supports linking drilling vibration to formation changes. Sitinjak reported stronger vibration in carbonate than shale using near-bit data from a Kuwait well. Flegner used a small drill bit and an acceleration sensor to compare four rock types. Jones linked tangential acceleration with rock density and gamma values. Esmaeili reported that vibration amplitude rose with rock compressive strength. Cai identified weight on bit, rotational speed, and lithology as major factors controlling amplitude.

The present study adds controlled weight on bit and rotational speed series with a full-size PDC bit. It also separates vibration features from drilling inputs before fitting three classifiers. The paper provides no numerical accuracy for the cited earlier studies. Its direct model comparison is therefore among BP, random forest, and GRNN under one laboratory protocol.

The authors did not include confining stress, pore pressure, or drilling-fluid effects. The model used one PDC bit, three lithologies, and a limited sample of 1403 samples. No field well validation was performed. The paper also reports no compressive strength values for the tested blocks. Those omissions prevent a quantitative field calibration of the observed vibration relationships.

The proposed real-time use remains a suggestion based on laboratory evidence and maturing downhole sensors. The authors call for larger datasets, field validation, and combined weight on bit, torque, and rotational speed information. Accuracy under those field conditions remains unknown.

The measured separation supports near-bit sensing for lithology monitoring with PDC bits. A monitoring system should retain weight on bit and rotational speed with each vibration record because both change amplitude. The paper’s laboratory configuration used 2 kHz acceleration acquisition and sensors 0.5 m behind the bit. It supports frequency-domain features as a more stable lithology indicator than amplitude within the tested range.

The study does not support choosing a diamond grade, cutter geometry, or PDC material. No cutter material or geometry comparison was reported. Engineers should read 95.2% to 97.4% as laboratory accuracy for three rocks under the stated conditions. It is not a measured downhole accuracy.

View Original Abstract

The evaluation of rock properties is an indispensable part of the process of developing deep oil and gas resources. Traditional lithology identification methods have limitations such as high cost and time consumption. During the drilling operation, the interaction between the drill bit and the formation occurs, and the dynamic vibration response of the drill bit can represent the geological characteristics of the formation. In this paper, the differences in vibration response during the drilling process are explored by experimental methods, and the feasibility of using vibration signals to judge the change in rock stratum is investigated. A full-scale drill bit rock breaking test rig is constructed, and laboratory experiments on full-size Polycrystalline Diamond Compact (PDC) bit rock breaking are carried out, during which vibration response data under different drilling parameters are collected. The differences among experimental datasets are then analyzed and compared, and key data characteristics are extracted. Based on these, a new method for discriminating formation lithology is proposed. The results show that the amplitude of vibration response is closely related to drilling parameters and rock properties. The frequency composition of the vibration is only affected by the properties of the rock strata and is not affected by drilling parameters. Furthermore, the model established based on differences in vibration responses can effectively identify lithological changes, with an identification accuracy rate exceeding 95%. This study offers a theoretical basis for identifying lithologic changes in field production and serves as a valuable supplement to existing methods.