Chemical vapour deposition of high-purity, heavily boron-doped diamond in a low-cost, custom-built microwave plasma reactor
Paper details
Section titled “Paper details”| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Journal | Carbon |
| Published | 2026-09-22 |
| Authors | Maciej J. Głowacki, Naz Ugur, Johannes Ackermann, Iuliia Neumann, Lena Hirnet |
| DOI | 10.1016/j.carbon.2026.122147 |
Undiluted trimethyl borate produced heavily boron-doped polycrystalline diamond at 1.48 μm/h on Si(100) in a custom NIRIM-type microwave plasma reactor. SIMS measured an average boron concentration of 6.48 × 10^21 cm^-3 at a plasma [B]/[C] ratio of about 105,000 ppm. Raman analysis indicated high phase purity, while UPS analysis indicated negative electron affinity of -0.18 eV.
Reactor and precursor control
Section titled “Reactor and precursor control”Growth used undiluted trimethyl borate, B(OCH3)3, as the boron source. A 20 ml stainless steel evaporator held the liquid, with hydrogen passing through a 19 mm cellulose wick. TMBT inflow depended on evaporator temperature, internal pressure, and carrier-gas flow. Its vapor pressure followed an Antoine equation stated to apply from -14.0°C to 91.5°C.
At 17°C, 700 mbar, and 8 sccm carrier hydrogen, the system delivered about 1.47 sccm TMBT vapor. The ratio calculation used 1 sccm = 0.74358 μmol/s, TMBT molar fractions of 0.0625 for boron and 0.1875 for carbon, and a methane carbon fraction of 0.2.
A dry ice and acetone trap before the pump condensed TMBT and most volatile byproducts without condensing oxygen or methane. The authors treated TMBT as potentially corrosive toward quartz. An amber deposit formed inside the tube after growth, and supplementary analysis supported a mixture of boric acid and quartz.
A cited reaction uses hydrogen to convert one TMBT molecule into two methane molecules, which may supply extra methyl radicals during growth.
Growth conditions and film formation
Section titled “Growth conditions and film formation”The reactor followed a published NIRIM design, with redesigned transitions between the stainless steel vacuum components and the quartz tube.
| Parameter | Growth condition |
|---|---|
| Carbon flow | 3 sccm CH4 |
| Hydrogen flow | 292 sccm direct and 8 sccm through the evaporator, for 300 sccm total |
| Microwave power | 700 W |
| Evaporator | 17°C and 700 mbar |
| Reactor | 790°C and 70 mbar |
| Plasma chemistry | [B]/[C] of about 105,000 ppm, with 1.47 sccm TMBT |
| Growth time | 4 h |
Square plates measuring 1 cm × 1 cm × 525 μm were cut from float-zone, two-side polished Si(100). After ultrasonic cleaning, the plates were seeded for 30 minutes in a 1% w/w detonation nanodiamond suspension. The authors skipped abrasive milling because ZrO2 residues could affect photocatalytic properties.
Cross-sectional SEM measured a 5.89 μm film thickness after 4 hours, giving 1.48 μm/h. Surface SEM showed grains above and below 1 μm, with {110} lozenges and {100} facets. Accordion-like twins were common, and one fivefold structure appeared. The cross section showed columnar grains that grew larger toward the surface.
Grazing-incidence XRD found diamond peaks at 44.85°, 76.62°, and 92.83°. Rietveld refinement showed a strong {110} preference, a slight {100} preference, and suppressed {111} orientation.
Raman phase analysis
Section titled “Raman phase analysis”Raman measurements used a 532 nm, 3 mW laser, a 10× objective, and a 25 μm slit. Seven spectra covered three center points and four edge points. Each spectrum averaged 128 exposures of 5 s.
The B1 boron band spanned 300 to 750 cm^-1, while B2 spanned 1050 to 1290 cm^-1. The diamond peak shifted below its undoped position of 1332 cm^-1 and developed a Fano line shape. The G band from 1470 to 1600 cm^-1 had low intensity.
Because sp2 carbon has a Raman scattering cross section up to 230 times that of sp3 diamond, the authors concluded that graphitic carbon was insignificant and phase purity high.
Four-component fitting gave a B1 center 9.5 cm^-1 lower at the film center than at the edges. The diamond peak was 5.55 cm^-1 lower, and its absolute asymmetry parameter was 0.95 lower. These changes indicated stronger boron incorporation at the center.
Boron concentration and distribution
Section titled “Boron concentration and distribution”Quantitative TOF-SIMS depth profiling was calibrated against commercial freestanding boron-doped diamond. The film grown at 105,000 ppm averaged 6.48 × 10^21 cm^-3 boron. Its depth profile ranged from 1.85 × 10^21 cm^-3 to an upper value of 1.11 × 10^22 cm^-3. Boron chemical maps showed a uniform distribution within the sampled region.
The commercial reference ranged from 1 × 10^20 cm^-3 to 6 × 10^20 cm^-3, with a 3.5 × 10^20 cm^-3 average. The study film therefore contained over 18 times as much boron on average.
A second film grown at about 127,500 ppm averaged 9.86 × 10^21 cm^-3. Measured incorporation was therefore not flat between the two tested feed ratios. The authors cite a methane-diborane study that estimated saturation near 30,000 ppm, although that estimate used Raman-based boron concentrations.
Band structure
Section titled “Band structure”UPS spectra were recorded at room temperature with a 5 eV analyzer pass energy and photon energies of 21.2 eV and 40.8 eV. The fitted valence band maximum was -1.1 eV relative to the Fermi level, and the cutoff gave a 4.2 eV work function.
Using a 5.48 eV literature bandgap, the authors calculated negative electron affinity of -0.18 eV. They estimated an energy uncertainty of ±100 meV. The Fermi level near the valence band maximum is consistent with p-type behavior.
The authors suggest that negative electron affinity could support electron emission after photoexcitation. Direct excitation from the valence band maximum to the conduction band minimum still requires 5.48 eV unless boron-related defects create intra-bandgap states.
Comparison with earlier growth
Section titled “Comparison with earlier growth”The 1.48 μm/h rate exceeded hot-filament reports of 0.094 to 0.179 μm/h at 11,400 ppm, 0.2 μm/h, and about 0.3 μm/h on silicon. A Rosiwal group reported 0.12 to 0.25 μm/h on niobium and 0.33 μm/h on silicon wafers. Li and co-workers reached about 2 to 3 μm/h for boron-doped hot-filament films and about 6 μm/h for undoped films.
Among microwave-plasma TMBT studies, Belousov and co-workers reported about 1 μm/h. Bogdanov and co-workers reached up to 4 μm/h at plasma [B]/[C] ratios up to 40,000 ppm. Einaga’s group reported typical rates of 1 to 2 μm/h and up to 5 at% boron.
The authors describe their result as the first heavily boron-doped, high-purity film grown at this rate in a NIRIM-type reactor with TMBT. These reports used different reactors and substrates, so they provide context rather than controlled comparisons.
Engineering implications and unresolved issues
Section titled “Engineering implications and unresolved issues”The authors interpret the {110}/{100} texture as a favorable balance of growth rate, defect content, and boron incorporation. They cite orientation-dependent boron uptake in the order {100} < {110} < {111}. Under this interpretation, {110} supports faster growth, while {100} grains carry fewer defects than {111} grains.
For material selection, the measured combination of heavy doping, p-type band positioning, high phase purity, and negative electron affinity is attractive for electrode and photoelectrode studies. Several device properties remain unresolved. The paper reports no resistivity, Hall carrier density, electrochemical activity, or photoelectrocatalytic performance. It also does not measure superconductivity, although prior work associates very high boron content with low-temperature superconductivity.
Lateral Raman data show lower doping toward the film edges despite uniform depth-profile maps. Reactor maintenance also requires a cold trap because TMBT leaves quartz deposits. The supplied version was posted on 25 March 2026 as a preprint, states that data may be preliminary, and had not been peer reviewed.
Materials and support
Section titled “Materials and support”For the paper’s electrochemical and photoelectrocatalytic applications, the matching material family is boron-doped polycrystalline diamond. 6CCVD’s diamond materials catalog lists MPCVD-grown single-crystal and polycrystalline diamond, boron-doped diamond, and thicknesses from 0.1 to 500 μm, which includes the paper’s 5.89 μm film scale. Use engineering support to define a custom growth and electrode request for heavy boron incorporation, high phase purity, and negative electron affinity.
View Original Abstract
Boron-doped diamond, an outstanding electrode material, is commonly synthesised via chemical vapour deposition (CVD) using expensive and toxic boron-containing gases. Alternative boron sources are therefore attractive; however, their use in the growth of phase-pure diamond films is so far limited. This study presents how trimethyl borate (TMBT; B(OCH 3) 3) can be used as a liquid precursor of boron for the growth of high-quality, heavily boron-doped diamond films in a custom-made, microwave plasmaassisted CVD system. These polycrystalline films were deposited on Si plates at a very high boron-tocarbon molar ratio (105,000 ppm) with homogeneous distribution throughout the film. The films exhibit an atypical surface morphology, composed of {110} and {100} crystallographic facets. Typical growth rates of about 1.5 μm/h were achieved for the process carried out without enhancements. The average concentration of boron in the films was determined to be 6.48×10 21 cm-3. Moreover, the films are characterised by negative electron affinity. The availability of these diamond films from a highly reproducible and very accessible procedure is opening new possibilities for electrochemistry, sensing and photo-electrocatalytic applications.
Boron Doped Diamond Electrode On Niobium Bdd Nb Electrode
View Specs →Boron Doped Diamond Electrode On Silicon
View Specs →
Boron Doped Single Crystal Diamond Plate
View Specs →References we cover
Section titled “References we cover”- Tuning sp3/sp2 carbon ratio of heavily boron-doped diamond electrodes fabricated via hot-filament chemical vapour deposition with CO2 addition
- Experimental Insights into Impurity Incorporation in Chemical Vapor Deposition Doped Diamond
- Influence of temperature on the electrochemical window of boron doped diamond - a comparison of commercially available electrodes
- Structural, Raman and photoluminescence studies on nanocrystalline diamond films - Effects of ammonia in feedstock
- Gas Composition Influence on the Properties of Boron-Doped Diamond Films Deposited on the Fused Silica