Skip to content

La collection Habib - mythes, réalités et devenir

FieldValue
Published2026-09-22
AuthorsMarie Chabrol, Charline Coupeau
DOI10.63000/g8mcv226rlvyx

The Mi-Régent, a 59.60-carat diamond from the Habib collection, brought 1,275,000 francs at the 8 February 1933 auction. Two stones sold in twelve minutes, enough to repay the loan that brought the collection to market. Marie Chabrol and Charline Coupeau trace the collection through public sales from 1909 to 1962. Their records establish prices, weights, and several later owners, but leave some famous identities and final locations unresolved.

The June 1909 sale at the Hôtel Drouot offered eight diamonds. Their results show a market more cautious than the published estimates suggested.

DiamondReported weightHammer pricePublished expectationResult
Pink diamond6 carats10,100 francs15,000 francsSold to Louis Aucoc
White-blue pear24 carats40,000 francs75,000 francsSold to Janesich
White-blue cushion23 carats78,000 francs100,000 francsSale status uncertain
Princesse Mathilde16 carats72,000 francs120,000 francsBought back by Habib
Idol’s Eye70 1/16 carats140,000 francs300,000 francsBought back by Habib
Pink diamond31 carats82,000 francs300,000 francsBought back by Habib
Mi-Régent58 carats182,000 francs400,000 francsBought back by Habib
Hope44 carats400,000 francs1,500,000 francsReported sale to Rosenau, with a disputed detail

The auction total was reported as 1,008,100 francs. Four stones returned to Salomon Habib. The Hope Diamond appears to have sold to Simon Rosenau, but the authors note that it may have been sold directly to him after the auction.

Reconstructing custody from several archives

Section titled “Reconstructing custody from several archives”

Chabrol and Coupeau combine private family archives with pawn registers, auction catalogs, administrative files, military records, newspapers, and later jewelry histories. The Crédit municipal’s engagement and release registers provide the strongest sequence for individual stones.

The Hope Diamond shows the limits of this evidence. It was acquired in spring 1908 from Frankel Sons and Company through Lindenbaum and Weil. Contemporary sources placed the price at $400,000, more than 2,000,000 gold francs, or $2,000,000. A 1938 interview and family memory instead assign the purchase to Isaac Habib, with Salomon inheriting the stone. The authors reject claims that Habib bought it for Sultan Abdul Hamid II or died in the sinking of the steamer La Seyne.

The identity of the Agra remains probable rather than proven. Archive entries list a pink diamond whose old-carat weight converts to about 31.40 modern carats. This weight matches the known Agra before its recutting. The records place it in the Habib collection between 1909 and 13 December 1913. An acquisition after the 1909 auction is only a hypothesis.

The auction history reflects Salomon Habib’s financial position. After the 1909 sale, most stones were returned to him and pledged as security. The loans recorded in 1913, excluding December, totaled 287,000 francs. On 13 December, the pink diamond was pledged again within a group valued at 400,000 francs.

Two diamonds, the Mi-Régent and the Bleu aigue-marine, were repledged for 414,000 francs on 9 January 1920. Planned auctions of these stones in 1921 and of seven collection diamonds in 1927 were both canceled.

By July 1931, Habib owed the Crédit municipal 1,285,000 francs. He opposed the sale of the stones, but the court granted him six months to proceed. Military records document his repeated wounds from the First World War. Together with the debt records, this supports the authors’ reading that liquidity needs, rather than a planned dispersal, drove several transactions.

The increasing weights of some stones resulted from metrology rather than physical change. The old gemstone carat weighed 205 mg and was divided into 64 parts. The metric carat adopted at the General Conference on 22 October 1907 weighed 200 mg, or 0.20 g.

France adopted the metric carat through the law of 22 June 1909 and the decree of 7 July 1910. Its use began on 1 January 1911. The same physical mass therefore produced a larger number of carats after conversion.

This explains the apparent gains between the 1909 and 1933 sales. A pink diamond moved from about 31.40 to 32.30 carats. The Mi-Régent moved from 58 to 59.60 carats. The Princesse Mathilde moved from 16 to 16.25 carats. Contemporary journalists treated these figures as stones that had physically grown.

The 8 February 1933 sale stopped after twelve minutes because the bids covered the loan. The Mi-Régent brought 1,275,000 francs from jeweller Hippolyte-Désiré Fromanger. The Princesse Mathilde brought 325,000 francs from Baroness de Forest.

The catalogue calculations included 11 percent sale fees. They gave 23,280 francs per carat for the 59.60-carat Mi-Régent and 21,745 francs per carat for the 16.25-carat Princesse Mathilde. Their 1909 hammer prices had been 182,000 francs and 72,000 francs, respectively, in the article’s item list.

The 1933 results therefore exceeded the 1909 prices, but they did not reach the much higher expectations reported before the first auction. The comparison also depends on the change in carat weight. Apparent gains must be separated from changes in market value.

The authors believe Habib retained the Idol’s Eye until 1946. Harry Winston acquired it that year, and May Bonfils Stanton bought it from him later in 1962. At the Parke-Bernet auction after Stanton’s death, Harry Levinson paid $375,000. The diamond was loaned to De Beers for a 1967 exhibition in Johannesburg, acquired by Graff in 1979, and remains in the Al-Thani Collection.

The heart-shaped Peace Diamond reappeared at Sotheby’s on 15 December 1938 as lot 35A. The London catalogue listed 12.25 carats, while the 1933 Paris records gave 12.33 carats. D. C. Collins bought it for 1,550 pounds. Habib donated part of the proceeds to support wounded soldiers.

The yellow Golconde d’or appeared again at Sotheby’s on 17 May 1962. Its 1933 catalogue weight was 95.35 carats, while the later catalogue recorded the actual weight as 95.40 carats. The 1962 sale was its last documented public auction. The Hope Diamond is now displayed by the Smithsonian Institution in Washington.

Three stones still lack established final locations: the 23-carat white-blue diamond, the 32.30-carat pink diamond, and the 14.30-carat green diamond. The records also raise an unresolved question about the 136.15-carat square green diamond. It may have been recut into the 95.40-carat yellow stone, but the loss of 40.75 carats leaves that conclusion unproven.

The metric carat conversion provides a concrete warning for provenance work. Any historical weight must retain its unit convention and conversion date. Auction lots, pawn entries, and custody records must also be checked before two similarly described stones are treated as the same object.

The paper reports no material characterization or device measurements. It therefore cannot guide the selection of diamond for technical use. Its practical value lies in documentary evidence for natural diamonds with a recorded collection history.

View Original Abstract

HABIB COLLECTION : MYTHS, REALITIES AND FUTURE - According to the British press of the 1930s, Salomon Habib had one passion: that of collecting the most exceptional specimens of diamonds. He also had an ambition that consisted of owning every possible color. This view of things is by no means an exaggeration. The man held in his hands fabulous stones which, even today, continue to fascinate those who admire them in museums and collections, where some of them are preserved: the Hope Diamond, which never leaves its honorable Smithsonian Institution, or the Idol’s Eye, part of the Al-Thani Collection. Whether blue, pink, yellow or completely colorless, diamonds had no secrets for this mysterious man, whose story is intertwined with the myths surrounding the gems he once owned. Through the various auctions of his collection and the memories of his descendants, this article aims to trace the journey of a legendary selection, as well as that of the stones which - one day - crossed Mr Habib’s path.