Feasibility of prototype diamond detectors for pulsed UHDR PBS small-field proton dosimetry for proton FLASH experiments
At a Glance
Section titled “At a Glance”| Metadata | Details |
|---|---|
| Publication Date | 2025-09-02 |
| Journal | Physics in Medicine and Biology |
| Authors | Jufri Setianegara, Aoxiang Wang, N. Gérard, Jarrick Nys, Marek Szczepański |
| Institutions | University of Pennsylvania, Ion Beam Applications (Belgium) |
| Analysis | Full AI Review Included |
Feasibility of Prototype Diamond Detectors for Pulsed UHDR PBS Small-Field Proton Dosimetry
Section titled “Feasibility of Prototype Diamond Detectors for Pulsed UHDR PBS Small-Field Proton Dosimetry”Executive Summary
Section titled “Executive Summary”- Validated Prototype Performance: Novel flashDiamond (fD) prototype detectors demonstrated no charge saturation under pulsed ultra-high dose rate (UHDR) pencil beam scanning (PBS) protons at dose-per-pulse (DPP) values of 32.6 ± 0.5 cGy, responding within ±1% of an ADCL-calibrated PPC05 ionization chamber.
- High Sensitivity with Reduced Active Volume: fD delivered a measured sensitivity of 613.29 cGy nC-1 (0.00163 nC cGy-1), with a sensitive element volume approximately 29.7% of standard microdiamond detectors—ideal for small-field UHDR dosimetry down to 1.5 × 1.5 cm2.
- Broad Energy Linearity: Tested across 70-226 MeV clinical proton energies, fD exhibited linearity within ±0.50% across dose-rate variations and produced profile measurements within ±2% of RayStation TPS calculations.
- Energy & LET Response: Showed water-equivalent response across most PDDs with localized over-response of ~5.49%, 6.51%, and 13.7% at the Bragg peaks of 226, 150, and 70 MeV respectively.
- Pulsed Beam Characterization: Operated in an S2C2 synchrocyclotron (IBA Proteus®ONE) delivering 228 MeV pulsed UHDR protons (1 kHz repetition, 10 µs pulse width, 129.5 nA nozzle current) with negligible saturation and reproducibility of ±0.80% (1 s.t.d.).
- Cross-Calibrated Cross-Reference: Validated against the PPC05 plane-parallel ionization chamber (calibration coefficient 59.23 cGy nC-1), Razor Diode, and microdiamond (mD) for absolute UHDR dosimetry.
- Application Outlook: Ideal for exit/transmission dosimetry in preclinical proton UHDR radiobiology (e.g., C57BL/6 mouse models) where field sizes can be as small as 1.1 cm and doses exceed 1000 cGy.
Technical Specifications
Section titled “Technical Specifications”| Parameter | Value | Unit | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Synchrocyclotron Model | S2C2 (IBA Proteus®ONE) | — | Compact single-gantry proton unit at Univ. of Kansas Proton Center |
| Nominal Proton Energy | 228 / 230 | MeV | Maximum energy transmission at synchrocyclotron exit |
| Clinical Energy Range | 70 - 226 | MeV | Continuously variable via wedged energy degrader |
| Pulse Repetition Rate | 1 | kHz | Fixed synchrocyclotron pulse rate |
| Pulse Duration | 10 | µs | Fixed pulse width |
| Conventional Max. Charge | 4.5 | pC per pulse | At isocenter under CONV delivery |
| UHDR Nozzle Current | 129.5 | nA | At isocenter, highest dose-rate configuration |
| Dose-Per-Pulse (DPP) | 32.6 ± 0.5 | cGy | Experimentally measured via Gafchromic film |
| UHDR Delivery Repeatability | ±0.80 | % (1 s.t.d.) | After log-file correction |
| Spot Size (in-air, σ) | 0.344 - 0.771 | cm | Range from 226 MeV to 70 MeV |
| In-air Spot Map (CONV) | 7 × 7 | spots | Square spot pattern for cross-calibration |
| Small-field Range Tested | 1.5 × 1.5 to 3.0 × 3.0 | cm2 | Square fields (4 × 4 to 7 × 7 spot maps) |
| Field-of-View Focal Length (x) | 294.5 | cm | Beam commissioning measurement |
| Field-of-View Focal Length (y) | 910.7 | cm | Beam commissioning measurement |
| Accessory Drawer Range | 17.0 - 45.4 | cm | Extension from gantry isocenter |
| Gantry Rotation Range | 325 to 188 (223 total) | ° | Compact gantry |
| fD Sensitivity (CONV protons) | 28.6 ± 0.1 | cGy nC-1 | At cross-calibration energy |
| fD Sensitivity (alternative) | 613.29 | cGy nC-1 | 0.00163 nC cGy-1; from proton-dose calibration |
| fD Nominal Sensitivity (mfr) | ~0.0025 | nC cGy-1 | Manufacturer specification |
| mD Sensitivity (measured) | 95.35 | cGy nC-1 | 0.01049 nC cGy-1 |
| PPC05 Calibration Coefficient | 59.23 | cGy nC-1 | ADCL-traceable |
| fD Dose-Rate Dependence | within ±0.50 | % | Across CONV repainting variations |
| Linearity Range Tested | 0 - 5 | Proton MU | Across 70, 150, 220 MeV |
| Energy Over-Response at 226 MeV BP | +5.49 | % | Bragg peak over-response |
| Energy Over-Response at 150 MeV BP | +6.51 | % | Bragg peak over-response |
| Energy Over-Response at 70 MeV BP | +13.7 | % | Bragg peak over-response |
| Sensitive Element Thickness | ~1 | µm | Diamond crystal thickness |
| Active Volume Ratio (fD vs mD) | 29.7 | % | Nominal comparison |
| fD vs mD Sensitivity Ratio | 15.5 | % | fD is ~15.5% as sensitive |
| fD vs PPC05 Sensitivity Ratio | 9.65 | % | fD is ~9.65% as sensitive |
| Small-field Agreement | within ±1 | % | fD vs Razor Nano / EBT-XD films |
| TPS Calculation Agreement | within ±2 | % | fD vs RayStation TPS |
| Dose Delivered for fD Calibration | 890 | cGy | Repeated for SNR matching |
| Measured Charge at 890 cGy | 1.455 ± 0.006 | nC | 0.4% percentage standard deviation |
| UHDR Pion (PPC05) | 1.0042 | — | Ion recombination correction |
| UHDR Ppol (PPC05) | 1.0097 | — | Polarity correction |
| Faraday Cup Collection Efficiency | 95.3 | % | In-house built for charge correlation |
| SSD Setup | 2 | cm solid water | Buildup for cross-calibration geometry |
| PDD Dose Calculation Resolution | 0.1 | cm | RayStation TPS voxel size |
Key Methodologies
Section titled “Key Methodologies”- Beam Source: IBA Proteus®ONE compact single-room proton therapy unit with an S2C2 synchrocyclotron generating 228-230 MeV pulsed protons.
- UHDR Tuning: Increased Dee voltage on the synchrocyclotron’s RF system, increased arc current at the ion source, and ESS optimization for maximum transmission at 226 MeV.
- Beam Monitoring: BMICs (IC1/IC2) disabled during UHDR to prevent electrometer saturation; beam monitoring performed via ICcyclo (cyclotron BMIC) and correlated against an in-house Faraday cup (95.3% collection efficiency).
- Gantry Configuration: All UHDR irradiations performed at gantry angle 0° (horizontal beam), 0° couch.
- Cross-Calibration Geometry: SSD setup with 2 cm solid water buildup, 5 × 5 cm2 CONV proton spot map at isocenter.
- CONV Calibration Reference: PPC05 plane-parallel ionization chamber (ADCL calibration coefficient 59.23 cGy nC-1).
- fD Linearity Assessment: Delivered CONV calibration spot maps at varying MUs per spot across 70, 150, and 220 MeV energies.
- fD Dose-Rate Dependence: Tested by increasing layer repainting while holding total MU constant at 70, 150, 220 MeV.
- Lateral Profile Measurements: Robotic couch shifted in millimeter increments; fD irradiated in 90° orientation; scans along both long and short axes of the active volume.
- LET Dependence (PDD): Motorized 1D water tank (IBA Blue Phantom PT); custom 3D-printed detector holder; fD in 0° orientation; 5 × 5 cm2 spot map at 226, 150, 70 MeV.
- UHDR Pulsed Beam DPP Characterization: Radiochromic film single-spot delivery at 5 MU/pulse, 129.5 nA; mean dose calculated from 0.5 × 0.5 cm2 central ROI averaged across 3 film readings.
- Small-Field UHDR Dosimetry: Spot maps reduced from 7 × 7 down to 4 × 4 (yielding 3.0 × 3.0 to 1.5 × 1.5 cm2 fields); cross-compared against Razor Nano ion chamber, EBT-XD film, and RayStation TPS.
- Detector Orientations: 0° orientation for in-water PDD scans; 90° orientation in solid water for cross-calibration and lateral profile measurements.
- Log-File Correction: Machine log files obtained for each irradiation to correct delivered MU fluctuations from nominal values (repeatability ±0.80%).
6CCVD Solutions & Capabilities
Section titled “6CCVD Solutions & Capabilities”The detector architecture validated in this work—small active volume, tissue-equivalent response, saturation resistance under high DPP pulsed beams—maps directly to MPCVD diamond material specifications that 6CCVD routinely produces.
-
Applicable Materials:
- Optical Grade Single Crystal Diamond (SCD) is the ideal substrate for replicating the fD prototype architecture. SCD’s well-defined energy levels and low trap density underpin the water-equivalent, LET-independent response observed across the 70-226 MeV range. 6CCVD’s SCD is available in thicknesses from 0.1 µm to 500 µm, enabling crystal-thickness tuning to match the ~1 µm active volume demonstrated in this study while preserving signal integrity.
- Electronic Grade Polycrystalline Diamond (PCD) offers a practical alternative for large-area detector arrays or multi-element dosimeter stacks where single-crystal uniformity is less critical. 6CCVD’s PCD plates/wafers scale up to 125 mm, supporting high-throughput production of detector batches.
- Boron-Doped Diamond (BDD) is recommended if the research scope expands toward combined dosimetry and electrochemical sensing (e.g., in radiobiological media), or for higher conductivity active layers with tunable resistivity to fine-tune saturation thresholds.
-
Customization Potential:
- Crystal Thickness Engineering: The Bragg-peak over-responses (+5.49% to +13.7%) and steep dose-gradient sensitivity observed in this study highlight the importance of sub-micron thickness control. 6CCVD’s polishing capability reaches Ra < 1 nm on SCD substrates, enabling the precision thinning required for these micro-volume dosimeters.
- Custom Metalization: For detector electrode fabrication (ohmic or Schottky contacts), 6CCVD offers in-house metallization with Au, Pt, Pd, Ti, W, and Cu. Typical detector-grade stacks such as Ti/Pt/Au or Cr/Au can be deposited and patterned to user specifications.
- Laser Cutting & Dicing: 6CCVD provides laser cutting services to define the active element geometry (the fD’s small sensitive volume corresponds to a precisely defined mesa structure). Custom die sizes down to sub-millimeter dimensions are supported.
- Substrate Backing: For rigid mounting in solid-water phantoms or SSD setups, 6CCVD supplies freestanding diamond membranes or diamond-on-substrate configurations (substrates up to 10 mm thick).
-
Engineering Support:
- 6CCVD’s in-house PhD engineering team can assist with material selection, electrode stack design, and active-volume geometry optimization for proton FLASH dosimetry projects. Our team is experienced in specifying diamond grade, crystal orientation, thickness, and contact metallurgy tailored to specific radiation modalities (pulsed protons, UHDR electrons, minibeams).
- For preclinical UHDR radiobiology platforms, 6CCVD can advise on detector configurations suited to exit dosimetry, in-line transmission monitoring, or small-field profile scanning as envisioned by the authors for C57BL/6 mouse experiments with field sizes as small as 1.1 cm.
-
Call to Action:
- For custom specifications, material consultation, or to discuss your proton FLASH dosimetry project requirements, visit 6ccvd.com or contact our engineering team directly.
View Original Abstract
Abstract Objective. This study aims to investigate the responses of prototype diamond detectors under pulsed ultra-high dose rates (UHDRs) pencil-beam-scanning (PBS) protons from a compact proton synchrocyclotron (IBA Proteus®ONE) for small-field UHDR dosimetry. Approach . flashDiamond detectors (fDs) were cross-calibrated with their relative proton responses characterized at conventional dose rates (CONV). Then, absolute UHDR dosimetry was performed and small-field response assessed. These experiments were also conducted with Razor Diode and microdiamond detectors (mDs) for cross-reference. Cross-calibrations were performed against an ADCL-calibrated PPC05 plane-parallel ionization chamber with 59.23 cGy nC −1 calibration coefficients. fD’s linearity, dose-rate, energy, and linear-energy-transfer (LET) responses were assessed under CONV protons. Pulsed UHDR PBS protons of 228 MeV were produced from a medical proton synchrocyclotron (IBA Proteus®ONE) for 1.5 × 1.5-3.0 × 3.0 cm 2 square fields. Nominal absolute UHDR dosimetry was performed at 3 × 3 cm 2 field sizes with relative responses at smaller fields benchmarked against it. Main results . fD had 28.6 ± 0.1 cGy nC −1 sensitivities under CONV protons and were linear in response with dose-rate independence within ±0.50%. fD were similar to mD in proton energy and LET responses. However, there is an over-response of approximately 5.49%, 6.51% and 13.7% at the 226, 150 and 70 MeV Bragg peaks respectively. Under pulsed proton UHDR irradiation (0.80% s.t.d, 32.6 ± 0.5 cGy dose-per-pulse), fD responded within ±1% as PPC05 with negligible saturation. fD agreed within ±1% with other comparable small-field detectors under small-field UHDR beams and within ±2% of RayStation treatment planning system calculations. There is negligible partial volume averaging with fDs. Significance . Novel fD detectors did not saturate under pulsed UHDR PBS proton irradiation. Their miniscule active crystals make them suitable for small-field dosimetry but render them relatively insensitive compared to mDs. When cross-calibrated, they are suitable for absolute small-field UHDR dosimetry or for relative exit dosimetry monitoring purposes during UHDR radiobiological experiments.
Tech Support
Section titled “Tech Support”Original Source
Section titled “Original Source”References
Section titled “References”- 2024 - Multi-institutional audit of FLASH and conventional dosimetry with a 3D printed anatomically realistic mouse phantom [Crossref]
- 2023 - The current status of FLASH particle therapy: a systematic review [Crossref]
- 2025 - Whole abdominal pencil beam scanned proton FLASH increases acute lethality [Crossref]
- 2024 - Preclinical ultra-high dose rate (FLASH) proton radiation therapy system for small animal studies [Crossref]
- 2022 - Determination of the ion collection efficiency of the Razor Nano Chamber for ultra-high dose-rate electron beams [Crossref]
- 2024 - Mechanisms of action in FLASH radiotherapy: a comprehensive review of physicochemical and biological processes on cancerous and normal cells [Crossref]
- 2021 - Spread-out Bragg peak proton FLASH irradiation using a clinical synchrocyclotron: proof of concept and ion chamber characterization [Crossref]
- 2020 - Feasibility of proton FLASH irradiation using a synchrocyclotron for preclinical studies [Crossref]
- 2024 - FLASH radiotherapy for the treatment of symptomatic bone metastases in the thorax (FAST-02): protocol for a prospective study of a novel radiotherapy approach [Crossref]
- 2023 - Definition of dose rate for FLASH pencil-beam scanning proton therapy: a comparative study [Crossref]